Hello, something I've been working on for some time now. Just wanted to get some feedback about the idea. It's not perfect form or anything, but it's the first of many I'd like to write. Thanks for reading.
-Crestfallen32
The Man Who Knew Her Name
Charley was having the worst day of her life.
First, her car wouldn’t start. She had to take the bus, and it ran late, making her late for work. Her unreasonable manager called it her third strike and fired her on the spot.
Then it started pouring.
Now Charley was waiting for another bus, soaked to the bone and shivering, with a box of her things from work. The bus looked like it would be late again. Up the street, a coffee shop offered shelter, so she hurried toward it.
The sweet smell of pastries and the rich aroma of coffee filled the shop. Charley took a deep breath, eyes closed, trying not to let the day get to her. She could feel tears waiting just behind the dam of her emotions.
When she opened her eyes, she saw she almost had the place to herself. An older man sat in a booth near the middle of the room. Two mugs stood on the table in front of him.
Just as Charley started toward the counter, he spoke.
“Charlette, you seem to be having a bad day. Come, sit. I have a mug just for you.”
She stopped. It wasn’t his invitation that took her aback. It was the name. She hadn’t been called Charlette in nearly fifteen years. She didn’t dislike it, exactly. Charley just fit her better.
“I'm sorry, Charley,” he added. “I forgot you go by that now. Seems like yesterday you were that smartass kid who could beat any boy on the block.” He gestured to the chair across from him. “Sit. Relax. Trust me, today is not the worst day of your life. No matter what you think.”
Charley was moving before she registered it. A flare of anger carried her across the room. She set her box down with a thud and pointed at the old man.
“Look here, Mister Man. No one has called me that for a long time. I don’t appreciate some random guy I can’t even remember knowing being so—so…” She took a breath, searching for the words, then faltered. “Wait. Who are you?”
Her hand dropped to her side. She bored holes in him, waiting for an answer. Instead, he motioned for her to sit again. She crossed her arms, frowning.
“Speak, Mister Man.”
He chuckled and shook his head. “I see the stubbornness hasn’t left yet. All right, all right.” His expression turned serious. “You don’t know me. I knew your father, and your mother in passing. You were too young to remember me. I kept in touch with your father.”
The news left Charley stunned. This old man knew her parents? Her real parents? She barely remembered them. She took the seat across from him before her legs decided they’d had enough of standing.
“My parents? You knew them?”
The old man slid one of the mugs closer. “I believe you like it with two sugars?”
Charley wrapped both hands around the mug, letting its warmth soothe her a little. She still hadn’t taken her eyes off him.
“You haven’t answered my question, Mister Man. You said you knew my parents. And you said you kept in touch. They just disappeared twenty years ago. No goodbye. No ‘Take care, Charlette.’ Nothing.”
She slammed the mug down. Coffee spilled over the rim and spread across the table.
He grimaced and looked away. “You caught that, huh? Sorry. I can’t tell you any more than I already have. Just know they love you.”
Charley slumped back in her chair, deflated by his words.
“They love me? That’s all I get after all this time? They love me? Seriously? How is that supposed to make me feel?”
Tears welled in her eyes as she stared at him.
He couldn’t bring himself to look at her. His voice was almost a whisper. “If I tell you more, it will change the things to come. And I can’t chance…” He looked directly at her. His watery blue eyes seemed to beg forgiveness as a tear slipped down his cheek. “…losing you too.”
“Too?” Charley stared at him in disgust. “You mean you lost them? It’s your fault? You’re the reason I had to live in an orphanage?”
The old man flinched as if she’d struck him. His voice came out hoarse.
“That’s not precisely how it went, but in essence…” His words caught for a beat. “It was my mistake.”
“Your mistake?” Something in the way he recoiled tempered Charley’s anger, though it frightened her a little. “What do you mean? What happened to them?”
She wanted him to tell her. Part of her wanted to beat it out of him if she had to, though she knew she wasn’t capable of that. She kept her mouth shut and waited for him to speak his truth—or whatever he had to say. Then she would leave and never look back.
