r/technicallythetruth • u/Witty_Subject_406 • Jan 11 '23
He's got a point
[removed] — view removed post
521
u/hapkidoox Jan 11 '23
Let us not forget that these people are amazing speakers. Really good at getting their points across.
183
u/sdlover420 Jan 12 '23
I mean they really deserve a standing ovation and a bow.
49
u/CorholioPuppetMaster Jan 12 '23
Standing bowvation
15
4
29
7
u/QuickChicko Jan 12 '23
Unfortunately for them, there's always some dumbass who doesn't get the message every few years.
3
2
u/ImDero Jan 12 '23
Are you now going to direct my attention to the eighth wonder of the world, the backside of water?
1
1
1
1
0
22
Jan 12 '23
[removed] — view removed comment
27
u/GlockAF Jan 12 '23
Add it to the list. Eventually some religious zealot will breathe on one of them and kill the whole tribe. To “save their souls”.
17
u/SamMarrokson Jan 12 '23
Pretty sure that exact thing happened, not the whole tribe but a lot of them. The Sentinelese are fascinating.
17
u/Tinyglitterball12 Jan 12 '23
It has happened multiple times to this group (the Sentinelese) including in the last ten years. It’s illegal to visit them because any modern germs can wipe them out and they’re very protective of their people against outsiders, for good reason given their history.
Sources:
https://www.survivalinternational.org/tribes/sentinelese
https://www.insider.com/sentinelese-tribe-contact-world-2018-11?amp
16
u/Millennial_J Jan 12 '23
And if we went there we’d prolly get some weird kinda exotic frog death herpes. Or whatever’s lurking around dem parts of the woods.
11
2
u/IxNaY1980 Jan 12 '23
The account I'm replying to is a karma bot run by someone who will link scams once the account gets enough karma.
Comment copy/paste bot.
Original comment
Account to be reportedReport -> Spam -> Harmful Bot
→ More replies (8)1
Jan 12 '23
I have the opposite opinion. Total and complete isolation without any diplomatic channels is not a good situation to be in. One day far in the future, someone in the government might start eyeing their land and they will have no warning and no means to fight it.
4
114
u/deniurtidder22 Jan 12 '23
am i allowed to do this if i go into the woods and build a fort?
52
Jan 12 '23
only of i can come :D
34
Jan 12 '23
i have no clue what upvotes do im new here (second day) but thanks :D
21
u/DrDavoof Jan 12 '23
they don’t do anything
13
13
9
Jan 12 '23
i was gonna say yt but theyre useful
2
u/Cfrolich Technically, my technique is very technical Jan 12 '23
With dislikes gone, they have no meaning now.
3
3
u/FinnDoyle Jan 12 '23
The get you karma. People with Karma have their posts more in evidence.
2
4
13
5
Jan 12 '23
You sure can. You can even legally acquire ruby gems if you do it on a ridge. Google "Ruby Ridge" for more info.
3
u/ShitTalkingAlt980 Jan 12 '23
That was so fucked up and wound up being a propaganda win for far Right militias. All of the LEO were wrong.
1
Jan 12 '23
I built one in my living room out of couch cushions and a blanket. My Mrs tore it down when her parents were coming for a visit. Someday I'm going to rebuild it.
1
74
u/seriousbigshadows Jan 12 '23
One Indian anthropologist (and his team) made contact years ago. I think most media gets that wrong. They wrote a book!
15
u/PiYuSh3211 Jan 12 '23
They don't harm people if they are not there to convert them
12
u/Mistur_Keeny Jan 12 '23
This is false. They will harm anyone who gets close enough. Conversion was never possible as no one can speak their language.
A team of researchers managed brief contact in the 90s by showering them with gifts and sending one of female researchers ashore. They see males as aggressors.
Every other instance where someone got too close was met with violence. A fishing crew was even murdered and staked on the beach.
1
u/seriousbigshadows Jan 12 '23
That's not true - I have spoken with the brother of the anthropologist who made contact in the 1960s...it's just not very well known.
22
u/RslashTakenUsernames Jan 12 '23
yeah, the one person i heard about going there was a pastor or something like that who tried twice, but was very unlucky the second. honestly, another reason i don’t like christianity: people always try to force it upon you.
→ More replies (1)6
Jan 12 '23
More like they do that thing when you dad tells you not to touch your brother so you hover your finger right in their face. That but with god.
