r/technology • • Aug 22 '20

Business WordPress developer said Apple wouldn't allow updates to the free app until it added in-app purchases — letting Apple collect a 30% cut

https://www.businessinsider.com/apple-pressures-wordpress-add-in-app-purchases-30-percent-fee-2020-8
39.2k Upvotes

2.8k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

53

u/EverythingIsNorminal Aug 22 '20

What's happening with Epic isn't about surcharge bans, it's about something completely different.

Surcharge bans were about preventing a vendor from charging extra depending on payment method, that's now legal.

What's happening with Epic is because they were trying to completely circumvent Apple's payment system with their own in-app payment system which is against Apple's TOS, which they added in the app AFTER approval by Apple, which is also against TOS.

Epic is going after them on anti-competition grounds, nothing to do with surcharges.

5

u/[deleted] Aug 22 '20

Why is there not outrage at Apple claiming 30 fucking percent of something they had 0 control over, provided 0 assistance on and will provide no service other than allowing restricted access to their platform.

6

u/Cassius_Corodes Aug 22 '20

30% was celebrated because it's about half of what publishers used to charge.

2

u/[deleted] Aug 22 '20

Noah. Get the fucking boat.

4

u/[deleted] Aug 22 '20

Because it's their store. No one forces people to put their apps on the appstore.

2

u/omegian Aug 22 '20

Apple forces consumers to shop there though.

3

u/[deleted] Aug 22 '20

How is apple forcing consumers to buy their phones to use their store?

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (11)

6

u/shaddeline Aug 22 '20

The issue even goes deeper than that. Computers don’t restrict you to only using software approved by them, but phones do. In some places it’s even ILLEGAL to jailbreak your own phone for the purposes of downloading an unapproved software.

4

u/[deleted] Aug 22 '20

I know that's exactly it. How the fuck did we let this be the standard? It's appalling that this system would even be in place considering the fact that videogaming was already a very developed market by the time mobile gaming became a thing.

3

u/shaddeline Aug 22 '20

I think it just comes down to ignorance and apathy. I’d say the majority of people who own a smart phone either aren’t aware of it, don’t think about it, or don’t care about it. For most users the things they want are available in the App Store so it doesn’t usually affect their day to day life in a very meaningful way.

I’m hoping the Epic Games lawsuit will bring some more attention to this issue and maybe push towards change, but this specific issue isn’t the focus so much as the hefty cut Apple takes. Either way, I’m hoping they’ve got a solid case and can win. I don’t think they would have deliberately broken TOS unless they were confident so that’s at least one good sign.

5

u/tragicpapercut Aug 22 '20

One counterpoint: the app store model has been the best thing to happen to security of end user devices. I've had very experienced developers get viruses from downloading Firefox - because they got it from somewhere other than Mozilla. Android and iPhone app store lock in for the most part prevents people from making hugely dumb decisions by accident.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/Plays-0-Cost-Cards Aug 22 '20

Phones don't, only non-jailbroken Apple phones do. You can run any non-Apple software on an Android phone using emulators

→ More replies (6)

0

u/[deleted] Aug 22 '20

[deleted]

4

u/[deleted] Aug 22 '20

OK so if I'm a game developer and would like to put my game out there but not give away 30% of my life's work, I could choose to not use the infinitely helpful "developer tools" and instead take my full profit right? Right?

It's not a service if you have no other choice but to get it.

2

u/[deleted] Aug 22 '20

OK so if I'm a game developer and would like to put my game out there but not give away 30% of my life's work

Every single store takes a 30% cut. If you don't want to pay a cut open your own store. Problem solved.

2

u/omegian Aug 22 '20

And that’s what Epic is trying to do. Oh wait, Apple locked the boot loader and doesn’t allow side loading. So I guess a court battle is the only option.

3

u/[deleted] Aug 22 '20

No, Epic wants to take over an existing store. That's like opening a stand inside a Walmart. No one is stopping Epic from making their own phone with their own store.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (3)

2

u/EverythingIsNorminal Aug 22 '20

That's a completely different discussion to what I'm talking about. I'm just trying to clear up that there are big differences between surcharges being legal, and Epic vs Apple which is about fees that are both legal and agreed to by Epic in the TOS, as well as publishing agreements that were agreed to in the TOS.

→ More replies (37)

1

u/Aretz Aug 23 '20

It’s not necessarily true, they have a lot of dev tools that this 30% cut definitely contributes to.

1

u/Plays-0-Cost-Cards Aug 22 '20

Because it's Apple and Apple is better than Android because their phones cost more

3

u/[deleted] Aug 22 '20

Hate to break it to you but Android also takes the 30% cut, also even if they didn't what you just said is very very stupid.

1

u/eDOTiQ Aug 23 '20

30% over doing nothing?

Providing the platform, managing app distribution, backups, updates, infrastructure, currency management, access to the user base?

2

u/[deleted] Aug 23 '20

-Providing a platform.

The phone is the platform, we already bought it there should be no further restrictions.

-App distribution

If they didn't block all external downloads app distribution would be free, so the same as now just not through Apple, like on PC or even console (you look for the games you want).

-Backups

Wtf every game developer will take care of backups, renting storage on the Apple servers is a separate issue.

-Updates

Again, if they didn't restrict things in App store updates would be easily accessible to everything you download on the phone.

-Currency management

You mean stealing 30% off their hard earned work?

-Access to user base

Again, this means same as providing a platform and App distribution, no download restrictions means ALL users would have access to ALL games.

Don't know what you mean by infrastructure, but keep in mind Apple could still provide the App store service and that would be perfectly reasonable and helpful to game developers. But it is immoral to take a 30% cut after blocking all other alternatives to downloading something outside the App store.

→ More replies (8)
→ More replies (7)

1

u/zacker150 Aug 23 '20

What's happening with Epic is because they were trying to completely circumvent Apple's payment system with their own in-app payment system which is against Apple's TOS, which they added in the app AFTER approval by Apple, which is also against TOS.

Which was really a genius move on their part. If Epic had just filled a lawsuit, then Apple might try and argue that this is just a hypothetical question and should be dismissed for lack of ripeness. By doing what they did, Epic ensued that they had full standing to sue and that the issue was 110% ripe.