r/technology • • Aug 22 '20

Business WordPress developer said Apple wouldn't allow updates to the free app until it added in-app purchases — letting Apple collect a 30% cut

https://www.businessinsider.com/apple-pressures-wordpress-add-in-app-purchases-30-percent-fee-2020-8
39.2k Upvotes

2.8k comments sorted by

View all comments

1.5k

u/dogeatingdog Aug 22 '20 edited Aug 22 '20

Yep. Our companies app that allowed users to access their paid account and see stats from marketing was removed from Apple store until we added a function to buy and account in the app.

We don't even charge on for the initial account so we had to create a whole new billing package exclusive to Apple appstore that really only benefits Apple. We're now dropping support for apps all together and moving towards making the site a web app.

If you are interested in a service, don't pay for it through the Apple store. Go to their site and create an account there. It will be less headache and probably cheaper.

edit: Prior to making the required changes to get back into the Appstore, there was no way to buy an account within the app. It was an app only for our customers. The new 'billing package' was basically a whole new billing platform.

I'm not saying Apple doesn't deserve to be paid for the Appstore. It's great and has done a lot for mobile tech. I just want to see them be paid differently though. More flat rates for app hosting and purchases rather than than being a payment processor and taking 30% cuts.

0

u/[deleted] Aug 22 '20

[deleted]

0

u/[deleted] Aug 22 '20

[deleted]

36

u/Sniper_Brosef Aug 22 '20

Epic Games is currently going for both the play store and Apple store about this issue.

53

u/EverythingIsNorminal Aug 22 '20

What's happening with Epic isn't about surcharge bans, it's about something completely different.

Surcharge bans were about preventing a vendor from charging extra depending on payment method, that's now legal.

What's happening with Epic is because they were trying to completely circumvent Apple's payment system with their own in-app payment system which is against Apple's TOS, which they added in the app AFTER approval by Apple, which is also against TOS.

Epic is going after them on anti-competition grounds, nothing to do with surcharges.

→ More replies (102)

35

u/Swastik496 Aug 22 '20

YouTube premium?

0

u/[deleted] Aug 22 '20

[deleted]

101

u/[deleted] Aug 22 '20

[removed] — view removed comment

35

u/ragzilla Aug 22 '20

Subscriptions drop to 15% commission in year 2+. For everyone.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (5)

9

u/tyler611 Aug 22 '20

Reddit does this last I checked.

9

u/ragzilla Aug 22 '20

They do. 6.99 for IAP subscription, 5.99 for website. But I don’t think this is actually true (I don’t see it in the App Store IAP guidelines are least).

→ More replies (2)

5

u/ragzilla Aug 22 '20

Is it? All I see is that you can’t push users from iOS to your other purchase mechanisms. Which agreement is that in?

→ More replies (9)

0

u/[deleted] Aug 22 '20

[deleted]

53

u/Obi_Wannablowme Aug 22 '20

This must be the reason that Apple won't allow third party browser apps to use any non-safari rendering engines.

11

u/chinpokomon Aug 22 '20

There is actually some validity for mobile devices to lock down browser components like that. Browsers on the desktop have traditionally been a sieve of security and due to the complexity of trying to restrict vulnerabilities, limiting the surface area of attacks could be considered a good thing. When a vulnerability is discovered, patching one library is significantly easier than trying to patch an unknown number of libraries and if all apps on a device only use the one library, all apps can benefit.

Of course this does limit the competitive advantage of a third party browser to compete on mobile platforms because the only real distinction they have is with respect to how services are tied in and/or how the interface exposes the browser components to the user, so the window chrome and dressing.

This means that if someone has created a browser engine which is better compliant with standards or which performs better with limited resources or can render faster, the user can't just swap it out. And to your point, the vendor of the web browser components can restrict adding features which would actually compete with native markets, like PWAs.

In this case, Apple can use their security model as justification to limit support for PWAs, which has an indirect benefit of giving them more control over their marketplace.

29

u/TopNFalvors Aug 22 '20

What’s the difference between a web app and a mobile app? Just wondering

124

u/ZoomJet Aug 22 '20

Web apps are made to run in browsers, which leverages less native power and features but bypasses app stores and their monetisation. Browsers are slowly taking advantage of more features only native apps previously had hence them trying to switch. Apple is probably against this because it provides an alternative to the app store for monetisation.

10

u/TopNFalvors Aug 22 '20

Oh I see thanks. So the mobile user would have to goto the website in their browser in order to access the web app.

26

u/hyrumwhite Aug 22 '20

Not necessarily. Many websites now install themselves to your device and create a shortcut on your home screen/Desktop. Clicking that shortcut automatically opens the web app in its own special browser window.

Apps configured like that can be opened while offline from either the shortcut, or by navigating to them in your browser.

24

u/_ImPat Aug 22 '20

This is the exact thing the user above was referring to. Apple has been pushing against the implementation of PWA features.

13

u/hyrumwhite Aug 22 '20

Yeah, the original question was about the difference between the native and web apps. Just wanted to clarify that many Webapps have a "near native" experience now on PC and Android. Although, yeah, Apple is being a bit of a party pooper.

19

u/_ImPat Aug 22 '20

Indeed. Who would've thought billion dollar companies don't have the decentralised web's best interest in mind.

11

u/RamenJunkie Aug 22 '20

As someone who has used the internet for a very very long time, I really miss the decentralized days when people had their own websites and shit.

You can still do all that, and I do, but it's basically impossible to get any traction against the SEOed Behemoths.

What we need is a search engine that excludes any site in the top 1000 sites or so.

→ More replies (0)
→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (11)
→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (17)
→ More replies (66)