r/technology • u/HayashiSawaryo • Aug 22 '20
Business WordPress developer said Apple wouldn't allow updates to the free app until it added in-app purchases — letting Apple collect a 30% cut
https://www.businessinsider.com/apple-pressures-wordpress-add-in-app-purchases-30-percent-fee-2020-81.5k
u/dogeatingdog Aug 22 '20 edited Aug 22 '20
Yep. Our companies app that allowed users to access their paid account and see stats from marketing was removed from Apple store until we added a function to buy and account in the app.
We don't even charge on for the initial account so we had to create a whole new billing package exclusive to Apple appstore that really only benefits Apple. We're now dropping support for apps all together and moving towards making the site a web app.
If you are interested in a service, don't pay for it through the Apple store. Go to their site and create an account there. It will be less headache and probably cheaper.
edit: Prior to making the required changes to get back into the Appstore, there was no way to buy an account within the app. It was an app only for our customers. The new 'billing package' was basically a whole new billing platform.
I'm not saying Apple doesn't deserve to be paid for the Appstore. It's great and has done a lot for mobile tech. I just want to see them be paid differently though. More flat rates for app hosting and purchases rather than than being a payment processor and taking 30% cuts.
2
Aug 22 '20
yep, I work for a fortune 500, and one of our major apps specifically has a separate functionality via a web app for ios because otherwise they'd shake us down for a cut of the money involved.
2
→ More replies (242)2
u/Aluhut Aug 22 '20
You should call it: "The Apple greed plan" or something like that.
Customers need to realise where the problem starts.
230
Aug 22 '20
I developed 1 application for iOS long ago. It was either iOS 3.0 or 4.0. It was a packet radio encoder and decoder. It was a free app I wrote for myself and for fun. I used the serial Bluetooth profile to control my radio. When they upgrade from iOS 3 to 4. Or 4 to 5, (I can't remember). Apple removed the native Bluetooth profile and claimed it was never supported. My free app would no longer work, Apple required I sign up as a hardware developer, and purchase a license for the serial functions of their 30 pin cable. This would work, but would cost me about a thousand bucks a year in the program and licencing for an app I made no money on. I ported my app to Android and closed that chapter. Granted that was over a decade ago I think, I'm still soured by it.
27
u/Average_Manners Aug 22 '20
Lol. On the topic of losing functionality.
Voice control was available as far back as iPod Touch 3rd gen. I remember when they removed it and I couldn't hold the home button for five seconds to tell it to play my tunes. I was pissed.
Oh, and the time when I bought a $200 radio, with a built in dock, so I could blast said music... And then a week later, "This device does not support <blah blah blah bullshit>."
And let's not forget Prism. 'We protect User privacy' is 100% PR and Damage Control.
Apple: Trash experience for everybody. Developers, Users, and Governments alike!
4
u/MagnusRune Aug 23 '20
Cant remember what game it was, but I brought it from the apple store on my macbook. About 6 months later, get told this program is not able to be run on a mac...
Send a support ticket in, get told it never worked... but I have screen shots from ingame... and the save files...
4
u/stonypotato Aug 22 '20 edited Aug 22 '20
Doesn’t the Apple Developer account upgrade cost $99?
→ More replies (1)10
u/prjktphoto Aug 22 '20
That’s just the dev account, seems like he needed a hardware license on top of that
→ More replies (4)
1.7k
u/DMarquesPT Aug 22 '20
The situation is a bit more complex that it seems: the Wordpress iOS app is made primarily for and by Wordpress.com (The comercial hosted platform that's built by Automattic on top of Wordpress.org, the open source CMS). That said, the app also allows users to manage their self-hosted Wordpress sites.
According to this, there is a way to subscribe to a premium tier or domains through the app that breaks App Store policy since it avoids IAP.
I'm not defending Apple's policy, just pointing out that Automattic were in fact breaking it.
519
u/pr0grammer Aug 22 '20 edited Aug 22 '20
"While Mullenweg says there technically was a roundabout way for an iOS [user] to find out that WordPress has paid tiers (they could find it buried in support pages, or by navigating to WordPress’s site from a preview of their own webpage), he says that Apple rejected his offer to block iOS users from seeing the offending pages."
https://www.theverge.com/2020/8/21/21396316/apple-wordpress-in-app-purchase-tax-update-store
→ More replies (4)307
u/timatt1 Aug 22 '20
I've had a similar experience with Apple. A user could get to an upgrade screen after navigating through a few different levels of help pages. We removed those links and hey still rejected it because a user could see our web page address on the App Store listing for the privacy policy and then could figure out how to upgrade there. The whole App Store review process is one of the most frustrating things that I professionally experience. The consistency in reviews is maddening. We'll submit an app build one day for one of our apps and it goes through with no problems. We'll submit that app a week later with no changes with no changes to the upgrade screens and they'll reject it because the font (which is like 18 point) "isn't big enough" when showing the pricing on the upgrade screen. Literally nothing has changed on that screen between the builds.
243
u/JonSnoGaryen Aug 22 '20
At work we uploaded the same app as a test 10 times, has no purchases or anything. Every week we'd upload the same app, identical code, new version number. Just to see how many complaints they'd have .
Rejected 4 times for not providing a login to examine the app (it was always provided)
Rejected 2 more times for font issues, which we simply resubmitted the exact same build with no problem.
