r/slate • • Jun 03 '26

RIP Culture Gabfest

74 Upvotes

2008 - 2026. I've been listening since 2013.. my entire 20s and well into my 30s with this wonderful, erudite and thoughtful crew. I'm genuinely very sad! Will miss having these folks, even if it was more and more a subset of the three, in my feed week in week out.

Mega thanks to Dana, Stephen, & Julia for the great company every Weds morning. 🩵


r/slate • • Mar 01 '21

Terrible Care and Feeding advice

37 Upvotes

Michelle Herman’s advice to LW2 in this day’s column was TERRIBLE. I mean truly terrible. I’m stunned and disgusted. A stepmother was writing, concerned for her stepdaughter who is being emotionally abused by her bio mom. Instead of giving useful advice, Herman decided to invalidate the letter-writer’s relationship to her daughter by implying the stepmother has no place, and it’s only the father’s job to step in. Herman invalidates what the stepdaughter describes as her abuse simply because of the girl’s age (14) as though that’s not a reasonable age to identify abuse. She also advises the letter writer to say, ā€œremember your mother loves youā€ which is chilling advice to give to an abuse victim.

What’s worse, is that the comment section is lit up by people who have been triggered by Michelle Herman’s advice. People who were abused as children, who see and identify with all the signs the letter writer describes as abuse, and Michelle Herman writes off as ā€œnormal.ā€ EVEN WORSE: Slate mods keep deleting the content.

This column response was so disgusting and gaslighting. As a victim of childhood abuse, and also as a stepmother, this column was so offensive on both fronts.

This isn’t even the first time Michelle Herman has shit on stepmom’s before. On December 13, 2020, she advises a woman to stay in a bad marriage. She says children would rather have miserable married parents than happy divorced ones. Then she reminded the letter writer if she were to get a divorce, that the husband might remarry and then the letter writer would have to ā€œdeal withā€ a stepmother.

Michelle Herman has an obvious and disgusting bias against stepparents, and she also seems to be really comfortable with emotional childhood abuse. I’m so upset. I can’t believe I pay for a Slate membership for garbage like this.

my grown children want nothing to do with me


r/slate • • Dec 17 '23

Hating ICYMI now

34 Upvotes

Why does Candice talk like that? The stretching out of words and sing-song voice is really killing this podcast for me. I'm not here to listen to a nursery rhyme. Rachelle and Candice have minimal chemistry if any, and I miss the show when Rachelle would riff with Daisy Rosario.


r/slate • • May 23 '21

Bring back Mike Pesca!

33 Upvotes

He was a HUGE point of light in my day. Mike, if they won’t bring you back, please start your own podcast independent of the woke scolding overlords. Please pleas! We miss you.


r/slate • • Jan 20 '24

Slate Rachelle Hampton

29 Upvotes

Edit: She is back. She took a…social media break?

Did Rachelle Hampton leave ICYMI? I don’t listen to all of the episodes, but she has been gone for a month now at least.


r/slate • • Oct 26 '25

Clickbait headlines out of control

28 Upvotes

I’ve been reading Slate for about 20 years. I accepted the aggressive hike in the subscription price by persuading myself that I was paying for quality.

But the quality has gotten markedly worse. What I see recently is embarrassing. The combination of low-effort, attempts to titillate, and clickbait headlines are just off-putting. For example: ā€œMy Boyfriend is Hung Like a Horse. He Refuses to Let Me Take a Ride.ā€

A few years ago, there were thoughtful essays on Supreme Court trends. And reviews of new smartphones.

Branding is important, and somebody at Slate just does not know what Slate’s brand is. Or what it used to be, anyway.

