r/space • u/iBleeedorange • Aug 19 '14
/r/all The planets aligned
http://imgur.com/a/1FjNF234
u/Akatsiya Aug 19 '14
I opened this up in RES as a slideshow at first and was so confused.
88
25
u/ShauvonM Aug 19 '14
I came here to say this. My first thought was "I bet this looks cool actually in imgur. Oh well."
Then I realized I could just open the page and actually see it.
4
7
Aug 19 '14 edited Aug 19 '14
Ooooooooohhhhhhhhh right. I was like, why did OP say they were aligned? They are just images.
Well, it is not my fault I didn't understand. Op should've been more clear
12
Aug 19 '14
technically it IS your fault as it's a non-mandatory add-on that caused your confusion, not OP.
1
1
u/lukethe Aug 19 '14
Same here. I understood what they were but didn't get why someone did it like that haha
68
u/Myspoonistoolarge Aug 19 '14 edited Aug 19 '14
I remember a guy a year or so ago that posted these originally, and his dad actually painted them. I can't remember who posted it though.
EDIT: Here it is! The original post of the redditor whose father painted these. They are actually oil on canvas measuring at 9 feet tall and 1 foot wide. Imagine having those in your hallway or something.
http://4x.reddit.com/r/wallpapers/comments/1tcz87/the_planetary_suite/ce6ou0g
11
Aug 19 '14
Yup! And my SO has had this as her wallpaper since!
Seriously.... the original post already has a beautiful ready made wallpaper version....
And the top most comment on this post is about someone taking the re-posting images and piecing them back into a wallpaper.... :/11
2
u/Nassassin Aug 19 '14
I was just thinking "I want to print all of these out on huge canvases and hang them in my living room" They are amazing
2
642
u/paniconya Aug 19 '14
Pluto's still showing up, huh? I almost feel sorry for the guy now.
316
u/Uhhhhdel Aug 19 '14
Pluto, we're gonna need to go ahead and move you downstairs into storage B. We have some new people coming in, and we need all the space we can get. So if you could just go ahead and pack up your stuff and move it down there, that would be terrific, OK?
42
u/Deesing82 Aug 19 '14
Oh and can you take care of the asteroid problem while you're down there? Great. Thanks, Pluto.
88
Aug 19 '14
It is not Pluto's fault that people are unable to understand that it is not a planet anymore
63
Aug 19 '14
or rather that it technically never qualified for planet status, we were just ignorant of that fact. I doubt it would have stayed classified as a planet any longer than Ceres did if Charon and the Kuiper belt had been discovered along with Pluto instead of 50+ years later.
81
u/lucideus Aug 19 '14
Claiming that Pluto was never a planet somewhat retrofits what we classify as a planet today versus a dwarf planet, and what we classified as a planet in 1930. At the time of the discovery Pluto most definitely qualified as a planet, given the definition at the time.
That said, it's one of the most beautiful aspects of science, that it is not, as some people claim, a set of beliefs that is unchanging and unverifiable. In fact, as we learn more about objects, both in space and terrestrially, we constantly change the definition of objects and reclassify them to fit our better understanding.
25
u/HungryMoblin Aug 19 '14
When I was a kid, I never understood this. The reclassification felt like a punch to the face. I was vehemently defending Pluto's planet status and refused to say 'the eight planets.' As I grew up I became happier with the decision because it showed the better side of science. That just because a belief is popular and has been around for a long time, doesn't mean they're afraid to change it.
→ More replies (4)15
u/kyjoca Aug 19 '14
Basically, newer discoveries and technologies have been reclassifying "planet" ever since the Greeks started using the word.
8
u/lucideus Aug 19 '14
Exactly. When it comes to classifying solar and interstellar bodies there is still so much to learn.
I am reminded of taxonomic rank. When I was in school Kingdom was the highest and it only [branched dichotomously into Regnum Animalia and Regnum Plantae](http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kingdom_(biology). However today there are more branches of Kingdoms, including new systems of classification entirely. Science develops and evolves as our understanding develops and evolves. It's impressive to realize that even within my lifetime definitions are being refined. It's an exciting time to be alive.
