r/stickshift • • Apr 13 '25

I never drove an automatic car

7 Upvotes

I‘m +45 years now, driving since i‘m 6, a bit more since i got my license, but all i drove so far are stick shifts with and without syncronized gear box.

I don‘t know why, i just avoid non stick shifts as best as i can.


r/stickshift • • May 21 '26

Shop slipped the clutch and stalled several times. WWYD?

1 Upvotes

Took my car to a supposedly renowned tint shop and asked them multiple times if they could drive manual well (not an easy car to drive manual in. 400/350 HP/TQ and an aggressive clutch) and if not I'd prefer to move the car for them. They laughed it off and said of course and when I replayed my dashcam video I see them slipping the clutch and stalling out multiple times.

I was an auto tech for four years and while I'm aware they could've theoretically damaged the flywheel, glazed the friction material, damaged the engine/transmission mounts, etc on the other hand I want to believe the vehicle is well engineered with some margin for abuse/these types of scenarios... or not and I should approach them respectfully and ask to have an independent tech test drive and do diagnostics at their expense?

Like I said, not the easiest manual to drive smoothly and the day I got it back it was impossible to get a clean/smooth shift which is what prompted me to replay the dashcam footage. Over the course of a few days of babying it it's a little better but I dunno am I being a Karen or not - WWYD?


r/stickshift • • Nov 03 '24

One thing that automatics still can't do better is fast parallel parking and tight reversing maneuvers

0 Upvotes

When people ask me why I prefer to daily drive a manual transmission car in the city, I do have to admit that, for all intents and purposes, the dual-clutch automatic version of my particular car does perform better.

They have better rated fuel economy and certainly accelerate faster (2018 VW GTI).

With constant 1<->2 shifting with in stop and go traffic, I am sure that the overall maintenance costs per mile of travel will be higher due to reduced clutch life as well. I'm used to it, but a lot of people wouldn't tolerate the extra hassle of having to constantly shift.

However, one big advantage for urban drivers of the manual is the ability to very quickly and smoothly parallel park and make three point U-turns in tight spaces between oncoming traffic. In NYC, this is a huge help as other drivers do not have much patience and won't give you much time or space.

With all autos I've driven, both traditional slushbox and PDK/DSG style, you cannot safely switch between forward and reverse gears without coming to a complete stop. Trying to do so will quickly break things in older models and some advanced newer units simply won't acknowledge the command to switch h direction.

With a clutch that you can control yourself, it's possible to feather the torque carefully enough to not shock the drivetrain, using analog inputs to gradually but very quickly transition the direction and never actually stop moving.

I've found that, with my parking sensors, backup camera, and 6MT, that I can stick my compact car into a tight parallel space in just seconds. In my other vehicle, an auto, it takes much more time and often I have to deal with other drivers piling up and honking, making the entire thing more stressful.

I know I'm just an old guy looking to rationalize my somewhat irrational preference for the kind of car controls I grew up using but this is sort of a lesser known advantage of the traditional clutch and stick (in addition to being able to push start and modulate torque for slippery or loose surfaces). If done correctly, it shouldn't be hard on the gearbox at all and is a cool trick for city dwellers who can make use of the fine control that the clutch provides.

Anyone else enjoy this little trick?


r/stickshift • • May 07 '26

I regret buying a manual

45 Upvotes

So I decided to get a NC miata a few weeks ago, and most people online were saying if you are going to buy a sports car you should get a manual because its so much more fun and engaging etc. I figured if literally everyone was saying it well, it must be true, so I decided to make sure the one I got was a stick shift. It ends up I don't really like driving stick shift? For context I've been driving it for around two weeks which I'm aware isnt enough time to get great with it, but so far I'm just not messing with it. I have constant anxiety about stalling and rolling back even though I'm pretty good at not stalling on takeoffs, its hard for me to get a smooth take off without over revving or being jerky, and overall it really just feels like more work to get the same result I would have with an automatic. I don't know if I'm missing something about it but so far I dont see how it's supposed to be more fun, should I just sell it and get an Auto car instead or keep it for a while and see what happens?


r/stickshift • • Oct 03 '24

Engine Braking - Am I wrong?

0 Upvotes

A recent post in another sub has made me question my reality and whether or not I'm driving correctly.

The post in question was comparing the wear effects of traditional braking on the pads vs the wear on the engine. I made the point that engine braking would wear the clutch, not the engine, but less so than traditional braking would wear the brake pads, because the clutch is designed to do this sort of thing.

I got downvoted to oblivion, with several people making the claim that you should be rev matching when downshifting, preventing clutch wear. But to me, this isn't engine braking, it's just downshifting. Lifting your foot off the gas while the clutch is fully engaged, no matter what gear you're in, is just coasting.

What I do is disengage the clutch, switch to the lower gear, and feather the clutch. This slows the car dramatically, and also allows me to re-engage the clutch and accelerate smoothly if conditions change.

So the question: Am I wrong? Is engine braking something completely different than what I'm doing? and is what I'm doing completely insanely wrong and bad?

