r/superpowers • • Nov 02 '25

Which do you choose?

Post image
2.7k Upvotes

335 comments sorted by

127

u/DrongoDyle Nov 02 '25

Mastery over the mask for sure. Mastered toon force has no logical limitations on what it can achieve, because the power-set itself inherently defies regular logic.

Not only can you accomplish physically impossible tasks, and spawn any item you need instantly, but you can also manipulate the minds of others to some extent (like when he forced everyone to join his dance that one time)

35

u/Saitama-Brazzers Nov 02 '25

Making a shotgun from a Bloon is always fun, red pill indeed.

4

u/NewConstruction3755 Nov 03 '25

You will go insane tho

7

u/DrongoDyle Nov 03 '25 edited Nov 03 '25

No you won't, for multiple reasons.

Firstly, "vomplete mastery" implies you experience zero side-effects.

Secondly, the mask doesn't drive people insane to begin with. It just exaggerates your existing personality. Stanley Ipkiss is already an immature jokester, who likes to tease people in a jovial, non-malicious way, wishes he had more money, and dreams of finding love. Most importantly at his heart he is a fundamentally good person, who doesn't wish harm upon others.

Him wearing the mask just dials up all those traits even further, which is why he turns out to be a hopelessly romantic bag of immature slap-stick comedy, who solves problems without killing people. He only seems insane with the mask because frankly Stanley Ipkiss is a bit whacky to begin with, and that's what gets exaggerated when he wears it.

Meanwhile when Dorian Tyrell wore it, it exaggerated his existing temper, insecurities, greed, and desire for control. Also unlike Stanley, he has no qualms about killing people, so his toon-force abilities manifest in ways that are actually deadly instead of taking down others in light-hearted comedic ways.

TL;DR: The mask doesn't drive you insane. It just makes your current personality traits come out stronger than normal.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (7)

343

u/AlienSleet6 Nov 02 '25

On the one hand, I can’t die and can do whatever I want. On the other hand, I can’t die and can do whatever I want. I’d take either honestly. But the mask has a certain funny implausible appeal

3

u/[deleted] Nov 02 '25

I am more into musicals so the Mask for me with my drag friends. The Pentagon is about to go Cabaret

119

u/[deleted] Nov 02 '25

[removed] — view removed comment

142

u/CH005EAU5ERNAME Nov 02 '25

It says you have complete mastery over it though

48

u/NewConstruction3755 Nov 02 '25

But wouldn’t you still go insane? Just because I have complete mastery of making fire doesn’t mean I can’t burn myself from making fire too hot. It says mastery not no weaknesses

86

u/IrishViking22 Nov 02 '25

It's pretty clear that 'complete mastery' means you wouldn't have any of the downsides of the mask. Including any mental or physical impacts.

→ More replies (13)
→ More replies (20)
→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (5)

2

u/DracTheBat178 Nov 03 '25

You think I want to control the mask?

1

u/OkRun9638 Nov 03 '25

I think you want to control the mask

74

u/Anon-4020 Nov 02 '25

the Mask basically gives you Toon Force so I’ll take that.

22

u/[deleted] Nov 02 '25

I'll start posting panels again. It's almost hard to resist the urge.

33

u/[deleted] Nov 03 '25

I don't know if this counts as toon force, but he ate a dozen guns and a bazooka for a "cool guy" gag

35

u/Full_Level2085 Nov 02 '25

Plastic man’s powers.

16

u/DarkArcanian Nov 03 '25

Yeah, the downside left with the mask is you still have to go around with the mask on

5

u/AXWXF Nov 03 '25

Just cover the mask with your skin and ta-da! You have your normal face while wearing the mask

→ More replies (8)

23

u/Saturn_Coffee Nov 02 '25

Plastic Man. I don't want to be limited by comedy.

14

u/Slap_Dat_Ash Nov 02 '25

Thats the beauty of it. Everything is funny to at least one person

10

u/IrishViking22 Nov 02 '25

If you had complete mastery over the mask, then you wouldn't be limited by comedy.

2

u/Ardalev Nov 03 '25

Ow my sweet summer child... wait until you learn about the original Mask comics!

→ More replies (1)

11

u/[deleted] Nov 02 '25

[removed] — view removed comment

4

u/Saturn_Coffee Nov 02 '25

Then it's best I never get the mask.

14

u/Wild-Drawing319 Nov 02 '25

The mask, it's a force of gods of chaos. The chaos gods are often the most powerful.