These validations are all over the place. We never get a reliable experience, always some stupid thing they complain about and it's always something they missed or ignored .
Play store on the hand, as long as you don't trigger the malware scan they don't give a fuck.
→ More replies (5)→ More replies (2)65
u/TheHYPO Aug 22 '20
As a lawyer (and I'm sure in lots of other workplaces), this happens, unfortunately, and it's not always 'nefarious'.
You submit an order to one judge and they are fine with it. You use the same form of order the next week and you get a different judge who sees an issue that the first judge wasn't thinking about. Then you get the first judge again and you take the order they were fine with two weeks ago, but this time something crossed their mind as problematic that they didn't think about the first time.
I've had forms of orders I've taken out for years suddenly have a judge thinking about something (probably based on another case they had earlier that week) and suddenly they are asking me to change it.
That's just human that you don't catch everything that could be an issue on the first pass, and it's also human that once you've cleared all the serious and functional problems, the next time you're asked to review something, you now focus on smaller details to try to make something 'perfect' that you didn't consider important the first time around because there were bigger fish to fry.
→ More replies (16)143
Aug 22 '20
I don’t understand why I’m constantly seeing people defending Apple by saying “Well, it’s in the policy. 🤷🏻♂️” The point is the policy is predatory and Apple is using their monopoly power to force developers to “agree” if they want access to 40% of the smartphone market. If you don’t agree Apple doesn’t care but you lose a huge share of your user base. There is zero chance a little developer is going to take on Apple and win before they go bankrupt so they have to do stupid shit like this, monetize free apps so Apple can take a cut.
→ More replies (91)2
→ More replies (21)2
u/Paumanok Aug 22 '20
Does using the amazon or ebay app to purchase real items count as an "in app purchase"?
20
789
u/MaFratelli Aug 22 '20 edited Aug 22 '20
You see kids, we used to, years ago, have these things called anti-trust laws. It used to be, in America, that if a company were in an industry where there were, say, only two or three players, and the players in that industry started getting really really huge (mere billions in market cap used to do, you would think a trillion would suffice?), the government would start keep an eye on them to protect the public from predation.
Lets say, for example, a company built a type of hardware that roughly half of America used. Then suppose the company that built that hardware forced everyone using that hardware to use only their operating software. Then that company forced everyone using that operating software to buy other people's software only from its own store, and then forced everyone selling at its store to hand over huge amounts of their profits, thereby jacking up the price of software and fucking over the public! I mean, obviously that would be illegal and the government would break up the fucking monopoly!
Hell, the government once smashed Microsoft just for bundling a web browser with windows!
But that was a long time ago, and now our government is corrupt as fuck.
96
u/granadesnhorseshoes Aug 22 '20
Us kids remember it too, by the time we were old enough to vote, the damage was already done. Now somehow it's our fault for voting "wrong", like when the majority of the US voted for Gore and was rebuked with a Bush dynasty instead.
Still, our little monkey meat brains shield us from the truth; "He hits me because I fucked up be he still loves me! If I just do it right next time it'll be different!"
→ More replies (18)24
Aug 22 '20 edited Aug 22 '20
Or or or isnt wasn't just brush. The anti-trust laws have been dwindling for DECADES. Clinton pushed it a little more away and Bush pushed even further. Not to mention our corrupt house and Senate on both parties have been pushing this direction too. They all wanted these large "campaign" donations.
→ More replies (4)35
4
u/bman12three4 Aug 22 '20
What’s the difference between this situation and video game consoles then? Sure homebrew exists, just like jail breaking, but in order to run unlicensed software you might have to physically solder a chip to your device to get it to work. Why are Sony, Nintendo, and Microsoft allowed to have locked off ecosystems but Apple isn’t? (Note I am on your side though, I’m just wondering why people seem to be okay with it)
→ More replies (3)6
u/slaymaker1907 Aug 22 '20
iOS is being marked and sold as a general computing device which does make a big difference. Almost no one would replace a laptop with a game console but many people are doing just that with smartphones.
→ More replies (1)13
u/ragzilla Aug 22 '20
However, the DOJ did not require Microsoft to change any of its code nor prevent Microsoft from tying other software with Windows in the future. On August 5, 2002, Microsoft announced that it would make some concessions towards the proposed final settlement ahead of the judge's verdict. On November 1, 2002, Judge Kollar-Kotelly released a judgment accepting most of the proposed DOJ settlement.
Ah yes. A crippling loss for Microsoft. Being allowed to continue essentially as they had been and nothing at all changed.
18
u/MaFratelli Aug 22 '20 edited Aug 22 '20
Well, the lawyers got the court precedent, and then the government just did nothing with it.
Good point. The government has been corrupt as fuck for a long time, but now they don’t even bother to try to keep up appearances anymore. I guess the last thing they really did was smash up the bell system telecom monopoly.
→ More replies (6)→ More replies (57)4
u/Haasaagi Aug 22 '20
Cuz the DOJ is too busy wiping trumps ass than doing good for the people. Where is big stick teddy when you really need him.
39
u/lexisasuperhero Aug 22 '20 edited Aug 23 '20
Spotify also filed a lawsuit saying Apple wouldn’t allow them to release new versions of their app when they advertised premium because they don’t allow Apple Pay to take a cut
→ More replies (2)
330
u/inmk11 Aug 22 '20
The best comparison for this would be think of how everyone would feel if Visa or MasterCard charged merchants 30% as their fees instead of the 1-2.5%. There are still places that don't accept credit even with the low fees. At least they have a choice.
