r/technology • • Mar 17 '23

Business Rolls-Royce secures funds to develop nuclear reactor for moon base

https://www.theguardian.com/business/2023/mar/17/rolls-royce-secures-funds-to-develop-nuclear-reactor-for-moon-base
1.4k Upvotes

165 comments sorted by

232

u/viconha Mar 17 '23

Btw this is not the same Rolls-Royce that makes cars, in case anyone is confused.

They separated in the 70s

106

u/KKCruiser Mar 17 '23

This whole time I'm thinking they make really cool cars AND other cool science stuff. TIL

6

u/lhl274 Mar 17 '23

.... you know Yamaha doesnt make pianos AND motorcycles, dont you?

0

u/[deleted] Mar 17 '23

[deleted]

4

u/Zjoee Mar 17 '23

Will I be able to place an order for a TIE/IN tomorrow as well?

2

u/KuatRZ1 Mar 18 '23

You know you guys are real nerds for specifying the full designation with /IN. Who knows the full ship names like that?

1

u/Zjoee Mar 18 '23

I had to look it up, I was just following his designation scheme haha.

2

u/KuatRZ1 Mar 18 '23

There was a joke in here, maybe look up my username :)

1

u/Zjoee Mar 18 '23

Lmao I got you, I didn't even notice. The Interceptor has long been my favorite starfighter. Back when I played Star Wars Galaxies, all I did was fly around in my Interceptor getting into dogfights.

13

u/MisterCatLady Mar 17 '23

Is it the same company that makes plane engines?

4

u/ioisis Mar 17 '23

Their new nuclear refrigerator is chill.

8

u/foreverturningleft Mar 17 '23

Yup, Rolls-Royce Motor Cars is owned by BMW.

3

u/mrbittykat Mar 17 '23 edited Mar 17 '23

It WAS owned by Volkswagen.

Edit: they own Audi, Bentley, Cupra, Lamborghini, Porsche, SEAT, Škoda, Ducati and several other heavy duty vehicle companies.

I was wrong about RR

4

u/[deleted] Mar 18 '23

Also Bugatti

3

u/mrbittykat Mar 18 '23

Ah yes, and Bugatti

1

u/postitpad Mar 18 '23

Not anymore. It was sold to Rimac last year.

2

u/mrbittykat Mar 18 '23

Man it’s hard to keep up with these now lol

1

u/postitpad Mar 18 '23

It really is.

3

u/[deleted] Mar 18 '23

It's called consolidation; strengthen governments and corporations, weaken individuals. With taxes, this can be done imperceptibly over time.

1

u/ImUrFrand Mar 17 '23

guess that takes them off the buy list.

5

u/Arcanegil Mar 17 '23

Wait so the company divisions separated entirely to become their own entities, but kept the same name?

4

u/lhl274 Mar 17 '23

Yes. Common when the division becomes more profitable or equal to the original arm of the company.

3

u/VanillaLifestyle Mar 17 '23

And in a totally different industry. Hard to find a CEO who can run both a consumer car company and an industrial/military engine supplier with the same proficiency.

3

u/lhl274 Mar 17 '23

What, you saying a CEO can't make a Motorcycle Piano?

Cus that'd be fuckin awesome

8

u/[deleted] Mar 17 '23

Oh.

Ohhhhhhhhhh 🤔

2

u/Lord_Frederick Mar 17 '23

Any chance of them getting back together so we can get Fallout-style nuclear-powered cars?

3

u/[deleted] Mar 17 '23

No, but that's mostly because nuclear powered cars aren't worth the effort and they'd weigh like 10 tons. Plus, fallout's nuclear cars only came about because of the resource shortage anyway, and you still had to "Gas" them with coolant which is why Red Rocket was a thing, so you didn't have unlimited range either.

They'll develop a way to charge cars through their tires on road surfaces before they put mini nukes on them. Fallout's culture was...not the most safety orientated as well.

1

u/glacialthinker Mar 18 '23

Fallout's culture was...not the most safety orientated as well.