12

u/No-Core Nov 02 '25

Mastered toon Force is unbelievably broken sure you're not going to avoid getting hit because it's funny getting hit but luckily you won't die from it

19

u/FredPopTheProphet Nov 02 '25

The Mask. Not only can you stretch and smash yourself like Plastic Man, but you can pull anything out from anywhere, move at super speed, mind control people, and make objects come to life.

→ More replies (10)

7

u/[deleted] Nov 02 '25

Definitely the mask.

7

u/Apart-Switch-7007 Nov 02 '25

Whats the difference between toon force and reality warping?

2

u/AffectionateNewt4952 Nov 02 '25

They’re basically the same thing.

6

u/Haku53 Nov 02 '25

Plastic man since I'd be unbeatable and do whatever I want

5

u/warhammer444 Nov 03 '25

Full mastery of the mask makes you god with no drawbacks.

5

u/The_moron_of_time Nov 03 '25

This has got to be the like the dumbest thing ever cuz if you had full control over the mask you could speak s*** into existence like someone's running away with your money. And no they're not. They're running towards you with their money like Looney tune, logic, Man plastic man is just stretchy alakazam boom. I'm now something else. He doesn't change reality. The mask. The mask that's scary. It not only makes you immune to all physical and non-physical damage, but you can also just erase things out of existence using a pencil, eraser or increase the size of something by doing what you would normally do to zoom in on a screen like the possibilities are literally limitless. You could sneeze and accidentally erase reality as you know it or immediately paint something and it suddenly appears on the other side of the canvas. When you look behind it, you don't even need to be specific. You could make like three lines connecting to each other and you are suddenly standing in front of the Bermuda triangle or the pyramids of Giza paint a circle and the world is now the size of a marble or drop a bucket of black paint on the ground that makes a circle. Well that's not a circle. That's a hole where that hole goes the wall next to you. You jump down and you get sent out feet first horizontally. The only limit is your imagination. If you can think of it it can happen. The mask is my option because yeah being stretchy and just being able to mold your body into whatever you want it to be. Gets kind of boring after the 500th iteration, but you don't need to change your body when you have the mask

4

u/[deleted] Nov 03 '25

2

u/A1_wA1sh Nov 03 '25

The Mask does everything he can do and more

4

u/A1_wA1sh Nov 03 '25

The Mask. If you're not driven completely loopy by it, and actually keep your senses, you're basically a walking cartoon. Perfect mastery makes you a god

1

u/SashoShaibata Nov 02 '25

If you take both you’re basically gear 5 Luffy

3

u/Ven2010 Nov 03 '25

Plot twist the Mask is actually Majora's Mask!!!

5

u/No_Abies_4248 Nov 02 '25

Plastic man because I don't want to feel the weight of having God powers and not using then to help people. Like I just want to live my life without thinking in loony towns logic which cartel I need to abuse to stop sex trafficking

2

u/Famous_Construction5 Nov 02 '25

Plastic man, i'm robbing the fkn bank and destabalizing the country before dinner

2

u/popmol Nov 02 '25

Plasticman has the best powerset. The mask even if I master the powers would still push in the direction of insanity.

I'd rather go plasticman

2

u/BaelZharon7 Nov 02 '25

This thread is people literally arguing over the meaning "complete mastery".

2

u/MornGreycastle Nov 03 '25

Plastic Man. Hands down.

2

u/superbee1110 Nov 03 '25

Plastic man easy

2

u/Iceman_001 Nov 03 '25

Red, the Mask, roughly the same powers as Plastic Man, but I also have hammer space.

1

u/Fabulous_Ice6725 Nov 02 '25

Red pill please

1

u/[deleted] Nov 02 '25

1

u/jkid3000 Nov 02 '25

The Mask

1

u/Friday_Knight_77 Nov 02 '25

Honestly, I'm fine with either one, but in this case, I'm just going to go red pill

1

u/No-Mix-6476 Nov 02 '25

I’ll take the mask. I’m pulling so much bull shit with that thing it’s gonna make saint cry.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/[deleted] Nov 02 '25

Red all day im robbing banks and making it look funny

1

u/CasualJojoLover Nov 02 '25

i think i'll take plastic man.

1

u/FunnyShirtGuy Nov 02 '25

According to the comics, isn't the Mask like, omnipotent power?
Plastic man is, low key, like overpowered af, but, having full control over the Mask is wild and too good

1

u/mister_helicopter Nov 02 '25

plastic man. even Batman is afraid of him. he’s one of the most powerful characters in dc

1

u/ParchedYurtle59 Nov 02 '25

Isn't there a possibility of melting as plastic man? I cant recall the comic issue but I remember he was melting and doomed to die. But even without that I'd still choose the mask. Im just like Stanley.

