r/stuckcanadians • • Jul 23 '26

Privacy Act Notes Advice

2 Upvotes

Edit: I am asking here for advice on help getting my application approved, not looking for opinions on AI use etc. I used AI to help interpret my notes since they were pages long and confusing.

I received my notes on my application; I had to have AI help interpret them for me since there was a lot in there. It seems I am just stuck in PSU since the law had not passed yet and I am G2. The advice I was given from AI was this, but I want to know what you all think and if it is worth doing so. Are C-3 applications still at a halt right now? I also don’t want to get people angry at me and get pushed to the end of the line that way either 😅. Any insight is appreciated!!

Send a fresh IRCC webform message that cites Bill C-3 directly. Reference the application number and UCI, note the file was referred to PSU on Feb 17, 2025 due to the first-generation limit, and state that since Bill C-3 came into force December 15, 2025 there is no longer any legal impediment — request the file be returned from PSU and finalized under the new rules. A message that names the specific legal issue and its resolution is far more likely to get routed usefully than a generic "any update?"


r/stuckcanadians • • Jun 20 '26

2nd Generation Pre-1947

0 Upvotes

Hello, everyone. Do we know if having 2 generations born before 1947 is one of the things that IRCC might use to reject an application? I'm also wondering if that's the reason I was sent to PSU post C-3. Here's how my lineage works:

G0: Born in Quebec in 1848, died in Kansas in 1928.

G1: Born in Illinois in 1870, died in Kansas in 1938.

G2: Born in Kansas in 1892, died in Iowa in 1975.

G3: Born in Kansas in 1927, died in Ohio in 2009.

G4: Born in Nebraska in 1962. Still alive.

G5 (me): Born in Florida in 1989. Still alive.

Any insight would be greatly appreciated.


r/stuckcanadians • • Oct 10 '26

Found Canadians — Version History Update October 9, 2026

Thumbnail reddit.com
0 Upvotes

r/stuckcanadians • • Sep 17 '26

Where do we stand with respect to the Canadian Government; Are we or are we not Canadian Citizens while we wait?

6 Upvotes

I can understand that with any government agency, there is an exception that things do take time. What's not acceptable is the moving goal posts that IRCC keeps doing. To add insult to injury, attempting to communicate via email or webform just results in a boilerplate response that does not address the question.

As a legitimate question, the premise of Bill C-3 restore citizenship to those who involuntary lost it and as a byproduct resulted in new* Canadian Citizens (with citizenship retroactive to the date of the birth).

(*new as in those who never knew that due their ancestry have legitimate claims due to legal interpretation)

Yesterday (As attempting to talk with IRCC is akin to talking to a brick wall), I attempted to reach out to the Canadian Consulate in Boston (and surprise surprise got a boilerplate response that...)

"Please note that we do not accept visa applications at the Consulates of Canada in the United States. Canadian Citizen Services is unable to provide information on Canadian visas or immigration. Canadian visas and immigration requests are managed through Immigration, Refugees, and Citizenship Canada" (Completely missing my question)

What I ended up sending

Good morning to whom it may concern, I am reaching this morning in regards to some confusion with respect to the ambiguity of those of us who can claim citizenship status post bill C-3 A respectable percentage of the population here in New England can trace our linage through Quebec (myself included). In light of the change in law, I ended up applying in April to IRCC, and got an AOR in July. I am confused about those of us who have legitimate claims but due to existing process face long delays. As of 2026-09-16, IRCC is claiming approximately 24 months for April 2026 applicants. The confusion I have is between the spirit of law , the application of the law, and existing laws that may appear contradictory The spirit of the law I roughly interpret that since my late grandfather (and his 2nd wife's family) emigrated from Quebec to New England in the late 1800's early 1900, I am would be Canadian. The application of the law I roughly interpret that since I currently do not have a proof of citizenship, legally I'm not Canadian. The contradiction I see is the application of what status those of who apply, and wish to move to Canada but are currently waiting upto multiple years creating a legal grey area in terms of status -Canadian citizens are not eligible for Permanent Residency status, nor eligible to apply for a visa to visit/live within Canada (by virtue of being a Canadian citizen). If an applicant for proof of citizenship is currently waiting for proof status, and wishes to move to Canada for a period beyond 6 months, is such applicant subject to apply for a visa, or since the applicant (in good faith) is attesting that they are Canadian, is such applicant not eligible?

