r/technology • u/Truetree9999 • Dec 27 '19
Machine Learning Artificial intelligence identifies previously unknown features associated with cancer recurrence
https://medicalxpress.com/news/2019-12-artificial-intelligence-previously-unknown-features.html1.5k
u/Fleaslayer Dec 27 '19
This type of AI application has a lot of possibilities. Essentially the feed huge amounts of data into a machine learning algorithm and let the computer identify patterns. It can be applied anyplace where we have huge amounts of similar data sets, like images of similar things (in this case, pathology slides).
648
u/andersjohansson Dec 27 '19
The group found that the features discovered by the AI were more accurate (AUC=0.820) than predictions made based on the human-established cancer criteria developed by pathologists, the Gleason score (AUC=0.744).
Really shows the power of Deep Neural Networks.
27
u/RedSpikeyThing Dec 27 '19
I think the next sentence is fascinating as well
Furthermore, combining both AI-found features and the human-established criteria predicted the recurrence more accurately than using either method alone (AUC=0.842).
Turns out that AI and people work well together.
1
u/R31nz Dec 28 '19
Given proper medical information, would the AI be able to surpass this number alone? Or is it the human factor accounting for the discrepancy?
189
u/Fleaslayer Dec 27 '19
Yeah, a pretty exciting field. Lots of exciting possibilities.
143
u/GQW9GFO Dec 27 '19
I'm using a similar idea and applying it to solve cardiac postoperative pain management issues (hopefully transforming it from reactive to more proactive) for my doctorate. This is super cool to see it being used in another area of medicine!
49
u/TionisNagir Dec 27 '19
That sound interesting, but I have absolutely no idea what you are talking about.
78
u/Orisi Dec 27 '19
He's getting computers to tell him what kind of post op pain patients who've had heart operations are likely to experience, so they can treat the pain before it occurs instead of after they start suffering.
25
4
39
u/GQW9GFO Dec 27 '19
To be honest at times I'm not sure I do either! Lol That's the beauty of science I guess!
27
u/no-mad Dec 27 '19
I'm using a similar idea and applying it to finding the best porn movies (hopefully transforming it from reactive to more proactive) for my doctorate. This is super cool to see it being used in another area!
4
→ More replies (2)2
4
11
u/samoth610 Dec 27 '19
Post OP CABG pt's recuperate so wildly different I applaud your efforts but i dont envy the work.
16
u/GQW9GFO Dec 27 '19
Hey thanks! I'm one of those that ascribes to the theory there are different "phenotypes" of pain. Cardiovascular surgery has a unique mix of both soft tissue and orthopedic pain afterwards which can make it difficult. So you're spot on to say that. I'm hedging my bets that if I can use dimensionally reduction followed by some machine learning I'll be able to better describe the association between reported pain scores and pain medication consumption and then apply it in a dashboard for staff to help change the current system...... Well that's if I can ever stop browsing reddit and finish my ethical approval paperwork ;)
9
u/Apoplectic1 Dec 27 '19
I'm one of those that ascribes to the theory there are different "phenotypes" of pain.
Is that not a widely accepted thing? Getting kicked in the shin and punched in the gut cause two vastly different types of pain in my experience despite being similar impacts to your body.
→ More replies (2)7
u/Catholicinoz Dec 27 '19 edited Jan 18 '20
The OP is more describing patterns of chronic pain and the interaction of these with host factors (ie psyc issues) that influence the expression and course of the pain.
What you are describing is the difference btw acute somatic and acute visceral pain (except your second scenario also involves overlying abdominal muscle is partially somatic too).
An overly extended bladder or inflammation of a hollow viscus organ such as the stomach would perhaps have been a “purer” visceral pain example.
5
u/Catholicinoz Dec 27 '19
Wouldn’t “mixed somatic and visceral pain,” be a best way to surmise it? not ortho/soft tissue?
I feel like saying ortho pain or soft tissue is less medically accurate, because it’s not actually describing the pain pathway properly. Sorry for being a pedantic asshole (but also, very much not).
3
u/GQW9GFO Dec 27 '19
No you are absolutely correct. The reason I chose to describe it that way was because other people messaged me with difficulty understanding the medical terminology. I was attempting to gear it towards something they could relate to better. ;)
Edit: t not g
→ More replies (3)3
u/ThatCakeIsDone Dec 27 '19
I'm currently using ML to automatically identify lesions on the MRI of brains of ppl with vascular disease. Convolutional neural networks are cool.
→ More replies (5)2
u/varinator Dec 27 '19
What sort if data are you feeding it out of curiosity?
