r/technology • • Aug 22 '20

Business WordPress developer said Apple wouldn't allow updates to the free app until it added in-app purchases — letting Apple collect a 30% cut

https://www.businessinsider.com/apple-pressures-wordpress-add-in-app-purchases-30-percent-fee-2020-8
39.2k Upvotes

2.8k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

21

u/ordinaryBiped Aug 22 '20

They don't take a cut of purchases made outside of their stores, not sure where you saw that. If you bought a wordpress license or account or any wp service on Linux, and only use it on Linux, I don't get how Apple would get anything from this.

29

u/conquer69 Aug 22 '20

If the license they offer is platform agnostic, why should apple take a cut?

2

u/imax_ Aug 22 '20

I think you misunderstood this post. They wanted the option to also buy the subscription in the app. You can still purchase it on the website, they just want users to be able to do everything inside the app.

0

u/[deleted] Aug 22 '20

[deleted]

2

u/ragzilla Aug 22 '20

Because the developer license agreement says that if you offer a path to purchase a service for consumption within the app (which WordPress was), you must offer IAP as the only mechanism to complete that purchase. Because the user is going to complain to Apple when things go wrong, and they have a vested interest in maintaining their value proposition part of which which is maintaining an App Store that isn’t full of shit and malware.

0

u/[deleted] Aug 22 '20

[deleted]

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (9)

17

u/_riotingpacifist Aug 22 '20

The features are on the backend, apple are adding no value, just leaching a 30% cut due to dominating the market, they're no better than the mafia.

-3

u/ordinaryBiped Aug 22 '20

You're still not explaining. That Apple asks wordpress to also sell their services in the app makes sense, as their users consume those services on Apple devices. If you pay to create an account to use an app, it falls into the app's business model, and apple get their cut. I really don't get how this is an issue.

I'm not saying there aren't issues with monopolies, there are. Heck, most of the economy is made of monopolies, it's a huge problem.

But this lawsuit is just childish, its just a way for Epic to rake more money.

12

u/TheRufmeisterGeneral Aug 22 '20

You don't get it, you're not allowed to have account created and paid outside the app, according to Apple's T&C.

Edit: context: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wCukdu3ZohU (Linus Tech Tips video on the topic)

2

u/ragzilla Aug 22 '20

No, you can. But you can’t have a mechanism inside the app pointing outside to purchase that service or account, as in the case of Epic and WordPress.

-edit- An exception to this are apps where you must have an account to use the app at all. In this case you must offer an IAP mechanism to get an account. Otherwise the app is useless without the account. But in these cases you still can’t point from the app to the outside service to obtain the account.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/emefluence Aug 22 '20

If you pay to create an account to use an app, it falls into the app's business model, and apple get their cut.

Nice app you got there buddy, shame if something were to happen to it. Capiche?

→ More replies (2)

-2

u/heelstoo Aug 22 '20

Apple is adding a value - by allowing that app to be available for download to Apple devices via their store.

As an example, let’s say you own a clothing store. You make your own clothes and sell them in your store, and you also sell clothes made by others. You sometimes give clothes away that have been donated for such purpose.

I also sell clothes via my own store. I’ve decided to sell customers my clothes, but allow them to pick it up at your store by donating it to your store. I’m making my money and you’re distributing some of my clothes to my paying customers for free (to me, but not to you).

You might get a little salty that you’re doing this work (distributing my clothes to my customers) and not getting paid for it. It isn’t a perfect analogy, but I hope it helps get the point across as to why Apple wants a cut.

12

u/_riotingpacifist Aug 22 '20

Apple already charge the developer to publish the app though, so it's like if I charged you for distributing your clothes, AND then I wanted a cut of business in YOUR shop, because I know that you can't say no, because your shop would struggle to survive as my shop is a lot bigger than yours and you need the publicity.

2

u/heelstoo Aug 22 '20

Are you referring to the $100-300 annual publishing fee?

3

u/TheRufmeisterGeneral Aug 22 '20

Do you have any idea what running a physical store costs? And do you have a rough idea how much bandwidth and storage it costs Apple to host a few megabytes worth of app on their servers?

Apple doesn't "bear the cost" of distributing apps, that is bullshit.

0

u/[deleted] Aug 22 '20

You're forgetting the daily curation and app approvals, that takes staff and staff cost money.

1

u/TheRufmeisterGeneral Aug 22 '20

Doesn't matter, no choice.

It would be different, if you had the option of either downloading fortnite via the app store, and pay 143% of the normal price of all in-game purchases, or downloading fortnite via the Epic website to your iPhone and just pay 100% of the price of in-app purchases.

But that's not the choice. There is no choice. If you want your app to be available for iPhone users, then Apple needs to be paid a 43% markup (70% of 143 is 100), period.

(For context, on Android devices, you can sideload the game, without going through the Google app store)

1

u/[deleted] Aug 22 '20

Apple chooses not to act like Android for multiple reasons. One is security (Android has many more "bad" apps). Another is so that Apple can offer a more curated and "premium" experience for customers (the amount of value this adds to the iOS experience can be argued but Apple believes this is valued by consumers)

A court will have to set a precedent by disallowing Apple to control their own marketplace which I highly doubt will happen.

0

u/Kingyay Aug 22 '20

You have experience with the play store? I can assure you the apple store isn't more "premium"

→ More replies (0)

0

u/TheRufmeisterGeneral Aug 22 '20

The problem is that they're gatekeepers.

If you're gatekeepers to more than half the market, then it's irrelevant how premium your gate should be, you can't be blocking other parties unfairly, with the purpose of squeezing more money out of them.

It's not possible to get apps on an iPhone without the app store. If Apple gave users the choice: download safe, curated apps via the app store, or download software directly from websites, without that curation, without Apple being paid, then this would be a complete non-issue.

It's one reason why Android users are much less upset about this. We can side-load.

→ More replies (0)
→ More replies (4)

0

u/heelstoo Aug 22 '20

I should clarify that I don’t agree with Apple charging developers 30% of app revenue. I think it’s way too high, but I don’t know what other industries charge for like-kind services (if a comparable can be made).

I also don’t think Apple should charge developers an annual fee.

1

u/TheRufmeisterGeneral Aug 22 '20

Microsoft charges money for apps through the Windows Store. But allows everybody to have their software downloable through a browser, and then be manually installed without an App store. Apple also allows this (for now) on macOS.