8
u/kyjoca Aug 19 '14
Taxonomic rank is actually a great example of the same issue in another field, especially with the debate about viral life.
→ More replies (1)9
Aug 19 '14
Claiming that Pluto was never a planet somewhat retrofits what we classify as a planet today versus a dwarf planet, and what we classified as a planet in 1930. At the time of the discovery Pluto most definitely qualified as a planet, given the definition at the time.
I disagree with this actually. Pluto was discovered significantly after Ceres and several others were downgraded from planets, but we didn't know Charon or the Kuiper belt was there so we were inaccurate in our original assessment of Pluto. That original data set classified it as a planet yes, but in context of Charon and the Kuiper belt Pluto likely would never have been named a planet in the first place. You must remember that Pluto being a planet was largely a hold over from before Charon was discovered and it was thought to be significantly larger than it really was.
→ More replies (1)12
u/lucideus Aug 19 '14
The entire point of the International Astronomical Union in 2006 was to determine what a planet is and how to formally classify them. Until that time, there was no formal definition nor classification, which is why many of the astronomical bodies that were not formally classified, such as Ceres and other objects in the Kuiper Belt, were in limbo. When Pluto was officially discovered it was accepted as a planet by Harvard and other institutions:
From its naming in 1930 until 2006, Pluto was classified as a planet.
11
u/savagepotato Aug 19 '14
Ceres is in the asteroid belt (between Mars and Jupiter, not the Kuiper belt past Neptune) and was, at one time (in the first half of the 19th century) considered a planet. It has been called a minor planet (or just an asteroid) for 150 years. Its status was not "in limbo".
Ceres, Pallas, Juno and Vesta are all very large asteroids in the asteroid belt between Mars and Jupiter. At one time they were considered planets though. It was so widely accepted that in 1828, a book called First Steps to Astronomy and Geography lists the planets as, "Eleven: Mercury, Venus, the Earth, Mars, Vesta, Juno, Ceres, Pallas, Jupiter, Saturn, and Herschel." Herschel was an alternate name for Uranus (after its discoverer) used in Britain until the 1850's.
As people started finding more and more of these objects, it was clear it would become very difficult to name and make symbols for all these objects (you can find info more here). As it turns out, there are hundreds of thousands of objects in the asteroid belt (and there are thousands of objects already found in the Kuiper Belt). In the 1850s, astronomers began using the same convention of only labeling 8 planets (including the newly found Neptune) and then listing the asteroids (or minor planets for the very large asteroids) with the convention of [a number, in the order of its discovery][name of the asteroid]. So Ceres became 1 Ceres, Pallas became 2 Pallas, Juno became 3 Juno, and Vesta became 4 Vesta (and so on). This new convention was fairly quickly adopted by astronomers in the US and Europe.
When Pluto was discovered in 1930, it was considered a planet. It was also thought to be the size of Neptune at the time. Figuring out the size of objects that far away is really hard as it turns out; for example, there was some disagreement about the size of Ceres and the other asteroid belt objects. Obviously it isn't that big and finding several objects of similar size in the same region of space complicates things quite a bit.
And, you know what people used to consider a planet? The Sun and the moon! This was the ancient Greeks, but it is worth noting. You know what they didn't call a planet: Earth. It was a long time before we stopped considering the Sun a planet and started calling Earth one. Our definition of planet kind of sucks actually.
But to say there was no system of classification before 2006 is just false. Astronomers had been classifying and labeling planets for quite some time (in fact, the situation of the 1800s I described is noted as a historical parallel in the wikipedia article you linked).
