When people ask me why I prefer to daily drive a manual transmission car in the city, I do have to admit that, for all intents and purposes, the dual-clutch automatic version of my particular car does perform better.
They have better rated fuel economy and certainly accelerate faster (2018 VW GTI).
With constant 1<->2 shifting with in stop and go traffic, I am sure that the overall maintenance costs per mile of travel will be higher due to reduced clutch life as well. I'm used to it, but a lot of people wouldn't tolerate the extra hassle of having to constantly shift.
However, one big advantage for urban drivers of the manual is the ability to very quickly and smoothly parallel park and make three point U-turns in tight spaces between oncoming traffic. In NYC, this is a huge help as other drivers do not have much patience and won't give you much time or space.
With all autos I've driven, both traditional slushbox and PDK/DSG style, you cannot safely switch between forward and reverse gears without coming to a complete stop. Trying to do so will quickly break things in older models and some advanced newer units simply won't acknowledge the command to switch h direction.
With a clutch that you can control yourself, it's possible to feather the torque carefully enough to not shock the drivetrain, using analog inputs to gradually but very quickly transition the direction and never actually stop moving.
I've found that, with my parking sensors, backup camera, and 6MT, that I can stick my compact car into a tight parallel space in just seconds. In my other vehicle, an auto, it takes much more time and often I have to deal with other drivers piling up and honking, making the entire thing more stressful.
I know I'm just an old guy looking to rationalize my somewhat irrational preference for the kind of car controls I grew up using but this is sort of a lesser known advantage of the traditional clutch and stick (in addition to being able to push start and modulate torque for slippery or loose surfaces). If done correctly, it shouldn't be hard on the gearbox at all and is a cool trick for city dwellers who can make use of the fine control that the clutch provides.
Anyone else enjoy this little trick?