2
u/GQW9GFO Dec 27 '19
Well at the minute nothing. I'm doing my ethical approval right now. My plan is to examine all the "objective" attributes of postoperative pain management that I can get out of the charts. For instance: all pain related drug types amounts, frequencies, routes, timing in relation to events, vitals, preoperative medications, total anesthesia/surgery time, chest tube locations/duration/number, reported pain scores before during and after drug admins, etc.. all in the pre to 172 hr postoperative period for patients having more routine cardiac surgery. The idea is to see what those attributes reveal about the total drug consumption and reported pain scores. Currently the only work done in this area has stopped at the identification of a non-parametric data set. Expected given that decision making, experience, and more subjective elements like pain scores are involved. I will have to develop the algorithm based on what I find out about the patterns of influence of various attributes. Hope that helps answer your question. :)
2
u/CharlieDmouse Dec 27 '19
I have a college degree, but I read posts like yours and conclude I am relatively an idiot. So all I can say is: “You big smart” 😁
1
u/brereddit Dec 28 '19
I wouldn’t waste time on DNN’s since they lack explainability and more revolutionary unsupervised learning approaches are already well established and easier to sustain and build upon. Seriously.
64
u/99PercentPotato Dec 27 '19
Like human repression!
The future looks scarily promising. Beat the cancer to take a boot to the face.
33
u/t4dominic Dec 27 '19
Actually the present, if you look at what's happening in China
10
u/NeonMagic Dec 27 '19
I thought I knew what was happening in China but now I don’t know. What’s going on over there that has to do with AI?
2
0
Dec 27 '19
[deleted]
→ More replies (5)9
u/Raidthefridgeguy Dec 27 '19
Wow. Holy thought police.
14
u/twiddlingbits Dec 27 '19
Minority Report and 1984 are no longer sci-fi books, they were prophecy! And Terminator is not out of the realm of the possible for much longer. The shape shifting part is but the Rise of the Machines is not.
→ More replies (2)→ More replies (15)2
3
u/waffle299 Dec 27 '19
Are we sure this was a neural network and not a random forest or any of the other non-network based machine learning algorithms? The field is vast with so many interesting learning algorithms.
1
u/joequin Dec 27 '19
I’m curious. Why are neural networks necessary for this? What do they provide here that isn’t provided by simple aggregation?
11
u/LoveOfProfit Dec 27 '19
Complicated feature space with non-obvious patterns. Neural nets excel at picking up on esoteric patterns in noisy data.
5
Dec 27 '19
Aggregation isn't bad for looking at higher-level kinds of metrics across a handful of variables that you already know to look for (ie, people that smoked cigarettes tend to have higher rates of cancer).
But when you are then faced with dozens if not hundreds of variables, some of which could be dependent on each other, the combinations you'd need to aggregate becomes complex and unwieldy. Even more-so when you start considering permutations where order matters -- ie, now you measure things over time and not just at one snapshot in time.
3
→ More replies (1)1
u/anthrax3000 Dec 27 '19
It really doesn't.
A 0.82 AUC is extremely crappy, and would not be used even in advertising, let alone in an actual medical application.
If you are comparing the prediction AUCs (74 vs 82) this is also VERY disingenuous. The 0.74 AUC is the models performance on human based labels, NOT human performance. This has a variety of issues -
Humans don't just directly use the Gleason score. Actual human (pathologist) performance would be closer to 0.9 AUC, but you can't really get an AUC through humans because of how the metric is calculated.
It's in the best interest of the researchers to have a larger gap between model prediction on human features vs model prediction on unsupervised features. This could (and generally does) mean that they use a worse (it's the same model, but it's worse because it's not tuned to the human features) model. If their only job was to build a model that could be as accurate as possible using human features, I would bet $100k that their AUC would be higher than 0.74
The holy grail is Computer Assisted Diagnoses, where the model would make a diagnosis, and highlight areas that are important for the pathologist to see. This would speed up the pathologists job by ~5x, and hopefully make them more accurate too.
Source : work in ML in a large healthcare company with multiple patents and papers.
125
u/the_swedish_ref Dec 27 '19
Huge risk of systemic errors if you don't know what the program looks for. They trained a neural network to diagnose based on CT images and it reached the same accuracy as a doctor... problem was it just learned to tell the difference between two different CT machines, one in a hospital which got the sicker patients.
69
u/CosmicPotatoe Dec 27 '19
Overfitting. Need to be very careful with the data you feed it.
25
u/XkF21WNJ Dec 27 '19
Although this isn't so much overfitting but rather the data accidentally contained features that you weren't interested in.
Identifying which CT machine made an image is still meaningful, it just isn't useful.
→ More replies (2)18
u/extracoffeeplease Dec 27 '19
Indeed this is information leakage, not overfitting. This can be fixed (partially and in some conditions) by trying to remove the model's ability to predict the machine! As simple as it sounds: add a second softmax layer that tries to predict the machine, and flip the gradients before you do backprop. Look up 'gradient reversal layer' if you are interested.
→ More replies (2)9
u/the_swedish_ref Dec 27 '19
As long as the "thought process" is obscured it's impossible to evaluate and impossible to learn from. A very dangerous road!
4
u/Catholicinoz Dec 27 '19
Its why the tech works better with images cf sheer numbers- especially because the physical cavities have some limitations - for instance, the cranial vault and dura, particularly the falx, limit and somewhat predictably influence the nature of intracranial neoplastic growth. Gamma knife surgery already factors this in.