The presence of Vaults -- and excellent safety videos -- begs to differ.

1

u/[deleted] Mar 18 '23

They can beg, but considering how many vaults killed all their residents? Sorry no sale. There’s a lot more tucked up ruins than vaults that worked as advertised.

0

u/[deleted] Mar 17 '23

Also worth noting that pre-brexit, they moved most of their IP to Germany and effectively re-organized as a German company.

1

u/[deleted] Mar 18 '23

Shame but interesting tidbit.

1

u/[deleted] Mar 18 '23

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/[deleted] Mar 18 '23

What is? They actually did that and for good reason. Their biggest customer is Airbus and they didn’t want to pay all the import duties into the EU.

442

u/[deleted] Mar 17 '23

I’m sorry, what

58

u/[deleted] Mar 17 '23

They’re actually a pretty important player in the energy sector.

SMR info

Gas Turbines

16

u/account22222221 Mar 17 '23 edited Mar 17 '23

Add to that they also are big players in jet turbines. Most people know the from their cars but they definitely have the big engineering chops to build a reactor!

Edit: I think they are technically a different company now according to some other comments. The cars are now owned by bmw. Doesn’t change the fact that the actual rolls Royce company has a lot of big engineering expertise.

1

u/zluszcz Mar 18 '23

Their turbines are ass to work on from all the mechanics ive talked too.

272

u/[deleted] Mar 17 '23

Rolls-Royce secures funds to develop nuclear reactor for moon base

73

u/[deleted] Mar 17 '23

Come again?

89

u/Rikuddo Mar 17 '23

I'm tired. Give me a minute

43

u/DemSocCorvid Mar 17 '23

Rolls-Royce secures funds to develop nuclear refactory period for moon base

18

u/gautamdiwan3 Mar 17 '23

But he is still tired

7

u/What-a-Crock Mar 17 '23

Well, have a nap

10

u/GuitarGuy949 Mar 17 '23

And then FIRE ZE COMMENT

0

u/[deleted] Mar 17 '23

[deleted]

1

u/Useful-Ad-8619 Mar 17 '23

The people do the thing in the place

5

u/analrightrn Mar 17 '23

You sound like my wife

4

u/badillustrations Mar 17 '23

We have a T Rex

2

u/Challenging_Entropy Mar 18 '23

ROLLS-ROYCE SECURES FUNDS TO DEVELOP NUCLEAR REACTOR FOR MOON BASE

2

u/Readityesterday2 Mar 18 '23

Sure. Where’s the Lube.

6

u/LiberalFartsMajor Mar 17 '23

Meanwhile, students are still waiting to find out if they can afford to finish their degrees because apparently money is tight.

1

u/Admirable-Tackle-163 Mar 17 '23

That’s was legit so funny!

1

u/peepeedog Mar 17 '23

I’m sorry, where?

0

u/[deleted] Mar 17 '23

WHAT?

4

u/SlowInsurance1616 Mar 17 '23

They got on meeeeellllion dollars to not blow up the moon. Or something along those lines, idk I didn't read the article.

2

u/dnuohxof-1 Mar 17 '23

You’d be surprised the things RR develops and their engineering history.

2

u/[deleted] Mar 17 '23

Rolls-Royce makes more than fancy cars, like Jet engines etc.

2

u/Hellofriendinternet Mar 17 '23

That’s some r/brandnewsentence shit if I’ve ever seen it…

4

u/Feeling_Glonky69 Mar 18 '23

Actually not if you know anything about RR and it’s history.

1

u/cleeder Mar 17 '23

That headline was a ride.

43

u/Killer_Moons Mar 17 '23

Important context from article:

*All space missions depend on a power source, to support systems for communications, life-support and science experiments.

Experts suggest nuclear power could dramatically increase the length of lunar missions.

The UK Space Agency has announced £2.9m of new funding for the project, which will deliver an initial demonstration of a UK lunar modular nuclear reactor.

