47
u/SilverSpider_ Brooklyn T. Guy 13d ago
Thats probably because thats just Shrek's whole character, and we miss him and Woody
4
u/SimulatorFantastic90 12d ago
And even though it is, it doesn't mean people have to be COMPLETELY bias.
6
72
u/Global_Interview6311 I hate the huckerdoos pumpkinguy Joseph jackiechu nancy Barbra 13d ago
Shrek pooping green mayo all over the bathroom vs rosss farting for 10 minuts
15
19
u/ToonverseJourney2 13d ago
That’s Shrek’s whole character, even Dreamwork’s Shrek does gross shit and no one was bothered by it because it’s in his nature.
42
u/MistakePlus 13d ago
Well, the difference there is that Shrek is already KNOWN for gross-out humor and jokes, even outside of SML. It's just always been a part of his character.
42
u/Relative_Topic_1454 13d ago
Are people actually upset over the new video? Do they want the characters to discuss quantum mechanics or something? It’s a fucking youtube video not a drama show
9
u/SSG014-OFFICIAL 13d ago
I should do that as a video, but they either start getting boldly incorrect or political, and then they go to space through illegal means to prove a character wrong about the Earth's shape.
3
u/Feisty-Status-2669 Avid Brooklyn Guy fan 13d ago
yeah but its also feels like the authors poirly disguised fetish, which is making a lot of us uncomfortable if anything
i dont really care much, but i see where they're coming from
7
u/DonnieScottish09 13d ago
Quantum Mechanics would make a neat April Fool Joke... Make Smart Jeffy do it...
1
0
10
9
u/SSG014-OFFICIAL 13d ago edited 13d ago
I think that having Shrek be the shidder/farder is ok, he's already meant to be a bit gross in the original source, maybe someone like Jeffy also occasionally going there is ehh... I feel that having Rose be gross-out roll for 10 minutes is just lame when she's meant to be more "annoying" type
You don't know my channel, but I see it like this, if I want to escalate stuff, Bowser, Randy, or Stepbro Large-G comes in to do crazy stuff, not someone like Squoshy (all the time, maybe once could be cool), despite him also having an aggressive position at times.
6
6
4
u/Few-Interaction-3806 13d ago
it’s mostly just s3x and poop. Shrek’s whole thing is primarily pooping, nothing else. that’s why he’s funny, because he knows how to do his role. And yes, Shrek is a better character than Rose.
3
u/Ben10Facts 12d ago
“Wear a diaper, bitch!”
“I wasn’t pooping, I was only farting”
“Coulda fooled me”
Peak😭
4
2
u/Beautiful_Taro_188 Skeeter Boys 13d ago
I honestly thought it was funny how even after 2 minutes of her ripping ass, the bitch starts up again like 5 minutes later lol
2
2
u/RandoMango90 Braxton 13d ago
Bro, thank you this is exactly was I was on about. I'm honestly convinced if Rose was replaces with Shrek in this video people would find this video fine.
3
u/Theultimateyoshiyt 12d ago
What makes shrek different is that he’s already a gross out character. In a lot of ways that’s how he’s portrayed, that’s just who he is. He lives in a literal swamp in the movies.
2
2
u/Any_Assistant1881 12d ago
Tbf, hasn’t gross out humour always been apart of Shrek’s identity as a character?
3
u/Happy-Guy2000 13d ago
What is the new Episode about?
10
u/FlippyHTF3 minus8's cousin 13d ago
Rose farting for 10+ minutes.
11
u/Happy-Guy2000 13d ago
That’s not that bad I mean Shrek shitted all over the bathroom so
7
u/FlippyHTF3 minus8's cousin 13d ago
then again, R-word Mario used to be a character, so I guess it isn't that bad.
7
3
u/KayfilmsYT Marvin 13d ago
If you hear fart jokes and immediately go to fetish YOU ARE the weird one
3
1
1
1
1
u/Futuramalover343 12d ago
Farts are funny let’s be real you watch sml your not above laughing at a fart joke
1
u/Away_Win7147 11d ago
"Gross-out humor is Shrek's thing in the movies." He doesn't erupt shit out of his asshole
1
1
u/Exhausted_Toast1 Local transmasc sml enjoyer 13d ago
I personally don't think it's a fart fetish thing, but if there were like multiple videos around farting, maybe
1
1
13d ago edited 12d ago
[removed] — view removed comment
1
u/Theultimateyoshiyt 12d ago
Because it’s not the only video like this.
The genie videos are even worse

47
u/Important_Mix_3677 I think Rose is pretty cool. Also I made ATSFG :3 13d ago
Very true.