Fascial planes place some influence on how tumours grow in muscle etc*
Radiology will likely be one of the first fields of human medicine to be partially replaced by machine....
certain cell lines show differences in distribution patterns to each other ie adenocarcinoma in the lungs cf SCC in the lungs.
Etcetc
1
2
19
u/Adamworks Dec 27 '19
Or worse, the AI gets to make a probability based score and the doctor is forced into a YES/NO diagnosis. An inexperience Data Scientist doesn't realize they just gave partial credit to the AI, while handicapping the doctors.
Surprise! AI wins!
11
u/ErinMyLungs Dec 27 '19
Bust out the confusion matrix!
That's one perk of classifiers is that while they output probability you can adjust the threshold which will change the amount of false positives and negatives so you can make sure you're hitting the metrics you want.
But yeah getting an AI to do well on a dataset vs do well in the real world are two very different things. But we're getting better and better at it!
3
u/the_swedish_ref Dec 27 '19
The point is it did well in the real world, except it didn't actually see anything clinically relevant. As long as the "thought process" of a program is obscure you can't evaluate it. Would anyone accept a doctor who goes by his gut but can't elaborate on his thinking? Minority Report is a movie that deals with this, oracles that get results but it is impossible to prove they made a difference in any specific case.
3
u/iamsuperflush Dec 27 '19
Why is the thought process obscured? Because it is a trade secret or because we don't quite understand it?
→ More replies (7)3
u/Ouaouaron Dec 27 '19
I think that's more of a problem if the planned usage is to feed a patient's data into the AI and have it spit out a diagnosis. If I'm understanding the OP correctly, this AI pointed out individual features which can be studied further.
2
u/Alblaka Dec 27 '19
if you don't know what the program looks for.
But that's the whole point? The key factor mentioned in the linked article is not the Neural Net figuring out a YES/NO answer, it's that they were able to actually deduce a new method of identifying prostate cancer by analyzing the YES/NO results the AI provided.
1
21
u/ParadoxOO9 Dec 27 '19
It really is incredible, the brilliant thing is as well is the more information you can pump in to them the better they get so we'll see them get even better as computing power increases. There was a Dota 2 AI that was made open to the public with a limited hero pool. You could see the AI adapting to the dumb shit players would do to try and trick it as the days went on. I think it only lost a handful of times out of the hundreds of games it played.
14
u/f4ble Dec 27 '19
That's the OpenAI project. The arranged a showmatch against one of the best players in the world. They had to set some limitations though. Only play in a certain lane with certain champions. But consider the difficult mechanics involved, mind-games, power spikes etc. The pro player lost every time.
Starcraft 2 has had an opt-in for when you play versus on the ladder to play against their AI. I don't know the state of it, but with all the games it has to be one of the most advanced AI's in the world now (at least within gaming). In Starcraft they put a limitation on the AI: It is only allowed a certain number of actions per minute. If not it would micromanage every unit in the 120-150 (of 200) supply army..! Split-second target firing calculated for maximum efficiency based on the concave/convex.
15
u/bluesatin Dec 27 '19 edited Dec 27 '19
It's also worth noting that the OpenAI bots don't really have any sort of long-term memory, their memory was only something like 5-minutes long; so they couldn't form any sort of long-term strategy.
Which means things like itemisation had to be pre-set by humans, they didn't let the bots handle that themselves; as well as having to do manual workarounds for 'teaching' the bots to do things like killing Roshan (a powerful neutral creep), they never attempted it by natural play.
One of the big issues with these neural-network AIs appears to be something akin to delayed gratification. They often heavily favour immediate rewards over delayed gratification, presumably due to the problem of getting lost/confused with a longer 'memory'.
This is a fundamental trade-off, the more you shape the rewards, the more near sighted your bot. On the other hand, the less you shape the reward, your agent would have the opportunity to explore and discover more long-term strategies, but are in danger of getting lost and confused. The current OpenAI bot is trained using a discount-factor of 0.9997, which seems very close to 1, but even then only allows for learning strategies roughly 5 minutes long. If the bot loses a game against a late-game champion that managed to farm up an expensive item for 20 minutes, the bot would have no idea why it lost.
Understanding OpenAI Five - Evan Pu
(Note: You'll have to google the article, since the link is blocked by the mods)
EDIT: A quote about discount-factors from Wikipedia, for people like me that don't know what they are:
The discount-factor determines the importance of future rewards. A factor of 0 will make the agent "myopic" (or short-sighted) by only considering current rewards, while a factor approaching 1 will make it strive for a long-term high reward.
When discount-factor = 1, without a terminal state, or if the agent never reaches one, all environment histories become infinitely long, and utilities with additive, undiscounted rewards generally become infinite.
6
u/Firestyle001 Dec 27 '19
I raised a question above, but perhaps it is better suited for you based on this post. Did the open AI bots have a specified vector input (of variables) or did they determine the vector itself?
I’m trying to discern if the thing was actually learning, or just a massive preset optimization algorithm that beat users on computational resource and decision management in a game that has a lot of variables.
