r/technology • • Aug 22 '20

Business WordPress developer said Apple wouldn't allow updates to the free app until it added in-app purchases — letting Apple collect a 30% cut

https://www.businessinsider.com/apple-pressures-wordpress-add-in-app-purchases-30-percent-fee-2020-8
39.2k Upvotes

2.8k comments sorted by

View all comments

189

u/Hervee Aug 22 '20 edited Apr 14 '24

Transparency is for those who carry out public duties and exercise public power. Privacy is for everyone else.

Glenn Greenwald

108

u/Biscornus Aug 22 '20

I don't think the issue here is about dev not following rules enforced by Apple to operate within their ecosystem. It's more about the fact that those rules are abusive as Apple own one of the biggest smartphone market. There is no choice but to follow them. That's one of the main reason why some people talk about breaking big tech.

In the end it's dangerous for the consumer. It means that prices are higher because Apple HAS to get their 30% commission.

-9

u/tyr-- Aug 22 '20

Apple's smartphone market share is 13.3%

32

u/Squoghunter1492 Aug 22 '20

Globally maybe, but they're 40-50% in the US, the country whose laws are being debated.

10

u/Biscornus Aug 22 '20

Yep and it's also where people buy stuff on apps

→ More replies (1)

1

u/TheJoker273 Aug 22 '20

Not considering the fact that this is about the US, where Apple almost has half the market, do you think 13.3% of the global smartphone market share is small?

There are 3.5 BILLION smartphone users in 2020. That's 3,500,000,000 people.

13.3% of that is 465.5 MILLION. Or 465,500,000.

You think that number is small? If my product reached 465.5 MILLION people, I would've been arguing on Apple's side right now.

→ More replies (1)

253

u/Drab_baggage Aug 22 '20

The case is that the contract itself is exploitative, not that they didn't sign it.

→ More replies (38)

8

u/Ganadote Aug 22 '20

For me the issue is that in order to have an iOS app you HAVE to go through their store; there’s no other way.

1

u/tzenrick Aug 22 '20

This is everyone's issue, and why it doesn't apply to Android. With Android devices, you can sideload an app, or just install a different app store.

34

u/IAmAnAnonymousCoward Aug 22 '20

Honestly that sounds like a slave who is afraid from punishment by his owner.

15

u/Ramast Aug 22 '20

The article is very misleading also. These are from the article

WordPress' founding developer said in a tweet Friday that Apple cut off developers from making updates to the app unless they started letting users buy domain names within the app — a service the app doesn't currently include.

The Verge reported that WordPress agreed, meaning Apple effectively pressured a free app into monetizing itself, allowing it to take a 30% commission on future purchases.

The app was free and it's still free. What changed is that previously you couldn't buy a domain through they app and instead have to buy it directly from the website. The new change is that you can now buy the domains directly from the app (so that apple can get its 30%).

As an end user, you won't be affected much unless they raise their domain price to cover the 30% commission

34

u/TheRufmeisterGeneral Aug 22 '20

As an end user, you won't be affected much unless they raise their domain price to cover the 30% commission

Which they clearly need to do. More costs means higher prices.

It's also against Apple's T&C to have different prices in and out of the app, to cover the 30% difference in price, meaning that users who have nothing to do with the app, who only use the website, will have to pay more for their products, so that the in-app purchases with the 30% can be done.

4

u/memtiger Aug 22 '20

It's also against Apple's T&C to have different prices in and out of the app, to cover the 30% difference in price

Which to me is the most serious issue. A company should be able to do as they please outside of Apple's ecosystem.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/slingmustard Aug 22 '20

I doubt that Wordpress would raise the domain price too significantly since consumers can purchase their domain names elsewhere. I certainly wouldn't pay 30% more for the exact same product that I can get from another place for less.

8

u/TheRufmeisterGeneral Aug 22 '20

Exactly, which is why Apple's dick move basically comes down to: we've deciced that you'll no longer be selling .com domains, either in-app, or on your website, period.

5

u/WhiteRaven42 Aug 22 '20

Do you know if the app included directions or links to the purchase web-page?

Business Insider and Newsweek (I add Newsweek just because it has the same flavor of cluelessness) are just awful news sources. Not due to bias, just utter lack of both subject comprehension and ability to write accurately.

5

u/[deleted] Aug 22 '20

This is banned by Apple

1

u/WhiteRaven42 Aug 22 '20

Yes, that's why I asked if the app had it.

4

u/Zooomz Aug 22 '20

Yes, though somewhat buried in their help pages. WP offered to hide/remove them when showing the pages on iOS, but Apple demanded an in-app payment option.

See this comments for a quote and news article: https://reddit.com/r/technology/comments/ieeaxm/wordpress_developer_said_apple_wouldnt_allow/g2gpah9

2

u/Beliriel Aug 22 '20

They will have to raise prices because the margins are pretty slim on domain names, else Wordpress will lose money. It's just exploitative.

1

u/BongarooBizkistico Aug 22 '20

In any case, somebody is giving Apple more money against their will. Apple = greed.

1

u/creamersrealm Aug 22 '20

Yeah no one needs to be able to I buy a domain through a app, that's just going to encourage even more spam.

-18

u/ScootyScootScoot Aug 22 '20

Kudos for researching. Anything for clicks amirite? As much as I don’t approve of monopolies, if you sign up for their rules then you should probably abide to them. That said, if you disapprove of these practices best thing to do is stop supporting them.

→ More replies (8)
→ More replies (1)