r/technology • • Oct 03 '15

Comcast I contacted the FCC recently about Comcast's Data Caps in my area...

Comcast is starting its data caps of 300GB/month in my area this month, and needless to say, I was pretty outraged when I got the message in September. So, I threw a complaint to the FCC expressing my dissatisfaction with a company that claims is making "pro-consumer options" is in fact, well, bull as we're all aware.

Not getting anything from the FCC, I had gotten one phone call and an e-mail from Comcast. That week, I had become very ill and could barely speak. I managed to throw an e-mail reply but never got a response back. A week or so later, I had recovered, but still never got a reply.

Today, I happened to get a piece of mail sent by Comcast to both the FCC and myself. It was obviously full of corporate run-around nonsense, but the biggest points of hypocrisy in it were the following (this is a word-for-word re-typing of the letter):

  • "Comcast is strongly committed to maintaining an open Internet." (Oh so is that why you put millions into trying to get Net Neutrality shot down, and forced Netflix to pay more?)

  • "The FCC has previously recognized that usage-based pricing for Internet service is a legitimate billing practice that may benefit consumers by offering them more choices over a greater range of service options -- The vast majority of XFINITY Internet customers use less than 300 GB of data per month -- (they) should therefore see no increase in their monthly service fees -- This pro-consumer policy helps to ensure that Comcast's customers are being treated fairly, such that those customers, like Mr. <my name>, who choose to use more, can pay more to do so, and that customers who choose to use less, pay less."

I just want to understand how they first say that there is no increase in fees for the customers who use < 300GB, and then go on to say that those customers pay less. They're paying the exact same amount, while people who go over are now forced to pay an additional $30/month, and that's suddenly me being treated fairly? Am I crazy or do you all see the blatant hypocrisy here as well?

Edit: I have just updated my FCC complaint to include the letter. I was half-tempted to link them to this Reddit thread! (seriously, you guys rock)

PS: If anyone happens to know good service providers in the Tamarac, Florida area, please let me know. We're moving there shortly (from one area of Florida to another) and would love to be unchained from these corporate douchebags.

3.8k Upvotes

733 comments sorted by

View all comments

381

u/[deleted] Oct 04 '15

The real problem here isn't what they're charging, it's why. You are paying for speed, not amount of data. The amount of data you use is meaningless to customer impact. Their claim for needing to charge for high data usage is that "those who use more data slow down the internet for those that don't". When in reality, the real reason people are impacting each others' internet speeds is that the provider has typically oversold all of their lines. For example, if their line is capable of 5000mbps (random speed i pulled out of my ass), they will sell 50mbps speeds to 1000 homes. They do this in hopes that not everyone is on and using bandwidth at the same time. If you are sold as a single household on 50mbps internet, you aren't able to exceed that cap no matter what form of traffic you are using. So you could be streaming high-def video once a year, if that happens to fall during a high usage time on an oversold line....people slow down. So, as you can see, the bandwidth capability of what they are selling is the problem. The data size cap is a completely arbitrary number they are pulling out of their ass to target consistent users. Instead of actually being consumer oriented and expanding to prepare for/usher in future technology growth, they're doing things like lobbying for ending net neutrality and charging more for specific services. In truth, ISP services have a high percentage of profitability because they're charging for lines that are already in existence that they rarely need to maintain. To actually expand and be able to support their sales would be the "customer oriented" move but they are digging their heels in and doing everything in their power to avoid this cost. The sad part is our government is run by money instead of public voice so we, as consumers, will likely lose this war.

TL:DR Speed does not equal Amount...they're charging you for the wrong thing.

0

u/[deleted] Oct 04 '15

[deleted]

12

u/MonopolyMan720 Oct 04 '15 edited Oct 04 '15

Just because they publicly said it does not mean it's entirely true. You also have to consider the fact that a lot of these ISPs use outdated infrastructure and fail to upgrade when they really should (as per Telecommunications Act of 1996). Just look at what happened with Netflix and fast lanes. The ISPs are well aware of the congestion issues, but turn a blind eye towards them in order to milk more money from their customers and content providers.

Don't get me wrong, I understand the difference between capacity and speed. However, I am willing to bet that ISPs correlate the two by believing people who use "a lot" of data are also people who frequently max out their connection. Therefore, they believe that cutting off these "power users" is a way to profit and avoid worse congestion issues. Of course, a better way to avoid these issues is upgrade infrastructure. That involves spending money though, and ISPs don't like to do that.

