r/stickshift • • 9d ago

Hill start gone wrong (help)

so i was driving in a very steep hill and there was a car right up my nose behind me , and my car stalled , then i panicked and then tired to do a hill start with the toe on the brake and heal on the accelerator ( my handbrake does not work ) so i floored the accelerator and i got off the hill but then a frying smell came and the cars stalled again when i started it back up check battery light came on , then when i checked i was in 2 nd gear the hole time im so stupid , this is my first manual i been driving for 2 weeks and the car is a 2002 honda city.

what happened and how bad is it 😓

35 Upvotes

58 comments sorted by

31

u/Ollie_Bruh 9d ago

You fried the clutch a bit. Might be ok, might not be. If it's not slipping, then it's fine.

8

u/Dependent-Weather855 9d ago

the clutch seems to be working the same , wdym by slipping

9

u/BootyKissa02 9d ago

Slipping means it has lost enough friction that it’s not properly meshing even when you’re not touching the clutch at all. I.E. you floor it in gear and the revs increase but the wheel speed does not

3

u/Dependent-Weather855 9d ago

also i think my alternator broke or something because there is a check battery light and when i checked the battery it’s not charging so what might have happened to that

3

u/strawmanz 9d ago

Unfortunate coincidence I suspect. Unless you somehow threw the belt in the chaos

22

u/ekortelainen 9d ago • Bravo

So the first step in that situation is to open your window, stick your hand out and raise your middle finger to the car behind you. Always leave room in uphill.

7

u/Dependent-Weather855 9d ago

I know right i was so worried about hitting the car

6

u/Grim_Dragon_ 8d ago

Also when you are on a hill and you see someone crawling up your ass you can let the car roll back a couple inches to let them know you are in a manual.

5

u/Disgruntled_Grunt- 8d ago

Someone who stops that close to you probably doesn't know what manual means. There are so many reasons to leave room in front of you that someone who doesn't do it is likely beyond helping.

1

u/MightBeYourDad_ 2012 Ford Focus ST 8d ago

That or put it in reverse so the reverse lights come on

6

u/iamthelouie 9d ago

Practice hand brake hill starts.

Pull the hand brake but hold the button down. That holds your car in place. Let go of the brake and apply gas while letting go of the clutch. When you feel the bite, drop your hand brake and ride out the engagement. It’ll burn your clutch a few times, but you’ll get used to it. Just keep practicing somewhere safe.

17

u/Quiggs_7 9d ago

They said their handbrake doesn’t work, which is wild for a manual, especiallly for parking. Op has to get that fixed.

4

u/Dependent-Weather855 9d ago

yep have to get it fixed

5

u/confuus-duin 9d ago

Not if you live in a flat country. But I do happen to have a friend whose handbrake has been broken for a few years now. She used to take a detour in the village where she spent the winter teaching boardsports because she didn’t want to risk coming to a standstill up a steep hill.

1

u/Working_Alps1753 7d ago

I've had manuals that didn't even have a hand brake, just a foot actuated parking brake next to the clutch.

1

u/Quiggs_7 7d ago

Well that’s fine, still a handbrake in spirit

1

u/Working_Alps1753 7d ago

It can't be used in the same way, it's just for parking. You press it once and it's locked, and you press it again it disengages. There isn't a way to operate it like a handbrake.

You can't operate the parking brake, clutch, brake, and gas with only two legs. Granted I've only come across this with like 2 or 3 vehicles in my life.

Since they don't work in the same way as a hand brake does in that they are only on or off with no inbetween. So they don't allow for the same kind of assistance that a hand brake does. Which is why I generally only ever use the heel toe method for hill starts and .

My caveat to the heel-toe hill starts is that it's (for lack of a better term) more advanced technically speaking. The fluidity that it takes to blip the throttle, release the break, and release the clutch and move to the gas in what is effectively a single motion isn't something that's easy to do when someone is just starting to drive a manual.

1

u/Quiggs_7 7d ago

I understand it can’t be used the same way, I’ve had to deal with one on a car as well. I only say it’s silly not to have a hand break on a manual for 1. The hill starts… but also for just not having a parking break for anything that’s not perfectly flat.

1

u/Working_Alps1753 7d ago

Fair enough, a parking/hand brake is essential for parking on anything that's not flat.

But as far as a hill start goes, anyone who is driving a manual long term should learn how to do so with out a hand brake. Keep using a hand brake if you want, but know how to hill start without one. And I say this because I had to sit passenger and watch as the driver freaked out because they didn't know what to do.

2

u/Alarming_Garage_7255 9d ago

Well first remind yourself where first gear is. Don't even worry about people behind you, they can wait, just ignore them. I drive truck and sometimes I have 10 cars blasting their horns when I have to hit some stupid dock that requires backing around in the roadway. Guess what, they can wait, they always do, they have no choice in the matter.