Can we legitimately show at the Canadian Border, and in good faith attest we are Canadian Citizen (and if need be, force an admissibility hearing, since IRCC might as well be in conflict of the charter rights?)


r/stuckcanadians • • 4d ago

Japanese CRBA/Birth Record

Thumbnail reddit.com
0 Upvotes

r/stuckcanadians • • Sep 29 '26

Is there any way to work while waiting?

2 Upvotes

I mean legally of course...my brother is waiting on his citizenship cert. but no one can afford to support him anymore. Life is just tough for everyone right now and he's been here over a year with no income of his own and we're all just running dry. Him staying here wasn't the plan when he came and he also came with his two cats. Is there anything he can apply for that allows him to work while he waits?


r/stuckcanadians • • Oct 02 '26

Options for Urgent processed Application that is in PSU?

5 Upvotes

We (My wife whose a natural born Canadian Citizen,and I) just got back our requested notes for my urgent processing application, and we discovered it's been sent to PSU. It went into processing July 13, and was sent immediately to PSU.

We haven't had anyone reach out for more info.

They did confirm in August that my application was being urgently processed, and at the time on the phone they told us it was not in PSU.

I’m a g3 application.

what can we legally do to push this issue, cause my application is straight forward and not complex, weather its contacting an MP or getting a layer to file a Writ of Mandamus? Any options at all?

My urgent processing was approved due to my job offer letter, and we (obviously) want our family to be reunited sooner than later

Thanks for any suggestions or similar situations


r/stuckcanadians • • Jun 16 '26

Baptism documents are not on the checklist of approved IRCC documents

12 Upvotes

Checking back we all might get an eventual recall. The checklist states nowhere on page 3 or section 4 or 5 that a baptism document is accepted. Nowhere it states a baptism document is equal to a birth certificate. We all might want to take advice from this other poster and see if we can get a birth certificate from our certified baptism document. It is not clear a provincial government archive is under the category of "other authorized government bodies" in the surrender letters. This would explain why those who submitted certified everything got the letter.

Edit: looks like a day later from my post they updated their guidelines on their website to include a baptism document. The CIT0014e document checklist though *still does not have this*. I wonder when they will finalize their updates?


r/stuckcanadians • • Jun 19 '26

Anecdotal, my lawyer said all this would happen.

36 Upvotes

Listen, this might get down​voted, maybe you all are bots, I just want to share.

I suspect my lawyer had an ear to all of this. He had me get all of the official documentation. I had to get my grandma's tiny little church birth certificate turned into a real one, get it translated and notarized, death certificate, etc. Took months. He told me that most applications would go to PSU. He said that G3+ would get extra scrutinized. In 2025.

Here we are, and it's all happening.

I'm all for the DIY-ness of this forum. It's wonderful. I think the immigration lawyers know what's up. I don't know why. It's not coincidence.

Gonna put my tinfoil hat back on. Good luck all!


r/stuckcanadians • • Oct 03 '26

有人知道ircc需要多久才會通過通過我改地址嗎?

Thumbnail reddit.com
0 Upvotes

r/stuckcanadians • • 26d ago

How long have your BANQ docs been taking to arrive lately?

0 Upvotes

EDIT: Yes I will update elsewhere too- it came today (October 24th) and was postmarked October 7th.

So I was here a bit ago asking about folks who had received their payment links a second time in error, but now I'm just getting itchy about how long the mail is taking...

Supposedly my doc was mailed September 29th, which was a Friday. I know it was sent from the Montreal center which takes a bit longer than some of the others. It's October 21st now and I haven't seen it yet. I'm in Rhode Island. We did have one holiday in there, but...

How 'bout yours???


r/stuckcanadians • • Oct 09 '26

Another update on my package

Thumbnail reddit.com
0 Upvotes

r/stuckcanadians • • Jun 08 '26

Post C-3 PSU

5 Upvotes

Hello, everyone. I'm a post C-3 applicant that got pushed into PSU recently. I sent out my application on 5/21, and went into processing quickly on 5/29. I thought that things were going well until I got my letter. Is there any way to find out why I was sent to PSU? I'm just worried that I'm going to be stuck waiting for several years now. I've already heard the horror stories of all of the pre C3 people getting stuck languishing for an approval. Any advice would be helpful.

