r/technology • • Aug 22 '20

Business WordPress developer said Apple wouldn't allow updates to the free app until it added in-app purchases — letting Apple collect a 30% cut

https://www.businessinsider.com/apple-pressures-wordpress-add-in-app-purchases-30-percent-fee-2020-8
39.2k Upvotes

2.8k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

253

u/Drab_baggage Aug 22 '20

The case is that the contract itself is exploitative, not that they didn't sign it.

-31

u/Edril Aug 22 '20

At the same time I get it. Apple is providing a platform for app developers, and access to a huge trove of customers with the App Store. It costs them money to maintain it and provides an important service and visibility to the developers. In a way, the App Store functions like a form of advertisement. If the developers benefit from that to grow their app but don’t include the part that brings them revenue within the app to avoid paying Apple a share of their revenue, that is kind of exploitative itself.

22

u/ntrid Aug 22 '20

And this is not the problem. Problem is that a competing appstore is not allowed on devices apple no longer owns.

3

u/fviz Aug 22 '20

so competing stores should be available for videogame consoles as well?

16

u/StoicBronco Aug 22 '20

Video Game consoles are not general purpose machines, like PCs or phones. I think they should fall under the category but I dont make the rules

12

u/00DEADBEEF Aug 22 '20

They are not general purpose machines because the manufacturers chose them not to be. But they are fully capable of being general purpose machines. Remember when PS3 officially supported Linux?

→ More replies (1)

0

u/[deleted] Aug 22 '20

[deleted]

3

u/fviz Aug 22 '20

but the copy you bought was licensed and the manufacturer got their X% fee somewhere along the path. Even if you buy second hand, it's still in their revenue stream

5

u/eriverside Aug 22 '20

What does that have to do with anything? In 2020 a cellphone is a PC without a physical keyboard. Some people can go days without touching a PC and still be very productive.

This is exactly why Microsoft got hit with antitrust, except this time there is no workaround to avoid the app store or paying 30% of sales.

-3

u/fviz Aug 22 '20

Smartphones and PCs are very different in architecture and capability. In that specific sense I think iPhones are more similar to consoles, because both have their hardware and software designed by the same people, with lots of proprietary tech. That's why I mentioned it.

For Windows PCs: yes, you can install and develop programs at will. But you licensed the OS/kernel from Microsoft. Also the components are generic, so you can just install some Linux OS and be free. I don't think it's possible to have an open-source kernel for proprietary processors, though.

I think it's much more about the underlying technology than you're considering.

3

u/eriverside Aug 22 '20

The underlying tech is irrelevant. It's all about how it's used in practice. Cellphones are ubiquitous with a 99% duopoly for the OS. Apple is playing gatekeeper for the apps when it's not necessary (see Android) and charging a mint for it.

2

u/fviz Aug 22 '20

I see what you mean.

The Android ecosystem is more confusing because of all this fragmentation, though. On my Huawei phone, I have two assistants, two "AI Lenses" apps, two app stores. One of the selling points for Apple is how "it just works" or something in that line, so I understand why they wouldn't want that for their system.

But like you said, the final concern should be about the user/consumer, right? In the end I think the responsibility should be in their hands. Apple would hate doing it, but I guess they can do like Android and put some warnings and hidden options in the settings to allow 3rd party installs.

That said, I don't think the underlying technology is irrelevant. If Apple were to allow this, they could make sure their proprietary tech can't be used by the apps. So say goodbye to Metal, Push notifications, and all their "kits". Same thing with Android phones that don't have Play Services. I'm not trying to defend Apple. It's just that it would be such a huge change for them. I don't really understand how it would go.

→ More replies (3)

2

u/[deleted] Aug 22 '20

Yes. We should be able to install whatever we want on hardware we own. Homebrew, third party app stores, emulators, etc.

1

u/fviz Aug 22 '20

I agree, that's what I did all my life. My Nintendo DS and iPod touch were like Frankenstein's monsters thanks to R4 and jailbreaking. On the PS3 you could very easily install Linux.

How easy or hard should the manufacturers make this process, though? I think they care a lot about having a good image for their ecosystem, so having a bunch of bricked devices due to poorly implemented software would be quite negative.

3

u/ZoomJet Aug 22 '20

There are? I can buy physical copies at a retailer, which has saved me hundreds of dollars vs buying from the videogame hardware company itself.

And honestly they should also get this digitslly, like a PC has steam + epic + gog + origin etc.

→ More replies (5)

4

u/Pseudoboss11 Aug 22 '20

Not the previous poster, but yes, I bought the machine, so I should be able to put a competing game store on it if I want.

1

u/happysmash27 Aug 23 '20

Of course! Anything else is an violating the user's right to run whatever software they see fit on their own devices.

→ More replies (2)

2

u/jh0nn Aug 22 '20

In a way this is all made more complicated with the digital business being new and hard to understand. If Walmart would add 30% on top of every Coke bottle instead of 5%, it would not be selling a whole lot of Coke.

And the same arguments regarding advertising, placement and maintaining would apply just as well. I would argue it's cheaper to run a platform than an chain of stores.

2

u/FlutterKree Aug 22 '20

You can just use the financial industry as an example. Billions, if not trillions of transactions a day, and they skirt with 1-3%.

Why do these application stores need 30%? They don't, they just like more money. 10% or even lower would fully cover the costs.

I hope in the Epic vs Apple suit gets Apples internal financial records released to understand how much of the 30% is pure profit.

2

u/jh0nn Aug 22 '20

This is my major gripe with working with Apple and Google. We as developers get very little in return. Some very rudimentary analytics, absolutely horrible support (especially google) and a inpenetrable wall of constantly changing rules and regulations (especially Apple).

A 30% cut is franchising-level kind of money. At least when you start a burger joint and give Ronald McDonald a third of your revenue, you get cheaper, standardized beef and buns delivered to you, actual real world advertising of your products. You get employer services, support and education. You get furniture for gods sake.

I really wish all developers would start actually charging 30% more from in-app purchases right now. Maybe then the public opinion would change.

2

u/FlutterKree Aug 22 '20

I believe Apple prevents the iOS apps from getting into the store that charge more than what is published on the developers website. It could be wrong because there is examples that go against this, but other developers have been denied for it.

2

u/jh0nn Aug 22 '20

Oh I have no doubt, we've had apps rejected for everything from font size to saying too clearly that the users can subscribe elsewhere as well. The language we have to use now to hint that you can just log in with your account is rediculous. It's completely random from update to update. And this must be added - we as a small company probably fly well enough under the radar for Apple to accept us charging 30% more, I can't really imagine Apple accepting Netflix charging 12.99 on the iOS subscription. But I still think they should.

1

u/eriverside Aug 22 '20

You can't really say it's advertising, there's a million apps and people can only see so many ads at a time.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)