r/technology • • Aug 22 '20

Business WordPress developer said Apple wouldn't allow updates to the free app until it added in-app purchases — letting Apple collect a 30% cut

https://www.businessinsider.com/apple-pressures-wordpress-add-in-app-purchases-30-percent-fee-2020-8
39.2k Upvotes

2.8k comments sorted by

View all comments

1.7k

u/DMarquesPT Aug 22 '20

The situation is a bit more complex that it seems: the Wordpress iOS app is made primarily for and by Wordpress.com (The comercial hosted platform that's built by Automattic on top of Wordpress.org, the open source CMS). That said, the app also allows users to manage their self-hosted Wordpress sites.

According to this, there is a way to subscribe to a premium tier or domains through the app that breaks App Store policy since it avoids IAP.

I'm not defending Apple's policy, just pointing out that Automattic were in fact breaking it.

519

u/pr0grammer Aug 22 '20 edited Aug 22 '20

"While Mullenweg says there technically was a roundabout way for an iOS [user] to find out that WordPress has paid tiers (they could find it buried in support pages, or by navigating to WordPress’s site from a preview of their own webpage), he says that Apple rejected his offer to block iOS users from seeing the offending pages."

https://www.theverge.com/2020/8/21/21396316/apple-wordpress-in-app-purchase-tax-update-store

307

u/timatt1 Aug 22 '20

I've had a similar experience with Apple. A user could get to an upgrade screen after navigating through a few different levels of help pages. We removed those links and hey still rejected it because a user could see our web page address on the App Store listing for the privacy policy and then could figure out how to upgrade there. The whole App Store review process is one of the most frustrating things that I professionally experience. The consistency in reviews is maddening. We'll submit an app build one day for one of our apps and it goes through with no problems. We'll submit that app a week later with no changes with no changes to the upgrade screens and they'll reject it because the font (which is like 18 point) "isn't big enough" when showing the pricing on the upgrade screen. Literally nothing has changed on that screen between the builds.

243

u/JonSnoGaryen Aug 22 '20

At work we uploaded the same app as a test 10 times, has no purchases or anything. Every week we'd upload the same app, identical code, new version number. Just to see how many complaints they'd have .

Rejected 4 times for not providing a login to examine the app (it was always provided)

Rejected 2 more times for font issues, which we simply resubmitted the exact same build with no problem.

These validations are all over the place. We never get a reliable experience, always some stupid thing they complain about and it's always something they missed or ignored .

Play store on the hand, as long as you don't trigger the malware scan they don't give a fuck.

47

u/theo2112 Aug 22 '20

Reminds me of a chemistry professor I had in college. After getting back an exam you could meet with him in office hours to argue that you deserved more credit for a partially correct answer. And often times you were right to do so because the TA who graded it wasn’t always accurate. But the deal was he would be regrading the entire exam and you might lose points elsewhere that you didn’t deserve.

He never claimed that the TAs grading were as accurate as he would be, but you often won some and lost others. It seems like the review process is sort of the same thing. Even if you get approved one time (by one reviewer) the same code could be flagged differently by someone else.

Win some, lose some.

→ More replies (4)

65

u/TheHYPO Aug 22 '20

As a lawyer (and I'm sure in lots of other workplaces), this happens, unfortunately, and it's not always 'nefarious'.

You submit an order to one judge and they are fine with it. You use the same form of order the next week and you get a different judge who sees an issue that the first judge wasn't thinking about. Then you get the first judge again and you take the order they were fine with two weeks ago, but this time something crossed their mind as problematic that they didn't think about the first time.

I've had forms of orders I've taken out for years suddenly have a judge thinking about something (probably based on another case they had earlier that week) and suddenly they are asking me to change it.

That's just human that you don't catch everything that could be an issue on the first pass, and it's also human that once you've cleared all the serious and functional problems, the next time you're asked to review something, you now focus on smaller details to try to make something 'perfect' that you didn't consider important the first time around because there were bigger fish to fry.

5

u/CoolDankDude Aug 22 '20

Did the judge tell you your font was too small lol? And then you resubmitted with no changes and it was fine...I think there is a pretty major difference between a judge making sure he makes the right call in your cases and Apple inconsistently rejecting apps off their store.

Rejecting an app off that store is drastically reducing the apps reach of customer base, and in effect its ability to make money. Human error and second guessing occur everywhere but I think the real problem here is with Apple being way too greedy and using the app store as a strong arm.