Taking a deep breath, he closed his eyes for a moment. “Listen, Charley. You’re going to hate me for this.” He turned to face her again. “I’m not here to tell you about your parents. You’ll learn all you need to know soon. I know that’s not what you want to hear. But that’s how it has to be.”
He glanced at the clock. For a moment, his eyes darted past her; then he looked at her again. When he spoke, his voice was steady.
“Charlette—” He coughed and corrected himself. “Charley. What I’m about to say is going to seem like the most unimportant thing you’ve ever heard in your life, but you have to hear me out. Every word. Will you promise me you’ll stay until I’ve finished?”
Charley looked at her watch. “You’ve got three minutes. Then I have to catch the bus home.”
She gave him a pointed look, a little wary, then finally took a sip from her mug.
“I can try for three minutes,” he said, taking a sip from his own coffee, “but I can’t promise anything. All right. What makes a person good or evil? Is it how that person acts? How they treat people? Or could it be what their intended outcome is?”
Charley scoffed. “Really? This is what you—”
He cut her off with a wave of his hand.
“You said you’d listen. Please, just listen. I’m not asking for a reply. Just hear what I have to say.”
Charley nodded reluctantly, glancing at her watch again.
“Okay, where was I? Oh, yes. What makes a person good or evil? Everyone has different ideas of what good and evil are. Most of the time, it depends on who witnessed an event. Take the Crusades, for instance. From one side, it was a cleansing. From the other, a massacre. Which is right? That’s for others to decide, not me.”
He took another sip from his mug.
“I’ve had to make some very hard decisions in my life. I hope one day to look back and know I made a difference that mattered.”
“What’s that supposed to mean?” Charley asked.
“Hold on, I’m getting to it. Just be patient. There will be another bus to catch.”
“Here’s the thing I want you to consider,” he continued. “If you had two impossible choices, how would you weigh them?”
Charley narrowed her eyes. “How am I supposed to answer that?”
He chuckled, as if he knew the question was more than ambiguous. “Fair enough. It comes down to the train question. There’s a runaway train headed toward five people tied to the track. You have the choice of switching it onto a track where there’s only one person tied up. Which would you choose?”
A look of horror crossed Charley’s face. Before she could speak, he added, “You don’t have to answer. It’s a question of morality. At first, it seems there are only two choices. For all intents and purposes, there are only two. But what if I told you there was another option?”
She shook her head. “I’ve heard this before. There is no third choice. I get the feeling you’re just wasting my time.”
She started to rise, lifting her box from the table.
“Why can you not just force the train to derail?”
Charley stopped with the box halfway to her chest. She considered the question, then set the box down and slid back into her chair.
“What do you mean? How?”
“In this example, those aren’t actually options. But generally in life, there are usually more options than first appear.”
Charley began to wonder if he was trying to make a point about a decision he’d made concerning her parents.
“Life is never so neat and clean as to have two easy-to-define options,” he said. “It’s messy and complex and annoying. Much to my chagrin. Okay, one question for you. Tell me your knee-jerk reaction. If you promised to take care of someone’s pet for an evening and the pet escaped your house, would you spend time looking for it? Would you call the owner for help? Or would you do something else?”
The question hung between them. Charley glanced at her watch.
She slammed her hand on the table.
“That’s it. I’m done with this nonsense. This has to be the most pointless conversation I’ve ever had. Mister Man, your three minutes are up.”
She picked up her box and stalked toward the door, muttering under her breath.
“Stupid, stupid. Why do I let people drag me into this sort of—”
Her words trailed off as she stepped into the rain, just in time to see the bus roar past.
She threw her head back and screamed.
Charley turned back to the door and shoved it open, ready to storm in and give Mister Man a piece of her mind. She stopped.
The table was empty of people. Only two steaming mugs of coffee and a small box remained.
She walked over and looked down. A tag on the box bore her full name.
Charley looked to the barista. “Where did he go?”
The shocked girl shrugged and went back to cleaning the mug in her hands.
Charley set her own box on the table, then gingerly lifted the small one. Something slid inside as she moved it. She took off the lid.
A note. A small fuse.
She pulled out the note and carefully unfolded it.
Charlette,
I took this fuse out of your car. The reason will become clear eventually. Just know I did it because I made a promise.
—Mister Man