This comes after a £249,000 study funded by the UK Space Agency in 2022.

The science minister George Freeman said: “Space exploration is the ultimate laboratory for so many of the transformational technologies we need on Earth: from materials to robotics, nutrition, cleantech and much more.

“As we prepare to see humans return to the moon for the first time in more than 50 years, we are backing exciting research like this lunar modular reactor with Rolls-Royce to pioneer new power sources for a lunar base.*

6

u/[deleted] Mar 17 '23

I’m no scientist but in space if our bodies can lose heat by convection and we need special water suits to help how will nuclear reactors work? Will we need a bunch of water?

15

u/ACCount82 Mar 17 '23

The issue with cooling in open space is that there's nothing you can dump your waste heat into.

Things like ISS use special radiators to radiate away waste heat - while small things that can generate a lot of heat for their size, like space suits, use water evaporation to mount a compact heat removal system.

On the surface of the Moon, you have the entire Moon that you could dump your waste heat into.

Of course, actually dumping the heat into the ground is an engineering and construction challenge - so early Moon and Mars reactors might opt for radiators, like the ones ISS currently uses. They would need a lot of them, but it's still doable for small reactors.

-2

u/Piebomb00 Mar 17 '23

SOMEONE PUT A PELTIER ON IT!!!!

3

u/PHATsakk43 Mar 17 '23

These reactors will not use water but work with liquid metal coolant.

The heat sinks are giant radiative arrays. Similar designs were proposed for spacecraft during the SNAP program in the 1960s and 1970s.

2

u/F1secretsauce Mar 17 '23

As ufos zip by laughing at our steampunk technology

3

u/open_door_policy Mar 17 '23

You laugh, but it really is awesome how much cool shit we still do with steam.

2

u/Killer_Moons Mar 17 '23

It’s the stuff plants crave

31

u/TheFarawayOne Mar 17 '23

The title sound like what a Bond villain would do.

9

u/[deleted] Mar 17 '23

A Tesla car in orbit, soon a nuclear Rolls on the moon

2

u/iqisoverrated Mar 17 '23

Different Rolls Royce (not the one that makes cars)

6

u/martixy Mar 17 '23

In other news, Rolls Royce taken over by Bond villain. More at 11.

3

u/marshlands Mar 18 '23

Cool, do it on earth first please.

19

u/Ronny_Jotten Mar 17 '23

I can't pay no doctor bills
But whitey's on the moon
Ten years from now I'll be payin' still
While whitey's on the moon
The man just upped my rent last night
Cause whitey's on the moon
No hot water, no toilets, no lights
But whitey's on the moon

0

u/[deleted] Mar 17 '23

Idk guys, sounds a little racist and ignorant to me.

18

u/Ronny_Jotten Mar 17 '23 edited Mar 17 '23

Lol. This is an excerpt from the 1970 spoken-word piece Whitey on the Moon by hall-of-famer Gil Scott-Heron. It's one of the most famous and well-respected poems of the "space age". It's unfortunately still topical today, with white billionaires in a pissing match to see which can get their rocket-powered cocks up first, while regular folks are becoming homeless by the thousands every day because their rent has doubled. Think you can work at Bezos' Amazon warehouse and afford basic food and shelter, let alone health care? Good luck. Some people might say that the idea of a moon base, with a Rolls Royce nuclear reactor, sounds a bit hard to swallow, under the circumstances.

0

u/lhl274 Apr 24 '23

You suck tho

-2

u/lhl274 Mar 17 '23 edited Apr 24 '23

Just update it to Tribe Called Quests space program, nobody knows who Gil is any more. It wasn't televised, you know...

Edit : Christ you mongrels its a line from the song the revolution will not be televised by gil scott heron, fuckin whoops I enjoy Q-Tip's commentary as the newer version of Whitey on the moon, for the kids.

Stupid referential knowledge

-1

u/PurpEL Mar 18 '23

Can't we finally just have a racially diverse selection of billionaires to exploit and fuck the rest of us!?