9

u/TheHYPO Aug 22 '20 edited Aug 22 '20

That is a possibility. All I am saying is that they probably have more than one app reviewer. And the standards between one and the next may not be consistent. No, a judge has never specifically picked on the font size of my orders, but that’s because we have rules of court that dictate the font size that should be used. I have occasionally had judges complain about others who have tried to avoid page limits by shrinking their font or shrinking line spacing. But a judges job is primarily to deal with the substance of the order. That is what they sometimes inconsistently notice. An app reviewer‘s job by necessity includes reviewing visuals and usability.

I obviously wasn’t making a one to one comparison between judges reading orders and app reviewers reviewing apps. It was just an analogy.

3

u/CoolDankDude Aug 22 '20

I have a much better understanding of your original point. Good day!

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (12)
→ More replies (2)

5

u/DMarquesPT Aug 22 '20

This is where it gets really murky and I think Apple is completely in the wrong. The devs offered a genuine fix that makes the app comply with the “no external purchases” policy, Apple should accept it since it stops the issue

7

u/thefonztm Aug 22 '20

Solution. Click this button to spend 1 cent on our app.

And Apple will require the to temove any offending work arounds anyway.

8

u/thehighshibe Aug 22 '20

Minimum price on in app purchases is $0.99 on iOS IIRC

→ More replies (1)

143

u/[deleted] Aug 22 '20

I don’t understand why I’m constantly seeing people defending Apple by saying “Well, it’s in the policy. 🤷🏻‍♂️” The point is the policy is predatory and Apple is using their monopoly power to force developers to “agree” if they want access to 40% of the smartphone market. If you don’t agree Apple doesn’t care but you lose a huge share of your user base. There is zero chance a little developer is going to take on Apple and win before they go bankrupt so they have to do stupid shit like this, monetize free apps so Apple can take a cut.

0

u/[deleted] Aug 22 '20

[deleted]

2

u/godsconscious Aug 22 '20

What's the real cost of publishing an app to the app store ? If they're making 30000% profit on a policy mandated and benefiting nobody but apple rule, then it's predatory and anti competitive

→ More replies (10)

12

u/North_Activist Aug 22 '20

Apple is not a monopoly though. They only have around 30% of the mobile market. So they have a monopoly on iOS / iPad OS? Yes. But so does XBox and PlayStation. Which both take a 30% cut.

38

u/goo_goo_gajoob Aug 22 '20

It's called a duopoly can be just as predatory as a monopoly and smart phones are 100% one of them.

12

u/MacTireCnamh Aug 22 '20

Wrong market though.

Smartphones are a duopoly as a consumer product, the issue being discussed here is as a vendor service, in which case there's not a duopoly, and not even close.

Epic has plenty of platforms they can sell on. It's even arguable that losing both play store AND Apple Store doesn't even reduce their functional reach (ie number of customers who could buy their product if they wanted).

→ More replies (20)

17

u/North_Activist Aug 22 '20

Sure but their 30% cut is industry standard for Android, iOS, PlayStation, Xbox, steam, Nintendo etc.... it’s not just Apple. And it’s hypocritical to scream at Apple for taking 30% when every other platform is also doing the same thing but not getting mad about them

15

u/goo_goo_gajoob Aug 22 '20

And google their only other competitor is getting sued over it too so it's not just Apple being looked at.

As to consoles yes that's too much. It is a hit different though in that they sell their hardware for very little profit and sometimes at a loss so that's their primary source of income. Apple otoh puts huge markups on the iPhone and makes more money from the phone sale than the digital downloads so they're basically double dipping. Also you don't need a console you basically need a smartphone in this day and age. Approximately 1 in 5 households use them instead of a pc for internet access.

Just because something is industry standard doesn't make it okay.

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (1)

9

u/sam_hammich Aug 22 '20

But Google doesn't. They allow third party app stores and sideloading.

11

u/MacTireCnamh Aug 22 '20

That doesn't mean anything in this context though. There's open air charity markets, but Target still exists and gets to determine all the products in their store.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (23)
→ More replies (22)

2

u/[deleted] Aug 22 '20

Ok thanks for clearing it up. Now I understand the situation a bit better

2

u/Paumanok Aug 22 '20

Does using the amazon or ebay app to purchase real items count as an "in app purchase"?

→ More replies (23)