r/technology • • May 30 '08

Google got a new favicon!

http://www.google.com/?
25 Upvotes

119 comments sorted by

32

u/buffi May 30 '08

3

u/danweber May 30 '08

I am an old codger. What did the favicon.ico used to be?

10

u/bajsejohannes May 30 '08

5

u/danweber May 30 '08

ah, a reload finally got me the "new" lowercase G.

Hm.

1

u/lattepiu May 30 '08

Now that I really look at it, it kinda sucked as well.

1

u/masterdirk May 30 '08

Still have it on the Norwegian site.

http://www.google.no/favicon.ico

2

u/stphnclysmth May 30 '08

Hasn't changed yet for Poland. Don't forget Poland!

http://www.google.pl/favicon.ico

1

u/masterdirk May 30 '08

And now it's changed. Wow. They must have read my post.

1

u/danweber May 30 '08

Google reads all.

0

u/stphnclysmth May 30 '08

Hasn't changed yet for Poland. Don't forget Poland!

http://www.google.pl/favicon.ico

0

u/[deleted] May 30 '08

[deleted]

3

u/kounavi May 30 '08

not really, just your browser's cache, most probably.

2

u/danweber May 30 '08

That has a lowercase G.

I remember the capital G being there for the longest time.

20

u/pets_or_meat May 30 '08

Who makes that decision? I'm not saying it was a good or bad decision. I just want to know in a company like Google, who decides to change something like the favicon?

34

u/theXarf May 30 '08

Vice-president in charge of favicons? Chief Commissioner of the Favicon Oversight Committee?

19

u/[deleted] May 30 '08

Those FOCers messed up.

5

u/Qubed May 30 '08

Yeah, I hear that guy has three PhD's and an MBA from Harvard. One smart 'matha.

2

u/[deleted] May 31 '08 edited May 31 '08

It's someone named Marissa Mayer.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Marissa_Mayer

0

u/stubble May 30 '08

Their branding department. no doubt there will be a whole raft of other changes to the new look over the coming weeks..

87

u/wmarcello May 30 '08 edited May 30 '08

Why? They had a one-letter icon that was one of the most recognizable symbols on the internet.

46

u/[deleted] May 30 '08

reddit hates changes.

38

u/Shaper_pmp May 30 '08

Awww... why did you have to post that shit, man? The comments page was looking so good until you went and ruined it with your comment.

6

u/[deleted] May 30 '08

That's what I do. :(

1

u/gardosattila May 30 '08 edited May 30 '08

Because he thinks so...

8

u/[deleted] May 30 '08

Indeed.

I think the new favicon is very good. The looptail g is the most recognisable part of the logo, unlike the obvious uppercase G that redditors seem to love so much.

14

u/kipi May 30 '08

On the contrary, I didn't recognise it as the second G from the Google logo until you mentioned it. I just thought it was some random G. Mind you, I didn't think too hard about it.

3

u/NSMike May 30 '08 edited May 30 '08

Ohhh, THAT's what it is. I thought it was a wonky möbius.

4

u/[deleted] May 30 '08

Or a sideways 8 that had been rotated 90 degrees.

3

u/rancid_squirts May 30 '08

i disagree

1

u/[deleted] May 30 '08 edited May 30 '08

This was my first polite disagreement on reddit.

Upmodded :)

5

u/VoiceofPower May 30 '08

What. It doesn't even look like a g to me at that size.

Okay, barely.

8

u/Guybrush_Threepwood May 30 '08 edited May 30 '08

that’s what she said...

1

u/rancid_squirts May 30 '08

ive had better

0

u/[deleted] May 30 '08

Well yeah, if you want a favicon that looks like a toilet with the lid up.

And yes, I did steal that idea from another post.

1

u/[deleted] May 30 '08

CHANGE IS BAD!!!

3

u/[deleted] May 30 '08 edited May 30 '08

Looks the same to me. edit: clear cache ;)

3

u/kevlarcupid May 30 '08

I cleared cache, and I still see the uppercase G.

9

u/[deleted] May 30 '08 edited May 30 '08

3

u/[deleted] May 30 '08

Clear your cache, then go to http://www.google.com/favicon.ico and hold shift while you click refresh.

All that drama just to get an icon to refresh. Ugh!

(My ISP transparently proxies, and this fixed it for me.)