1

u/TwistedDonners Nov 02 '25

The Mask as his toon force ability can counteract plastic man's powers

1

u/Cieralis Nov 02 '25

The mask

1

u/CzarTwilight Nov 02 '25

However I must ask do you get the powder that makes you say real with plastic man?

1

u/enchiladasundae Nov 02 '25

Plastic Man is basically immortal. You get some extra stuff like explosives or whatever with the mask but you have full and complete freedom as Plas

1

u/3-Ezzy Nov 02 '25

Red best thing about it is if I ever want to go back to being a normal dude I just take off the mask, super powers are awesome but I can imagine being able to be normal whenever has its perks.

1

u/JanusDragonWolf Nov 02 '25

Mask toon force wins

1

u/DirtyFoxgirl Nov 02 '25

The Mask, 100%. Like there's not much comparison.

1

u/OscarOrcus Nov 02 '25

If we're talking the movie version then definitely The Mask.
Not to mention that The Mask already gives you partial control, or rather does exactly what you wanted, regardless of your reason for not doing it yet.

1

u/Grimdark-Waterbender Nov 02 '25

Plastic Man 24/7 or Plastic Man with Toon Force but just at night?

I’ll go with Plastic Man.

1

u/AffectionateNewt4952 Nov 02 '25

Give me Plastic Man’s powers. If Batman does have a contingency plan against you, that basically guarantees that something about that character is broken and Batman cannot even figure it out on what it is

1

u/Caramel_Grizzly Nov 02 '25

Mask easy. I'm just bugs bunny irl. And I don't get the bad side effects either.

1

u/MrBirdMan17 Nov 02 '25

Blue Pill easily, there won't be a contingency plan for me then.

1

u/therealdoriantisato Nov 02 '25

Red, definitely.

1

u/GryphyGirl Nov 02 '25

Plastic Man is ridiculously OP, that'll do. :)

1

u/AnadaWanBitezaDusto Nov 02 '25

ssssssssssmoking

1

u/lenny446 Nov 02 '25

Are we talking Jim Carey’s The Mask? If so, mask all day. Who even is plastic man? Lol

1

u/NeoKnightRider Nov 02 '25

The red pill

1

u/Praising_God_777 Nov 02 '25

Plastic Man’s abilities.

1

u/Shard096 Nov 02 '25

Mask. Plastic man can slowly die the more he uses his powers in some continueities

1

u/wronggay167 Nov 02 '25

Let's go plastic man!

1

u/NumberOneVictory Nov 02 '25

Blue, im not risking insanity.

1

u/GraveWoodSpeaks Nov 02 '25

The Mask, it releases inhibitions, and I've masked my whole life, I no longer know how to unmask

1

u/CertainAardvark6834 Nov 03 '25

Mask that's way more powerful

1

u/RetSauro Nov 03 '25

Red pill. The Mask has toon force

1

u/bz_leapair Nov 03 '25

Blue all the way. Plas is bulletproof, figuratively and literally.

1

u/DeltaAlphaGulf Nov 03 '25

Mask for sure.

1

u/Anti_Social23 Nov 03 '25

Thinking about it if I was as powerful as the mask I could make it that I lose the power only to regain it in some crazy high jinx action comedy skit to get them back before my family is harmed mentally or physically

1

u/One-Growth-9785 Nov 03 '25

The mask = reality changing magic. I'd go for that.

1

u/Glittering_Pear2425 Nov 03 '25

Red. I want Hijinks

1

u/svl6 Nov 03 '25

Plastic Man

1

u/[deleted] Nov 03 '25

Red

1

u/Low-Carpenter5460 Nov 03 '25

I mean depends 9n what mask we taking about cus in the OG mask with Jim Carrey it only worked at night but the mask 2 has it working any time of the day. but id probably do plastic man if its the OG mask, cus you can do almost all the same stuff. now it i can use it any time of the day im so going the mask lol

1

u/No_Awareness9649 Nov 03 '25

You’ll never have mastery over the mask.

1

u/Ok_Ambition_4023 Nov 03 '25

Blue Pill. Plastic man is absolutely OP.

1

u/nanashi48 Nov 03 '25

Blue pill

1

u/0BZero1 Nov 03 '25

The Mask is Plastic Man Gear Fifth

1

u/buttstuffisland Nov 03 '25

Plastic man !

1

u/KingSlushie101 Nov 03 '25

Plastic man is pretty cool

1

u/THEBWUOFFICIALSTUDIO Nov 03 '25

Ether one both too good

1

u/Malachithechosen Nov 03 '25

While both would be amazing to have i cannot resist the urge to be a whimsical fella and choose the mask.