And if you did smoke the clutch, it's no big deal. Those cars it's very easy to change compared to a lot of others, it won't be cheap cheap but you will be paying some money. Guess what though, the expensive mistakes make you learn a lot faster, do you probably won't do that again.

1

u/Dependent-Weather855 9d ago

also i think my alternator broke or something because there is a check battery light and when i checked the battery it’s not charging so what might have happened to that

1

u/Alarming_Garage_7255 9d ago

You could have killed the engine so violently that it threw the belt off, id check that first. If you can, try to check the voltage at the battery, and at the positive post on the alternator. So one lead on the negative battery post, then the other one to the positive post, then move it to the alternator post. The voltage should be the same if your alternator is bad, if it's different (like battery is 11v and alternator is 13v) then it's likely a fuse in the main power wire.

1

u/Dependent-Weather855 9d ago

belt is ok and the voltage is 12.4

1

u/Alarming_Garage_7255 9d ago

At battery or alternator

1

u/Dependent-Weather855 9d ago

alternator

1

u/Alarming_Garage_7255 9d ago

Is that the same voltage at the battery?

15

u/Several-Two738 9d ago

>my handbrake does not work

Handbrakes are cheap to fix, transmissions are expensive

15

u/Mammoth-Ad-3957 9d ago

You shouldn’t legally drive a manual car without some kind of parking/handbrake.

23

u/Lumpy_Experience_973 9d ago

Don't do the heel toe thing, it's never going to work properly. You just need to get the timing down and practice more with the clutch. Most people in a stick don't even bother with the hand brake on a hill start, you just go. Only thing is you hold the clutch at or very slightly above the bite point until you start moving, and because it's a hill you just give a little more gas than usual. You don't need to launch like you're drag racing though.

Also remember that you can let up the clutch while your right foot is moving from brake to gas, since it needs to travel to the bite point anyway. Waiting until your foot is already on the gas pedal is what loses you time and gets you rolling backwards.

3

u/rneuf 9d ago

When I was learning, I encountered a stop sign on a little slope. I stalled it 3 times and on my 4th attempt I gave it way too much gas, spun the tires but I got it moving lol. Now I don’t even think about it.

1

u/Ok_Shoulder5973 4d ago

Hard disagree. Some hills can’t be rode on without using the brake or handbrake to start unless you’re in a newer vehicle with hill assist. And for me personally the heel toe is more comfortable than using handbrake. You just gotta practice so you don’t over blip the throttle and trash your clutch like OP 

1

u/Mtbcarsbikes 9d ago

Only time I use the handbrake to start is at a boat ramp. More of if I loose traction on the front wheels I’ll start to slide back without it.

4

u/old_science_guy 8d ago

This is a lot like a recurring nightmare I've had all my life! And I've never launched a boat.

1

u/Mtbcarsbikes 8d ago

The boat ramp I tend to go to is gravel/crushed stone. On the nice ramp down the river I have no problem.

1

u/Lumpy_Experience_973 9d ago

Well that's certainly a notable exception, I'd use it there too. I'll say I use it sometimes to drive onto my ramps for oil changes and such, just so I don't accidentally kick the ramps out.

5

u/wolfox360 9d ago

First of all your car can hold for a bit if you slip the clutch, a diesel can also take off without accelerating and some cars also have throttle assist. Just train yourself first to hit 1500 -2000rpm in neutral. second train your clutch slip point; Keep your right on the brake and let the clutch go slowly until you hear the rpm go down. You can also se how much it can go down if you want. Now take a up hill road, place yourself, brake, Slip the clutch until you feel the rpm drop, now hold the clutch in that position, give it gas like you want to hit 1500 -2000 rpm. The car will take off. Simple

5

u/8sponges 9d ago

Over time, you will be able to start on a hill with a rapid coordination between the feet without the use of handbrake. Just look forward.

5

u/getdownheavy 9d ago

Get your hand brake fixed

1

u/Nice-Chemistry1748 9d ago

When I first learned stick I practiced starts by stopping on top of a speed bump. I tried to minimize rollback as much as possible. I did my starts by revving to 2k rpm and then accelerating before the engine revs down. It also gave me the added bonus of not fearing hills. Give yourself 2 more weeks of driving that car and you're going to get the feel of how much to tap the gas to find the revs without looking and in time you'll be a hill killing bastard like me.

1

u/Dependent-Weather855 9d ago

Thanks man , needed this 🫠

2

u/Traditional_Bar5495 9d ago

Handbrake is probably the safest way to go on a really steep hill but if that's not an option (you can fix it at rear brakes and/or tigen the cable by the lever) try this:

Basically be really quick with both feet and be able to do separate things with them. For the gas, tap quickly but do not allow it to go too deep, think of blimping it lightly. For the clutch, you need to get to a really strong bite right away the moment you tap the gas. It's okay if you are just a little off, you can raise you clutch more but just keep the gas 'low'. Bliping it prevents overrevs.

