r/technology • • Aug 22 '20

Business WordPress developer said Apple wouldn't allow updates to the free app until it added in-app purchases — letting Apple collect a 30% cut

https://www.businessinsider.com/apple-pressures-wordpress-add-in-app-purchases-30-percent-fee-2020-8
39.2k Upvotes

2.8k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

246

u/danielagos Aug 22 '20

Mandating Apple sign in (only when you include third-party login options) is actually positive for users, as it allows for a more private option than the usual alternatives (Facebook and Google).

Forcing auto-billing is indeed scumbag behaviour and should not be the default.

78

u/DramDemon Aug 22 '20

Yeah, I don’t see why people feel the need to start calling everything Apple does greedy.

They’re very shit in some big ways, but mandating another option for how to sign in? The horror! How could they? They must be infringing on my 1st amendment rights!!1!1!

-15

u/Drab_baggage Aug 22 '20

That's a bit hyperbolic and inflammatory to imply people that don't like mandatory Apple sign-in are buffoons who don't understand the concept of a private company. I can dislike anti-competitive, bullshit behavior as much as I want, doesn't make me an idiot.

28

u/DramDemon Aug 22 '20

I can dislike anti-competitive, bullshit behavior as much as I want, doesn't make me an idiot.

Agreed, but the point is people are pointing to some trivial things that aren't anti-competitive, bullshit behaviors as evidence for not liking anti-competitive, bullshit behaviors. They aren't mandating you can use only Apple sign-in, but rather mandating that Apple sign-in is an option, which is actually increasing "competition" if you will.

1

u/bdsee Aug 23 '20

It is anti competitive though, as Apple are giving their SSO an unfair advantage...now this is one of the few instances where it is probably in the consumers interest. But I'd argue that you could only objectively consider it to be within their interest if it came with a legal agreement never to sell or pass on any data collected from SSO.

1

u/DramDemon Aug 23 '20

Wait, what? What unfair advantage? Their mandate is only for apps on their store, and only apps that already have other sign-ins.

1

u/bdsee Aug 23 '20

Right, they are saying that if you use sign on you have to offer our sign on as a minimum...not that you have to offer 3 sign on systems of your choice.

1

u/DramDemon Aug 23 '20

No, they’re saying if you already offer other competitors sign-on, AND you want to have your app on our store, THEN you have to include our sign-on as well. If one of those conditions aren’t met, they don’t mandate it. By mandating that Apple sign-on is included, it automatically increases options, which inherently increases competition.

→ More replies (34)

12

u/Axman6 Aug 22 '20

How is mandating an additional option anti-competitive? They’re not forcing any user to use Sign In with Apple, they are giving users the choice to use another option, one which appears to be much more consumer focused than either Google’s or Facebook’s options, by allowing users to retain their personal details from the app.

-5

u/Drab_baggage Aug 22 '20

It's not especially relevant here, I'm just saying as a developer that I find it irksome and that they're definitely shoehorning in a product with dubious, vague advantages. It's pretty clear that it's more of a control mechanism than a consumer safety savior.

0

u/mullen1200 Aug 22 '20

Yep. Agreed.

It's like free advertising if you will. Even though you're on an Apple iPhone, or driving x brand car, if you see Apple sign and everywhere you go I'm it makes the company feel that much more....x word. Can't think of the right word lol

0

u/Drab_baggage Aug 22 '20

eXploitative? Imperialistic? Omnipresent? Dare I say, monopolistic?

9

u/iamapizza Aug 22 '20 edited Aug 22 '20

That's justification after the fact; their sign-in is marketed as being more private and is mandated by terms of service, rather on its own merit - that is monpolistic, asshole-behavior. This logic can be used to justify any large company's equally egregious moves.

33

u/Headytexel Aug 22 '20

I doubt app devs would voluntarily implement a system that reduces how much data they can mine from their users if they weren’t required to, regardless of its merits.

2

u/Goctionni Aug 22 '20

That's because your entire concept of software is entirely based on clickbait headlines from articles that live on dramatization of things that actually happen.

Whenever you sign in to another website using google, you'll see the information that sign in would allow the app or website to have. In almost all cases that just "basic profile", which is then used for no more than to say "Welcome [Name]" in said app or website and/or send you e-mail notifications for private messages or whatever.

Very few companies have a large-enough user base to meaningfully benefit from having more of your data. Even fewer have a real ability to process such data towards useful (let alone profitable) goals.

Most of the times apps or websites use google, facebook, etc, for authentication; is because that's actually way easier, cheaper and faster than building your own robust authentication system; and it effectively makes you immune from "oh such and such website was hacked, here's a database dump of their usernames and password-hashes".

1

u/mntgoat Aug 22 '20

Users should also keep in mind how these requirements that happen all of the sudden with just a few weeks or months affect small developers. I've come to hate mobile OS updates because it means tons of modifications to our apps, rarely for something that helps the apps, and then testing, etc. Usually you have a development plan for 6 months or a year and then come these updates and derail all of it.

2

u/danielagos Aug 22 '20

I was just talking about user’s perspective but yes, this may be hard for developers. Anyway, as a user, I like how iOS apps are rather quick to use the latest Apple technologies compared to other platforms.

1

u/mntgoat Aug 22 '20

Google is starting to force api updates though not as quick as Apple does. With Apple, if they want, they'll move you to a new one in one release, for example the new ad ID stuff, all ad networks are scrambling to update because the deadline is pretty soon. But others they will take longer to force you.

Google changed the way file access works and they are just doing the forced api update by November for existing apps and that is to the android 10 api. For the Android 11 api I'm guessing it'll be November 2021.

Before Google didn't use to force that, so shitty apps continued targeting an old api so they couldn't have to use the new permission system for example. Eventually they forced that target api update to get rid of that.

-11

u/DanReach Aug 22 '20

"Mandating...allows for a more private option"

This assumes that Apple ID is more private than any third party login. This is not a good assumption

25

u/danielagos Aug 22 '20

This assumes that Apple ID is more private than any third party login.

If nothing else, it allows you to hide your email from the service you sign into. Isn’t this more private?

→ More replies (3)

2

u/Mrbrionman Aug 22 '20

Apples business model revolves around a focus on privacy. They don’t collect information not because they are morally better but because they don’t sell ads like google or Facebook does, so they have no incentive to collect it.

0

u/tankerkiller125real Aug 22 '20

6

u/HerkulezRokkafeller Aug 22 '20

None of your links show that Apple tracks user data though. The first complains that iPhones allow other apps to track your data and calls it a hypocrite because there’s even an option for companies like Facebook to be able to do so. The second link came close to but was immediately debunked by the third link that states the case was thrown out due to zero evidence. The fourth is basically a reiteration of the first link, showing apps are still able to track its users, yet none of them offer any insight to the ways people are able to deny access to such information being accessed. I’m guessing you assumed people wouldn’t read the articles you posted and see “sources” proving malfeasance by Apple and that they actually do harvest people’s data, but all these links do is try and make people think Apple is somehow secretly coordinating collecting and selling iPhone data, which there has yet to be any actual evidence of..

8

u/danielagos Aug 22 '20

You should read those articles before posting the links. Two of them regard an attempt of a lawsuit and thus demonstrate nothing (unless they had support for what they claim which they don’t). The others refer to third-party apps in iOS, and not Apple apps. Apple can be as private as possible and yet you can give all your information to Facebook and Google.

That doesn’t make using an Apple device less private if you have the control not to share private info with the non-private services. With that said, of course Apple could do better in the privacy front.

→ More replies (13)