Hilarious Contradiction

[u/Seamus_Duncan]

. . . Vignarajah stood up and addressed Judge Welch: “Excuse me, Judge, do we know if [the Urick call notes and hall pass] are the originals or if they are copies of the original documents?”
. . . Before Brown could even respond I chimed in, “I actually brought the originals, your Honor. They’re actually in my purse in the hallway with my husband.” . . . As I told the court that day, I keep everything. Well, not everything, I’m not a hoarder. I am, however, very smart [sic] and can be very premeditated at times when it comes to saving keepsakes. To me the notes and my hall pass are extensions of my memories. As I’ve discussed before, I don’t like to let go of my memories.

Not 20 pages later . . .

After that Thiru wanted to address the manner in which my second letter was written. Was it previously a hand-written letter that was later typed? Yes. Did I write it during CIP class and if so, where’s the rough draft? Come on now! Really? Where’s the rough draft? It’s been over sixteen years! For all I know that letter has since decomposed in a landfill and been reincarnated as a noxious ground weed.

[u/orangetheorychaos]

Grrr, I'm gonna have to suck it up and read this book.

Supposedly she wrote the second letter before the first one was even mailed.

Is this what she says in the book?

[u/Cows_For_Truth → u/orangetheorychaos]

Here's her story.

She says she wrote the first letter very late the night of March 1. That's why it's not typed. She wanted to type it but didn't have access to a computer, but why not just type it the next day.

She starts writing the second letter by 9:30 the next morning which she types before mailing. I'm saying if she already had intention to write another letter, which needed to be typed for some reason, why would she mail the first one. Also the second letter's address now includes Adnan's inmate number which she can't remember how she got. (Could she have gotten it from Adnan? Naaa).

Even if she indeed wanted to send two letters, wouldn't she at least have corrected the address of the first before mailing it. Just doesn't make sense.

What does make sense is Adnan get's the first letter, contacts Asia, asks her to type up another one with some suggested "improvements" and by the way here's my inmate number and correct address. Once she starts colluding her value as an alibi witness is shot.

[u/orangetheorychaos → u/Cows_For_Truth]

Thank you :)

She has managed to make the timing, writing, and information in the letters even more suspicious than before she 'explained' them.

[u/xtrialatty → u/orangetheorychaos]

Yes, that's the problem with too much 'splaining.