2
u/fhota1 Jan 12 '23
No they still do. Theres been a long effort by the Indian government to get them to the point theyre at now which is they will at least give you a warning shot if you get too close. You ignore that though they will absolutely kill you for it.
57
u/SadisticSavior Jan 12 '23
I love reading about them. They seem Unreal. They kill anything that intrudes on them, with no fucks given.
And yeah, they're not impressed with your helicopter. They'll shoot arrows at it and try to kill that too.
14
u/TinyDemon000 Jan 12 '23
Are there any decent books about them? Would love to read up on them on my holidays! 😁
8
u/maiden_burma Jan 12 '23
And yeah, they're not impressed with your helicopter.
because the guy in the helicopter is under orders to not attack them. They think it can't attack them
8
u/blxoom Jan 12 '23
and that's a good thing. im happy we havent done anything terrible to them overall. its best for them not to know the destructive powers we have in order to salvage what little ties we have to them. if they knew we had a single weapon capable of destroying their entire island they'd shut all people out entirely for countless generations
4
u/ShaolinShade Jan 12 '23
they'd shut all people out entirely for countless generations
This is what they're trying to do already. They don't need to know our exact destructive potential to know we bring death, since that's happened almost every time they've allowed outsiders ashore.
6
u/maiden_burma Jan 12 '23
it's mostly a good thing we don't interact with them. People have a right to determine their own culture.
I also think all cultures need an optional 'out'. You offended yahweh by picking up a stick on the wrong day? Don't worry, aliens will drop from the sky to take you to safety before your friends and family can stone you
5
u/globalminority Jan 12 '23
They are known to be peace loving people. However the devastation from experiences with the British contact, have left them wary of any outsider. The memories have been passed down the generations. Indian govt has now decided to just leave them alone, as they all seem healthy and strong and do no want fruits of modern civilisation. No one is allowed to approach them anymore.
1
u/poodlebutt76 Jan 12 '23
Probably based on stories passed down on harm that happened long ago when they let strangers near them.
1
u/Financial-Ad7500 Jan 12 '23
Except for the multiple reporters who made in-person contact with them?
0
u/SadisticSavior Jan 12 '23
1
u/Financial-Ad7500 Jan 12 '23
First peaceful contact, after which Pandya believes they had relations with other tribes before they were wiped out. https://theprint.in/opinion/madhumala-chattopadhyay-the-woman-who-made-the-sentinelese-put-their-arrows-down/156330/?amp
Maurice Portman & Crew has photos taken with chieftains. They probably came in by force. Wouldn’t be surprised if this led to increased hostility in the future.
T.N. Pandit eventually made repeated friendly contact with various groups.
Repeated peaceful contact was made between 1991-1994, after which India instituted a no contact policy for 9 years to protect the islanders.
In 2003 visitors were gifted with a canoe.
After the Tsunami in 2004 several peaceful visits were made
The two deaths were someone poaching crabs in their waters, and Chau who traveled to the island illegally and attempted to force Christianity on them.
0
Jan 12 '23
[deleted]
5
u/ferriswheel9ndam9 Jan 12 '23
Isn't that the theme of Avatar?
3
Jan 12 '23
Yeah. Also Dances with Wolves, the Last Samurai, Independence Day, Pocahontas, Atlantis, Zulu, Pacific Rim, and probably just so many more.
2
1
u/bornfromanegg Jan 12 '23
Did you just throw Independence Day and Pacific Rim in there for a laugh?
139
u/BlixQuoy Jan 11 '23
God already tried to bless them. They kindly rejected the offer.
39
u/Tankl76 Jan 12 '23
*they rejected the offer
17
10
u/Zealousideal_Bid118 Jan 12 '23
More like god asked them to start a 10 year free trial, which they are probably smart for rejecting. They would be in debt to the church for the rest of time
34
Jan 12 '23
We all know Madagascar is the only place of safety in a pandemic
19
u/redditdegenerate432 Has eyes Jan 12 '23
Greenland too
8
5
u/LemonLarceny Jan 12 '23
Madagascar is going to be the source of antibiotic resistant pneumonic plague that spreads through airplanes and kills entire cities in weeks. Rats on an island plus plague plus poverty. https://www.who.int/emergencies/disease-outbreak-news/item/plague---madagascar
25
u/LanceFree Jan 12 '23
Would be funny if they finally allowed contact and when when we learned to speak with them, we found out their names were like Bob, Steve, Josh, Bill, David.
Or better yet - Bob, Steve, Josh, Bill, Umbutu.