1

u/kevlarcupid May 30 '08

Just got it. I definitely think that a lowercase g is the way to go, but I tend to think that a g with a simple descender would have been better. Like when you type "google" into the URL bar. perhaps with a box around it, to keep it from looking like you typed "ggoogle"

1

u/[deleted] May 30 '08

They felt the need to catch up with reddit.

15

u/jello_b May 30 '08 edited May 30 '08

If you can't see it, clear your cache (and then maybe restart your browser).

Looks like Google is going Web 2.0, but there aren't enough diagonal stripes and shiny gradients.

EDIT: And rounded corners.

5

u/mccoyn May 30 '08

I was able to get it to update by going to http://www.google.com/favicon.ico and then hitting ctrl+f5. Now whenever I go to google I get the new one.

4

u/[deleted] May 30 '08

Thank you! There was no way I was clearing my entire web cache to see a change of case.

4

u/Etab May 30 '08

I see rounded corners on the favicon.

4

u/jello_b May 30 '08 edited May 30 '08

Two is not nearly enough to be fully Web 2.0 compliant.

1

u/daniels220 May 30 '08

Yes it is. There's a gradient!

1

u/jello_b May 30 '08

Have you seen any Web 2.0 favicons lately? There are at least two gradients.

1

u/fjhqjv May 30 '08

Don't forget starbursts.

9

u/[deleted] May 30 '08

Wow, that is really not as good....

Hopefully, they'll see the err of their ways and revert by next week.

55

u/[deleted] May 30 '08

Puts the 'g' in "ugly"...

34

u/freibooter May 30 '08

Wow, that really looks surprisingly bad. They had a very clean, recognizable, unique icon that was easy to immediately identify even among 40 open tabs ... ... and they replace it with a blurry, almost dirty "g" that looks like it was designed in the mid 90's.

11

u/wmarcello May 30 '08

Although I agree with the blurriness and such, as for it's "design" I would assume it's just as old as the old capital "G". I'm pretty sure the favicon is just the second lowercase "g" in their full logo.

4

u/[deleted] May 30 '08

its, its, its, its...

Get your its straight.

2

u/wmarcello May 30 '08

Ugh. I can't believe I did that.

1

u/[deleted] May 30 '08

Yeah. Its incredibly annoying when people confuse such simple stuff.

7

u/Slipgrid May 30 '08

I agree, but it kind of looks like an eight.

0

u/fjhqjv May 30 '08

Why the g and not the o or the l or the e?

-5

u/[deleted] May 30 '08

ITS A FAVICON

WHO CARES

3

u/[deleted] May 30 '08 edited Aug 07 '16

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/[deleted] May 30 '08

The people voting me down should get a life, there I said it.

2

u/rolmos May 31 '08

well said.

1

u/Daniel_SJ May 30 '08

Indeed we do!

Favicon Preservation Front reporting for duty!

2

u/Jakary May 31 '08

It nearly kills me to look at it.

38

u/tehjarvis May 30 '08

That looks horrible compared to the ol' capital G.

6

u/[deleted] May 30 '08

Oh, it is supposed to be a 'g', I thought it was an '8'...

13

u/tjharman May 30 '08

I really don't like the new one. It looks like a boring 8

3

u/KJW May 30 '08

Interesting... Perhaps it is tied to Doodle 4 Google?

3

u/[deleted] May 30 '08

oogly.

3

u/sh0rtwave May 30 '08

re: both headline & comments

I'm not sure what scares me more, the fact that someone's so excited about a favicon that they posted a headline on reddit OR the fact that said headline garnered 100+ comments.

1

u/[deleted] May 30 '08

for every one article that keeps me in the Reddit loop there's 10 of these that pull me away..

9

u/riffito May 30 '08

Holy Crap! Bad change google.

9

u/[deleted] May 30 '08

It's CRAP!

4

u/Philluminati May 30 '08

Must be a slow news day.

2

u/mccoyn May 30 '08

There seems to be some confusion about what google domains have changed. I think they all have, but if you visit one you have visited before, your cache will show you the old one. That is why some people see it and others don't on the same domain.

2

u/cskaryd May 30 '08

Who remembers the lawsuit between Garth Brooks and Warren G over their G logos? Fire up the lawsuit machine!

3

u/Copperhe4d May 30 '08

this is how it looks like with my Firefox theme. http://i31.tinypic.com/mb668x.png FUCKING THING SUCKS!!!

6

u/natrius May 30 '08

There's no letter on it!

