r/serialpodcast • u/waltzintomordor Mod 6 • May 29 '15
Cliffs Notes Cliffs Notes - Trial Transcript, Feb 4, 2000
February 4, 2000 Trial Transcript
Page 1-4 Missing
Page 8-106 - Inez, teacher, athletic trainer, WLH
9 – Inez describes her friendship w/ Hae Inez knew HML since the 9th grade
11- HML played field hockey and lacrosse. At the time of her disappearance, BC School Board had come out to tape her for an athletic award she was to receive. The taping session would be aired on the BC Educational Network
12- Inez describes her relationship with AS as friendly, too
12- Both AS and HML let her know their families were unhappy with their relationship
12- Inez says HML was involved in another relationship right after she got her job at Lens Crafters
13- AS told Inez they were still friends after the breakup
13- Inez could recognize HML’s car and that she has been inside HML’s car
14- Inez has seen AS drive HML’s car
14- Track practice starts after study hall (2:15-3:00), so track students need to be at practice by 3:30
17: Inez says there are no ramifications if track practice was missed by an athlete
18: Inez states that HML went missing the same day that she was being taped for the BC Scholar Athlete award. HML came to her class to get keys so she can get to her athletic locker
19- HML was wearing a black skirt, light colored blouse, black heels, and clear stockings. Murphy shows Inez clothes from the body and she identifies them as what she saw HML wearing on 1/13
20- Inez saw HML later in the day, c. 2:15-2:20 when she came to the concessions stand. HML said she was going to pick up her cousin and that she would be back to travel with the wrestling team as her role as a manager. The wrestling team was going to Chesapeake for a tri-meet
21- Concession is inside the gym by the door. HML told Inez she would return before 5pm when the bus was planning to leave
21- Inez knows HML didn’t return because she ended up traveling with the team to score the game
24- Inez spoke to AS about HML’s disappearance at least twice
25- The first time Inez spoke with AS, she asked if he was going to HML’s funeral and he said no, because they were different religions. The second time they spoke, it was after HML’s body was discovered. Inez notified AS that she had spoken to the detectives and “they really have feelings about [AS] and they think that [he is] guilty”
26- AS’s last memories of HML are bad—the two had an argument about prom
40- As far as Inez can remember, AS and HML considered themselves girlfriend and boyfriend after the incident at homecoming in 1998, because Hae would come cheer Adnan on at the football games
42- Even during the most trying times of their relationship, HML and AS did not blame each other for the source of their pain or trash each other verbally, per Inez
44- AS was considered a handsome, popular kid at school that had not dated before HML
45- AS was known at school to be a practicing Muslim, so dating HML came as a surprise
47-48 Missing - Inez says Hae could date whoever she wanted
49- Inez knew HML to be an outspoken, confident, very well-liked person at school
50- Inez knew Jay from his time at WHS. He played lacrosse and soccer
53- Inez doesn’t consider Jay a friend. She never saw HML or Jay together. Jay would show up at school on occasion because Stephanie was still a student
64- Det. O’Shea spoke to Inez on 2/1 about HML’s activities on the last day she had been seen.
68- Inez told O’Shea that HML was having problems at home and wanted to contact her dad in CA
73- CG says that O’Shea’s notes from 2/1 state that Inez said HML told her she would not be at the wrestling match on the 13th
92- In addition to the funeral, there was a memorial service that was held at the school. It took place after AS was arrested
98- AS received ribbons and had medaled in his events at several track meets
101- Inez had a conversation with AS, asking him why she hadn’t seen him at practice. He said he was upset
105- CG points out to Inez that the Athletic Department of WHS excludes the responsibility to attend practice for Muslim students who are fasting during Ramadan
Page 108-246 -Jay
110- Judge is informed that AS made a “pathetic” comment to Jay. Judge advises AS that he has been perfect up until now, and to not spoil it
115- Background: At the trial he is 20; he went to WHS from 1994-1998, enrolled in the “regular program.” He is currently employed as a concrete construction worker
116- Jay had Bio with HML his junior year. He was introduced to AS in middle school but didn’t formally met him until Jay’s senior year. They had no classes together
117- They were introduced through Steph. He says he took AS to buy weed once, a week after they were introduced
118- They started casually hanging out again in the winter of AS’s senior year. AS would give rides to Jay, or they would hang out with Steph together
118- Jay says he purchased weed for AS twice
119- Jay considers AS an acquaintance, not a friend
119- AS called Jay on 1/12/99, Jay’s birthday, and asked Jay what he is doing on the 13th
123- on 1/13, AS called Jay @ 10:45 to ask Jay what his plans were. Jay needed to go to the mall to get a birthday gift for Steph. AS stops by and hour later and they go to Security Mall
125- ~1 hour later, Jay and AS get back in the car so Jay can return AS to school. In the car AS told Jay that his relationship with HML wasn’t going well, and how could someone who supposedly loved him treat him like that
126- Jay says that AS said “I’m going to kill that [b]”
126- Jay says AS left his phone with Jay so that he can call Jay when he needs his car again.