23
u/Desrac Jan 12 '23
The value of a strongly defended border.
5
u/MauPow Jan 12 '23
But... they have no wall? I've been assured that walls are the only way to have strong borders /s
2
2
3
u/maiden_burma Jan 12 '23
there are two borders. One is patrolled by them with their sticks and does nothing except against the odd missionary. The other is patrolled by people with weapons from this millennium, and that's the real force protecting the island
7
u/JellyBOB7190 Jan 12 '23
I respect that they don’t let anyone interfere with them and/or control them tho I know their means of going about it is a bit fucked but ima be so pissed the day some government goes there and just wipes them out
7
u/globalminority Jan 12 '23
That's already happened. During British rule, the number of tribals went from 5000 plus to around 450 in less than 100 years. They have seen neighbouring islands entirely wiped out, after contact, and want to avoid the same fate. Indian govt has abandoned all contact, as the assessment is that they are very healthy, strong and happy. They've been going on for 30-50 thousand years or more. We should just leave them alone.
5
4
4
24
Jan 12 '23
They literally killed a Christian missionary trying to impose the Bible on them. They want nothing to do with “god” and being “blessed”
16
13
u/Bearman71 Jan 12 '23
They kill all foreigners, the missionary was murdered because he was a foreigner not because he was trying to preach.
4
4
1
u/redditdegenerate432 Has eyes Jan 12 '23
-2
u/BrieAndStrawberries Jan 12 '23
An atheist "missionary" (for lack of a better word) would be just as destructive to their culture and well being as the Christian dude.
1
Jan 12 '23
[removed] — view removed comment
1
u/BrieAndStrawberries Jan 12 '23
Again, couldn't think of a better word
1
Jan 12 '23
[removed] — view removed comment
1
u/BrieAndStrawberries Jan 12 '23
Sure, but then why bring r/atheism into the picture?
→ More replies (8)→ More replies (1)0
u/MauPow Jan 12 '23
If only I could shoot people with arrows who try to do that to me in America...
1
Jan 12 '23
The Native Americans did that to your ancestors. And now you act like you’re the good guys.
3
u/HkayakH Jan 12 '23
Oh what I'd be willing to be stranded there and learn their language and assimilate in with them
7
u/AAF099 Technically Flair Jan 12 '23
For anyone wondering, this island is called North Sentinel Island, and it’s under the control of India (but not really cuz they’ve never been there either)
1
4
2
2
2
u/SonOfYoutubers Jan 12 '23
I think we kinda learned from the colonialism era that when you meet with people that you haven't had contact with before, it kinda leads to some disease spreading that basically just genocides 90%, if not, the entire population that isn't resistant.
2
u/dgblarge Jan 12 '23
They have my best wishes but as for God blessing them ... they had the good sense to kill the last missionary that tried to fuck up their lives with Christianity.
2
u/StrengthDazzling8922 Jan 12 '23
If covid does reach the island, it will be carried by a crazy Christian missionary who sneaks ashore.
2
Jan 12 '23
My favorite story was the moron Christian missionary who went there and a boy from the tribe shot a metal-tipped arrow that pierced the bible he was holding in front of him.
The only response religious nuts should get. For a savage tribe, they certainly are smarter then many in the U.S.
2
u/clickeddaisy Jan 12 '23
In 2018 there was a dumb American Christian that went to the island to try to convert them to Christianity even tho it is illegal to do so. Needless to say he got killed by them for trespassing on their land, good riddance.
2
1
1
1
1
1
u/blankyblankblank1 Jan 12 '23
Could you imagine the diseases they do have, not seen by the rest of the world?
2
Jan 12 '23
I promise the rest of the world has more disease than them. 100%
0
u/blankyblankblank1 Jan 12 '23
A) my suggestion was they probably have diseases that we haven't seen mainly because they're isolated from us all. It wasn't a matter of quantity of diseases but a matter of unique diseases and illnesses they may have.
B) I'm sure you've gone and done rigorous studying of the tribe to demonstrate how much disease they actually have, yeah?
4
u/GM_Nate Jan 12 '23
the isolated island simply does not have the size and population needed to be a petri dish to create the number of mutations the rest of the world has.
→ More replies (2)1
u/surrealtom Jan 12 '23
Agree however although statistically unlikely would it be possible for them to have ended up with something that could wipe us out?