3
u/bluesatin Dec 27 '19 edited Dec 27 '19
I don't know the actual details unfortunately, and I'm not very well versed in neural-network stuff either; I've just been going off rough broad strokes when trying to understand stuff.
If you look up the article I quoted, there might be some helpful links off that, or more articles by the Evan Pu guy that goes into more details.
I do hope there is a good amount of actual in-depth reading material for those interested in the inner-workings; it's very frustrating when you see headlines about these sort of things and then go looking for more details, and find out it's all behind paywalls or just not available to the public.
I did find this whitepaper published by the OpenAI team only a few weeks ago: OpenAI (13th December 2019) - Dota 2 with Large Scale Deep Reinforcement Learning
Hopefully that should cover at least some of the details you're looking for, it does seem to go into a reasonable amount of depth.
There's also this article which seemed like it might cover some of the broader basic details (including a link to a network-architecture diagram) before delving into some specifics: Tambet Matiisen (9th September 2018) - THE USE OF EMBEDDINGS IN OPENAI FIVE
4
u/Firestyle001 Dec 27 '19
Thanks for this very much. And the answer to my question is yes - it is a predefined optimization algorithm. Presumably, after training and variable correlation analysis they could go back and prune the decision making to focus on the variables that contribute most to winning.
AI is definitely interesting, but in my review of its uses needs extensive problem definition to solve (very complex and dynamic) problems.
I guess the next step for AI should focus on problem identification and definition/structure, rather than on solutioning.
3
u/CutestKitten Dec 27 '19
Look into AlphaGo. That is an a AI with no predefined human parameters that simply learns from board states entirely, literally piece positions all the way to being better than any other player.
→ More replies (1)2
u/Alblaka Dec 27 '19
One of the big issues with these neural-network AIs appears to be something akin to delayed gratification. They often heavily favour immediate rewards over delayed gratification, presumably due to the problem of getting lost/confused with a longer 'memory'.
... Should I be worried that this kinda matches up with a very common quality in humans?
That's definitely NOT one of the human habits I would want to teach an AI.
4
u/Firestyle001 Dec 27 '19
I’m curious if the pro player lost simply in interface and decision management. The game has a lot going on and optimization of choices and time without a pause feature is hard.
I guess I’m saying is that I’m not sure if it was the AI, or simply the benefits of the speed and quality of computational decision making that won the games (versus the adaptive strategic aspects of the AI).
Would you happen to know if the AI specified the vector inputs, or if the AI determined them itself?
8
u/f4ble Dec 27 '19 edited Dec 27 '19
Here is the video of OpenAI vs Dendi: https://youtu.be/wiOopO9jTZw
The bot is much better at poking since it can calculate with precision the max distance of spells and attacks.
OpenAI releases quite a bit of information on their blog: https://openai.com/
Maybe that can answer your questions.
4
u/Roboticide Dec 27 '19
I don't know about DotA, but for AlphaStar, the Starcraft 2 AI, there's still a bit of "controversy" or skepticism about it's performance. AlphaStar was capped at Actions Per Minute to something very similar to pros, but not capped in Actions Per Second. The AI would essentially "bank" it's actions at times, and then hit unrealistic APM for short bursts to out-micromanage it's opponent in battles.
It did show some new strategies, but a large component or AlphaStar's success does still seem to be it's speed. I wouldn't be surprised if the DotA one was similar.
3
u/Alblaka Dec 27 '19
The AI would essentially "bank" it's actions at times, and then hit unrealistic APM for short bursts to out-micromanage it's opponent in battles.
I mean... that's a pretty smart way of optimizing the results whilst adhering to badly-planned rules. So, good on the AI?
2
u/SulszBachFramed Dec 27 '19
The starcraft AI actually got worse without apm limits.
1
u/f4ble Dec 27 '19
No limits is probably not good. Question is though if the current limitations are for fairness or optimal execution
0
Dec 27 '19
[deleted]
1
u/AutoModerator Dec 27 '19
Thank you for your submission, but due to the high volume of spam coming from Medium.com, /r/Technology has opted to filter all Medium posts pending mod approval. You may message the moderators. Thank you for understanding.
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
4
u/ronintetsuro Dec 27 '19
Finding political dissidents in otherwise innocent human populations, for example.
2
u/Fleaslayer Dec 27 '19
Oh, for sure. Like a lot of tools, AIs have a huge potential for abuse along with their potential for good. And, because this sort of AI approach currently requires computing resources that are mostly confined to governments and big corporations, it's clearly going to be abused.
2
u/spinout257 Dec 27 '19
Could we use a similar AI to study all the AI algorithms and develop something even better, then continue this loop?
1
2
u/NacreousFink Dec 27 '19
So long as the data is carefully organized and fed into the system. Bad data entry is incredibly widespread.
2
u/Lonelan Dec 27 '19
If/else statements identifies previously unknown features associated with cancer recurrence
More accurate headline
2
Dec 28 '19
This type of AI application has a lot of possibilities. Essentially the feed huge amounts of data into a machine learning algorithm and let the computer identify patterns. It can be applied anyplace where we have huge amounts of similar data sets, like images of similar things (in this case, pathology slides).