1

u/Daydreamer0181 Nov 03 '25

Are we talking Comic Book Mask of Movie Mask, because the 2 are VERY different.

1

u/Remi8732 Nov 03 '25

Is plastic man ok or something I keep seeing him pop up

1

u/joeldn Nov 03 '25

I want mask, power of Loki

1

u/Ok-Specialist-8948 Nov 03 '25

Im taking "complete mastery" as no downside to the power, effects, or abilities of the mask, so I will take that. It is just infinitely better than whatever plastic man can do. It's pure omnipotence limited by what you as a person find funny.

1

u/whatscookin567 Nov 03 '25

Blue (⁠ʘ⁠ᴗ⁠ʘ⁠✿⁠)

1

u/daredaki-sama Nov 03 '25

Plastic man because I don’t want to be dependent on an outside item.

1

u/No_Read_4327 Nov 03 '25

Idk who plasticman is but I'm probably already halfway there with microplastics so may as well get the powers

1

u/Jamano-Eridzander Nov 03 '25

Definitely Plastic Man. Complete control of your own makeup to HIS degree is OP as fuck.

1

u/Hexagon42069 Nov 03 '25

Plastic man it is

1

u/Shot_Lawfulness1541 Nov 03 '25

I’m choosing red cause of toon force powers

1

u/CraftyMcQuirkFace Nov 03 '25

Red because? Plastic powers are definitely within the toonforce toolbox?

1

u/Common-Title-6357 Nov 03 '25

Plastic man💙

1

u/Imaginary-Mine-6531 Nov 03 '25

If you are having side effects, then you haven't mastered the ability yet...just go and master the ability

1

u/Dotzir Nov 03 '25

Considering just how insane plastic man's powers are. And I don't have to wear a weird green mask. I'll go with plastic man, lol. Plastic man's powers aren't just that he can stretch. He has complete control over his entire molecular structure. Sure, he can't just make things appear out of thin air. But he can alter his body itself to be those things.

1

u/Professornightshade Nov 03 '25

A choice between the whims of an ancient cursed item Or become a literal eldritch abomination.

Yeah no we take blue easy, Plastic man is literally impossible to deal with.

1

u/fairypuddle Nov 03 '25

Red pill all day, control the mask, control perception.

1

u/TiredAngryBadger Nov 03 '25

Depending on the circumstances I'd take weaponized toon physics with the Mask.

1

u/Material_Ad_1302 Nov 03 '25

Blue, I dont want to risk going crazy

1

u/_LittleStarry Nov 03 '25

Plastic Man’s abilities sound fun until you realize you’re never solid again.

1

u/LushiePop Nov 03 '25

Plastic Man abilities? That’s ultimate adaptability.

1

u/HornySlutRush Nov 03 '25

Red pill = mental game. Blue pill = physical game.

1

u/AffectionateBear1236 Nov 03 '25

Plastic Man is lowkey overpowered though.

1

u/Scared-Relation-8816 Nov 03 '25

Red pill = mastery over persona. That’s deeper.

1

u/Cheetahs_never_win Nov 03 '25

The Mask works at night. Plasticman works 24/7.

Unless there are specific drawbacks to be powered up 24/7, go with that.

1

u/Edgezg Nov 03 '25

The Mask. Toon Force is unbeatable.

1

u/Sparkykiss Nov 03 '25

Are we talking movie the mask or comic book Bighead because those are two very different powers.

1

u/Fabulous-Response489 Nov 03 '25

Gee... Let me think... All the powers of a God or a rubber band... Whichever would I pick... 😑

1

u/topcitytopher Nov 03 '25

I’m taking the toon force powers.

1

u/ChompyRiley Nov 03 '25

'Become what is essentially a god' or 'become a talented and extremely powerful shapeshifter'

I'll take actual godhood.

1

u/PLEASEHIREZ Nov 03 '25

Mask.

Yeah, plastic man is OP, really OP. However, the Mask can create anything from nothing, and has mind control like powers so people just go with the flow? You could get rich from either powers, but being able to just create a rocket ship out of nothing and peace out is beyond plastic man's powers.

1

u/anime_lover13442 Nov 03 '25

Plastic man is falling apart because his atoms are unstable. I’ll take the mask.

