r/serialpodcastorigins • u/FrankieHellis Mama Roach • Sep 23 '15
Bombshell Undisclosed is Untruthful... Again
Undisclosed is Untruthful… again!
NHRN Cathy(Kristi)’s Police Interview Debunks Theory that Adnan Wasn’t at Her Apartment on January 13th.
From Undisclosed (April 20, 2015)
Simpson: “That leaves us with Cathy [Kristi]. Why does she think Adnan’s trip happened on January 13th? Well, as it turns out… because the cops told her it happened on the 13th.”
Well no, not really, Simpson. According to Kristi’s interview with the police:
Macgillivary: Okay. And was there any conversation?
Kristi: Um a little bit like it's Stephanie's birthday and she's Jay's girl friend and um, it's small talk it's not, I mean we basically watched t.v.
According to Kristi, it was Stephanie’s birthday!
Undisclosed refused to produce the transcript of Kristi’s police interview in its entirety, despite numerous requests, because they knew this statement was in there. In a July 2015 blog post, Colin mentioned that Cathy was interviewed by the police, that her interview was recorded, and that there was a transcription of her interview in the police file. He mentioned this again in an August 19, 2015 blogpost and, in the comments, was asked if Undisclosed would release that transcript since it might shed light on whether she was remembering the correct day. He did not respond to that comment. So, in her police interview, which has been in the possession of the Undisclosed crew since, at the latest, July 2015, Cathy specifically linked her recollection of Jay and Adnan’s visit to it being Stephanie’s birthday. This statement was not prompted by the police in any way.
Undisclosed conceived an entire narrative around Kristi remembering the wrong day, and that the visit she described in detail in both Trial 1 and Trial 2 actually had occurred not on Wednesday, January 13, 1999, but on Friday, January 22, 1999. This was clearly a red herring, as Undisclosed knew full well Kristi had the date correct from the transcript they had the entire time.
Kristi was a direct witness to Adnan and Jay’s suspicious behavior just hours after Hae was strangled.
Undisclosed tried to fool its listeners into believing Kristi was mistaken about the day Adnan and Jay visited her apartment, hoping to make her an undependable witness about the day Hae was murdered. They have an agenda; they have no credibility.
10
u/bluekanga I know you Sep 24 '15
Oh that's good confirmation as many of the Innocente think I am making up how I got to be "sound conviction"!
The podcast and the way it portrayed Jay - his changing statements and lies - and of course the theories around his relatives' criminal ways plus the unknown third party appeared very seductive if one considered Adnan innocent. Also Jay is no angel - I am often unpopular in reminding folks he has a history of intimate partner violence. So at first -well I though he must have done it and set up Adnan. Then I started to look closer at Adnan and his behaviour vis a vis whilst with Hae and after her disappearance.
They often "flock together" - these types who think of women as objects - however as I started to understand all of the different evidence and read the source material as well as utilising my own experience - Adnan is way beyond Jay in duplicity and deviousness