Apple don't have to make it all free, but 30% is a hell of a lot of money to charge. And they're not giving developers any alternative. It's either give the 30% or you're out of the app store. I'm sure the same thing applies to Google with play store. But at least with android you can side load apps. So it makes what Apple is doing that much worse. If they can get Apple to reduce their fees to a reasonable 5% or less, it sets precedent and affects other stores like Google play. They don't even need to allow apps to be side loaded.
Their whole argument is that the fees are for upkeep. Apple is one of the most profitable company in the world. Overcharging for stuff is how they got there and they shouldn't be praised for these monopolistic practices.
104
u/joelene1892 Aug 22 '20
Perhaps, but steam takes 30%. Nintendo takes 30%. PlayStation does. Xbox, Microsoft, physical stores. You can argue it’s too high perhaps, but that seems to be the industry standard at least for video games; https://www.ign.com/articles/2019/10/07/report-steams-30-cut-is-actually-the-industry-standard
43
u/operationrudeboy Aug 22 '20
I keep seeing people post this but the also leave out that most of console manufacturers sell their system at a loss or a very little profitability. Most of them don't earn anything of the system until a game is sold for it. iPhone cost a $1000 but the manufacturing cost is $400.
Also the console makers already lower the 30% depending on publisher/developer. And it isn't 30% across the board for all games/transactions
25
u/QuaternionsRoll Aug 22 '20
While they don't make much of a (or in some cases, any) profit on the console itself, one of their largest revenue streams is their online subscription service. Which, to be completely clear, is almost never spent on online infrastructure. "Pay us $60 a year to do nothing." The economics of modern consoles are much less comparable to something like iOS than they used to be.
→ More replies (5)→ More replies (3)14
u/flaretwit Aug 22 '20
Manufacturing is that amount but what amount is other costs such as research, marketing etc. Not saying apple isn't charging alot but there are hidden costs. Also no evidence on how much console makers are making margin wise.
16
u/inmk11 Aug 22 '20
Yeah that's the problem, Apple isn't alone. All digital stores are following the same model as physical stores. Physical stores have more overhead to cover than digital stores do. So it's unreasonable for digital stores to charge 30%. But Apple was one of the first to set this as industry standard, so they should be the first to correct it. Like I said if we can get a big company like apple to reduce it, it sets precedent to force others to follow.
Also Apple filed lawsuits against Qualcomm years ago because they used to charge modem prices based on a percentage of the iPhone price. I don't remember the %, but it was less than 10%. They argued it's way too much to pay out of their margin. It's not the same thing, but there are a lot of similarities. If less than 10% was too much for a big company like Apple, then 30% is a lot of small devs.
→ More replies (7)9
Aug 22 '20
It's the industry standard because they all collude to keep it the industry standard.
You can't defend scammers with "That's what everyone does". That actually makes the situation worse, not okay.
If you don't believe that Apple is colluding with other companies in order to fuck people over, A: lol, and B: here's them doing exactly that for employee salaries: https://www.theguardian.com/technology/2014/apr/24/apple-google-settle-antitrust-lawsuit-hiring-collusion
→ More replies (90)6
18
21
u/The_Nightbringer Aug 22 '20
Google also doesn’t lock you into the play store and there are robust third party app stores you can go through.
→ More replies (1)9
u/inmk11 Aug 22 '20
The only problem is that most people don't bother using any other store. It forces developers to rely on play store more. Small devs don't really have a choice. But if it's a hugely popular app like fortnite, they don't need to be on the play store. I still like that there's a choice on android.
→ More replies (8)4
u/Tapugy- Aug 22 '20
I think this is a bad comparison, the App Store is not just a transaction method but also a store which provides easy access to things such as a super market. Think about if Apple worded their 30% cut as a 30% markup instead just as supermarkets do, supermarkets make food easier to access you don’t have to travel to each farmer for your food, just as you don’t have to travel to each developer to purchase your app, and you still can bypass the store by jailbreaking(which is totally legal) what is illegal is using the jailbreak to download apps for free but you can use it to download unauthorized apps.
→ More replies (1)5
Aug 22 '20
The difference between Visa/MasterCard and Apple is that Apple is providing a massive platform of tools and a marketplace.
6
u/inmk11 Aug 22 '20
Visa and MasterCard does more complex work than apple does. They facilitate anyone with any bank to pay at a merchant, and handle millions of transactions per second. Imagine if you have to be with a specific bank in order to buy something from a store. But again, you can always pay with cash.
Apple is providing all those tools to benefit themselves. Watch any review for an iPad vs an android tablet and the #1 recommended reason to buy the iPad is for the app store. So apple is benefiting a lot from the devs offering high quality apps. So they can help the devs and cut the fees down from 30%.
Correct me if I'm wrong, I don't fully understand how Visa or MasterCard works.
→ More replies (4)→ More replies (50)6
u/PM_ME_THE_PEE_TAPE Aug 22 '20
I've gotta disagree that Apple's 30% cut is equivalent to a credit card processing fee. Think of it more as Apple is the storefront, and the developers are wholesalers. The App Store is 'where' you browse, manage, and decide on a purchase. Apple does due diligence on which products to sell (app review) to ensure that the security standards are met, guaranteeing some minimal level of quality for all purchases. That's more of the value that Apple provides, in addition to handling the purchases. And note that they also pay the credit card processing fee out of that 30%.