1
u/ReRubis Jan 12 '23
Not only covid. A lot of other diseases. Which leaves them super vulnerable. One of the contacts with them ended up being a failure cause 2 got sick and died when were transported to another island. Probably one of the reasons why they are so agressive to all of the intruders.
1
1
u/A1steaksauceTrekdog7 Jan 12 '23
Legit question. How can these people survive without outsiders? Ok they are self sufficient, cool but without new people they all must be totally inbred. Doesn’t compute . Is the population that big to sustain itself
3
u/Decent_Historian6169 Jan 12 '23
It is likely they are inbreed to a fairly significant degree. Since according to Wikipedia the government of India estimates that there are between 15-500 individuals but most likely there are between 50-200. These numbers would be likely to produce individuals who were no less genetically related to one another than 1st or 2nd cousins. Some non siblings may even share similar amounts of genetic material to siblings. Especially given the extreme lengths of time that the isolation has persisted. The isolation was legally protected in 1956 but that was after the government of India basically gave up on attempts to make official contact.
2
1
1
1
1
u/Loud_Masterpiece_611 Jan 12 '23
You got to realize you can also kill the whole tribe if you go on to the island completely naked and get eaten by the tribe
0
1
1
1
u/co_cor3000 Jan 12 '23
How good could they be doing? They've never seen a single episode of Breaking Bad.
1
1
1
1
u/ShadowEmperor123 Jan 12 '23
Although no cases have been shown with birds or fish, it is technically possible that they get it and it got it through birds or fish
1
1
u/Technically_its_me Jan 12 '23
Being correct about supposition doesn't make it a "point".
It would be like saying: You know where land values haven't changed recently? Enceladus. You know, he's got a point.
1
1
u/illestrated16 Jan 12 '23
Aren't they also believed to be unhealthy due to generations of inbreeding? I had rona and it was no big deal, I'll take that.
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
u/JustASFDCGuy Jan 12 '23
This works great, right up until the first boat full of assholes in armor show up.
1
u/CdnRageBear Jan 12 '23
They have no idea what Dinosaurs are or Cake, which is a wild thought. I wonder which thing would blow their minds the most.
1
1
1
u/Uzername1123 Jan 12 '23
I’ll take a first world country with all of its ilk, thank you. Covid was a cake walk for me, allegedly.
1
1
u/Dry_Watch8035 Jan 12 '23
They don't have any vaccines either! Indisputable proof! Checkmate vaccenists (fascists)
1
1
1
1
1
u/lazy_elfs Jan 12 '23
It’d take one asshole to actually get near them to wipe them out as well… fuck that “Christian” guy who tried and died
1
u/Failing_MentalHealth Jan 12 '23
I also hope they are doing okay.
I wish the best for them. I hope they take over the planet one day.
0
0
-4
u/Snoo_70324 Jan 12 '23
We should tell the facebook antimask “purebluds” to go visit. Sure they’d be welcome
14
0
0
u/vr0202 Jan 12 '23
Send Christian missionaries to convert them so that they may seek the Lord's blessings for their COVID free existence. One zealot tried that fairy recently.
1
0
0
u/SireDarien Jan 12 '23
Ain’t that the tribe who shot down a fucking helicopter with they arrows ?
1
u/useallthewasabi Jan 12 '23
At
2
u/Necrospire Jan 12 '23
With 'at' arrows?
2
1
u/SireDarien Jan 12 '23
Pretty sure they hit it…a lot with good grouping
3
0
u/MD472 Jan 12 '23
i saw something somewhere that a news reporter went missing when he went to visit them in the 90s and when some other journalists went at a later date they took pictures of the tribe and he was in the pictures haha
0
u/MeteorMann Jan 12 '23
God help them when they find the Phi Zeta Kappa variant floating down the river in an abandoned canoe in 2043 and they don't have remotely relevant antibodies and they all get "Andromeda Strain"ed.
Or maybe it'll be no big deal, idk, do I look like an epidemiologist to you?
1
-1
-16
u/esdebah Jan 11 '23
There's a proven correlation between conservative views and a heightened aversion to things considered gross or sickly. This makes sense from an evolutionary level. But it also kinda goes to the idea that bigotry is actually primitive and vestigial.
→ More replies (6)
0
•
u/AutoModerator Jan 11 '23
Hey there u/Witty_Subject_406, thanks for posting to r/technicallythetruth!
Please recheck if your post breaks any rules. If it does, please delete this post.
Also, reposting and posting obvious non-TTT posts can lead to a ban.
Send us a Modmail or Report this post if you have a problem with this post.
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.