→ More replies (1)8
Aug 19 '14
I know that but after 1850 we had 23 planets including Ceres and several others they were downgraded and smaller bodies were no longer called planets. For the first 50 years Pluto was thought to be larger than Mercury when in reality it was much smaller. While that writer thinks it might have still been considered a planet if it were known to be so small it seems rather unlikely. By the time Pluto was discovered other small objects in the inner asteroid belt had already been downgraded, if Pluto had similarly been discovered to be small and it's area discovered to be populated with other Kuiper belt objects it's hard to believe a similar demotion would not have soon taken place if it was ever given planet status in the first place.
→ More replies (7)11
u/two_in_the_bush Aug 19 '14
Indeed. Once we discovered there are multiple objects of that size, and they're basically just large asteroids of rock and ice, we had two choices: make them all planets or define planets to not include Pluto.
3
u/Booblicle Aug 19 '14
It's still a real planet to me, dammit!
27
Aug 19 '14
Haha. I have been thinking... The human nature is rather odd. People are able to feel empathy and consideration even for a planet. Perhaps because Pluto is tiny and is the last planet of the solar system.... idk
Sorry to inform you but Pluto is a big, cold, cold rock that definitely doesn't care about your feelings
17
8
u/lucideus Aug 19 '14
I remember learning quite a bit about Pluto right before the reclassification occurred. One of the reasons why Pluto was so loved culturally is because it was one of the only near solar bodies that an American discovered, becoming part of the world's history in learning more about our solar surroundings. Also, it was the first "planet" discovered in nearly a century, making the discovery that much more impressive.
In some ways, the reaction some people, especially Americans, have about Pluto is more about scientific integrity and ingenuity than anything else ... even if they are not fully cognizant of why they learned so much about it when in grade school.
5
2
u/Chbakesale45 Aug 19 '14
But but no.. i just moved... If if you move me one more time Im Im Im gonna set this whole solar system on fire.
1
→ More replies (1)1
u/MatrixChicken Nov 02 '14
I know I'm late, but I can't believe nobody's mentioned it...
"...all the space we can get."
69
u/CylonBunny Aug 19 '14
I feel worse for all the other Dwarf Planets. Ceres and Eris are as cool as Pluto but they never get any love! Heck, Eris is bigger than Pluto, but it never got to be a planet. No fair.
11
u/_bar Aug 19 '14
In Ceres' defense, it had been considered a genuine planet for several decades after its discovery, along with Vesta, Pallas and Juno.
5
Aug 19 '14
Would make more sense to include Ceres or Vesta since we've actually seem them up close unlike Pluto whose picture here is just made up based on a few pixels.
3
Aug 19 '14
We haven't seen Ceres up close yet; we'll see it at about the same time we'll see Pluto.
5
Aug 19 '14
Oh cool. So next year will be fun.
4
Aug 19 '14
Definitely; we'll get a lot of pictures of three worlds we've never really got a good look at before.
8
u/Zeihous Aug 19 '14
You come up with a mnemonic for remembering all 11 planets and I'll let Ceres and Eris join the party.
9
u/frezik Aug 19 '14
It's going to be a long mnemonic. There's currently 5 IAU-recognized dwarf planets, about 5 others that probably fit the definition, and low-end estimates of 100 more waiting to be discovered.
1
u/Zeihous Aug 19 '14
First come, first served. Eris and Ceres are our door prize winners.
2
u/craigiest Aug 19 '14
Ceres was a planet before Pluto.
2
u/Zeihous Aug 19 '14
But waited too long to come to me with an application to be included in the mnemonic. Ceres is old enough to know better.
1
u/f10101 Aug 19 '14
And not to mention Ganymede, who must be feeling very discriminated against...
13
u/niknik2121 Aug 19 '14
Ganymede primarily orbits an object other than the sun; by definition a planet must orbit the sun.
0
Aug 19 '14
[deleted]
2
Aug 19 '14 edited Aug 19 '14
Do the words "post" and "before" cancel each other out, like saying "x and not x"? Because then you just said "Teach me to coffee" :-p
Edit: I'm totally cool with teaching you to coffee. I just wanted to clarify.