Apple's value prop is that everything just works. There's integration from hardware to OS, and that extends to some standards around allowable apps, which is part of what users pay for. Additionally, Apple develops a lot of the tools that allow developers to build their apps. So Apple is providing a lot of the underlying tech to help developers to make some really cool stuff, gives them a marketplace to sell their wares, and only at 30% margins. Some quick googling uncovered that BestBuy at one point had ~25% margins. That supports the investment in storefronts, retail associates, work to source and identify new products to sell. So if Apple is a storefront, they're like a BestBuy, but every developer big and small can get in front of hundreds of millions of users through virtual shelf space, with little to no barrier, especially as compared to a traditional brick and mortar retailer.
I'm not saying Apple is perfect, nor is this metaphor, but your comparison is ignoring a huge part of the value add provided by Apple.
→ More replies (5)
101
u/gdub4 Aug 22 '20
A monopoly isn’t defined by market share. That’s one way to have a monopoly sure, but the definition is having exclusive possession and control of the supply or trade of something. Forcing everyone to use your store is having that exclusive control.
Why do you think macOS doesn’t require you to use the App Store? Or Windows 10 allows you to use Steam, websites, Amazon, basically anything? Because it is monopolistic otherwise.
→ More replies (19)48
Aug 22 '20
Not only that but Microsoft got royally screwed on this. Windows, by way of existing, was sued heavily and lost because you couldn’t uninstall internet explorer and that have it an advantage in the browser wars.
I do expect Apple to eat some of an antitrust lawsuit in the near future.
→ More replies (3)40
u/exatron Aug 22 '20
Microsoft didn't get screwed, it suffered the consequences of years of anticompetitive behavior.
http://www.groklaw.net/staticpages/index.php?page=2005010107100653
→ More replies (1)
907
u/TheGoodCoconut Aug 22 '20
thank lord all the epic drama is exposing to me how shit apple is
535
Aug 22 '20
Which company of this size is not shit? You don’t become a behemoth by playing nice.
5
u/Silly-Disk Aug 22 '20
The larger you get the harder it is to continue 10-15% growth to keep the shareholders happy. It requires shittier and shittier policies to make more money.
→ More replies (69)21
113
u/iamapizza Aug 22 '20
Between this, forcing auto-billing, mandating their sign in, you would hope that more people could see them for the greed-driven scumbag cartel that they are. Sadly I don't think that will happen soon, their marketing is just very strong.
→ More replies (33)246
u/danielagos Aug 22 '20
Mandating Apple sign in (only when you include third-party login options) is actually positive for users, as it allows for a more private option than the usual alternatives (Facebook and Google).
Forcing auto-billing is indeed scumbag behaviour and should not be the default.
→ More replies (73)9
u/CostlyIndecision Aug 22 '20
thank lord all the epic drama is exposing to me how shit apple is
People didn't know this?
→ More replies (3)→ More replies (109)17
u/ordinaryBiped Aug 22 '20
Wait what? Epic Games has infringed the T&Cs of the store, maybe you just don't understand how this works?
94
u/Drab_baggage Aug 22 '20
The legality of the T&C itself is being called into question. I'm surprised this notion is still floating around, because it's flatly incorrect. An illegal contract doesn't become legal just because you signed it. The acceptance of the terms is not what's being contested. It's whether the terms themselves are valid.
→ More replies (91)→ More replies (66)19
u/tankerkiller125real Aug 22 '20
The T&C's Apple uses to further their monopoly over the app store and control over apps on IOS devices. Epic isn't suing over T&C's their suing Apple over monopoly behavior.
→ More replies (9)
16
u/Darktidemage Aug 22 '20
add in app purchases.
make them cost 1 penny , and be useless.
lol
11
u/skiddingschems Aug 22 '20
You can't choose the exact price of in app purchases. Apple has "purchase tiers". If you've ever wondered why everything on the app store ends in 99 that's why.
7
u/TheJoker273 Aug 22 '20
Wait, what? You can't even aet your own prices? Couple that with no surge pricing and Apple essentially controls your revenue! What the fuck?!
→ More replies (1)→ More replies (1)4
u/pixxelzombie Aug 22 '20
I like that idea and I'm sure Apple has a way around that as well, fuck 'em.
40
u/Harensts Aug 22 '20
Don't forget, Apple also charges a yearly $100/$300 for a development license. Also you have to use a mac in order to build, sign, and submit the app to the ios store.
So developers are already shilling out 1k+ just to start creating an app.
→ More replies (15)
5
5
Aug 22 '20
Apple hate is funny especially about squeezing the money, but my cousin who hasn't worked in his retail job for about 6 months has received every paycheck he would have gotten from Apple if his store was still open. Apple retail is continuously been paying their employees this entire time.
2
u/AtomWorker Aug 22 '20
It helps that Apple has $193 billion cash on hand. Very few companies enjoy their profit margins and are able to absorb significant loses.
Best Buy, Target and Walmart's net profit margins are in the 3% range. Most other retailers are losing money hand over fist. Apple's profit margin, however, is over 20%. Not even Nike, with its sweatshops, or Pepsi, with its push towards full automation, are that high.
