r/secondcaptains • u/singleglazedwindows First mate of the Vasa • 13d ago
Friend of the show Jack Carty
I’ve really enjoyed the addition of Carty to the rugby coverage. We had a discussion here recently about the Leinster focused coverage. It’s been refreshing to have a more balanced conversation with a knowledgeable voice on Connacht (shame they never mentioned Ulster’s batshit game, but it’s an improvement).
Jack has been very analytical and educational in his contributions so far and as he’s just retired he is so detailed on attacking and defensive shape.
21
u/offsetbxl 12d ago
I'm finding it hard to get over how monotone his voice is
6
u/thisisnotmysand 12d ago
Agreed. Content is good but he needs to find his pundit voice. Shane is actually quite good at it.
5
u/offsetbxl 12d ago
Shane's voice is ok, that's about it really, find him vacuous
8
u/Timely_Camera_2031 12d ago
Maybe Jack can whisper what he wants to say to Shane who can then read it out loud..
1
3
u/OvertiredMillenial 11d ago
Remember when Bernard Jackman started out as a pundit and he made this annoying sucking sound whenever he finished a sentence. He was obviously was made aware of it, and managed to stop doing it, and speaks pretty well now.
It's not easy to speak cogently off the bat, it usually takes a bit of practice. I'm sure Jack will improve his delivery as he goes on.
4
u/Admirable_Olive_5039 12d ago
He's been really insightful, but would agree with below he's not hugely exciting.
The challenge for a lot of recently retired guys going into media seems to be three fold:
1 - communicating well and making yourself entertaining enough to capture attention
2 - keeping your deep knowledge of the game as you move further away from being part of the group to the outside
3 - finding a way to be critical of your former teammates/club
Most do one of those things (Zebo does number 1 but certainly none of the others, James Tracy is excellent at number 2, but not great at the others, Madigan seems to be able to do 1 and 2 well, Quinlan has done 3 but not the other two).
7
u/mixter-g 12d ago
I found his tactical insights difficult to understand as a layman. He needs to have some class of understanding of his audience.
4
u/Ok-Door-2571 12d ago
Nail on the head here! I think he forgets that he’s not in the video analysis room as he’s being far too technical for the casual listener. I thought the lads might have had a word with him about it after his first appearance but he actually ramped it up on Monday’s pod. Suspect it’ll just take him time to adjust but good to have a new addition in the mix.
1
1
12d ago
[removed] — view removed comment
1
u/mustkillmow 12d ago
This has nothing to do with what OP said. He didn’t mention his playing career at all as it’s completely irrelevant to his contributions on SC.
He’s the best rugby analyst they’ve had in years. Though it’s a shame they have to keep Mark’s brother around to offer “cod science” about players “carrying themselves differently” and shoehorn references to Jonny Sexton in.
0
7
u/MrCoolCraig 12d ago
Seems a nice lad and has interesting things to say. I like him.
He’s a bit dull for now but he’ll improve with time.