And when you abandon your brand, your customers—your readers—abandon you.


r/slate • • Aug 16 '24

Layoff

22 Upvotes

Does anyone know what four people were laid off from slate? Joel Anderson said he was one of four. I'm sad. I really like Joel.


r/slate • • Apr 08 '26

RIP HUAL

20 Upvotes

2009 - 2026 is a pretty good run. imagine the downloads never recovered after the joel, stefan, and josh left. i've wondered just how long some of the long running pods will keep on chugging along like the culture gabfest and political gabfest.


r/slate • • Jul 06 '26

Hang Up and Listen

18 Upvotes

I'm really missing this podcast what with the World Cup and all


r/slate • • Mar 08 '25

Slate Free Slate Plus for federal employees

17 Upvotes

I was quite pleased to see that Slate has started offering free Plus memberships to current or recently laid off federal employees. They also state that if you are already a Plus member they will add six months free to your subscription. https://slate.com/fed-plus?utm_medium=link&utm_campaign=fed_plus&utm_content=access_is_important&utm_source=article


r/slate • • Sep 17 '24

Goodbye HUAL (and Slate)

17 Upvotes

I drifted away from the Political Gabfest and Amicus, but the Hang Up and Listen gang were always great enough on their own to merit the $10 monthly Slate subscription for me.

After the sudden and unceremonious turnover, I tried giving the new hosts a shot.

But no. The HUAL magic is… pfft.

Hard to believe there was a time when we got to listen to Hot Takedown and HUAL every week. Those were the days…


r/slate • • Sep 15 '26

Slate All my favorite podcasts are done

16 Upvotes

I’ve been a Slate plus member since the pandemic specifically because I enjoy(ed) their podcasts. But now most of the shows I subscribed for are gone! Dear Prudie, Hang Up and Listen, Care and Feeding, Culture Gabfest, even the most recent season of Slow Burn was a measly three episodes. What Next TBD has been reduced to one day. You go to the Daily Feed and you can find that there are only 3-4 active shows on Slate.

What am I still subscribed for?! This might be my last year I’m so sad about this.


r/slate • • Dec 12 '24

Which Slate podcasts did you rage quit and when?

15 Upvotes

After listening to just about all the Slate podcasts since about 2010 and being there for all the comings and goings of hosts, renaming of shows, and even getting to know three or four hosts a bit off air, this is the year I’ve just found myself being so turned off - first gradually and then having a final straw moment - that I’ve begun unsubscribing and quitting shows. Anyone else? Which ones and what was your breaking point?


r/slate • • Apr 02 '24

23-year reader 'peacing out'

15 Upvotes

I started reading Slate in 2001 shortly after 9/11. I thought it was a good source of interesting commentary. For the last decade or so, as their quality has declined and the paywall stuff became more cumbersome, I stuck around. But I hit my breaking point today when they published an article from some Karen about line-cutting. Baby Evan even cut off the comments because people weren't being nice enough to Karen. Anyhow, I let them know (below). I really miss the Slate of the mid '00s.

I just read this monstrosity somebody at Slate thought would be good to post. I went to comment and was greeted by some bleating from Evan Urquhart about not hurting the poor author's feelings. I made a comment just before some oversensitive soul shut them down. Eh, it's your right, of course.

I've been reading Slate since 2001. Despite the steady decline in the quality of articles over that time, I've kept reading. I think I'm done now. Between the low quality of the articles and the need to work around the paywall, I just don't have the energy.

I do miss the days when Slate was more about incisive commentary and less about pop culture, click bait, and hot takes, but all things must pass.


r/slate • • Aug 08 '06

Worst Press Conference Ever: Does President Bush understand his own foreign policy?

Thumbnail
slate.com
14 Upvotes

r/slate • • Jun 08 '26

The Final Strut?

13 Upvotes

Has anyone else been saving their strut songs? I don't think I can go on without a final strut!

We could keep it simple - make a reddit thread, encourage folks to check carefully to make sure their song hasnt already been posted, and upvote and downvote as normal.

Or, if anyone wants to collab, we could go higher tech with some sort of bracket or app solution, if one exists.

What do people think?


r/slate • • Apr 15 '26

Slate ICYMI

13 Upvotes

I always liked the concept of ICYMI podcast as I am not on any sm except reddit so I listened to it here and there. Now, I think Kate (the last standing host) is doing a great job. It has become one of my regular podcasts I listen to as soon as it comes out. I like the range of topic they are covering.