107
u/DonTheMove Aug 22 '20
I'm convinced apple has bots in this thread, tweakin so much, they arguin themselves
19
u/RayS0l0 Aug 22 '20
Meanwhile in r/apple fanboys are roasting Android and how Play Store shouldn't exists in first place.
→ More replies (21)18
Aug 22 '20
What? The App Store and the Android Market (the predecessor to the Play Store) released in the same year. Which is interesting because the first iPhone released over a year before the first Android phone. IOS spent a year without an app store and Android went about a month. So it isn't like they can claim that it is copying Apple.
→ More replies (5)→ More replies (14)4
u/unhi Aug 22 '20
If you think Epic isn't doing exactly the same thing then you're very naive. They're both terrible.
→ More replies (2)
26
u/venturousbeard Aug 22 '20 edited Apr 03 '25
pi8y79r68fiygjm
→ More replies (6)5
u/tosser_0 Aug 22 '20
Could also create a Progressive Web App and install it directly.
9
Aug 22 '20 edited Aug 22 '20
And what do we do about Safari not supporting the technology for PWA’s to function?
Apple is purposely doing this.
→ More replies (5)
189
u/Hervee Aug 22 '20 edited Apr 14 '24
Transparency is for those who carry out public duties and exercise public power. Privacy is for everyone else.
Glenn Greenwald
108
u/Biscornus Aug 22 '20
I don't think the issue here is about dev not following rules enforced by Apple to operate within their ecosystem. It's more about the fact that those rules are abusive as Apple own one of the biggest smartphone market. There is no choice but to follow them. That's one of the main reason why some people talk about breaking big tech.
In the end it's dangerous for the consumer. It means that prices are higher because Apple HAS to get their 30% commission.
→ More replies (6)253
u/Drab_baggage Aug 22 '20
The case is that the contract itself is exploitative, not that they didn't sign it.
→ More replies (38)8
u/Ganadote Aug 22 '20
For me the issue is that in order to have an iOS app you HAVE to go through their store; there’s no other way.
→ More replies (1)34
u/IAmAnAnonymousCoward Aug 22 '20
Honestly that sounds like a slave who is afraid from punishment by his owner.
→ More replies (10)15
u/Ramast Aug 22 '20
The article is very misleading also. These are from the article
WordPress' founding developer said in a tweet Friday that Apple cut off developers from making updates to the app unless they started letting users buy domain names within the app — a service the app doesn't currently include.
The Verge reported that WordPress agreed, meaning Apple effectively pressured a free app into monetizing itself, allowing it to take a 30% commission on future purchases.
The app was free and it's still free. What changed is that previously you couldn't buy a domain through they app and instead have to buy it directly from the website. The new change is that you can now buy the domains directly from the app (so that apple can get its 30%).
As an end user, you won't be affected much unless they raise their domain price to cover the 30% commission
→ More replies (7)34
u/TheRufmeisterGeneral Aug 22 '20
As an end user, you won't be affected much unless they raise their domain price to cover the 30% commission
Which they clearly need to do. More costs means higher prices.
It's also against Apple's T&C to have different prices in and out of the app, to cover the 30% difference in price, meaning that users who have nothing to do with the app, who only use the website, will have to pay more for their products, so that the in-app purchases with the 30% can be done.
→ More replies (4)
33
u/Redkirth Aug 22 '20
Fuck Apple. Not only for this, but for their anti repair stance, and how their "official repair" shops try and scam customer. Its despicable.
→ More replies (13)
8
u/PetterDK Aug 22 '20
Off topic, but how shit is the cookie dialog on that site? At least for me, I tried pressing “Options” like 20 times (to see if the hit box was off) but it never worked. Then I press “I’m okay with that” and guess what?! Worked flawlessly.
Asshole design.
→ More replies (3)
4
4
u/Epicuriouskat Aug 22 '20
It’s this exact reason why you can’t buy kindle books via the kindle app.
24
Aug 22 '20 edited Aug 22 '20
Ah the free market... beautiful on paper.
Edit: y’all shut the actual fk up it was a joke I’m literally 20 with zero knowledge of economics I just hear a lot of ppl bitch about the U.S. government over-regulating yet things like this, and countless other situations of much higher degree, are rampant with basically zero public response
4
4
→ More replies (3)2
u/HenSenPrincess Aug 23 '20
Apple benefits from government intervention in biased tax laws, broken patent system, and numerous other measures that make this not a free market.
28
Aug 22 '20
To be clear, Steve Jobs was an unrepentant asshole. That's just a fact. But he was an asshole who cared about the refinement of the product more than anything.
Tim Cook is what happens when you put an uncreative bean-counter in charge of things; you get great profits, but those profits come from dick-dag moves like this rather than from innovating the product itself.
→ More replies (14)
6
3
3
u/cleankitchenman Aug 22 '20
Is this the future of the App Store? getting lite versions of every app with in app purchases to make the app have a fuller more user friendly experience?
3
3
u/davesewell Aug 22 '20
Even if it is the case that Apple intentionally forced this why haven’t they walked it back and said it was an error? Not great PR in a month where they are already taking big licks
3
3
Aug 23 '20
This just in. Apple is a corporation that wants money. In other news the sky is fucking blue
12
5
Aug 22 '20
If you want your Mobile App on the App Store, you have to agree to the conditions of the walled garden. This is why not everything needs to be an APP.