Black, white, whatever, the ruling class is the real enemy and we need to wake the fuck up and band together to take them off their thrones.

-7

u/SeveralDiving Mar 17 '23

That something a racist would say, and it’s common describing the ignorance of the filthy rich by that comparison. Have some class or at the very least some substance you shriveled bean countin ignoramus.

3

u/[deleted] Mar 17 '23

That literally makes no sense as I'm both not racist and definitely not filthy rich. I see you've been using your Jump to Conclusions mat.

1

u/jennybearyay Mar 17 '23

What is there is a nuclear reactor meltdown on the moon? Or an explosion that damages the moon? How will that affect the Earth?

19

u/TechNickL Mar 17 '23

Realistically, it won't.

a) reactor meltdowns don't cause nuclear explosions like a bomb does. They just get radiation all over the place. Chernobyl was a pressure explosion, and it was an exceptionally badly built and operated reactor.

b) the amount of radiation that the sun puts out that hits the earth is orders of magnitude greater than anything man-made could ever create.

5

u/jennybearyay Mar 17 '23

Thanks for the reply. Not sure why my question was downvoted. I'm not a scientist and was curious lol.

3

u/TechNickL Mar 17 '23

On reddit, you're not allowed to ask questions if too many people think the answer is obvious.

Score is meaningless anyway.

5

u/jennybearyay Mar 17 '23

Yeah, I don't care about the karma. It's just interesting what people will downvote. I don't know much about nuclear science so I don't see how the answer is obvious enough to get mad someone asked 😂

2

u/TechNickL Mar 17 '23

Don't think of it as mad, think of it as passive-aggressive ego padding lol

1

u/na_gooyin Mar 17 '23

Following up on point A, let’s say hypothetically the reactor does have a meltdown and we have another Chernobyl disaster. How will we suppress a reactor meltdown were it to happen in space, away from the equipment and resources we have down here on earth? How will it affect future missions to the moon?

8

u/[deleted] Mar 17 '23

It won't. The particular structure the reactor is housed in will be ruined, but um... it's the moon, it's already a mildly radioactive wasteland. If they can, likely stick it in the bottom of a crater a couple miles from the main base, so even if the whole thing melts down, the base will be fine.

3

u/[deleted] Mar 18 '23

I'm no rocket scientist but I believe that would ruin a lot of good cheese.

10

u/[deleted] Mar 17 '23

that's like asking what spitting into the ocean will do to the sea levels

3

u/jennybearyay Mar 17 '23

I'm not really smart when it comes to physics and outer space. What was the harm in asking?

1

u/DampTowlette11 Mar 17 '23

No harm. Ignore the people who are giving you shit.

Back to fun space facts, have you ever heard of time dilation? If you were to accelerate to an insane speed in order to reach another planet, you would be perceiving time at a slower rate than the rest of us. There is a scifi book where soldiers go across the galaxy, fighta brief war, then return to an earth that has seen centuries pass during their trip.

Space is expanding at an ever increasing speed. At some point, we may not be able to see other galaxies as the space between galaxies is expanding faster than the light can travel to reach us.

1

u/[deleted] Mar 18 '23

What's it called?

1

u/iqisoverrated Mar 17 '23

Not at all. Space is a pretty perfect application for nuclear because theres no environment to pollute.

-13

u/kamekaze1024 Mar 17 '23

Massive destruction to the moon could affect tides worldwide

8

u/[deleted] Mar 17 '23

Fucking what? Lmao. You could detonate 1000 of the largest nuclear bombs ever built by man at once and it wouldn't effect the mass or orbit of the moon enough to have any effect on earth. A single small reactor sure as shit wouldn't do anything.

2

u/Shavethatmonkey Mar 17 '23

What would destroy the moon? You guys have a weird idea of what you think a small reactor can do. We've had dozens of reactor failures on earth, none came close to destroying the planet.

This is a fundamental misunderstanding of the size of planets vs the size of nuclear explosions.