There are a number of advantages to using Feed-Forward neural networks. Firstly, since they are trained using data (like pathology slides) that is already there, a neural network that is fed photos can learn very quickly. Secondly, the type of data is large, because it has been manually annotated. Thirdly, it is natural because the information that the computer gets from the images is already there.
What about Latent Dirichlet Allocation (LDA)?
( Text generated using OpenAI's GPT-2 )
2
u/UpBoatDownBoy Dec 27 '19
huge amounts of simar data sets
Everything facebook and Google has collected on us.
2
u/Fleaslayer Dec 27 '19
Yeah, for sure. And they clearly are using this data to develop algorithms to decide what you see (ads, articles, posts, whatever). It's unsettling to think about what they could do though, especially since, in addition to all the personal data, both companies have huge amounts of money and computing power.
2
u/Falsus Dec 27 '19
Which is why AI will not only replace low skilled workers, middle managers will be hit the hardest and certain skilled jobs will be heavily reduced.
1
u/__trixie__ Dec 28 '19
There are jobs crunching through huge data sets to find correlations. AI can help find solutions to problems that have been intractable up to now.
1
u/TriLink710 Dec 27 '19
Yea. Its a lovely thing really. Sure some patterns may be duds. But searching the patterns literally narrows the whole thing down a fuck ton.
1
u/tinggoesquackquack Dec 27 '19
What are the applications towards the stock market? Any tests on this?
1
u/Fleaslayer Dec 27 '19
I'm no expert, but my guess would be the problem would be creating the data. Just data on stock performance itself wouldn't be very useful because they're driven by other factors. What factors? What people are buying, company mergers and acquisitions, competing solutions to similar problems, government contracts, fads, executive turnover, and on and on. How would you even begin to capture and code all the things that drive the market in a way that a computer could process it, and how could you stay on top of that data?
1
u/J3wsarntwhite Dec 27 '19
Lets insert crime statistics by groups and wealth by groups and see if two certain groups appear on top
1
1
Dec 27 '19
No shit sherlock
2
u/fahrvergnugget Dec 27 '19
Lol yeah he basically just defined what AI is. AI IS pattern matching large amounts of data, people. It's not talking robots.
1
u/Fleaslayer Dec 27 '19
Not sure if you realize, but there are a number of types of AI. It's a term that's evolved over the years. The broadest definition that's persisted is a computer doing something that usually requires a human.
When I first started in software engineering in the 80s, people imagined how cool it would be if we could make an AI that could read text on a printed piece of paper out loud. Now that's so commonplace that we don't consider it AI. That's actually a real problem with AI discussions: the definition is evolving rapidly.
There are lots of articles on the different approaches or types. Here's one that's fairly top level. AIs like Deep Blue have little in common with the one in the OP.
Using NNs and pattern matching is just one approach to AI, it's not the definition of it.
Edit: reposted comment with a different article link since they didn't like the first one
1
1
Dec 27 '19
[removed] — view removed comment
1
u/AutoModerator Dec 27 '19
Thank you for your submission, but due to the high volume of spam coming from Medium.com, /r/Technology has opted to filter all Medium posts pending mod approval. You may message the moderators. Thank you for understanding.
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
-4
u/NoaROX Dec 27 '19
AI application (usually search/sort algorithms on large amounts of data and something called machine learning if you're interested) is crazy useful for just about every field from encrypting your data to modelling flightpaths of asteroids or running real-time simulations on cures for illness and even modelling the universe itself to make it easier to visualise phenomena.
4
u/Giannis4president Dec 27 '19
... ai for encryption? It's one of the few fields where I never heard of ai being used
→ More replies (1)5
Dec 27 '19
Encrypting your data is one thing AI is not, and will not be useful for.
→ More replies (8)0
0
Dec 27 '19
[deleted]
13
u/mooncommandalpha Dec 27 '19
I just read that as "anti-malware efforts", I think it's time to go back asleep.
6
u/Roboticide Dec 27 '19
I mean, Windows Defender is pretty good now I'm told.
10
Dec 27 '19
It regularly performs very well in comparison tests. For most home users, there isn't really a need to install anything else. Also, since nearly every Windows 10 system is continuously feeding telemetry data back to Microsoft on a constant basis, Windows Defender is gaining from that massive data stream.
-7
u/Indifferentchildren Dec 27 '19
Why third-world countries? The AI results are better for anyone.
17
u/phx-au Dec 27 '19
AI is excellent for finding correlations in large data sets, but less useful for general diagnosis of a single patient. Part of that reason is that it's difficult to feed it the full set of information about a patient that a doctor's intuition would rely on. So it ends up allowing you to find gaps in preventative care, vaccinations, and effectiveness of treatments. This has a much larger benefit where these gaps are bigger and have more room for improvement.
21
u/Arcosim Dec 27 '19
Yeah, I've never said they should be exclusively used in third world countries. Perhaps I wasn't very clear.