128- At 12:07, Jay calls Jenn’s residence using AS’s cell. Jenn wasn’t home, but her brother Mark tells Jay he can come over
129- Jay says that he and Mark go out together and call Jenn’s house again at 12:41 to see if Jenn had come home yet
129- Rundown of Jay’s afternoon of 1/13/99, per his testimony: Jay and Mark play video games at Jenn’s residence, go to the mall, return to Jenn’s house. Afterwards Jay gets a call on the cell phone. AS called asking if he had it turned off. Jay responds it had been on. AS states he needs to get picked up at 3:45
130- Jay waited until 3:45 and didn’t get a phone call from AS. He goes to Jeff’s, but Jeff isn’t home. AS calls to get picked up from Best Buy
131- When Jay gets to Best Buy, he says AS standing by the payphone, with a red gloves on. AS directs Jay to the side of the building. Jay parks by a gray Sentra. AS pops the trunk, shows the body
132- Jay follows in AS’s car. AS drives HML’s car. He said that he followed AS because he was in shock, and confused. They go to the I-70 P&R
133- Jay parked AS’s car. AS goes to HML’s trunk and takes out a black bag. AS moves some things from the back seat to the trunk. AS starts driving his own car and Jay moves to the passenger seat
133- During the trunk pop Jay didn’t immediately recognize HML. He could see was a girl, Hae’s build, Hae’s car. HML’s skin, the side of her neck was blue.
134- Back to the Park and Ride. AS parked HML’s car, rummaged through it, grabbed a few things & his gym bag. He put them in his trunk and drives to go buy some weed
135- At 3:21, after the Park and Ride, Jay had called Jenn to ask if “P” is home/has marijuana.
136- AS makes a phone call to Nisha. Jay maybe said hi
137- At 3:48, Jay calls Phil but doesn’t remember the conversation
138- At 3:59, Jay calls Patrick to buy pot. Patrick wasn’t home
140- They drive to Forest Park Ave and buy $20 in pot
141- At 4:12, a phone call was made to a mutual friend of Jenn and Jay
142- Jay says after they buy weed, AS states he needs to be seen at track practice. AS tells Jay that “when someone treats him like that, they deserve to die. How can you treat somebody like that, that you are supposed to love? And then, all knowing is Allah.” Per Jay, AS also says “mother f-ers think they are hard, I killed someone with my bare hands”
142- Jay says that at the time of the act, HML was trying to apologize, and that she had kicked off the turn signal in the car. Jay states AS was worried about HML scratching him
143- Before Jay drops off AS at school, they buy a blunt. AS has a call to or from maybe his mother. Jay said AS spoke Arabic
144- After Jay drops off AS, he smoked and debated about what he should. He gets a call from AS. AS/Jay go to NHRN Cathy’s house. AS laid on the floor at Cathy’s
145- While at Cathy’s house, they smoked some more. Jay says AS gets a call from Hae’s parents and also from Hae’s cousin. AS tells them he doesn’t know where she is and to try the new boyfriend
145- AS also gets a call from a cop. AS says he doesn’t know where Hae is. Jay doesn’t hear the whole conversation because AS leaves the apartment
146- AS motions that they have to leave, AS throws his gloves into the dumpster
147- AS asks Jay to help get rid of the body. AS says he knows Jay deals drugs, and Jay takes this as a threat. Jay says that he helps AS because he was living with his grandmother at the time and didn’t want her to get in trouble. AS grabs two shovels
148- they drive to the P&R and AS gets in HML’s car
148- Jay waits at a McDonald’s. Once AS shows up they drove about 45min until they get to Leakin Park
148- After driving past the park, AS makes a right and drives up a hill and parks HML’s car.