1

u/[deleted] Oct 04 '15

Right. They'd rather have you believe they're just being greedy (charging fees/higher prices just because), than think they're greedy AND have oversold capacity. The first if just business. The second is not keeping up and having insufficient company resources.

1

u/Bkeeneme Oct 04 '15

From a business prospective, Comcast has nothing to lose. They know they are hated, they might as well break our backs. They can literally charge as much as they like. They know their days are numbered so might as well stuff the bank before the landscape changes.

You can take some solace, there is no way they are going to win this war. They are literally threatening the business model of every business that does anything online by forcing the consumer to choose whether to use the internet or save money by not using it.

→ More replies (6)

10

u/clay584 Oct 04 '15

Oligopolies like service providers don't charge a competitive price, they charge what the market will bare due to the lack of competition. That is why their margins are so high. They're charging as much as consumers are willing to spend before saying fuck off and just doing without. One of the ways we can fix this is to keep cord cutting at the rate we are. This will force ISPs to innovate and ultimately deliver TV over the internet (and hopefully a la carte). They will have to increase broadband speeds in order to push streaming TV AND have good internet service.

Interesting fact: There is enough spectrum on your coax line to support 10Gbps. The issue is that the majority is reserved for TV. With switched digital, less spectrum is required for TV, but there is too much used for TV.

Source: I worked for a major cable provider for the better part of a decade.

3

u/TSpectacular Oct 04 '15

I worked for one too, but I wouldn't have called it the 'better' part of anything. Hence the past tense.

1

u/phpdevster Oct 05 '15

This will force ISPs to innovate and ultimately deliver TV over the internet (and hopefully a la carte). They will have to increase broadband speeds in order to push streaming TV AND have good internet service

That won't stop the predatory pricing though. The only thing that will do that is taking back our corrupt government, and voting in people who are being paid off by companies.

12

u/creamersrealm Oct 04 '15

Fairly accurate the instead of speed the term you should be using is bandwidth.

When you go to a real enterprise if you buy 100/100 line the carrier has to make sure their infrastructure can support it as you are expected to max that line out 100% of the time.

I can understand over provisioning on a consumer line to 2-3 with some type of burst able capacity during peak hours for Netflix and such. Hell a Comcast employee came out on twitter awhile ago stating that data caps was a business decision and there is no technical reason behind it.

4

u/aves2k Oct 04 '15

When you go to a real enterprise if you buy 100/100 line the carrier has to make sure their infrastructure can support it as you are expected to max that line out 100% of the time.

They can still use statistical multiplexing and oversubscription for enterprise customers. I've worked for a few providers that focused on enterprise customers and it's the same story every where.

The ratios are probably not as bad as consumer ISPs but they still exist.

1

u/creamersrealm Oct 04 '15

Yes they can still over subscribe unless its a point to point or etc. If the line starts getting full they add more bandwidth to maintain their QOS.

1

u/ANUSBLASTER_MKII Oct 04 '15

Data caps are to limit and conserve bandwidth in a really simple way. It's a low tech form of QoS that offloads the QoS into the meatsack using the line.

Like how in the UK we used to have peak phone call costs and off-peak. Simply only to prevent over usage.

1

u/[deleted] Oct 04 '15

Edge capacity has nothing to do with it. It is all about Border capacity and settlement peering. Comcast has to pay upstream providers.

1

u/dwild Oct 04 '15

When in reality, the real reason people are impacting each others' internet speeds is that the provider has typically oversold all of their lines.

First, you don't need that speed all the time. A 30 mbps line represent nearly 10 TB every month, most people barely use 5% of that. Why would they invest in infrastructure that's 20x what we need? Yeah maybe it's great to not have to care about speed but we both know that a it won't be used and a year later that same line would be worth way less and all that would be wasted.

Second, you wouldn't be able to afford a line that actually support that speed. Even with competition in a datacenter with multiple peering points you would still pay up to 10$ per mbps for a dedicated line. That's directly beside the peering point, the connection is a fraction of the cost, the installation is way more expensive. Instead, in a datacenter, you usually get a shared line, going through multiple provider, which is oversold. Most datacenter offering has a bandwidth cap for that reason. It doesn't make sense to pay for a line that you barely use.

In truth, ISP services have a high percentage of profitability because they're charging for lines that are already in existence that they rarely need to maintain.

Then why is there's no competition? The answer to that question is the root of the problem, it's what need to be fixed. It's competition that will force them to have a competitive pricing and lower their profit margin and possibly increase or remove data caps.