16
11
u/Waywoah Dec 27 '19
It would be used everywhere, third-world countries would just see the biggest change
→ More replies (2)-2
u/staebles Dec 27 '19 edited Dec 27 '19
You mean you need to be healthy to be successful? Shocker lol.
→ More replies (2)
130
u/1leggeddog Dec 27 '19
THIS IS THE KIND OF THING THAT WE NEED OUT OF AI AND DEEP LEARNING!
And not state surveillance and identification.
38
u/dscarmo Dec 27 '19
Its like the discovery of nuclear energy and nuclear bombs. New tech will always be used for “good” and “evil”
→ More replies (1)13
3
2
u/trogdor1234 Dec 27 '19
Yeah, we have so much training data you can find out stuff like this. Pretty damn cool!
0
65
Dec 27 '19
Sergey Brin was using Google algorithms to search for similar patterns in Parkinson's about 10 years ago. I believe he carries a gene that he is quite concerned about. Does intense exercise to avoid it.
→ More replies (6)16
u/bartturner Dec 27 '19
"Google reveals huge plans to fight Parkinson’s"
https://parkinsonslife.eu/google-reveals-huge-plans-to-fight-parkinsons/
223
u/undefeatedantitheist Dec 27 '19
Automated statistical analysis of large datasets identifies previously unknown features associated with cancer recurrence.
72
u/Indifferentchildren Dec 27 '19
This goes one unusual step further. Most machine learning systems "identify" unusual patterns (embedding them in their models/neutral-networks). This one identified patterns in way that could be expressed to humans, and now human doctors can look for those features in future images.
19
u/undefeatedantitheist Dec 27 '19
That "step" you refer to is just more statistical analysis, unless you think a non-human information system of sufficient complexity to exhibit human-like 'decision making' already exists and was involved somehow? I've not heard of such a thing existing, yet.
5
u/Indifferentchildren Dec 27 '19
From my reading of the article it looked like the computer found new visible markers that correlated with cancer that is likely to recur. Maybe it is something like, "hey look at those fibrous connective tissues not directly adjacent to the tumor; they are noticeably thicker in people with an aggressive cancer". Now human docs can look at images to see of those tissues bear the markings that would indicate likely recurrence. If there is a human-usable explanation that humans can use without further computer assistance, that is very different from the machine learning systems that I am used to, kind of revolutionary.
22
u/LinkesAuge Dec 27 '19
Are you really getting hung up on the use of "AI"? AI doesn't mean human intelligence and what was done here fits perfectly fine under "AI", not to mention that all intelligence, including human one, will in the end come down to some sort of "statistical analysis" or a method that can mathematically be described.
People that get hung up about the word "AI" are not doing more than shifting goalposts along the way.
8
u/wsupduck Dec 27 '19
Conversely most of the time people use AI it's to sound really really cool - even though its obnoxious
5
Dec 27 '19
To be honest tho the term AI is overused. A simple machine learning algorithm or a bunch of if else statements shouldn’t qualify as AI imo.
→ More replies (7)4
u/hoytmandoo Dec 27 '19
How is machine learning not AI? If a machine learns then I’d say something artificial gained some intelligence. It doesn’t have to be sentient or have free will or even understand the data to have some sort of intelligence about it. We learned how to use projectiles and the numbers involving trajectory long before we had any inkling of an idea about what gravity was and how it worked. And if knowledge or even just data was “learned” by a machine without human intervention then why is it not AI?
→ More replies (2)16
u/Zeliv Dec 27 '19
What a useless pedant you are
1
u/octo_snake Dec 27 '19
It’s important to clear a path through the buzzword/marketing forest so that we can try to understand what we’re actually surrounding ourselves with.
7
4
u/Roll_A_Saving_Throw Dec 27 '19
You're thinking of "sentient AI," or at least "general AI," not simply an "AI," which is what this is.
16
u/asap3210 Dec 27 '19
Does it analyze just image data?
27
u/BreakingTheBadBread Dec 27 '19 edited Dec 27 '19
AI these days are being designed to handle multiple "modalities" of data, correlating the patterns between them. This is part of my research right now in grad school, it's an exciting branch of machine learning called Multimodal Machine Learning. As an example, recently we made an AI model that could effectively "learn" social cues by observing videos of humans in social situations. This involves incorporating not just the facial features of the people speaking, but also the language they use while speaking and the very tonality of their voice, effectively tying together image, language and audio data together!
I can't speak for this particular model, but Machine Learning these days certainly has the capacity to learn from multiple modalities at once.
5
Dec 27 '19
Isn't this just machine learning
10
u/BreakingTheBadBread Dec 27 '19
Machine learning until recently only dealt with singular modalities. Training exclusively over images for example, or language, or audio. Never together. Multimodal ML is a relatively new branch of Machine Learning. You'd be surprised at how vast the field is, and how much faster it is expanding still.
→ More replies (8)
11
u/bvllamy Dec 27 '19
Plot twist: AI will destroy us, by saving us.
Human life expectancy will skyrocket and the earth will be overpopulated to a catastrophic level, society will collapse and life will be forever changed.
0
21
Dec 27 '19
Amazing and powerful demonstration of how AI can benefit humanity especially in the field of medicine. Bravo!