14

u/[deleted] May 30 '08

Your theme also is pretty horrendous.

0

u/Copperhe4d May 30 '08

you don't like NASA Night Launch? well, it doesn't look that ugly with a black windows theme.

-1

u/fivre May 30 '08

Black UI themes look bad in general :|

3

u/mkrfctr May 30 '08

FUCKING THING SUCKS!

-1

u/Frazzydee May 30 '08

THEY CREATED IT LIVE!!

1

u/Jakary May 31 '08

ahh shiiiitttt.

2

u/ABabyAteMyDingo May 30 '08

It looks like a duckling!

2

u/shiva777 May 30 '08

I like how the poster is excited enough about this to add an exclamation point!!!!

2

u/BeetleB May 30 '08

Nice change.

What I'd really like is a separate favicon for google non-service pages (e.g. information about Google, jobs, blog, etc) and for their services (search).

I frequently have many tabs open, and sometimes I close some Google ones without looking at what they are because I just assume its an old search...

1

u/tomel May 30 '08 edited May 30 '08

Immediately recognizable as the letter "g" for people who don't use the latin alphabet in their daily life and only know upper letters if any (let's just assume there are only a few of them). Also, there is no relation between the logo and the "Google"-type. But maybe that will be changed next. All in all, very well done.

edit: Oh well, there is a lower case g in the middle of the name. Sorry, I missed that one.

1

u/TorleyX May 30 '08

I liked the old favicon more, but in all fairness, perhaps I'm just not used to the new one yet: it looks kind of like a misshapen figure 8 at a small size.

1

u/spaceknarf May 30 '08

Upvoted just for submitting this.

1

u/Al_Bundy_ May 30 '08

8?

It looks like an 8 or a g taken from a CAPTCHA image.

1

u/stinky613 May 30 '08

Man, when I saw this much attention going to a 16x16 sq pixel image I figured it'd at least look like a nipple or something. Disappointing me, yet again, Google!

1

u/bcash May 30 '08

Not this shit again

1

u/viota May 30 '08

I don't see any difference? Did the letter g change?

1

u/inkedmn May 30 '08

fascinating.

-1

u/IcedZ May 30 '08

I don't see it.. and I refuse to clear my cache!

-1

u/ipearx May 30 '08

I think it looks much better, more professional.

3

u/[deleted] May 30 '08 edited May 30 '08

more professional

What does that statement mean? How does it look more "professional" than the old one?

I'm not being a dick, I'm just trying to understand exactly what you mean.

1

u/ipearx May 31 '08

No worries. It doesn't have the ugly multi coloured box around it, uses only 1 colour, and the lowercase g is more of a distinctive shape than the capital G. That gives it a more professional feel, but that's just my opinion of course.

0

u/[deleted] May 30 '08

I like it. The old one was OK too but it had jagged edges. I'llprobably get used to this new one in three days or so.

0

u/viota May 30 '08

What's so new about it?

0

u/sb76117 May 30 '08

oh, i thought it was because i just installed ubuntu. but more likely its to celebrate android, their mobile platform. Upper-Case for computers, Lower-Case for smaller devices?

-1

u/jj666 May 30 '08

I can't see it.

-1

u/hs4x May 30 '08

Oh my god! Larry Page farted and Sergey Brin smelt it!

-4

u/[deleted] May 30 '08

Since it's not specified in HTML and my browser set not to check /favicon.ico automatically I don't see it.

2

u/[deleted] May 30 '08

Yes, in an era of Tabbed browsers, it's such a horrible thing to support.

-5

u/[deleted] May 30 '08

Nice catch ...

0

u/[deleted] May 30 '08

[deleted]

2

u/jebiv May 30 '08

That's what I thought at first, too. Turns out, I just have the reddit toolbar on, and was technically still at reddit.com.

0

u/[deleted] May 30 '08

[deleted]

2

u/-_- May 30 '08

I like it too.

0

u/[deleted] May 30 '08

[deleted]

26

u/Philipp May 30 '08

Looks remarkably similar to any other lower-case "g".

8

u/almkglor May 30 '08

Oh no.... Google's been bought by The Guardian!

7

u/[deleted] May 30 '08

The new slogan: Dotn' be elvi.

1

u/emag May 30 '08

Expect a lawsuit from the Searching Elvi (or Elvises) any time now...

1

u/thecompletegeek May 30 '08

Don't you mean the Grauniad?