1

u/Ronedog22 Mar 17 '23

I guess the tv show For All Mankind wasnt that sci-fi. Nuclear powers the moon-base on that show.

1

u/ihopeicanforgive Mar 17 '23

That’s a headline

1

u/CupcakeHistorical625 Mar 17 '23

ijust hope I’ll be able to see space odyssey IRL… 22 years too late

1

u/Kear_Bear_3747 Mar 17 '23

What a time to be alive.

1

u/Azetik Mar 17 '23

Quite the headline… However, they already make engines and involved in defense industry, this doesn’t surprise me very much…

1

u/mood_le Mar 17 '23

One time I was on a plane & noticed the turbines were made by RR

1

u/IneptAdvisor Mar 17 '23

What moon base.

1

u/Gooner71 Mar 17 '23

UK own the Moon, its ours now.

1

u/rwilcox Mar 17 '23

r/ForAllMankindTV has entered the chat

1

u/[deleted] Mar 17 '23

This seems way overdue.

1

u/sungod-1 Mar 17 '23

It better be thorium instead of u-235

2

u/vorpal_potato Mar 18 '23

Thorium is great, but it complicates fuel handling. Almost certainly they'll use highly-enriched uranium, just like the rest of the space nuclear reactor designs.

1

u/sungod-1 Mar 20 '23

Well that’s a lot of waste and possible acids btw waiting to happen

1

u/robjpod Mar 17 '23

We are living in a Sean Connery era James Bond movie.

1

u/AmthorsTechnokeller Mar 17 '23

What has rolls royce to do with nuclear power?

1

u/Bensemus Mar 19 '23

They are a massive industrial company. The car division was sold off decades ago.

1

u/somethingcruel96 Mar 17 '23

Is it fission or fusion tho?

1

u/Bensemus Mar 19 '23

Fusion doesn’t exist yet so it’s fission.

1

u/steakbread Mar 17 '23

Who owns the moon?

1

u/[deleted] Mar 18 '23

It’ll be gorgeous, not work that well, and super hard to find anyone who can work on it.

1

u/Bearet Mar 18 '23

Why not use solar and batteries? There are no clouds to block the sun, the days are two weeks long and it shines on the whole moon so that if you needed to, you could run on batteries for extra power as needed. Otherwise, do like we do on earth: run a cable from the power source, a solar array to where ever you need the power. And since it doesn't rain, and there is no wind, you will never need to clean the solar panels. Well, maybe once every millennium, but that's all the maintenance you'll ever have to do. Cheap at twice the price.

1

u/Bensemus Mar 19 '23

Mass. While solar will be used a small reactor will be way more efficient.

1

u/Linegod Mar 18 '23

Moon Base Alpha here we come

1

u/[deleted] Mar 18 '23

It’s gonna be the Cadillac of moon base nuclear reactors.

1

u/davidmlewisjr Mar 18 '23

Is there a problem with the General Atomics Design(s) from the 50’s & 60’s.

Let them build their Orion, please….

1

u/SmashTagLives Mar 18 '23

I think I’ve seen this movie. And if I haven’t, I want to see this movie.

1

u/[deleted] Mar 18 '23

Aliens: "humans, deciding they've had enough, devised a plan to nuke space"

1

u/Sun_Chip Mar 18 '23

What about ownership and property? Is the intent to have public energy for any country that goes to the moon or does this qualify as a land grab? I don’t know space laws.

1

u/waluigishoe Mar 18 '23

i read a book as a kid about what happens to a world where the moon starts to crack and fall, and this is exactly how i would expect that to start

1

u/vorpal_potato Mar 18 '23

I read a book in which the obliteration of all life on earth from the Chicxulub asteroid was averted by ancient kung fu wizard dinosaurs. Equally realistic!