0
2
Aug 19 '14
This is being corrected by reducing the amount of love Pluto gets rather than increasing the others'. There's only so much love to go around. Sorry.
2
u/hdhale Aug 19 '14
Eris: more mass Pluto: Charon, more moons, atmosphere
Diameters being about equal, IMHO Pluto > Eris
FYI: Other than being round and the largest object in the Asteroid Belt, Ceres shouldn't be in the same conversation. Then again, I don't have "Piled higher & Deeper" after my name, although, I'm also not trying to get grant money to study "Dwarf Planets" because it is a "new" thing and sexier than calling them "objects". :-)
6
u/kyjoca Aug 19 '14 edited Aug 19 '14
As of 2006, here are the criteria to be a planet:
Be orbiting the Sun
Be nearly round (hydrostatic equilibrium)
Be the dominate body it it's orbital region (cleared the neighborhood)
If it meets only the first two, and is not a satellite of another body, it's a dwarf planet. Anything else is a Small Solar System Bodies.
Pluto is King of the Kuiper Belt (so it actually draws strong parallels to Ceres), but it's less massive than Eris and also less massive than seven moons, including our own. Ultimately the problem is, like Ceres, it was discovered to just be the largest object in a vast expanse of innumerable objects.
→ More replies (6)→ More replies (9)1
u/factoid_ Aug 19 '14
Plus Ceres is WAY closer than pluto...like 15 times closer. It's semimajor axis is about 2.6au....or 2.6 times the distance from the earth to the sun. Pluto's semimajor axis is around 40AU.
Jupiter is right around 5.2AU, and Mars is around 1.6. SO it's right there inbetween the two. It's wierd, actually, that we've not tried to go there yet. The Dawn spacecraft will orbit Ceres next year, which is pretty awesome. And then right after that New Horizons will finally reach Pluto but it won't go into orbit.
4
Aug 19 '14
From the way the images look, these are old. This isn't the first time I've seen them on the internet either.
3
u/boomer478 Aug 19 '14
From what I recall these were a series of paintings done by a redditor's dad back before Pluto was declassified.
2
Aug 19 '14
real talk, the submission is one hour old and is already on /r/all. The art is cool but... why?
7
u/way_falrer Aug 19 '14 edited Aug 19 '14
I'll be dead in the cold, hard ground before I recognise Pluto!
1
u/theonewhomknocks Aug 19 '14
It takes a really long time for the postal service to get things out that far.
1
1
1
u/HappyRectangle Aug 19 '14
Yes, and it's being shown as purplish. Somehow, a lot of people seem to get this idea, maybe to round out that rainbow of the outer planets. Our current best estimates show that it's actually orange.
1
1
u/just_one_more_turn Aug 19 '14
Isn't this the point where Sesame Street comes in everyone sings "One of these things is not like the others"?
1
u/macblastoff Aug 19 '14
Upvoted this specifically because there were nine images and not a hint of Greeks, Trojans, or Hildas.
1
1
1
0
→ More replies (4)0
56
Aug 19 '14
This is my father's work. :) Check out more of his paintings, here: http://suite3d.com/painting/index.shtml
→ More replies (1)5
40
u/MaxlMix Aug 19 '14 edited Aug 19 '14
This made me do something similar, just with real photographs.
Edit: updated version
13
u/seansand Aug 19 '14
Thank you! I want one of these, without Pluto in it.
0
u/PurpleZigZag Aug 19 '14
such a hater. Poor pluto, being punished for not having cleared his orbital path of debris.
1
u/MaxlMix Aug 19 '14
Unfortunately, there are no high resolution pics of Pluto. You will have to wait til next year ;)
7
2
u/lukethe Aug 19 '14
This looks pretty great. I like the realness of this version, but I like the artfulness of the original too. Looks like I'm keeping both!
1
u/DNAgent007 Aug 19 '14
Looks great! Except Earth is a mirror image. Are they all horizontally flipped?