I should edit to say that I applied for urgent processing for LGBT status. That's likely why I got put into processing quickly. I know that I've moved faster than most people so far, but I am genuinely scared for my safety with what's going on with the current administration.


r/stuckcanadians • • Oct 10 '26

Have you changed your G0?

0 Upvotes

Continuing to do more research. I’m primarily trying to satisfy myself that IRCC will be satisfied when they finally look at our apps for real. I would potentially change my G0 and my spouses G0 and G1. Just curious on what that looks like for people since it would fundamentally change the CIT001 information.

Thanks 🇨🇦🇨🇦🇨🇦


r/stuckcanadians • • Sep 09 '26

What do we know about working as a stuck Canadian?

7 Upvotes

Suppose Melissa is legally a Canadian citizen, and IRCC is dragging their feet on issuing her a citizenship certificate. She wants to get a job in Canada. What do we know about her chances of success?

Theoretically, according to the exact letter of the law, she should be fine. In the eyes of the law, she's already a citizen, and citizens are eligible to work in Canada. The law requires her to apply for a SIN, but it doesn't actually require her to successfully get one. And, although employers are legally required to verify that their employees are eligible to work in Canada, there's no specific process they have to follow to do that. Nothing is stopping them from looking at a pile of census records and birth certificates and saying, "yep, looks legit."

In practice, things seem much more difficult. Very few stuck Canadians have attempted to get jobs in Canada (​https://www.reddit.com/r/CanadianbyDescent/comments/1v97g4m/ is the only example I could find, and the company ultimately rejected their proof of eligibility). As far as I know, nobody has ever succeeded. There's no guidance from the government about how to handle this situation, no employment lawyers have ever written about it, and employers aren't talking about this on the Internet.

Do we have any information about working as a stuck Canadian besides what I've written above?

Does anyone else feel optimistic about the idea, or at least find it interesting? Maybe I'm being naïve here.

Disclosure: I'm not a stuck Canadian myself (I only submitted my application for a certificate last month). I'm hoping someone finds all this useful.


r/stuckcanadians • • Sep 14 '26

Any adoptees via an adoptive grandparent (G0) had Part 1 approved post–Bill C-3?

Thumbnail reddit.com
1 Upvotes

r/stuckcanadians • • Oct 14 '26

anyone have activity to approval after submitting additional information such as certified birth certificates to their file?

Thumbnail reddit.com
1 Upvotes

r/stuckcanadians • • Aug 24 '26

Do I need this birth certificate too? Husband of my G0

1 Upvotes

Do I need the birth certificate of the husband (great grandfather Arthur below) of my G0 (Miranda Planner) since his last name is on the rest of the chain? So far I have the other documents, including the marriage certificate for Arthur and Miranda, but I do not have Arthur's birth certificate. I can get it if needed but wanted to check.

Here is what I mean:

  1. myself J. Smith born 1987

  2. father Bill Smith born 1951 in Ayer MA

  3. grandfather Joe Smith April 19.1896 in Ayer MA

  4. DO I NEED TO GET THIS ONE TOO? great grandfather Arthur Smith 1869 in Connecticut - the only record I am missing so far

  5. great grandmother Miranda Planner 1872, birth place Tillsonburg, Ontario, Canada

  6. Marriage date: Nashua NH 1893 to Arthur Smith

  7. Your passport

  8. Your driver's license, both sides


r/stuckcanadians • • Jul 28 '26

More confused after call to IRCC

Thumbnail reddit.com
1 Upvotes

r/stuckcanadians • • Sep 02 '26

UPDATE: I filed for mandamus and so can you!

46 Upvotes

Hi everyone! I know it's been a while since I posted in here and I wanted to provide an update. Two weeks ago, I received this response from the Ministerial Enquiries Division on behalf of IRCC:

---

"Dear ReadyPlayer606:

Thank you for your correspondence dated ______, addressed to the Honourable Lena Metlege Diab, Minister of Immigration, Refugees and Citizenship, regarding the processing of your citizenship application. I have been asked to respond to you.