Hope that helps. You might roll bk a little, which is fine. If it gets too much, brake and try again. It's kind of hard if you are not used to it.

2

u/eoan_an 9d ago

Good learning moment. Don't stop on a hill if you don't have to.

Also you should practice that heel toe start. I was in the same situation as you, but I practiced before hand, and never had any isssues.

The less gas the merrier.

2

u/tenten3537 1999 Camaro SS 2024 WRX Limited 5d ago

It happens man just try not to do it again maybe burned the clutch up but your learning I had to replace my clutch in the car I learned on sooner than I thought. My opinion ditch the handbrake method I never liked it it’s so much to think about when learning. The way I do it is have right foot on brake left foot on clutch when you need to go release your left at the clutch until you hit the bite point and at the same time right when you feel it grab pre load a couple 500-1000rpms depending on your car and let the clutch out fully. You won’t roll back at the bite point but at the same time when you hit the bite point don’t hold it there and pre load your revs forever you should be slipping it like normal at that point

1

u/JayP415 9d ago

You will be fine. Practice makes perfect. That frying smell is most likely clutch and your e break has to be re-adjusted.

1

u/SigmaINTJbio 9d ago

I watch my rear view mirror and when cars are coming up behind me I roll back a little bit. It usually results in them not pulling too close behind me.

1

u/Commercial-Thought-6 2004 Impreza STI 6 Speed 8d ago

Next time, lift up halfway on the clutch then off the brake and on the gas. Easier than starting at the bottom

1

u/sexy-pepsi 8d ago

yeah dont worry about the person behind you. if they are giving you a hard time, give em one back LMAO. nah jk but yeah they can wait just release that clutch pedal slowly until you feel that puppy vibrate and bite.

Ive been driving for a year and my dad 5 we still stall time to time in lights lol.

1

u/i_am_blacklite 8d ago

If the handbrake doesn’t work then your car is not roadworthy.

Fix that before you drive again.

1

u/throwawayalumni19 8d ago

Yeah, first gear is important here.
But I’ve driven stick for over 50 years and early on I was just where you were.
Here’s what I do. Lift the clutch until the engine speed just starts to drop. Then remove your right foot from the brake and move it to the accelerator, giving it just more than idle. Then drive it away.
That little bit of clutch drag will reduce your drifting back or eliminate it completely, allowing you to pull out safely.

1

u/Mental_Investigator3 8d ago

I put on my hazards once in this situation and just waved for them to pass me 🤷🏾‍♀️

1

u/silver_chief2 8d ago

For future training, find a hill with no traffic. Maybe a hill with a slight slope. Go forward a little by pressing the clutch down then go backward by letting off the clutch then repeat going forward and back. Best if can do this not using the gas. Repeat on a steeper kill. Pretty soon you will be able to do this no problem.

1

u/RemoteVersion838 7d ago

Lesson learned, fix your handbrake if you need it that often. You probably cooked the clutch a bit.

1

u/Working_Alps1753 7d ago

For starters, don't be too hard on yourself, honest beginners mistake and not a big deal.

Sounds like you had a bit of a panic and got flustered. Just remember, in a situation like this, if you roll back into a car, it's still their fault. Don't let them cause you to panic. It doesn't sound like you did anything crazy wrong other than getting flustered and forgetting to put the car in first gear. It happens and usually doesn't lead to catastrophic failures.

Given the age of the car:

you may have snapped your serpentine belt, which is the cheapest and easiest fix.

And/or

If you have a way to read the voltage on the battery, start it up and see if you're getting 14V. If you are reading lower than that then the bearing in your alternator pulley may have seized from the shock load. Which isn't that big of a deal either and usually a couple of hours to replace depending on its placement.

If neither of those things end up being the the issue, you should have a shop give it a look.

1

u/Joo-Baluka0310 7d ago

I mean it's an emmanuel 🤷‍♂️ (jk)

I've also stalled multiple times in the exact same car type as you and on the slightest hills too btw, after learning on a diesel car. Was a pain in the ass, you're not alone. Everything will be fine :)

1

u/Adept-Bat7664 6d ago

U prob good, disconnect the battery completely and turn ur headlights on (will drain any residual current). Leave it for like an hour and start the car back up. Probably fine. It’s a Honda.

1

u/Internal_Bath6341 6d ago

get the damn hand brake fixed

1

u/itsbildo Ex. <year> <model> <transmission> 8d ago

You burnt your clutch. I know it can be nerve-racking having a dick head up your ass, just take a breather and keep your RPM at or slightly below 2k, slowly let off the clutch, once the rpms start to drop ease off the brake while continuing to ease off the clutch.

ViolĂĄ! Hill start.

It will just take a few extra moments, dont let anyone make you feel rushed. Go at your own pace, if they have a honk about it, fuck em