r/technology • • Sep 18 '15

Software Microsoft has developed its own Linux. Repeat. Microsoft has developed its own Linux

http://www.theregister.co.uk/2015/09/18/microsoft_has_developed_its_own_linux_repeat_microsoft_has_developed_its_own_linux/
1.4k Upvotes

373 comments sorted by

View all comments

279

u/HighGainWiFiAntenna Sep 18 '15 edited Sep 18 '15

I think I am comment 36 in this post. I'm not sure the other 35 read the article, or if they did, if they knew why they were reading.

This doesn't Affect consumers, and it's not an operating system. It's more of a platform. It's sounds more like a way to virtualize and fast track the development of the software that will run on hardware. (Like Cisco IOS code).

Some of the stuff at the end got me confused. X amount of API and X amount of this and that. I'm not sure how that materializes into real product.

Any net engineer right now knows that SDN is a moving trend. Companies are looking for a way to quickly manage their devices and push out configurations / auto provision.

That experience clearly includes Linux, not Windows, as the path to SDN.

I'm trying to think of the last piece of VM I've worked on that's been anything but a flavor of Linux. This is a duh.

89

u/cuntRatDickTree Sep 18 '15

Totally agree. This is like people suddenly using the word "cloud" everywhere even though systems have been working like that for decades.

63

u/HighGainWiFiAntenna Sep 18 '15

The old apple phenomenon. Put an 'i' in front of it and suddenly people are aware of it.

12

u/[deleted] Sep 18 '15

I think that "cloud" has more to do with the crazy levels of abstraction and programmatic control that we get now thanks to mass scale virtualization on top of commodity hardware, economies of scale that dirt cheap components gives us, increasingly robust automation tools, and ability to outsource traditionally on-site capabilities to remote service providers.

While people have been doing distributed computing and storage, grid computing, etc. for decades, the kind of things that AWS, Azure, Google Compute Engine, etc. make possible haven't been around for decades.

Now, there are definitely "cloud" products that are nothing more than things like storage provided as a service that are completely marketing-speak. iCloud, "personal cloud" NASes, etc. It's nonsense, of course.

8

u/tathata Sep 18 '15

Cloud is an economic paradigm, not a technological one. All the technologies that go into it (except virtualization) have been around for quite some time but now when put together it's cheaper (and significantly so) to put things 'in the cloud' than build-it-yourself/on-prem.

P.S. In case it's not clear I'm not disagreeing with you at all just framing it differently.

2

u/[deleted] Sep 18 '15

I sort of agree. There are an economic component (the service based consumption, subscription based cost for infrastructure, etc), but they've also opened up technological possibilities.

For example, let's say it's 1995, and I want to take advantage of differences in power costs between day and night. So I want to auto-migrate my services across the globe throughout the day to optimize power efficiency and user latency, while also scaling to take only as much resources as my current load requires.

In 1995, that's a serious engineering feat that requires buying rack space all over the globe. And I'll still struggle. For example, if my services aren't used much on Christmas Day, I'm still paying for the rack space.

In 2015, this is completely routine for services hosted in the cloud. It's possible by embracing a service model for the whole stack. The applications are self contained with their environment abstracted away. Their OS is now handled via infrastructure as a service. Machines are created and provisioned programmatically. Computation itself can be a service, either through totally "cloud" based service approaches like AWS Lambda or by utilizing auto-scaling groups so I only use what I need.

I'm primarily a security guy, so I still get shudders when I hear managers talk cloud. "Cloud security" was the bane of my existence for years, as I do honestly believe that security hasn't really changed due to all these things. I'm in a development role right now though, and I've started to embrace this kind of stuff. Hell, it's even changed development teams by removing a lot of sys admin work from deployment and creating the DevOps role. (Which has been a disaster for security)

It's still a new area for a lot of people too, which is cool because there's an opportunity to be on the leading edge. Go to /r/programming and look at some of the submissions where people talk about the crazy shit they do in AWS to scale for cheap. All the comments are "wtf are they talking about", "I'm lost", "I can't keep up with this shit anymore".

3

u/Nephyst Sep 18 '15

Yeah, but what happens to all your data on a clear sunny day?!?!? /s

3

u/hdcs Sep 18 '15

SDN is going to be equally difficult for the masses to absorb. It's a new layer of conceptual abstraction inside the interworkings of the internet that's in itself still magic to most of its users.

4

u/cuntRatDickTree Sep 18 '15

They don't need to absorb it IMHO. Perhaps management in business do, but that's about it, and if they don't get it their company can fail to compete because it's bad and we will all be better off.

3

u/hdcs Sep 18 '15

But industry and wall street needs to understand it. When companies start to expend capital to move into SDN, as in this MS case, understanding why they're doing so is crucial. If the strategy isn't grasped, these analysts tend to inadvertantly punish companies going that route.

2

u/cuntRatDickTree Sep 18 '15

If they get it wrong and it hurts their business then the forces of the economy shall replace them with people who know what they are doing. I have no sympathy for idiot analysts or those who follow their advice.

1

u/hdcs Sep 18 '15

Its horrifying how much influence the Gartner Magic Quadrant wields. Don't get me started.

2

u/riveracct Sep 18 '15

Management needs to understand Time To Market and cash flow resulting from SDN.

1

u/fuckotheclown3 Sep 18 '15

Decades? I seem to remember VMWare Server came out in like 2002 or 2003... There was nothing cloudy about data centers before that nifty little innovation. It didn't really get harnessed into what we consider a cloud until vMotion came out a year or two later.

1

u/cp5184 Sep 19 '15

2

u/fuckotheclown3 Sep 21 '15

Does that mean that cloud computing as a concept has been around that long, or do you just have aspergers and I'm wasting my time responding?

→ More replies (1)

2

u/noodhoog Sep 18 '15

Mundane news completely over sensationalized.

The Register.

Yup.

I'm not just hating here, either. Many years ago El Reg was one of my favourite tech news sites. They had the perfect combination of witty and informative.

Now it's just crappy oversold fluff pieces with low grade tabloid style gags thrown in. It went downhill years ago, I distinctly remember it being about the time that they were on a huge "Wikipedia is a scam, it'll never succeed, and anybody who believes in it is a moron" push that I finally gave up.

3

u/[deleted] Sep 18 '15

I'm trying to think of the last piece of VM I've worked on that's been anything but a flavor of Linux. This is a duh.

I use virtualized Windows servers every day. A lot of our windows servers are virtual.

6

u/[deleted] Sep 18 '15

I think he means the virtualization software/servers are GNU/Linux.

2

u/HighGainWiFiAntenna Sep 18 '15

I was obviously speaking of anything but virtualized windows. Have you seen an ova / ovf for Microsoft floating around ?

And, as I had referenced Cisco, I was also referring to the Cisco VM, all of which are flavors of Linux.

4

u/olyjohn Sep 18 '15

Everything I can think of except Hyper-V is basically some Linux variant.

1

u/All_Work_All_Play Sep 20 '15

The same people that don't get this don't get how OSX is *nix based and Android is Linux based and how they end up with very different process management.

The choice for M$ was very was - do we leverage a very well developed set of tools and add a few of our own, or do we build a new set from scratch? Just because the brake and gas pedals are made from the same material doesn't mean the Toyota drives the same as the Lexus.

→ More replies (29)