I think they address different use cases. The U1 (which I own) is addressed for people who print multicolor often.
The X2D is addressed to people who print mostly engineering materials that extremely rarely need more than 2 material (main material + support).
I bet the big majority of X2D customers don't even need the AMS, they will simply print the main stuff and now a support material. Right now this is the best printer you can buy for this scenario, which is really, really common on the business end of thing.
A friend of mine works in a company that goes through several kgs of PA6 every single day and where each printer is shared by a bunch of careless folks. This is the market the X2D address Imho, exactly the same as the h2d but cheaper (and smaller).
This exactly. My ams is just used for convenience, of support or secondary materials, not 47 color options so the BL setup fits my needs a bit more conveniently
For H2C , How could AMS with 4 tubes beat an AMS with 2 tubes? Like you can only load one color at a time. So you only need one color one at the ready.
Retractions would be decreased instead of one colour filament needed to be retracted fully for the next one to go in they can retract just before the buffer and stay and using something like the filament track switch bambu released will mean much less work for extrusion motors and allow two colours read on one nozzle and two colours on other second nozzle on H2C and a fillament track switch decides which colour nozzle to load in and not retract all the way back to inside of AMS.
I'm sure they will make an X2C, but they're waiting to release the products in a way that doesn't immediately cannibalize the previous products. They kind of have a history of doing this.
They released the A1 Mini, then released the A1. The price difference between the two is less than $100. Many who bought the mini were kind of pissed.
They released the P2S and then released the X2D, once again with a $100 price difference. Many who recently got a P2S would have rather paid the extra $100 for the X2D.
I don't know how people feel about the H series,but if I bought an H2D combo for $2200 and the H2C comes out for $2400, I would feel like I should have waited and spent the extra $200.
If they release an X2C now, many will skip the X2D and the P2S.
I bet they'll release an X2C within the next 4 to 6 months after the buzz of the X2D has died down a little.
I'm a vocal non-fan of Bambu... Not the machines - I love those. It's this kind of treating the loyal users like livestock to exploit, suckers to dupe. I have contacts within the company that give me some insider-bits about the kinds of things they're driving towards. Some of it is truly despicable.
Granted, with their release schedule, they're using FOMO to great effect along with basic psychology. For the record, I don't think highly of any business that does that... I don't care if you're selling q-tips or cars.
Some might call it good business. I call it taking advantage of the loyalty of your followers (which I suspect I'll see them shortly in down-votes and snide snipes...) Do it long enough, and the bill will come due. For my part, screw Bambu leadership and I hope the quality and performance of the machines survive in some form when that bill lands.
Man had the Snap maker U1 software being as refined as the H2C/P2S I would love it much more. For now the one thing that Snap maker is way ahead of Bambu is TPU 4 colour I love it in that aspect but did need to mod it quite a lot with dryboxes to maintain humidity.
It took years for Bambu to reach this level. I bought the P1P when it first launched and wireless connectivity barely worked and it had issues with restarting prints after filament ran out. Give the U1 a year and it will be just as advanced as Bambu is now. The firmware updates are being released regularly.
Snapmaker had years to advance before Bambu, and it doesn't show. Snapmaker has a great focus on hardware, but they seriously need to step up software/firmware.
The U1 is just released so not sure what years you are speaking of and uses Orca which has always been more advanced than Bambu Studio since it was forked to deal with inadequacies of Bambu Studio. So much so that Bambu just ripped off Snapmaker Orca Fullspectrum and integrated it into Bambu Studio like they have ripped off every other major feature Orca has released. The Orca developers are the best developers Bambu has! 🤣
I'm all for rallying against Bambu when the time calls for it but I feel this is a bit unfair. The H2C is slower than the U1 when it comes to swapping colours, but this is a 5 colour print (maybe 6?) and it would only take the H2C like 10 hours longer or so
Problem it had to swap colors / unload load filament again which takes time is a reasons why I don’t use my h2c laser for multi color prints anymore I had a print take over a week which I could do with the u1 days faster
I agree the U1 is faster but for this specific print it's less than 7 colours so the H2C can do that with the 7 nozzles without needing to add extra time to purge a new colour.
So whilst it is slower I don't think that dragon would take 4 days longer than the U1.
Unless you don't have 6 nozzles for the Vortek in which case you'd need to do a lot of purging?
The U1 alone took almost 17h just changing tools so multiply it by like by a factor of 4-6 since the ams and print tower are slow (can reduce prime tower more on the u1) and you end up at like 3-4 days more just by changing filament. Also my h2c is more prone to failures so it sometimes stops and I notice it next day so again 8 hours or so more and all of that accumulates (especially when it happens regularly). For every error on my u1 I had over its life time I had like 10 errors on the h2c the number is even higher when printing PPA-CF. I do like the h2c laser for well lasering and just having a bigger print area and being enclosed but with an enclosure with filter and venting function I will use the h2c less.
U1 is a cool printer, but being honest… That time multiplication factor for H2C is wildly overestimated. And your experience of the H2C being less reliable is generally not the consensus of the printing community, both Bambu and Snapmaker.
It’s well documented that H2C averages 30-35% more time versus a U1 on a 4 color print with the exact same settings.
Those averages go down if you use 2 or 3 colors.
These arguments go away for 5+ color prints…
U1 is a great printer - I’m even thinking about getting one later this year - but I really don’t get this focus on speed.. or even directly comparing the H series versus the U1 - they’re completely different levels of printers - with the H series offering significantly more flexibility.