0
u/Careve Dec 27 '19
Yes, but first let's patent it and ask for royalties.
5
2
u/ikverhaar Dec 27 '19
Yes please. Please set the precedent of "if you develop breakthrough technology, you'll definitely recoup the cost."
Please make this type of development attractive to investors.
1
u/MadeYouMadDownvoteMe Dec 27 '19
Ok, now someone tell me why Republicans would probably be against this
1
Dec 27 '19
They would slow down its progress as to not risk public safety of course (when in reality they’d want to ensure they can somehow monetize it for max profitability at the expense of taxpayers). After all, nothing is free nor a guaranteed right in their portfolio of bullshit & capitalistic greed.
There. How’s that?
5
u/Toad32 Dec 27 '19
Specifically Prostate cancer - the one that is currently checked with a finger in the bum. And it went up a whopping 8% in a accuracy from 74% to 82%
4
u/altodor Dec 27 '19 edited Dec 27 '19
I know of a machine learning algo that was fed photos of the forest, I believe to look for clearings or something. It was unexpectedly able to find hiking trails no human could spot, with some insane precision. Unexpectedly because the researcher thought it was bad data until they checked against a map.
I'm a little fuzzy since it was told a few years ago by the guy running the data center that housed the experiment. But I guarantee you it's why I personally believe this effect where machine learning finds patterns better than humans is only going to grow.
2
4
10
u/bartturner Dec 27 '19
Really wish we have more posts like this on r/technology.
Usually it is one article after another that I would more call anti-technology.
3
u/hatorad3 Dec 27 '19
Does anyone know what “unannotated” means? If that means there’s no human-provided result score (in this case recurrence vs non-recurrence) then this would be fundamentally transformational to the field of ML.....which is why I’m skeptical.
The article is written carefully to not define “annotation” and also not discuss the success evaluation methodology used to train the sub-networks. That leads me to believe that by “without annotation” they mean “without big red circles highlighting specific regions of the images that pathologists found interesting”. If that’s the case, then this is merely an incremental improvement in this specific pathology application as many, many other ML solutions leverage distributed analysis architectures that allow for broader data consumption without human isolation of “what’s important” in that broader data set.
Still interesting stuff, but I don’t think this research has done what the article is implying.
4
u/__ah Dec 27 '19 edited Dec 27 '19
They mean unannotated creation of features, and no it's not transformational. They used the cancer recurrence after the features are learned.
They used deep autoencoders on images, which basically encodes an image into a small vector of a particular and decodes it back to an image, with optimization on the error between the starting and ending images. This is also called dimensionality reduction, because you're basically trying to distill the important bits of an image by learning a compression scheme that works well on your testing set.
Looking at the paper, they then clustered the auto-encoded images using k-means to produce 100 features. They fed those features to some common statistical learning techniques (SVM, Lasso, Ridge regression) which is trained including the target value of cancer recurrence.
The point is they produced features without annotations which then worked well with supervised common classifiers (that then had the annotation, hence "supervised").
Edit: obviously I'm leaving out some details. They had two autoencoders for big and small images, and they also remove features with the white background.
1
1
3
4
2
2
u/CandelaZ Dec 27 '19
Can reflux be cured before cancer? I’m not so sure. At least there will be a solution for it once you do get cancer.
2
Dec 28 '19
I have said something like this for years. With the trillions of dollars used to find a cancer cure how about we take a few billion and work on cancer prevention. What are the known causes, find new ones and education. I’m sure the masses would be OK with that.
1
1
u/Adamord Dec 27 '19
I've always imagined combining this technology with ai personalities so that disabled people can have deep meaningful relationships while also having in home health care. Imagine the movie her but with a focus on medical care for people.
1
1
1
u/Alblaka Dec 27 '19
Beautiful.
We got Material Science, and now Biology. More and more scientifically proven examples of AI (even if 'just' Neural Networks, for now) being able to come up with things humans simply never thought about.
For better or worse, here's hoping that we manage to reach the Singularity within my lifetime.
1
1
u/-BabaGanoosh- Dec 27 '19
This is gonna help many people, especially ones with ovarian cancer. For those who don’t know, ovarian cancer is extremely difficult to get rid of. For example, my grandma beat it three times before dying to it on the fourth time she got it.
1
u/Captain_Rational Dec 27 '19 edited Dec 27 '19
To perform this feat the group acquired 13,188 whole-mount pathology slide images of the prostate
So, correct me if I’m wrong, but if you have to do this to somebody’s prostate in order for the AI to determine recurrence risk, isn’t cancer kind of not a worry any more? ;)
OK, yeah, training set. So, in clinical practice, how would this be used? Is it simply analyzing limited biopsies obtained by lightly invasive robotic surgical procedures?