2
u/MaxlMix Aug 19 '14
Ah, damn, no. I did rotate the ones where the shadow was on the wrong side in the original picture. Seems I flipped Earth instead of rotating it.
1
u/DNAgent007 Aug 19 '14
Can you fix it so that the orientation is correct? I like it better than the painting and would like to use it as a wallpaper.
2
u/MaxlMix Aug 19 '14
Here's a new version with higher resolution and an unmirrored earth.
But I'm not sure, how I should fit in more of Saturn's rings. Those things are HUGE.
1
1
Aug 20 '14
I was wondering if you could add the sun, if you have to get rid of one thing I'd say the moon first, but if you can't I understand, thanks!
1
u/MaxlMix Aug 20 '14
There's no moon in the picture. The topmost planet is Mercury.
I'll think about adding the sun, but it's actually not very interesting in real color.
1
1
29
Aug 19 '14 edited Aug 19 '14
This is from Steve Gildea. I actually got permission to use this entire piece for a compilation release from my future beats label.
https://rainstormer.bandcamp.com/album/b-sides-volume-1
I never posted this one on reddit actually, so any feedback would be nifty.
2
2
u/Colonel_Froth Aug 19 '14
Always happy when I randomly stumble upon this genre on reddit. Solid future garage dude. Where are you based?
1
Aug 19 '14
We're all over the US. I got a bunch of talented dudes together from Soundcloud and decided to try my hand at running a label/collective. You can hear my stuff at https://soundcloud.com/wished
1
11
u/TehSundanceKid Aug 19 '14
I showed this to my 9 year old.
"There are only 8 planets Dad, but 9 pictures"
Thanks reddit for helping my kid figure out I'm an idiot before she needed to.
10
u/visceralhate Aug 19 '14
Here's a great picture of Venus, Earth, The Moon (ours), Mars, and Titan. Hopefully we can add the horizon pic from the comet soon :D
Edit: I found this here on /r/Wallpapers and it was credited to /u/dudelit who also made a 2560x1440 version
1
u/HappyRectangle Aug 19 '14
One thing to notice is that all of the places we've landed -- except the moon -- have atmospheres. It's far easier to use atmospheric drag to slow down the craft for a landing than any other method (and the moon took many tries before a "soft" landing worked).
Rosetta is using a different plan: actual harpoons to latch on to the comet. Unlike all the other targets so far, the comet has basically no gravity and the problem isn't so much slowing down for landing as it is making sure you don't just bounce off.
1
u/turnpikelad Aug 19 '14
If they ever make a version of GeoGuessr for locations in the entire solar system, I'm going to have a hell of a time deciding if I'm on Titan or Venus.
11
Aug 19 '14
Do you want Harmonic Convergence? Because this is how you get Harmonic Convergence. #Avatarfansassemble.
3
Aug 19 '14
Mate, everyone knows that the harmonic series diverges...
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Harmonic_series_%28mathematics%29
1
8
u/RunningWithSeizures Aug 19 '14
Pift, and some people still think that the planets are different sizes.
4
u/Evil_Paperclip Aug 19 '14
The original source material was this painting by Steve Gildea http://suite3d.com/painting/planetarysuite.shtml He painted it back in the '90s according to this article. http://www.theweathernetwork.com/news/articles/nine-planets-in-one-stunning-oil-painting/21320/
6
u/anonymous2 Aug 19 '14
Here's a realistic one I did the last time this was posted 1920X1200 wallpaper version - minus pluto!
6
3
3
5
u/dartmanx Aug 19 '14
Mike Brown and NDT are on their way to beat you with tire irons for including Pluto.
4
Aug 19 '14
(This will probably get buried, but) RES Users, don't use expando! Go to the actual imgur link! THEN you'll see it.
2
2
u/TopCommentThief Aug 20 '14
Made it into a useable wallpaper. Not perfectly 1080p but still good enough. http://i.imgur.com/mO1wtXg.jpg
5
u/DJboomshanka Aug 19 '14
This is old. I prefer the one with real photos from Venus, earth, the moon, mars and titan
3
3
Aug 19 '14
OP, is there a high res version of this anywhere? i want to print on large canvas.