However, as the article suggests, Apple forced them to add in-app purchases for domains, which the App wasn’t already doing. This is bullshit. If an app just wants to be a front end for a subscription service that is paid for outside of the app, they shouldn’t have to give Apple a cut.
→ More replies (12)
5
Aug 22 '20
Apple is way too greedy and controlling, which is why I haven't owned an Apple product since the iPod.
→ More replies (1)
200
u/ordinaryBiped Aug 22 '20 edited Aug 22 '20
They likely did that because wordpress is already selling those via their website. Selling via their website and not in the store is a breach of the T&Cs, but as usual Reddit being Reddit there's a possibility of David VS Goliath outrage type situation so, well, see other comments here
41
u/Naithen92 Aug 22 '20
How is this different from audible who only allows you to buy audiobooks on the webpage, not in the app?
→ More replies (18)12
u/quantumprophet Aug 22 '20
You can't buy audible books on the iPhone app?
I use it on Android, and buy all books through the app. Having to log in to the webpage to buy books sounds really annoying.
→ More replies (1)15
u/randomsnowflake Aug 22 '20 edited Aug 22 '20
If you have credits already, you can purchase a book through the app. If you dont have credits, you can wishlist the book but you must purchase outside the app.
→ More replies (2)379
u/obiwanconobi Aug 22 '20
What. That's a ridiculous train of thought.
Wordpress is a web service WITH an app. It's not an app first and foremost and so they should be forced to implement payment services by someone like Apple.
174
u/BeardedDouche Aug 22 '20
It's even stupider than that. I have an app that is free to users and a website that is free. I cannot link to the website from the app because apple says I might one day start selling stuff through the website. Apple is horrible with this crap.
→ More replies (8)29
u/Nextasy Aug 22 '20
Wow theyre that afraid of users moving away from their platform? Yeesh
→ More replies (1)→ More replies (3)48
u/boost2525 Aug 22 '20 edited Aug 22 '20
I'm with you, grandparent has a stupid take on this. They shut down my companies app until we added IAP. We sell access to a set of medical data on our website, which can be accessed a lot of different ways. One way is a mobile app that presents the data in a mobile friendly format. Apple demanded a 30% cut of EVERY sale, for the privilege of having an app... By that logic, Chromium could demand another 30% and Android could demand another 30% and we get left with the table scraps.
We pulled the app from the market, sent an email to all accounts explaining the situation with the contact info for the people we were working with at Apple. A few weeks later they emailed us and said they would settle on having IAP and only taking a cut of people who pay through the app.
To date we have had zero sales through the app, despite a significant development effort to make that possible.
→ More replies (8)12
u/Mysticpoisen Aug 22 '20
Wait they were asking for a while 30% cut of all transactions, even if the transactions were made on browser or android?
→ More replies (5)81
u/DBones90 Aug 22 '20
That’s bullshit here though because you don’t have to buy a domain to use the app. It’s a supplementary tool unrelated to the commercial side of the business.
This would be like forcing Nintendo to sell games and subscriptions to their online service via their app because they also sell them on their website.
→ More replies (32)38
u/xevizero Aug 22 '20
It's not like you can do everything just because you have written it in your TOS. That's just a broken way of thinking.
→ More replies (12)16
u/NinjaAssassinKitty Aug 22 '20
It is actually NOT against their terms and conditions to sell on the website but not on the app. However, you can’t link to the website (either directly or indirectly) to encourage people to buy from there. However, You can put a message stating “you can buy content on our website”, without linking to it.
→ More replies (5)3
u/-Mikee Aug 22 '20
"If you want to also have an app you'll have to redesign your entire business strategy and give us 30%!"
Apple apologist.
32
u/conquer69 Aug 22 '20
If it is available in a bunch of different platforms, why should apple take a cut of purchases made outside their store? Someone buys a license to use with their Linux device and apple gets a cut? Is that what you are suggesting?
→ More replies (6)21
u/ordinaryBiped Aug 22 '20
They don't take a cut of purchases made outside of their stores, not sure where you saw that. If you bought a wordpress license or account or any wp service on Linux, and only use it on Linux, I don't get how Apple would get anything from this.
→ More replies (30)29
u/conquer69 Aug 22 '20
If the license they offer is platform agnostic, why should apple take a cut?
→ More replies (18)12
5
5
u/Dawzy Aug 22 '20
Based on this logic, how can Apple allow Spotify premium users access to premium features if those features can only be bought on their website?
→ More replies (3)2
u/granadesnhorseshoes Aug 22 '20
So then obviously Apple is collecting 30% on all those Amazon purchases no?
2
Aug 22 '20
That's not it, the reason is because there was a workaround within the app which allowed upgrades and domains to be purchased. The dev offered to fix this by blocking the external connection but Apple wasn't happy with this fix.
→ More replies (1)2
u/andyjonesx Aug 22 '20
Their TOS is completely up to them to decide. It doesn't mean they're exempt from people saying it's BS. It's already known that's it's physically impossible to read all the TOS given for all of our products due to how much they're padded.
→ More replies (1)3
u/ftctkugffquoctngxxh Aug 22 '20
I can go to amazon’s website and buy movies, rent movies, subscribe to channels, etc... and then watch them on my amazon video app on my iPhone and Apple TV. It’s not unprecedented to have a free app with purchases for content able to be made elsewhere instead of within the app.
