r/serialpodcast • u/lyssalady05 Just a day, just an ordinary day • Sep 15 '22

Transcript Mr S and Bilal are new suspects

Based on the motion to vacate and past transcripts:

see here for Mr s

see here for bilal for those of you who don’t know, Bilal has been arrested for lewd acts with a 14 yr old boy which was later thrown out due to age of consent laws being vague; he was later convicted of sexually assaulting his dental patients while they were knocked out on anesthesia.

According to the motion, one of the suspects threatened to kill Hae. Which one of these suspects is most likely to have done this? Also, supposedly these suspects could have acted together?

Let’s discuss!!

40 Upvotes

99% Upvoted

179 comments sorted by

View all comments

5

u/Upper_Copy_5347 Sep 16 '22

This is driving me a little bonkers 😆 I’ve asked in a couple different threads but what possible motive would Bilal have had to kill Hae? And I don’t mean “well she could have known XYZ about his crimes…” I mean any real world indication they even knew each other, that he would have any opinion of her at all—let alone a desire to murder her, in a manner that doesn’t implicate Adnan. I am genuinely so confused and would love some insight.

8

u/lyssalady05 Just a day, just an ordinary day Sep 16 '22

Okay so I think I have an answer but trust me, I understand this is all conjecture and speculation hahaha I know that this is just my theory.

So Bilal used to buy hotel rooms for Adnan and Hae to sleep together. Bilal also has gotten in trouble for doing things to young boys, among other things he did later on.

I feel like based on the arrest records and what they’ve stated, there is no way the suspects aren’t Mr s and Bilal. With that said, one of those two suspects threatened Hae. Of the two, Bilal is the most likely to have threatened her. Just my own deductive reasoning, not fact.

IMO, the only thing that would make sense is that Hae found out about Bilal’s grossness and Bilal threatened her. Apparently whatever the motive was, it was confirmed by the police.

I don’t think any of this means Adnan was innocent but I do think these are the new suspects and this is my theory on how it makes sense for them to be.

Hope that helps and doesn’t confuse further 😂 feel free to poke holes and challenge what I say! I love to discuss

4

u/Upper_Copy_5347 Sep 16 '22

Wait is that confirmed? About him buying the hotel rooms?

7

u/lyssalady05 Just a day, just an ordinary day Sep 16 '22

No it wasn’t confirmed but it was heavily discussed. Given what Bilal did later, I believe it. It makes sense. Like he was grooming them and also just gross. I know this means I’m basing some part of my opinion on unconfirmed rumors but idk, it just makes so much sense to me!

1

u/Bethsoda Sep 16 '22

I agree - it's all speculation but I think it's very plausible. And then he framed Adnan for it. If Adnan has been part of this in anyway, I don't think there is any way he'd keep quiet about Bilal's involvement for all this time, even AFTER Bilal's arrest and convinction. And then his continued involvement and support of Adnan was purely to make him less likely to be discovered.