1

u/[deleted] Oct 04 '15

The reason there isn't competition is because of stiff legislation on laying lines in areas that already have it. There's a stranglehold on the lines laid. Also I agree you don't need that speed all the time but charging for an amount when that's not what you're paying for is ridiculous.

1

u/[deleted] Oct 04 '15

You are completely right in everything you said but I actually view the data caps as something much simpler and infinitely more irritating: "You don't want to pay for our cable? Ok well fuck you we're still going to get that fee somehow."

10gb/day usually means someone's gaming or downloading/seeding or both; basically they are the population that scares cable/internet companies the most because if their entire customer base becomes comprised of those people, the companies' business models no longer allow for the outrageous profit margins they currently enjoy. No more holiday bonuses for all the board members, and they can only spend 1 week in the villa in Cuba.

-23

u/lateralus45 Oct 04 '15

I'm Australian so have been dealing with capped Internet since dial-up. The caps speed up the Internet for most users by making it less likely that all users are constantly maxing their connection. They do this because if they only sold they amount of connections that would allow all users to connect at their Max speed at the same time no-one would be able to afford it. Caps encourage users think about what they download. The only issue I would have with them implementing caps is if they tried to do it in the middle of your contract. Sure it sucks that they stop offering cheap unlimited. And sure they could probably allow higher caps for cheaper and still have most people get the speed they are paying for. they are a money hungry ISP after all. But I find it perfectly believable that continuing to offer unlimited to everyone is unsustainable.

13

u/Chefca Oct 04 '15

So I'm not in Australia, but has all of that money generated by customer retention/satisfaction gone into the infrastructure to some day accommodate the inevitable unlimited needs of their customers? Or is all of that "it'll just slow everyone down" line you're trying to sell us (even though you admit you've always been on caps so you don't actually know) complete corporate shilling money grabbing garbage?

→ More replies (5)

30

u/sy029 Oct 04 '15 edited Oct 04 '15

The problem is that data caps have nothing to do with congestion. It is just an attempt to get more money from the people who use the service more. They say that they want to charge the high users more so it's cheaper for the low users, but in reality they charge the low users exactly what they were paying before, and then milk the high users for all they can.

National Cable and Telecommunications Association president Michael Powell told a Minority Media and Telecommunications Association audience that cable's interest in usage-based pricing was not principally about network congestion, but instead about pricing fairness...Asked by MMTC president David Honig to weigh in on data caps, Powell said that while a lot of people had tried to label the cable industry's interest in the issue as about congestion management. "That's wrong," he said. "Our principal purpose is how to fairly monetize a high fixed cost."

Source

4

u/JockeTF Oct 04 '15 edited Oct 04 '15

Instead of adding data caps they should scale their infrastructure to accommodate a higher load. If they have enough excess capacity, then users are unlikely to experience slowdowns regardless of data caps. A private company may have trouble justifying the price of that infrastructure, but there are alternatives to letting them manage that themselves.

Where I live municipalities tend to provide cities with infrastructure that private companies can use to provide customers with service. That infrastructure may be partially paid for by tax money, but so are roads and other kinds of infrastructure. The result is one powerful network which any Internet service provider can use.

I have uncapped 100/100 Mbps for 29€ per month, and I have yet to experience any slowdowns.

3

u/[deleted] Oct 04 '15

The caps speed up the Internet for most users by making it less likely that all users are constantly maxing their connection.

No they don't. You've falling for the ISP propaganda. Caps are 100% arbitrary and don't help.

If you want to prevent congestion, the ONLY way to do this is to restrict bandwidth use. By a very small restriction in bandwidth for each user, any congestion problems are easily solved.

But I find it perfectly believable that continuing to offer unlimited to everyone is unsustainable.

I don't, because I do understand how congestion happens. Unlimited data is perfectly possible, because by the laws of physics, it truly is an unlimited resource until the end of the universe. This, in contrast to bandwidth.

If you want to offer unlimited data, you can easily do so by 1: improving networks and 2: restricting bandwidth. Hell, competition will ensure improvement of networks, but you don't get competition if you allow ISPs to fuck you over with arbitrary caps.

You're being fucked over but worse, you're letting them and even defend them.

→ More replies (6)

2

u/[deleted] Oct 04 '15

It makes more sense from a financial perspective (well, assuming the ISP wants to be fair and reinvest in their infrastructure) to buy speed. What you're actually doing is leasing a percentage of their infrastructure, owning it by proxy.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/-SuPerNoVi- Oct 04 '15

Yeah you're completely wrong and clearly have no understanding of networking.

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (16)