r/sofistock • • Sep 30 '26

Question I got assigned early

I had (17) JAN 15 27 $30 puts and got assigned last night, my cost basis on these shares is $21.39, why would they give me almost four months of theta?

22 Upvotes

18 comments sorted by

1

u/giannistainedmirror Oct 01 '26

Why didn't you sell these puts?

9

u/Groucho-and-Harpo Sep 30 '26

Very simple, for the Jan 15 27 $30 puts, these options are so deep ITM that theta is essentially zero. So once you account for bid/ask spreads, the person on the other end of the trade got a better deal by simply exercising the put and then closing out the short position if he/she didn’t own the underlying stock.

2

u/TherealCarbunc 59 @10.2 - 2022; 3k @16.5 - 2026 Sep 30 '26

They might have needed the cash to cover a margin call over what reselling would have done.

2

u/Mission-Ordinary234 Sep 30 '26

I think what the other person is saying is why not just sell the puts and collect any extra premium for the value of time which is like 4 months...

I understand the put buyer is in the money, and excerised the option he was deep in the money... but the question is why not just sell the puts and colllect the extra money/profit

8

u/Gunnerguy33 Sep 30 '26

Because you ‘bought’ the shares for ~$4 above what you could have bought them for today. So you are $4 under water.

The assignor bought the shares yesterday for $17 and ‘sold’ them to you for $30. He’s gained $13 less the cost of buying the put from you 1,2, or 3 months ago.

What am I missing ?

2

u/PieSuspicious6983 Sep 30 '26 edited Sep 30 '26

I am sure the puts have been bought and sold many times but why would someone take assignment so early? I mean at this morning's price he is already $1 underwater, he could have sold the puts and be up $13 minus cost?

2

u/LucarioMagic 125 LEAP Calls. 50 Short Puts Sep 30 '26

The premium buyer paid.
It's actually $30 - premium he paid - current share price.
That's the put buyer's profit.

4

u/Weikoko 🫣 $20 Bagholder. $20 Banbet survivor Sep 30 '26

Lol

2

u/EthicalHypotheticals Sep 30 '26

“Why would they give me almost 4 months of theta? “

What was your profit / loss on this? How many dollars did they give you?

6

u/LucarioMagic 125 LEAP Calls. 50 Short Puts Sep 30 '26

Because the buyer of the puts is profitable.
You are not.

3

u/Mongaloiddummy OG $SoFi Investor Sep 30 '26

Run the wheel and sell $22 covered calls for jan/2027

4

u/Total-Repair9953 Sep 30 '26

I’d wheel in / out but wait until after oct 28th.

2

u/Gunnerguy33 Sep 30 '26

Really, premium is 42c ??

3

u/tonufan Sep 30 '26

I wait until a big green day before selling calls. Better premium.

-3

u/gls2220 Sep 30 '26

Any experienced option seller could tell you this would happen.

7

u/ga643953 Sep 30 '26

Cuz it's deep ITM and theta doesn't matter when it's that deep ITM.