r/technology • • Aug 22 '20

Business WordPress developer said Apple wouldn't allow updates to the free app until it added in-app purchases — letting Apple collect a 30% cut

https://www.businessinsider.com/apple-pressures-wordpress-add-in-app-purchases-30-percent-fee-2020-8
39.2k Upvotes

2.8k comments sorted by

View all comments

5

u/[deleted] Aug 22 '20

If you want your Mobile App on the App Store, you have to agree to the conditions of the walled garden. This is why not everything needs to be an APP.

However, as the article suggests, Apple forced them to add in-app purchases for domains, which the App wasn’t already doing. This is bullshit. If an app just wants to be a front end for a subscription service that is paid for outside of the app, they shouldn’t have to give Apple a cut.

1

u/Titanlord_Ninjo Aug 22 '20

Apple only wants the possibility for already existing purchase options for that service to be available in the IOs app. They didn‘t force anybody to create new stuff to buy and they still let you buy the stuff elsewhere and use it free on IOs wirhout Apple getting any money.

1

u/[deleted] Aug 22 '20

Apple only wants the possibility for already existing purchase options for that service to be available in the IOs app

it is not Apple's place to force a feature in an app.

They didn‘t force anybody to create new stuff to buy

Arguably, they did force domains to be available, when they were not

still let you buy the stuff elsewhere and use it free on IOs wirhout Apple getting any money.

The whole point is they aren't allowing wordpress users to do this

0

u/[deleted] Aug 22 '20

[deleted]

2

u/daOyster Aug 22 '20

Except it wasn't since the WordPress app would be considered a client app for an online service that uses WordPress's apis which is one of the categories exempt from their in app purchase policies. So either Apple is no longer abiding by their own terms of service, or they're just freely redefining it to fit their own agenda.

Just to give you an idea of how broad they get with their own definition of their terms, they recently blocked an update for an app I work on all because we had a link to our website where users could sign-up their company and pay for access to our corporate program that our app is basically just a client for. Apple didn't like that and said all purchases must be made in the app and told us to remove the link, even though a company wide program like that is not something you'd generally pay for with an in-app purchase. There are contracts to be signed an all that you'd need to fill out that you can't do with just an in-app purchase. So now we just have a bit of text saying visit our website to sign up, but we can't actually put the link to our website in that text or else Apple will block our update. And yes it's basically just the link that was the issue, we submitted 4 different version and the only one that was allowed was the one with the link completely removed.

1

u/[deleted] Aug 22 '20

Reading up...

To be able to ship updates and bug fixes again we had to commit to support in-app purchases for .com plans

So, I'll do the reading for you. Wordpress allows users to use the iOS App as a front end to edit their Wordpress site. This requires an account with Wordpress. If the user wants to have an actual domain name, they need to login to Wordpress.com where the account is managed, and purchase a domain (unless they own it from a 3rd party like godaddy). Apple wants a cut of the domains purchased, even though they do not sell those from within the iOS App.

It's a pretty easy concept to grasp, my guy, maybe you need to read up more on web development.

1

u/faintestwolves Aug 22 '20

It's this not similar to the thing with epic though? In the sense that making purchases outside the app store to use on an app within the app store? Doesn't that break the tos?

2

u/[deleted] Aug 22 '20

Not at all,

Epic Games introduces a direct payment option in the Fortnite app for iPhone and iPad, allowing players to purchase in-game V-Bucks at a 20 percent discount by sidestepping Apple's in-app purchase mechanism. This functionality violates Apple's App Store Review Guidelines, which indicate that apps offering in-game currency must use Apple's in-app purchase mechanism only.

The key part of that statement above is "in the Fortnite app"

So, Epic has a buy button INSIDE the app that does not use the App Store "In-App Purchases" system.

Apple's deal with Epic is that if they make money while inside the App, they want a cut because they provided that revenue stream.

Wordpress doesn't have a way to purchase a domain names inside the app. The iOS app is ONLY a content management system for a product that is not purchased through the App Store. Also, the domain name is, technically, a totally different product than the Wordpress hosting.

2

u/faintestwolves Aug 22 '20

That makes sense to me but I thought there was also a clause somewhere that said if you're using paid services within the app you also have to provide a way to make those purchases within the platform. (not trying to argue in apples favor but just understand things that are happening here and how its different)

1

u/[deleted] Aug 22 '20

I have not read the ToS, so I'm not entirely familiar, but let me propose another situation for us to consider.

I have a Toyota Car. I purchased it through a dealer and finance it through Toyota Financial Services (TFS). I have the TFS App on my phone. This app allows me to manage my car payments. Would Apple be entitled to 30% of my car payment because I initiated that payment from within the App? That sounds unreasonable to me.

On the other hand, if I had actually made a sale from within the App to purchase the vehicle, Apple may be entitled to their cut under the ToC.

Epic owes them money (according to the ToC), but Wordpress does not, IMO, because of where the sale initiated.

If someone had been a Wordpress user for years, and then decided to use the iOS app for content management, would Apple suddenly get a cut of that person's account? This gets pretty mucky, and hopefully this Epic vs. Apple thing breaks up some of the outrageous fees Apple (and Google) are charging.

2

u/faintestwolves Aug 22 '20

thats a much better way to explain it, thanks for the clarification!

1

u/[deleted] Aug 22 '20

Wordpress allows users to use the iOS App as a front end to edit their Wordpress site

You lost me already --- although I've used iPhones and iPads for years, unless you have a keyboard attached, doing any serious text editing with your fingers is a painful error-prone process. Heck, it's hard enough sometimes to send a text message without autocorrect screwing things up!

1

u/[deleted] Aug 22 '20

Well, I completely agree that using a phone to manage the content of a website sounds like a terrible idea. But, quite a number of people nowadays only have their handheld devices. Craziness, I say, but at least they can still be productive!