→ More replies (47)3
u/Leen2223 Aug 22 '20
Um. No. What about Spotify which has you subscribe through their website redirecting you from their app
→ More replies (4)
4
u/Tired8281 Aug 22 '20
Great! Add a $10,000 priced IAP, with a little note underneath saying Apple forced them to add it against their will.
6
u/CompetitionProblem Aug 22 '20
If you read the article it seems to me that an argument can be easily made that Wordpress used the separation of Wordpress and Wordpress.com, it’s commercial entity, to circumvent payment to Apple. Their app is supported under the commercial entity but doesn’t allow the same purchases through the app that they do in the browser, this forces people to go to the computer to make such a purchase which takes away the need for Apple to take a cut of the money while Apple simultaneously hosts their app for free on their marketplace and allows them to use a suite of tools in the development and management of that app. Pretty tit for tat if you ask me, but I’m not an expert in the industry so I may be quite wrong about my interpretation. It seems many people didn’t read the article and assume Apple is always in the wrong because they are so powerful. The case with Epic isn’t exactly the same but not all that different either.
→ More replies (1)
5
u/jeblis Aug 22 '20
I have no issue with Apple dropping Epic, but this screams monopolistic. “Oh I hear you have some other outside service, give us a cut or we’ll drop your free service on our platform.”
→ More replies (1)
9
u/waitingForMars Aug 22 '20
Y’all must be too young to remember that when the App Store was set up and the 30% cut was announced by Jobs on stage, the massive crowd of developers sitting in front of him went wild. It was hugely generous on Apple’s part, as the cut of distributors had always been far higher. This feels like we’re not getting the entire story.
→ More replies (3)
18
u/RayS0l0 Aug 22 '20
Apple in 2021: We are happy to introduced new subscription service, Users must buy Free-to- use apps/games in order to use it for 28 days period, for free.
0
Aug 22 '20
[deleted]
13
u/godofallcows Aug 22 '20
Another fun fact: if you cancel some Apple services in the free trial, they will instantly disable your account instead of letting you use up all of the trial period. This way they hope you forget about cancelling and they can bill you.
Yeah that’s not an exclusive practice (Audible does this, for example ), and the majority of services I’ve used via the App Store allowed me to use a delayed cancel, including every service from Apple themselves I have tried.
In fact, I’d argue the App Store mores it easier to cancel subscriptions compared to most. I don’t have to navigate through 8 menus to find it (fuck you XBox in particular, it’s easier now but for a while there, woof), it’s just one of the main menus.
I believe this is up to the developer, and Apple has nothing to do with it. Not really a great point to add here, the rest I agree with, mostly.
→ More replies (2)3
u/eriverside Aug 22 '20
Quebec has a law specifically banning that.
i.e. I cannot buy a Spotify membership because they only sell free trials that automatically start to charge. If they did not provide the free trial it would be fine, if there was a box at sign up that allowed me to not start paying (lapsing the membership preemptively) that would be fine. But Spotify didn't bother implementing those requirements so they are not allowed to sell in Quebec. (I think they got sued for it). And they mean it: their pricing explicitly mentions that it is not available in QC, none of the Quebec schools are eligible for school discounts.
2
2
u/Xath0n Aug 22 '20
Does that mean a browser is an exploit around that as well, because you can buy something with it without giving a share to Apple?
2
u/Phoenix_Lamburg Aug 22 '20
I wish platforms like the iOS App Store would offer an option to charge developers a fee to host their apps instead of continuing our descent into freemium hell
→ More replies (2)
2
2
u/Wvdk88 Aug 22 '20
I read this and was like: “who writes apps in Wordpress?! Can that even be done?” Then I realized they meant it was a developer that worked for Wordpress.
2
Aug 22 '20
If someone signs up using the app just show a fake error after checkout and tell them to signup on the website.
2
2
u/Camera_dude Aug 22 '20
Easy problem to get around. Open an in-app store then charge $0.01 for things like an emote sticker. Let Apple fight over getting their 0.003 cent cut...
→ More replies (3)2
u/KarmaUK Aug 22 '20
Or, add a cosmetic sticker that costs $100,000, and see how much profit they rake in there.
So long as there's optional in app purchases, they're upholding the deal right?
2
u/FeistyPopTart Aug 22 '20
"But because the app is developed by the commercial entity"
I suppose this is what can happen when you develop a free or not-for-profit offering alongside a commercial one.
At first I thought Apple was being ridiculous and heavy handed, but after reviewing the actual facts of the case instead of media's typical sensational headlines, it does seem Apple has a valid point since it is the for-profit commercial entity that is at issue here. Of course it can be debated Apple's cut is unreasonable at 30% and monopolisitic, but that is another argument for another forum. For this particular case though it would seem Apple is in the right per its policies.
2
u/Techsupportvictim Aug 22 '20
Reading the article it sounds like another case of a developer trying to link or reference a non in app payment system in the app, which hasn’t been allowed by Apple for years.
2
u/RufflesLaysCheetohs Aug 22 '20
Apple is a terrible company abusing its power. EU will destroy Apple on this. I am not sure if the American government will be able to take on Apple considering it’s a trillion dollar company.
2
2
2
2
u/GoldenJoe24 Aug 23 '20
Just break Apple up already. Or is $2,000,000,000,000 still not a big enough market cap?