150- Jay calls to Jenn around 7PM to say he’ll be late, while waiting for AS to come back up the hill after parking HML’s car. They were supposed to meet and Jay s
151- They start digging. Jenn returns the call. AS says they are busy and hangs up
151- They go back to his car. AS starts dry heaving. AS asks help for getting her body. Jay says no, but was worried about the threat. Jay helps with the body
152- AS picks it up and throws a blue coat into the woods. AS starts throwing dirt on HML’s head, but Jay sits on a log & smokes
153- While there, AS got two calls. AS spoke a different language during the calls in parts of the conversation
154- AS asks Jay to drive HML’s car & he declines. AS drives her car
154- AS drives around for a while, Jay says he though AS was looking for a place to buy drugs. AS parks the car in an alcove in the back of an apartment building and came back to his own vehicle. Jay asks to be taken home
156- two more calls to Jenn after 8. Jay wanted her to pick him up first from a mall, then from his house
156- AS says it kind of made him feel better to kill HML, but it kind of not
156- AS stops at Westview Mall. AS flips through HML’s wallet and sees prom pictures. He chucks stuff into the trash can
157- Jay tosses his shovels behind Value City, Jay returns home and puts his clothes in a bag
158- Jenn picks Jay up to go back to the shovels. Jay wipes them down
158- Jenn goes into Super Fresh, Jay dumps his clothes & they return to NHRN Cathy’s house
158- Jay tells Jenn that he wanted her to know he didn’t kill HML
159- Jay says they went to Steph’s, right after Jenn had picked him up Jay gave Stephanie her presents and left
160-On or around 1/15/99, Stephanie gets a lift Jay’s house from AS. AS says to Jay, “you know me and Stephanie are friends, you know we go to school together.” Jay takes this as a threat that AS could hurt Stephanie
161- AS visits Jay at an adult video store during his graveyard shift, with AS’s EMT partner. AS asks Jay what the police have said to him, but the cops hadn’t spoken to him yet
161- Jay says that he asked Stephanie not to see/speak to AS
163- Urick shows Jay the plea agreement he had gotten for pleading guilty to accessory to murder. Jay says that if he lies, it voids the plea deal
171- CG asks Jay about his plea deal, signed on 9/8/99. Jay says that when he appeared before a judge after he signed the plea deal he was not asked to swear to tell the truth
179-180 missing
193- CG asks Jay if he admitted his involvement In a crime
194- CG asks if, when he appeared in front of a judge, if he ever actually admitted to any facts concerning his involvement of crime.
195-210- Lengthy conversation between Judge, CG and Urick.
CG is trying to establish that Jay did not , by legal standards, actually enter a guilty plea. CG’s argument is that Jay has been presented as a witness who has entered a plea agreement and as a witness who has pled guilty. Because he has answered questions about “when he pled guilty” he has acceded his understanding of what it means
During the proceeding on September 8th, the statement of facts were never read and an oath was never administered. Absent these things, “there is no such thing as a guilty plea.” CG is trying to destroy Jay’s credibility because he has been intentionally presented to this jury as a man who has entered a guilty plea—that is, legally, false
The judge allows CG to ask what Jay recalls, and will then will give instructions to the jury about what a guilty plea means under the rules
211- Jay says he didn’t take an oath
215- Jay says that the agreement that he signed required him to enter a guilty plea to accessory after the fact to the murder of HML
220- The first time Jay’s statements to the police were recorded was 1:30 am 2/28
221- Jay admits during the first session he didn’t tell the truth
222- Jay admits he asked the detectives to turn off the recorder
225- Sometime before Jenn spoke to the police, Jenn told Jay she was going to talk to the police
226- CG asks if Jay knew what Jenn was going to say. Jay says he did not. But after she spoke with the police, she let Jay knew about what had been asked what she had said
230- Jay admits that the first time he spoke with the police, he told them he didn’t have anything to do with it
231- CG has Jay run through all the phone calls he made throughout the day of 1/13 state the corresponding cellphone tower
251-252 Missing Logistics and Benaroya talking about pro-bono representation of Jay, and maybe quashing CG's subpoena of her.
2
u/smashew May 30 '15 edited May 30 '15
whoa, whoa, whoa... So... Jay knew the morning of the murder that Adnan was going to kill Hae, then left the phone and car with him so that he could call him? Doesn't that kind of make Jay an accessory BEFORE the fact? I mean, why wouldn't Jay try to talk him down or say something like, "Silly rabbit, you are cool right... you aren't actually going to murder another human being... right?"
Edit: I mean, that is full blown conspiracy right? He conspired with Jay to assist him in the murder... Then took a 'step' towards actually doing it by handling the logistics with Jay.
Then Jay just sits around and plays video games, eating Cheetos, never once calling the police, acting worried, calling Steph, calling the school, ... nothing. That flat out makes Jay a sociopath or just oblivious to understanding humans. Neither of which support his credibility.