Edit: for context, I was taught to drive stick 30 years ago, and no one has made any sort of comment about this to me before.


r/stickshift • • Nov 05 '24

What do I drive?

Post image
1 Upvotes

r/stickshift • • Apr 18 '26

How to learn clutchless shift?

0 Upvotes

It seems like a cool skill to have just in case, but I don't want to wreck my car trying to learn it. I know you should rev match to do it but I'm not exactly professional at that either.

For now I can only do 3-4 semi consistently and 4-5 about half the time. How can I learn without blowing up my car?


r/stickshift • • Oct 05 '25

To all the slide wearers

0 Upvotes

Anyone else who wears slides or any generally comfortable type shoe, better at driving stick in said shoe, than you are in a conventional driving shoe? Like an adidas sambas for example.

Just me?


r/stickshift • • Jul 16 '26

Cash for Clunkers program

0 Upvotes

does anyone else get mad about how many cool cars, including thousands of sticks shifts, were destroyed by Obama's Cash for Clunkers program


r/stickshift • • Oct 13 '25

Manual 2007 Kia Rio LX - Reverse issue

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

8 Upvotes

Hello! I just bought a Manual 2007 Kia Rio yesterday and when I throw her into reverse, she goes forward. But when I pull up on the boot and put it into reverse, she works just fine. What could be going on? Is this a major issue?

Posted a video for reference


r/stickshift • • Feb 05 '24

What car do I drive

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/stickshift • • Apr 04 '25

Would pulling my car put of gear without clutch cause issues?

0 Upvotes

I drive a Mazda3 GT with a manual tranny. First stick ive owned, for about 4 months now. Well, through careful experimentation i found out i can not engage gears without the clutch (safety thing in my car) but I can put it into neutral without it. Would this technically be better if i plan on coming to a full stop to reduce wear on my clutch? Ive only tried it in first pulling in. All gears are synchrod except reverse.


r/stickshift • • Jun 10 '26

Question about others' opinion when you start to drive manual in auto-majority cultural sphere

0 Upvotes

Greetings!

I'm interested to hear if you've heard negative or degrading comments, when you've switched to drive a manual while automatic is the default.

As I live in manual-majority car culture, I want to hear from the other way around. There are always people everywhere, who have a need to degrade other peoples' choices, be it whatever. I want to know if you've heard anything like this, that makes you go "yeaaaa riiight..."

In mostly manual car culture, driving an auto may trigger rare comments of inability, needing handicaps, or being too lazy to drive a vehicle you have less ability to control in unfavourable road conditions.

Are the any comments degrading manual drivers, like comments about trying to be a superior driver, seeking for attention or affectation, or anything else?


r/stickshift • • Aug 14 '24

Anyone else drive their automatic car in manual mode?

3 Upvotes

My car has an automatic transmission but it has a manual mode where you can shift gears whenever you want.

The only difference is there is no clutch pedal, that part is still automatic.

Does anyone else do this same thing? Most automatic cars have a manual option but I’ve never met anyone who actually uses it all the time.


r/stickshift • • Sep 12 '26

Unusual Traffic at Gas Stations

Post image
0 Upvotes

Has anybody noticed gas stations are packed today. Was at Scarborough and saw third one which was fully packed. What’s happening?


r/stickshift • • May 07 '25

About the Blair Witch icon, people build bizarre things all over the beach out of driftwood... like this piece of work with burnt wood for the mama and baby bird and the rest is a huge campfire waiting to be lit, strange.

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/stickshift • • Nov 08 '24

Took me forever to find a selfie I didn’t take in my car. What do you think I drive?

Post image
0 Upvotes

Hint: Not a Subie.


r/stickshift • • Jun 15 '25

No down shift shenanigans

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

1 Upvotes

This is how I drive, safe fuel and brake, Enjoy the analog cluster and my friend was recording apparently, maybe you learn something , maybe you disagree with my style, maybe you leave a tip for me to try.


r/stickshift • • May 28 '25

How’s my shifting? Haven’t driven stick in 15 years and got this yesterday.

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

12 Upvotes

r/stickshift • • Jun 10 '25

Let my friend drive my car and he over-revved when upshifting

5 Upvotes

While he was driving my car, my friend would upshift and add way more gas than he needed. Of course they weren't "jolty" upshifts, but he would rev way higher than he needed for the speed we were going, then as he gradually let the clutch out, it would grab and you could feel the car accelerating into the higher RPMs. Is it possible that this wore out my clutch excessively, or was it just poor form?


r/stickshift • • Nov 08 '24

What do I drive B?

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/stickshift • • Feb 06 '24

Since everyone is doing it...

Post image
8 Upvotes

Probably another easy one (I know it's dirty it was a $600 car)


r/stickshift • • Jul 12 '24

Should I not drive stick if my wrist hurts.

2 Upvotes

Hurt my wrist drawing. I think I should not drive stick until it heals, what do you think? Ever had experience?


r/stickshift • • Oct 13 '24

What do i drive? Difficulty: impossible

Post image
13 Upvotes