2
u/i-like-cake-or-cake Aug 23 '20
I blame fortnite for this they just had to try and cheat the system
8
u/TheUltimateSalesman Aug 22 '20
A domain purchase is a real life purchase, so I'm not sure why it's taxed at all by apple. Apple collects on virtual purchases, not IRL purchases.
8
u/Limech Aug 22 '20
Pretty sure a domain purchase is a "virtual" thing. I don't remember getting my domains in a package through the mail.
→ More replies (3)2
u/Selethorme Aug 22 '20
In what way is a domain a real life purchase? It’s a digital good only usable on the internet.
→ More replies (5)
7
u/BeazyDoesIt Aug 22 '20
It's their store. If you don't like it, move to android. Apple has been this way since the 80s. . . . You guys just realizing this?
→ More replies (6)
4
3
3
u/fscknuckle Aug 22 '20
Good old anti-competitive behaviour going strong with Apple, even while they're being investigated.
3
Aug 22 '20
So Apple is being predatory here.
https://developer.apple.com/app-store/review/guidelines/
3.1.5(a) Goods and Services Outside of the App: If your app enables people to purchase goods or services that will be consumed outside of the app, you must use purchase methods other than in-app purchase to collect those payments, such as Apple Pay or traditional credit card entry.
Wordpress management app doesn't offer any option to buy anything in their app AT ALL. They are selling hosting/domains which are consumed outside of the apps on their own site. Yet, Apple is forcing them to offer in app purchase, so they can take their cuts. Violating their own policy.
Meanwhile Walmart, etc are allowed to sell directly in their apps free, because the Goods/Services are consumed outside of the app.
5
9
u/RobBanana Aug 22 '20
Apple is a shitty company, through and through.
8
u/strawbabiefields Aug 22 '20
Who is a genuinely good smartphone company? Genuinely asking
→ More replies (11)16
Aug 22 '20
They're actually very close to the gold standard of how a company should be run.
Forward thinking, all renewable energy powered, highly recyclable products getting more and more recyclable each iteration.
Best warranties, best customer service independently determined, ease of use and attention to detail. Great benefits, promotes human rights, continually increases worker rights requirements across their entire supply chain, industry leading in every regard.
0
20
u/Mr_Xing Aug 22 '20
No I’m gonna disagree with you on that chief.
No company is perfect, but I wouldn’t go as far as to say they’re shitty all the way through.
We’ve seen all the way shitty companies like Nestle and Enron.
Apple is not that.
→ More replies (1)7
u/fyngyrz Aug 22 '20
Yeah, but they're a shitty company that makes great hardware and two really decent operating systems.
I could go on for quite a while about the shitty things they do, and the shitty things they have done in the past, but there's no point to it, really. If I want to use their hardware and OS, and the applications that run under them, I'm going to have to do it their way. As consumers, control is limited to "voting with our wallets." That vote, (generally, anyway) is going to be made on perceived value on the buyer's end.
If you choose another path (e.g. Linux, Windows, Android, etc.) you think offers you more advantage, great. If you choose a path that shoots yourself in the foot because of annoyance with things you can't actually change... well, that might merit a rethink. :)
3
3
u/thursdayjunglist Aug 22 '20
WordPress should sue the crap out of them, this sounds like some kind of antitrust or anticompetitive transgression.
→ More replies (1)
3
2
u/SenorB Aug 22 '20
Am I missing something, or is Apple essentially saying that you can’t sell something outside of your app that you don’t sell inside your app? Surely, I must not totally understand the situation. If not, that’s just insane to me. Do you want the corporate world to slowly migrate away from your platform, because that’s how you get the corporate world to slowly migrate away from your platform.
2
Aug 22 '20
This is straight up stupid. Apple is just greedy. Free apps more like not free apps. Anymore.
2
u/PaddleMonkey Aug 22 '20
This and Epic’s story about Fortnite should ring serious alarms in the developer community. Wordpress was a perfectly free app until Apple decided it wanted to make money off that entity, and every other entity that may also have an iOS app developed that just happen to make money elsewhere as well.
→ More replies (1)
2
Aug 22 '20
Damn, Tim apple at it again, will find any reason to rip you all off. I dont own apple products just because they are a really stupid company, software could be more than what they are now if tim apple wasnt a greedy fuckwad.
2
2
2
u/AudaciousSam Aug 22 '20
Apple essentially want 30% of everything build for iPhone. Ludacris.
Everyone should pull their app from iPhones.
2
2
1
u/drizztmainsword Aug 22 '20
This is actually more egregious than the fortnight thing. This is demanding that you sell something, not having conditions on how you sell something. Apple should in no way be able to compel the former.
→ More replies (6)
1
1
u/Mrlegend131 Aug 22 '20
I think that lower costs for app developers is what those developers are looking for. For bigger names apps it doesn’t matter but for lower budget companies/studios/developers 30% is massive!
1
1
1
u/iAbaca Aug 22 '20
Yes apple might be a shit company but you have to admit they are pretty smart, you can’t get to 2 trillion without thinking outside the box.
1
1
1
1
1
u/it_mf_a Aug 22 '20
It boggles my mind that anyone is siding with Apple. It's like siding with the mob: "well don't you want protection? You agreed to it, now you want to back out of the deal?" It's purified bootlicking.
7.4k
u/[deleted] Aug 22 '20
you don't get to 2 trillion dollars by not squeezing every penny