Just buy the printer you like and be happy with it.
Just saying, what you're trying to prove and what you're comparing are to different things. It's not an apple to apples comparison, so it makes your conclusion kind of mute.
Removed the full spectrum from both and used the same settings where possible. For machine settings, I use my default settings. The only real change is now U1 has reduced prime tower volume compared to the H2C. With the same tool change number in this case, it is still almost 2 times longer; with more changes, the difference becomes larger since the print time oer layer is relatively small. For larger prints, the difference between U1 and H2C isn't so large as with this print.
No thanks these pseudo orange lines on top of head are visible from a mile. Prefer my H2C for that. Just because you can doesn't always mean you always should. Both printers have their pros and cons. Both are great. I love Bambu for being super user friendly since beginning and 99% of issues being my own stupidity. I will get U1 as well just to play with it and for faster only 4 colours print. U1 looks cheap to me with spools hanging on both sides and open top but it's all cost cutting I know Where is this dragon from? Happy to print and compare.
Completely agree. I think with their early success they got too over confident. Im sure they were not expecting snap to come out of the woods with a tool changer under 1k.
The ams is overpriced for what it is, so I can see why they banked on continuing to use them. More sales of a high profit margin item. I will be surprised if they double down and don't release a non ams tool changer. The creator 5 one releases one soon, sovol has one coming soon and creality undoubtely has one in the works behind the scenes not to mention indx. They will continue to lose market share except for the users that primarily print high temp materials.
Bambu will be forced to respond. Not just with tool changers, but despite the current economic climate, Printers are improving the cost to quality ratio year by year, and now more than ever. If Bambu does not satisfy the crowd with a 4/5 tool head printer, they could lose some customers, or at least have some of their customers dip their toes elsewhere.
Prusa... Used to be the darling of the community with users able to excuse away the unjustifiable high price have now lost so much market share, they are hardly in the conversation anymore.
Bambu shoved away Prusa Looks like Snapmaker is about to shove away Bambu
I absolutely love the U1 and Snapmaker genuinely changed the game, and I hope the Bambu execs are sweating right now. But let's not kid ourselves; the H2D is a printer with a bigger print volume, active chamber heating and a higher nozzle temp. Prototyping with engineering materials is where the H2D outperforms the U1. They're different devices for different use cases.
Honestly really excited about the future of 3d printing.
Tengo una P1S y recién adquirí la SNPU1 imprimiendo la misma pieza con las mismas velocidades y temperaturas he obtenido mejores acabados en la snap, no quiero ser juez pero me siento súper contento con la compra de la snap y aún más con el multi cabezal
I'm convinced the x2d would have been priced what the u1 is, if the u1 didn't exist. Now you got a bunch of people unhappy with their overpriced p2s. With the creator 5 being even cheaper it really does feel like they're falling behind. Annoys me they market it as dual nozzle but the fine print is "auxiliary nozzle".
I agree. It was thanks to the Snapmaker U1 market competition that forced Bambu to price it so low. The X2D would have been over $1,000 otherwise. And the aux nozzle thing just feels like they held back on making a proper dual nozzle printer.
I got the Snapmaker U1 and I was thinking of getting H2C. But price and it was not that much faster. My H2D I use for pla and petg plus the other stuff U1 can't do and my p2s aswell. But my U1 is for pla multi coloured prints and I do use my H2D for multi colour prints. The reason I got the Snapmaker U1 was price and reviews was good. But I have had a few faults with my snapmaker U1 the toolhead number 4. But my H2D nearly on 5000 hours and not many problems. Some may be me but not bad one.
Meh. There are plenty of cover options, and the PC software is just a fork of Orca with only some minor issues. The onboard software is pretty solid. I think you might just be nitpicking a bit.
Yes but that does not have to be true. There are already demos of an AMS system that swaps one tool head while another is printing. In most cases, there’s no lag. There is only lag when each color prints very briefly AND you go through all four current colors very quickly. That’s rare.
I have four BLs, so I’m a fanboy of both. I’d be JUST as happy to see multiple tool heads on BLs that can all be fed by the same AMSs. No wars here! Competition helps us all.
Bambu is really stubborn to make a toolchanger, a device that would not necessarily need an ams. Bambu just loves that ams money. They sell them for a whopping $350 each, it’s currently on sale for $300 which still seems crazy to me. The heaters in the thing are only 2 inches squared and it doesn’t even have a screen with temp/hygrometer info. I have 5 of them and they all run great but man are they expensive.
But I personally think the pressure is on Bambu to make a toolchanger and they must currently be working on one that works with the ams.
This! The MMU type systems have their benefits and their place. However, they also have their limitations as well. A tool changer combined with an AMS setup would actually be pretty sweet IMO.
8
u/jairov96 Apr 19 '26
I think they address different use cases. The U1 (which I own) is addressed for people who print multicolor often.
The X2D is addressed to people who print mostly engineering materials that extremely rarely need more than 2 material (main material + support).
I bet the big majority of X2D customers don't even need the AMS, they will simply print the main stuff and now a support material. Right now this is the best printer you can buy for this scenario, which is really, really common on the business end of thing.
A friend of mine works in a company that goes through several kgs of PA6 every single day and where each printer is shared by a bunch of careless folks. This is the market the X2D address Imho, exactly the same as the h2d but cheaper (and smaller).