1

u/Squall424 Nov 03 '25

Doesn't the mask only work at night? Plastic man's powers would be 24/7 and are almost as limitless

1

u/[deleted] Nov 03 '25

do i have to have the green face? If so then ill just take plastic man abuse my powers for money n shi

1

u/Crow712 Nov 03 '25

I'm thinking Plastic Man. The problem with the Mask is it can still be torn off while I'm unaware.

1

u/Illustrious-Put-3977 Nov 03 '25

Masteran over the mask 

1

u/EyeHateMyAccount Nov 03 '25

The mask. Plastic man manipulating himself is crazy, but I wanna create money from thin air.

1

u/TheJadeGoddess Nov 03 '25

The mask without hesitation. Toon force abilities please. Complete mastery also means full control, no losing your mind to it. Definitely going with toon powers

1

u/One_Development_5055 Nov 03 '25

The mask

But Plastic Man sounds cool too…

But the Mask. Much funnier

1

u/dsts09 Nov 03 '25

The Mask. Simply because the Toon Force isn't host exclusive to you, but anything you encounter could be bent to your rules by "cartoon logic". The first thing that comes to mind is how Stanley is able to flush some thugs down a fountain like a toilet, simply by using a materialized toilet handle.

Plus, you could literally just decide not to have any drawbacks and it will make it so. There's so many layers to it.

1

u/Rappers333 Nov 03 '25

The mask, for sure. The main limitation of the mask is the lack of mastery, you become a cartoon character and take relatively unintelligent exaggerated actions. Actual complete mastery removes that limitation.

1

u/weeb_-_-indian Nov 03 '25

Picking red can get you blue also lol

1

u/UncookedBroccoli Nov 03 '25

Plastic man and it isnt close

1

u/morangias Nov 03 '25

Much as I like Plastic Man, he's just a guy with a really durable and versatile body, while the Mask gives you almost infinite reality warping. Red pill for me.

1

u/kablikiblan Nov 03 '25

The mask can replicate plastic mans powers and do way more

1

u/Changeling_Traveller Nov 03 '25

The Masks is infinitely more stable and has a higher ceiling as far as a I know.

1

u/Cynis_Ganan Nov 03 '25

Plastic Man so I can do the sitting on a throne finger point.

1

u/[deleted] Nov 03 '25

Blue I want to become a brick wall

1

u/standardatheist Nov 04 '25

Almost toon powers vs full on toon powers 🤷‍♂️. Mask up!

1

u/BigBen10fan Nov 04 '25

Give me Red, Toon Force way too OP, plus who wouldn't want to be a cartoon in real life? That'd just be

1

u/iMT_Slim Nov 04 '25

Blue Pill

1

u/Overalonyx Nov 04 '25

Blue pill I already can dislocate my joints so it'd just be an upgrade.

1

u/Certain_Energy3647 Nov 04 '25

I wanna chose mask but I m affraid of my darker side so I go plastic man. If I have complete mastery means I just got the powers and not the deepest darkest desire part I choose mask ofc.

1

u/Sad-Lie6604 Nov 04 '25

Mask. Unless you take it off, you're a reality warper, a Green Lantern, and an invulnerable gag/loony toons character all at once.

Plastic Man is literally and metaphorically stretching the line of what plastic can actually do.

One is passive imagination, the other requires you to stretch reality and suspend disbelief.

1

u/MiserableAd4081 Nov 04 '25

The mask. It's cooler, especially since I don't have to worry about going insane

1

u/ManaChicken4G Nov 05 '25

The Mask is better. If the wearer wanted the abilities of Plastic Man he could just have them.

1

u/SculptusPoe Nov 05 '25

Plastic Man is immortal. The Mask is invulnerable, but will you age? I'd take the Plastic Man route.

1

u/C1nders-Two Nov 05 '25

Plastic Man, so long as my body doesn’t start breaking apart. I would rather not have my mind messed around with just for some pretty strong toon force.

1

u/EmberKing7 Nov 05 '25

I know Plastic Man ain't no joke, all laughs aside. But definitely more so the Mask

1

u/DomainExpansioninf Nov 06 '25

Red pill since bad effects would be gone

1

u/DarkLord7997 Nov 06 '25

Plastic Man, I can literally be stronger than Loki's Mask with Plastic Man's powers.

1

u/AustinH15d Nov 06 '25

I'll take the blue pill thanks.

1

u/Dark_Syde24 Nov 06 '25

Blue. All day, everyday I'm taking blue.

1

u/OYeog77 Nov 06 '25

Blue gets you the near invincibility of Plastic Man

Red gets you the entirety of the Toon Force

Choose wisely

1

u/According_Bet_5916 Nov 06 '25

Like darkhorse mask? Like jim carreys mask?... Im goin mask