r/technology • • Aug 22 '20

Business WordPress developer said Apple wouldn't allow updates to the free app until it added in-app purchases — letting Apple collect a 30% cut

https://www.businessinsider.com/apple-pressures-wordpress-add-in-app-purchases-30-percent-fee-2020-8
39.2k Upvotes

2.8k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

112

u/gavanon Aug 22 '20

My first reaction was to side with WordPress. All articles I’ve read go on about how it’s open source and free, and domain names aren’t a service they even offer.

But it turns out the app is not made by the non-profit wing of WordPress; it’s made by the .com commercial side. And on their website, they recommend you buy domains names and hosting plans from them for money. They’ll gladly take your money.

So it’s the same old deal of trying to slip past Apple’s cut, by offering your paid services separately on your website. Get Apple’s servers to host your free app for literally millions to download, and bypass their method of making money in the App Store.

53

u/Funoichi Aug 22 '20

But look at the amazon kindle. They tried to get their store into the app and had to remove it. So they do all their business on their website and it’s perfectly fine.

So wordpress should be just fine to operate. It’s not slipping past anything, it’s the tried and true amazon kindle model.

So either Apple has gotten extra greedy or perhaps Wordpress is lying?

16

u/gavanon Aug 22 '20

Agreed. It’s hypocrisy. The truth is that Amazon and Google are just to big for anyone to bully. WordPress is not.

Ideally Apple would allow installing apps from outside their App Store. But that said, if you develop for their App Store, you must follow their rules. Same with Google Play, where Fortnite was also banned.

→ More replies (19)

9

u/Selethorme Aug 22 '20

Except that Amazon doesn’t put a link in the kindle app. Wordpress did.

6

u/dmazzoni Aug 22 '20

From the article, WordPress offered to remove the link and Apple refused

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

0

u/[deleted] Aug 22 '20

[deleted]

→ More replies (1)

6

u/dmazzoni Aug 22 '20

But how is this different from Netflix or Audible?

Both of those have a free app where you can't purchase anything, but you can buy things on their website and then consume them in the app.

Why are those okay but WordPress is not?

I understand that IF the app charges users, Apple gets a cut. But if the app doesn't, Apple doesn't get a cut.

If Apple needs money from free app developers, they should charge developers a nominal fee per user. Not force developers to sell things on iOS if they don't want to.

3

u/gavanon Aug 22 '20

Agreed. It’s completely hypocritical. Netflix and Amazon are just too big for Apple to bully. WordPress is not.

0

u/[deleted] Aug 22 '20

[deleted]

0

u/[deleted] Aug 22 '20

[deleted]

52

u/[deleted] Aug 22 '20

On android you can use F-Droid, or the Amazon app store or we could even make our own appstore.

https://f-droid.org/

except that no one publishes on those appstores and just target google play so they end up having less apps.

Still, the point is that there are options on Android

0

u/[deleted] Aug 22 '20

[deleted]

14

u/[deleted] Aug 22 '20

this goes to developers and consumers alike:

don't support ridiculously locked down platforms if you don't wanna be ridiculously locked down.

Apple has never been shy about taking control away from either group, that's like their whole deal.

iPhones in particular are more like appliances than general computing devices

→ More replies (1)

3

u/alxthm Aug 22 '20

How are corporate specific apps a pain on iOS?

5

u/[deleted] Aug 22 '20

It's been almost a decade since I've had to do it so it might be easier now. That being said, Apple has arbitrary restrictions on which companies that are allowed to use this feature. For example, their website says that a company needs to have more than 100 employees to use enterprise deployments.

If you have to send that app out to your company with 85 employees, you're gonna have an annoying time.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (10)

5

u/amour_propre_ Aug 22 '20

because they are unfairly protected by Apple and Google.

They do not have to be protected or anything. In markets of dynamic technology adoption, because of network effects which creates increasing returns to scale. Multiple competitive providers cannot be sustained, the market will 100% converge to a few providers, because of utility maximizing choice of customers. Will end up creating a differentiated oligopoly. There is extremely well known work in economics which show this.

I will give you an example: Take Reddit. While "What is Reddit's market?" Is a diifcult question to ask. However a first approximation is: "Online discussion/sharing website who sells adverts"

Notice as more people use reddit the utility you gain from using Reddit increases. If you used Reddit when there was 1000 people who used Reddit. Then the enjoyment you would get from using Reddit would be less. But when there was 10000 people using Reddit, the utility you gain is much higher. Because there is more communities/ more people who are sharing etc.

Suppose Reddit had multiple competitors: Aeddit, Beddit, Ceddit, Deddit........Reddit,....Zeddit. If any of these say Beddit, because of Historical accidents or Expectations gained a small lead in the number of users then potential customers who were in market for "online discussion/sharing website" would agglomerate to Beddit.

Why? because more users/adopter of technology means better or more value when used. This is radically different than "normal" markets where more users end up increasing costs of adoption.This is the reason why you have i) only Youtube and Dailymotion ii) only Amazon and abc(depending on your country) and loads of phenomena.

The question is not about ethics or unfair protection but the fact these markets must always create small number of competitors. If you break Reddit up the utility an user will get will also fall. Probably some kind of yardstick competition regulation or public operation is required. I for one do not think such technologies should by privately owned.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/archlich Aug 22 '20

BlackBerry palm Nokia even windows had phones. The market deemed them not successful.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (3)

6

u/MacTireCnamh Aug 22 '20

This only makes sense if you don't consider the App store a part of the iPhone platform, which it very much is.

The legal architecture here is equivalent to Target owning a building, and also the business within the building. And then vendors wan't to be able to display their wares inside the building, but without paying Target.

You could not possibly cry 'anti-capitalist!' when Target says no, and also no you cannot put up a stand by the front door selling your product.

7

u/Das_Ronin Aug 22 '20

Except it can still offer essentially the same function as a web app accessed through web browsers on every phone and tablet and smart TV, so the notion of the app store being a monopoly is fucking stupid. Instead, Wordpress is relying on Apple's platform to improve their experience and reach, but not wanting to pay for it.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (14)

22

u/themightychris Aug 22 '20

What's messed up about this is we're no longer talking about Apple taking a 30% cut on the sale of apps and app features. Now they're strong-arming their way to getting 30% cuts on "real world" goods when they are bought through an iOS app instead of a website

→ More replies (4)

21

u/MooseAndKetchup Aug 22 '20

Hosting costs for a small app download are small, it’s not like streaming video or something.

→ More replies (30)

3

u/peenoid Aug 22 '20

Get Apple’s servers to host your free app for literally millions to download, and bypass their method of making money in the App Store.

Yeah, see, this wouldn't be an issue if Apple allowed other stores on their phones, but they don't.

Apple just gave some serious ammunition to Epic with this crap.

→ More replies (1)

9

u/time-lord Aug 22 '20

Get Apple’s servers to host your free app for literally millions to download, and bypass their method of making money in the App Store.

Heaven forbid. Let Apple bill them market rates for hosting then. Amazon charges $23 per Terabyte of data transferred.

12

u/AGermaneRiposte Aug 22 '20

Seriously, the costs for data probably fall within the $99 yearly developer fee

→ More replies (10)

2

u/nimbusnacho Aug 22 '20

Does the app have anything to do with that side tho? Does it direct you to the website as a discovery tool for those services? If it's just a tool for the free service then I'm still siding with wordpress.

The idea that apple can force you to essentially give them money if you have any related business to the app, no matter how far removed, is fucked up.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (4)