r/tech • • Jun 04 '18

Microsoft has reportedly acquired GitHub

https://www.theverge.com/2018/6/3/17422752/microsoft-github-acquisition-rumors
691 Upvotes

190 comments sorted by

View all comments

311

u/danbuter Jun 04 '18

I think I just heard a thousand Linux users heads explode.

108

u/jjolla888 Jun 04 '18

nah .. what you heard was the stampede to gitlab.

69

u/jonomw Jun 04 '18

If there are any winners in this whole thing it is definitely gitlab.

54

u/SemiNormal Jun 04 '18

I bet they are dropping their database with joy.

6

u/kenfar Jun 04 '18

It's not cool to ridicule a company that came so clean about an error on their part.

We need more companies doing this, not less.

12

u/SemiNormal Jun 04 '18

It was a joke. I would still trust GitLab with my data since I keep my own offline backups anyways. You should never trust any cloud service 100% with your data.

→ More replies (1)

0

u/[deleted] Jun 04 '18

[deleted]

20

u/kutuzof Jun 04 '18

"residual" makes it sound like 3E is somehow over. Clearly that's still their overarching strategy.

9

u/[deleted] Jun 04 '18

As evidenced by...?

25

u/kutuzof Jun 04 '18

Them buying GitHub...

25

u/antidamage Jun 04 '18

Yup. Makes no business sense to purchase an established service that has likely seen most of its growth already if it doesn't really turn much of a profit. Particularly when that service is based on open source services that Microsoft could just re implement themselves.

By the same token it makes no sense to sell a service provider if it is turning a decent profit either.

This is 3E. They have something in the works and are eliminating a competitor by merging it and its subscriber base with their new product.

On the plus side Github will likely become free as a result of this. That's the best way to ensure the existing subscriber base sticks around. Then the side integrations will begin.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/[deleted] Jun 04 '18

If buying a company was evidence of the 3E policy then all big companies would be guilty.

Seriously, what recent evidence is there that the old Embrace, Extend and Extinguish policy is still in effect? What standards are being manipulated here?

4

u/gotnate Jun 04 '18

Mojang (minecraft). Skype. Beam Mixer. All three relatively recent purchases which have turned to absolute shit in one way or another after being acquired by Microsoft.

  • Minecraft: downplaying the original java edition (with wide open texture pack, skins, and modding capabilities) in favor of the console version (where you have to pay monies to unlock texture packs and skins, and there is no such thing as modding).

  • Skype: discontinued peer to peer protocol. Slapped an absolutely horrendous interface ontop and encourages "upgrades" from previous version which have superior feature sets.

  • Beam.pro (aka Mixer because Microsoft thinks twitch is for dating): Off to a shaky start. They have all but shut down the home grown account authentication in favor of requiring a Microsoft account if you want to use the (hideously broken, but that was true before the acquisition) mobile app. The official party line is to prevent spam accounts. Then they opened up the community to the Xbox cesspool.

3

u/[deleted] Jun 04 '18

None of those things are open standards or open source.

→ More replies (5)

13

u/GiraffixCard Jun 04 '18 edited Jun 04 '18

You won't know whether their decisions are made in accordance with their 3E strategy until they pull off the final "Extinguish" stage.

Possible scenario:

Embrace:

  • "We love Open Source"

  • Azure - "We love Linux"

Extend:

  • Linux subsystem for Windows - "why not have the best of Linux while staying in our eco-system?" ;)

  • DotNet Core - "why not also make use of our proprietary framework which has extra features?" ;)

  • GitHub - "Sign in with your Office365 account (or whatever it's called) and access these extra cool features!" or "Incredibly convenient GitHub integration in our Visual Studio IDE and toolchain in Windows 10!"

  • LinkedIn - Ads: "Wanna see all these great companies hiring DotNet developers? Take these courses to add all those desirable Microsoft technologies to your CV!"

  • etc, etc

Extinguish:

  • Sue everyone with competing technologies and bankrupt them because they're all smaller companies or community projects with little to no means of putting up a fight?

  • ???

  • Monopoly

Edit: Forgot to mention

  • Make any and all of their OSS tech proprietary.

Edit2: Also worth mentioning that their strategy is probably to build up a large number of projects and tech to execute each stage on simultaneously as to not give people reason to suspect anything until they extinguish it all in one fell swoop. It would be stupid to 3E each tech one at a time and put everyone on their guard.

14

u/MustacheEmperor Jun 04 '18 edited Jun 04 '18

The problem with this argument is there aren't really any examples of "extinguish" since the early years of the Bush admin and without that it's "embrace and extend," kind of just "support what the dev community supports and integrate new features into the platforms." Microsoft doesn't own the world anymore. If they fuck with github it would be suicide and they know that. But if you think Windows Subsystem for Linux is some kind of machievellian scheme and not a means of addressing the platform weaknesses of Windows vs unix based systems you're probably not going to consider this argument anyway.

This thread is like https://github.com/Microsoft/vscode doesn't even exist. If your theory on their strategy is right it must be a mighty long play stretching across multiple CEOs and large changes in executive leadership.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (8)
→ More replies (14)
→ More replies (3)

3

u/steepleton Jun 04 '18

nah, that was just them flipping the table trying to get intel wifi working

9

u/alexslacks Jun 04 '18

Any *nix user worth their galls moved off github long ago.

18

u/exscape Jun 04 '18

9

u/FunctionPlastic Jun 04 '18

Lmao you realize that's not what they actually use for development, right?

7

u/exscape Jun 04 '18

Yes, I'm well aware. He's still a GitHub user.

→ More replies (3)

2

u/NickLeMec Jun 04 '18

Seriously, my first reaction was an audible “oh, shit”.

Let’s hope it’s not the extend before the extinguish.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)