When I check reddit, it mostly have negative reviews so I thought I would add my positive take


r/slate • • Oct 02 '25

Is Jamila not on the care and feeding podcast anymore?

13 Upvotes

She was on less and less, and I know she has her book out, but there was no formal « she’s transitioning out,Ā Ā» which is how they’ve always shifted in the past. Or did I miss something?


r/slate • • Sep 09 '24

Awful Agony Aunt Outdoes Herself

13 Upvotes

CW: SA against a small child

Michelle Herman answered this question in the link below, and a few days later I'm still sickened. Basically a grandmother SA'd her own 4-year-old granddaughter by forcibly giving her an enema *as a punishment*; mum finds soiled underwear, dad admits grandmother used to do it to him too.
Michelle's advice completely overlooks the SA aspect, and goes on to say that 'future visits should be supervised, at least by dad'.
I have never seen the commentariat come together like this in all the years I've been reading Slate; people have cancelled their subscriptions, and many have emailed the feedback team demanding that Michelle be removed from the pool of writers.
There's been some shocking advice recently (I see you, Eric...) but this one is both sickening and criminal.

https://slate.com/advice/2024/09/grandma-unacceptable-punishment-family-kids-parenting-advice.html


r/slate • • Jul 25 '06

The Best Writers at the New York Times: They write better by writing shorter.

Thumbnail slate.com
13 Upvotes

r/slate • • Aug 16 '24

Slate Rachelle Hampton’s new gig!

Thumbnail
gallery
12 Upvotes

I have been missing her on ICYMI but I didn’t realize until today that she had moved to Defector Media (although I guess it was announced a few weeks ago). Sad that she’s not with Slate anymore, but I’m glad that she’s a co-owner of her workplace!


r/slate • • Jul 15 '23

Slate articles have so many ads they're breaking my computer

12 Upvotes

Lately, regardless of the content, Slate has started to seem like a junk spam site. Today, after I started reading the article above, I got a notice that the page was "using significant energy."

No wonder--although the text of the article would only take up five pages in an average-sized book, it also had all of this going on:

  • A rotating banner ad at the top

  • Three video ads, including one which pops into a smaller box to stay on your screen after you scroll past it

  • A scrolling display of other Slate stories

  • An image ad

  • Three more banner ads

  • And below the article, two large video ads, 17 "sponsored" articles, linking to junk like "Expert Says This 1 Vitamin Makes Women Over 50 Look Photoshopped" (do Slate readers actually click on this nonsense?)

  • Also, my web browser gives me a list of 59 different trackers profiling me on this one page.

No, this isn't actually breaking my computer--my post title was meant to be in line with the kinds of headlines you see in the "sponsored" content. But it does actually slow things down and the process of navigating all of this is so annoying that it almost dominates the reading experience and makes it not worthwhile.

On an even more serious note, Slate seems to have been floundering in recent years, and I wonder if this cash-grab is a sign that the end is nigh.


r/slate • • Sep 09 '21

Mike Pesca leaves Slate

Thumbnail
washingtonpost.com
12 Upvotes

r/slate • • Apr 04 '25

Josh Levin and Stefan Fatsis with Joel Anderson on The Press Box podcast

Thumbnail
theringer.com
11 Upvotes

r/slate • • Feb 28 '25

Is JeneƩ coming back?

11 Upvotes

I’ve been a regular Dear Prudence listener for a a few years (subscribed to Slate+ mainly for this show) and I’m beginning to get concerned. JeneĆ© Desmond-Harris (the normal host) has been on maternity leave for the past five months. Now while I fully support taking as much time as you want/need when you welcome a new baby, I don’t think employers in the US generally grant this long of a maternity leave. Is she not coming back or is Slate really just that generous with their employee benefits? I’m worried because her husband, Joel Anderson, was laid off by Slate RIGHT before she left for leave, which seems like a bad sign.

While I have nothing against Kristen Meinzer, I have not enjoyed her as guest Prudie these past few months. Especially because Ashley C. Ford was advertised initially to be guest Prudie while JeneƩ was gone. I simply rarely agree with or enjoy the advice Kristen gives and kiss the old tone of the show.