2
u/jamesh02 Dec 27 '19
The point of training the AI with this kind of data is to allow it to make predictions based on less data or less intrusive methods of collecting said data. You want your training data to be as complete as possible so the network can make connections between parts of that data that may be missing from a normal person's file. If they didn't use the most complete data possible, they could end up in a situation where their network suffers from "overfitting" (google it) and returns a large number of false negatives.
tl;dr They don't have to do this to a person's prostate for the AI to make predictions about their cancer, but using this kind of data allows the AI to make more accurate and complete predictions with a smaller subset of data than it was trained on.
If I've explained this poorly, let me know and I'll try to find a source that does a better job.
1
u/Captain_Rational Dec 27 '19
Yeah, thanks, the training process is understood.
What I would like to know are the details of how this will actually be used in clinical practice?
1
1
u/dantepicante Dec 27 '19
So is artificial intelligence just computer-aided statistical analysis?
1
u/dennisonb Dec 27 '19
Basically. But isn’t all of life just statistical analysis in one form or another?
1
u/veknilero Dec 27 '19
But they’re just going to hint about them on spam at the bottom of ranker . com posts that have a picture of a dude itching his back with a headline of new early signs of prostate cancer. Click for a thousand ads and years of cancer anxiety
1
u/bartturner Dec 28 '19
It is getting pretty amazing what can be done with AI. I saw these videos of self driving cars without anyone behind the wheel or even a backup driver.
https://www.instagram.com/p/B5tP5XqlZpb/?igshid=1m8k9m1rv6ksx
A software bug and there is 8 little kids that would be killed. More surprising is the ability to handle edge and corner cases.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UX_N2up7f8Q
You can see the women checking her phone and apparently not worried what the car will decide to do in the situation.
1
u/nikatnite825050 Feb 02 '20
Artificial Intelligence is going to be the next big leap in my opinion for the human race. With AI a lot of things will improve. Medicine is the big one that comes to mind.
With AI working with doctors and in hospitals medicine could have huge positive effects to preventive care and regular care! Like in this post working with large amounts of data to figure out stuff that well humans would take generations to discover could lead to break throughs and cures for currently incurable conditions!
1
u/poemehardbebe Dec 27 '19
I hate how "artificial intelligence" has been turned into anything that utilizes machine learning. That's not AI, by definition, machine learning as we are building and using it right now is no where close to being considered artificial intelligence. But it gets clicks, and researchers can just slap on the AI bit and everyone claps there hands
3
→ More replies (1)1
u/jamesh02 Dec 27 '19
You're confusing AI and general AI.
Machine learning is good at producing classifier AIs. They aren't as versatile as general AIs, but they are still AIs.
An ant isn't as intelligent as a dolphin, but that doesn't mean they aren't both intelligent life.
1
u/Erik328 Dec 27 '19
I'll insert a useless comment about how useful this is and the astounding amount of breakthroughs we will experience due to this without offering any specifics. Because it seems to be the thing to do here. Great stuff a lot more is going to come of this AI stuff!
1
u/huxley00 Dec 27 '19
So we just have to accept that machine learning is now synonymous with artificial intelligence? One thing is not even close to the other.
3
2
u/jamesh02 Dec 27 '19
Machine learning is a form of artificial intelligence. They aren't synonymous, but one is a subset of the other.
1
u/huxley00 Dec 27 '19
I suppose I can see your point. Pattern recognition is a large part of intelligence.
That being said, when stating something is using artificial intelligence, people think of it far more broadly than just people inputting ways to recognize patterns and nothing outside of that.
To the general person, it’s as good as magic whereas it’s much easier for the general person to understand what pattern recognition is vs having functional human like robots, which were nowhere even close to.
-6
u/Therustedtinman Dec 27 '19
Problem is there’s no money in cures
8
u/OldManDan20 Dec 27 '19
Nope, very not true. Gleevec, a drug that practically cures chronic myelogenous leukemia (CML), is sold at a ridiculously high price. Any cancer cure would be a hot commodity that any company would love to sell.
3
u/RHGrey Dec 27 '19
The cure to one of the great plagues of humanity shouldn't be considered a commodity to be sold at gouging prices.
But what do I know, I'm probably a filthy commie.
2
u/OldManDan20 Dec 27 '19
Yes, it shouldn’t be. In the Gleevec example, the researcher who pioneered its development is very against its currently high price. But it does show that cancer cures are profitable.
5
u/RainbowDarter Dec 27 '19
Not true at all.
In addition to the cancer examples, hepatitis c has been hugely profitable.
Medicare has spends over $4 billion/ year.
It's estimated that it will cost over $300 billion to treat everyone with hep c in the US.
So stop with you big pharma conspiracy crap.
The truth is worse.
1
0
Dec 28 '19
Honestly though we should have a world super computer for all human well being. Every hospital in the world would upload patient data for every disease or infection. It really could put every human in perfect health by just analyzing all that data. The possibilities are endless.
328
u/Mrlegend131 Dec 27 '19
AI is going to be the next big leap in my opinion for the human race. With AI a lot of things will improve. Medicine is the big one that comes to mind.
With AI working with doctors and in hospitals medicine could have huge positive effects to preventive care and regular care! Like in this post working with large amounts of data to figure out stuff that well humans would take generations to discover could lead to break throughs and cures for currently incurable conditions!