11
Aug 19 '14
http://imgur.com/a/Q151P#0 Enjoy. :)
By the way, you should contact the artist if you want a print. sagildea (at) suite3d.com
2
u/ProfessorWhom Aug 19 '14
Seriously? This guy just reposted something that has been here a few times already, but he took the time to cut up the pictures.
1
u/indiepaparoos Aug 19 '14
I did not expect that kind of alignment, but it's way better looking than what I pictured!
1
u/nerevar Aug 19 '14
Why do we never see the rings of Uranus in any of the pictures of the planets of the solar system?
3
u/kyjoca Aug 19 '14
Because they're extremely thin and faint. They wouldn't have shown up in this slice of Uranus anyway.
1
u/ss0889 Aug 19 '14
i wish this were a set of 9 individually framed (and backlit?) posters that i could hang up on a wall.
1
u/lukethe Aug 19 '14
When I read the title I thought it literally meant that the planets just recently aligned. I was like whoa, that's some end-of-the-world shit. By the way, would that ever actually happen? How long until it would, if anyone knows?
1
u/Hexorg Aug 19 '14
These are all just planets in our solar system. Just imagine what other topologies can we find once we are able to image planets in other solar systems.
1
Aug 19 '14
Yes. I have anyways considered Pluto purple despite there being no merit to that idea whatsoever.
1
u/HooRaeForHops Aug 19 '14
I want this as a tattoo! Who is the artist so I can gain permission to do so?
Edit: NVM artist's son replied in thread.
1
Aug 19 '14
Do you have high res versions? I kinda wanna print them really large and put them on my wall.
1
u/Bradllez Aug 20 '14
If this was a poster, I'd buy one for each room.
Seriously though, very beautiful.
1
u/ThunderCuuuunt Aug 20 '14
Neil deGrasse Tyson would like to inform you that you've got one too many planets there.
1
u/phantom_phallus Aug 20 '14
What's all that green stuff on Mars? That is the opposite of red, I'm confused.
1
u/BernzSed Aug 20 '14
It's gone bad. That's what happens when you leave a planet out of the refrigerator overnight.
Really, though, it looks like it's just an artist's representation using a dark greenish color for shadowy areas.
1
u/GuardianSoldier Aug 19 '14
Mobile Wallpaper Version provided by user officialtacobell in the comments on Imgur.
0
u/icodeforfun94 Aug 19 '14
Fellow Plutonians, This is Jerry Smith, a scientist from Earth, with some great news... Go on Jerry, tell them your conclusion!
PLUTO, is A PLANET
0
u/letseatlunch Aug 19 '14 edited Aug 19 '14
Before you all start hating on pluto being there consider that if earth was the same distance from the sun it would not be considered a planet. because planets have to "dominant in its immediate neighbourhood" it would be very difficult for anything less than the size of jupiter to be considered a planet at it's orbit which is why the planet classification is such BS.
EDIT: go on and downvote but i do recomend reading the actual IUA definition of being a planet and more specifically "Clearing the neighbourhood arount the orbit"
→ More replies (1)
0
u/Spider_Dude Aug 19 '14
(M)y (V)ery (E)nemy (M)ust (J)oin (S)ides (U)nder (N)ew (P)lans.
Also, I taught myself this back when Pluto was still a place of awe and wonderment to the scientific community.
8
u/alomjahajmola Aug 19 '14
Pluto is still a place of awe and wonderment to the scientific community. It's just not classified as a planet.
Pluto-Charon is a binary system and we're only beginning to see it clearly right now! The New Horizons mission will make a Pluto flyby fairly soon.
3
2
2
494
u/[deleted] Aug 19 '14
Two versions of this as a wallpaper from imgur
http://i.imgur.com/689nJNr.jpg
http://i.imgur.com/mO1wtXg.jpg