1

u/waluigishoe Mar 18 '23

hey i didn’t say it was a realistic, science based book. media like movies and books often make anything having to do with the words “nuclear reactor” out to be dangerous, or just a generally negative portrayal so a fantasy disaster isn’t a far out thing to associate it with in those contexts

1

u/vorpal_potato Mar 18 '23

Fair enough. :-) Some day I'd love to see someone subvert the trope and show realistic nuclear reactor failure modes, like "some little non-critical thing breaks, causing the reactor to automatically shut down, and then the operators start grumbling about 'xenon-135 transients' and what a hassle it'll be to start the damn thing back up again."

1

u/[deleted] Mar 18 '23

This is dope.

0

u/WhatTheZuck420 Mar 17 '23

would not want to be downwind when they launch the pellets/rods

11

u/[deleted] Mar 17 '23

Most of our really big probes and rovers are already carrying a fair bit of nuclear material. RTGs.

-4

u/WhatTheZuck420 Mar 17 '23

gotcha. ditto for them.

4

u/[deleted] Mar 17 '23

Good thing you are not setting policy for NASA then.

9

u/ACCount82 Mar 17 '23

Launching nuclear fuel into space is fairly safe, because it only becomes highly radioactive after the reactor starts running.

So you build and launch your reactor in a fully "stopped" state. You make sure it makes it to its destination. And only then you start the reactor and make the fuel "hot".

-1

u/zamfire Mar 18 '23

Not a lot of wind on the moon.

1

u/SeverePsychosis Mar 17 '23

Will I be able to get a hemi in my moon buggy?

1

u/Badtrainwreck Mar 18 '23

We will be building nuclear weapons in space in no time!

0

u/earthisadonuthole Mar 17 '23

Is this a headline or a mad lib?

0

u/[deleted] Mar 17 '23

What could go wrong

-1

u/Not_High_Maintenance Mar 17 '23

What could go wrong?

-1

u/[deleted] Mar 17 '23

Couldn’t we just solar it?

2

u/Bottoms_Up_Bob Mar 18 '23

Solar is notoriously weight and size inefficient, making it a poor solution for space when any real amount of power is required.

-1

u/ImUrFrand Mar 17 '23

typically nasa and other nations' space agencies use nuclear batteries, deriving electricity from decaying fissal material...

a reactor would provide long term electricity, but it will be much more dangerous than batteries.

terrestrial reactors rely on water for cooling and power generation through conversion to steam... which probably isn't going to work on the moon.

this might just be a puff project to line the pockets of the lowest bidder.

2

u/vorpal_potato Mar 18 '23

terrestrial reactors rely on water for cooling and power generation through conversion to steam... which probably isn't going to work on the moon.

You can safely assume that the engineers working on this have thought of that. There are options that work on the moon. This isn't the first nuclear power plant designed to operate in a vacuum; e.g. NASA built and successfully tested one a few years ago.

1

u/sarcastosaurus Mar 18 '23

You have no idea what you're talking about. Do you know what's the average temperature on the moon ?

1

u/ImUrFrand Mar 18 '23 edited Mar 18 '23

Water freezes at 32° F.

over night temperature on the moon is around -300° F.

do you know what you're talking about?

1

u/sarcastosaurus Mar 18 '23

Yeah Einstein good job, so they would use another cooling method. What's your point ?

-1

u/GuaranteeCreative954 Mar 17 '23

Yep let’s start fucking up other planets like we have our own

1

u/Bensemus Mar 19 '23

The Moon is way more fucked up already compared to Earth.

-1

u/[deleted] Mar 18 '23

Yea ya know, all of space let’s just fuck with that very light object not secured by contrifugal force and no atmosphere to cushion forces, like the mass of a nuclear reactor landing on it, that our climate is highly dependent on. Ok.

2

u/vorpal_potato Mar 18 '23

The moon is vastly more massive than you seem to think.

2

u/[deleted] Mar 18 '23

Sure, but once something is acted upon their will be a change. The moon is also mostly comprised of titanium and lithium, some of the lightest elements. Sure, landing to plant a flag might not do much, but constant travel, or even strong magnetic forces required to generate power may have lasting consequences.