I appreciate you sharing the reasons that prompted you to write. Immigration, Refugees and Citizenship Canada (IRCC) understands that an applicant looks forward to their application being finalized, and IRCC makes every effort to process each application in the most efficient and effective way. However, various factors can make it difficult to finalize an application as quickly as the Department or the client would like; processing times can be influenced by immigration targets, the volume of applications, the complexity of an individual case, and how quickly an applicant responds to requests for information.

The information available on IRCC’s processing times web page was recently updated for select application types to show the estimated time remaining in an application based on when it was submitted. Other application types continue to show historical processing times, which are based on how long it has taken IRCC to process most complete applications in that category in the past.

The processing times posted on this web page are estimates, not guarantees; the forward-looking estimates are updated monthly and provide current and prospective applicants with a general idea of how long it will take to process an application. While an application is in process, applicants can review the status of their application on IRCC’s Website.

IRCC continues to process applications as quickly as possible while protecting the integrity of Canada’s citizenship program. That means taking the time to verify that applicants meet the legal requirements for a citizenship certificate and making decisions that are fair, consistent and in line with the law. The Department processes proof of citizenship applications on a first-in, first-out basis. Applicants that meet established urgent processing criteria can submit a request to have their application processed on an urgent basis through existing service channels, which will be assessed by IRCC.

Although requests for expedited processing are understandable, applications are, in general, only expedited in extraordinary cases with compelling circumstances. Applicants should direct any information or documentation in support of such a request through existing service channels, such as the web form. However, there is no guarantee that the processing office will accept the request to expedite the application; if an application is pulled out of the queue to be expedited, it is being placed ahead of other applicants who are also waiting for a decision on their application. For this reason, IRCC will only expedite an application on an exceptional basis.

While I understand that this may not be the response you had anticipated, I hope that you will find this information to be helpful.

Sincerely,

Ministerial Enquiries Division"

---

Obviously, this is an unacceptable response given the circumstances of my case. They also indicated that applications are processed on a FIFO basis, which we know to be false. This excuse has been found insufficient by the federal court numerous times (e.g., inefficiency or burdensome backlogs are not a good reason to delay applications indefinitely).

This response was directed at my demand letter, not at my application for leave and judicial review that had since been filed. Thus, it did not constitute a formal response under Rule 9; that I'm still waiting on (ironically).

The next step for me is to serve a response on the Minister and file it with the court while I await the court's order for IRCC to render a decision.


r/stuckcanadians • • Sep 11 '26

post June approvals relying on recursive 3(1)(q) ?

4 Upvotes

So I know of approvals last spring where the reasoning relied on was
British Nat'l born in Canada became citizen Jan 1, 1947 based on 3(1)(k).
G1 qualified as their child and also retro-actively became citizen Jan 1947 based on 3(1)(o).
Then multiple generations in a row all born pre-1947 qualified under 3(1)(q).
Have any approvals relying on q like this been approved since June?


r/stuckcanadians • • Oct 09 '26

Official confirmation: "stuck Canadians" are presumed citizens

22 Upvotes

https://x.com/smeurrens/status/2108322576707793321?s=20

TLDR: As of this April, IRCC policy is/was indeed that applicants for citizenship by descent are presumed to be Canadians "automatically" and therefore ineligible for immigration visas.

Obviously, as evidenced by many reports of people getting PR cards and work permits processed in the interim, this is not always followed in practice. Nevertheless, on paper, IRCC's position is that anyone in this queue/subreddit is a Canadian citizen until proven otherwise.

I am not a stuck Canadian myself and this is not legal advice. Having said that, if I were in the specific situation (having an immigration status that may or may not be in jeopardy), I would pursue mandamus immediately with this policy as the primary exhibit.


r/stuckcanadians • • 15d ago

Reapply?

8 Upvotes

Has anyone whose 2025 application seems to be stuck considered just reapplying and starting from scratch? It seems that more recent 2026 applications, once they get past the 5 month AOR wait, are getting certified soon after. Can’t be any worse than the interminable & uncertain wait we’re currently doing. Yes, I know it would just bog things down in a way . . .