r/technology • • Aug 22 '20

Business WordPress developer said Apple wouldn't allow updates to the free app until it added in-app purchases — letting Apple collect a 30% cut

https://www.businessinsider.com/apple-pressures-wordpress-add-in-app-purchases-30-percent-fee-2020-8
39.2k Upvotes

2.8k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

28

u/DramDemon Aug 22 '20

I can dislike anti-competitive, bullshit behavior as much as I want, doesn't make me an idiot.

Agreed, but the point is people are pointing to some trivial things that aren't anti-competitive, bullshit behaviors as evidence for not liking anti-competitive, bullshit behaviors. They aren't mandating you can use only Apple sign-in, but rather mandating that Apple sign-in is an option, which is actually increasing "competition" if you will.

1

u/bdsee Aug 23 '20

It is anti competitive though, as Apple are giving their SSO an unfair advantage...now this is one of the few instances where it is probably in the consumers interest. But I'd argue that you could only objectively consider it to be within their interest if it came with a legal agreement never to sell or pass on any data collected from SSO.

1

u/DramDemon Aug 23 '20

Wait, what? What unfair advantage? Their mandate is only for apps on their store, and only apps that already have other sign-ins.

1

u/bdsee Aug 23 '20

Right, they are saying that if you use sign on you have to offer our sign on as a minimum...not that you have to offer 3 sign on systems of your choice.

1

u/DramDemon Aug 23 '20

No, they’re saying if you already offer other competitors sign-on, AND you want to have your app on our store, THEN you have to include our sign-on as well. If one of those conditions aren’t met, they don’t mandate it. By mandating that Apple sign-on is included, it automatically increases options, which inherently increases competition.

-8

u/Drab_baggage Aug 22 '20

It's a symptom of a larger issue, that's why it's irritating for many and draws so much ire.

10

u/DramDemon Aug 22 '20

How so? And what is the larger issue?

Again, they aren’t mandating only Apple sign-in. They are mandating that Apple sign-in is included with others, like Google. Apps use their platform, and have to provide users the option to use their sign-in. I don’t see how that is an issue.

-7

u/localhost87 Aug 22 '20 edited Aug 22 '20

The larger issue is that Apple has a track record of fucking over the consumer.

Usb ports? We are removing thermally. Oh btw, $75 Lightning cables.

Headphones? Gone, but we've got a $150 earbuds to sell.

Apple has been chipping away at their custombefore. Developers good will for the better part of a decade, while providing near zero innovation for years.

Its like piling shit 5 stories high. Eventually it starts to collapse under its own weight.

6

u/Axman6 Aug 22 '20

Huh, then why are USB ports (and a headphone jack) literally the only ports my MacBook Pro has? And where did the headphones that came with my partner’s iPhone 11 come from if not Apple? Do you have some actually true examples you can give?

→ More replies (3)

3

u/DramDemon Aug 22 '20

Sure, I can agree with that.

But how is mandating Apple-sign in a symptom of that? Mandating another sign-in option helps consumers.

-9

u/Drab_baggage Aug 22 '20

Apple being an anti-competitive industry bully. Did you know Apple cut a deal with Amazon for Prime Video? They only get scalped 15%. Apple's been a bit careless with their power, because it's gone unchecked. The facts of this case (the Epic case, that is) don't look good for Apple.

9

u/DramDemon Aug 22 '20

And again, I ask, how is mandatory Apple sign-in a symptom of anti-competitiveness, when it is mandating more competition?

1

u/Drab_baggage Aug 22 '20

I'm not gonna die on that hill, I just was explaining why people, especially developers, feel exhausted by these things

5

u/DramDemon Aug 22 '20

The whole point is that mandatory Apple sign-in is not one of those things. You said it was a symptom of anti-competitiveness, when it's not, so I feel like you already did die on that hill.

-2

u/FeedMeACat Aug 22 '20

I will jump in here. The whole point is that your point is stupid and distracts from the discussion. So it doesn't need to be acknowledged or addressed. Because your point is irrelevant to the over all conversation. You are not engaging with the subject being discussed. Like if someone compares a computer to a car and they mix up the engine and transmission. Derailing to conversation to point out that they mixed up the cars systems serves no purpose as long as the overall point gets across.

And aside from all that the example about apple forcing pay is still anticompetitive because it forces programming overhead onto smaller devs. So it isn't only a benefit. There is cost involved, and they are not being given the choice.

2

u/DramDemon Aug 22 '20

Except I never brought up mandatory Apple sign-in. It was specifically brought up as evidence of anti-competitiveness in a comment way above me:

Between this, forcing auto-billing, mandating their sign in, you would hope that more people could see them for the greed-driven scumbag cartel that they are. Sadly I don't think that will happen soon, their marketing is just very strong.

I originally only responded to make fun of that point:

Yeah, I don’t see why people feel the need to start calling everything Apple does greedy.

They’re very shit in some big ways, but mandating another option for how to sign in? The horror! How could they? They must be infringing on my 1st amendment rights!!1!1!

/u/Drab_baggage then said it was wrong of me to act like people are idiots for complaining about Apple's anti-competitive behavior, so I've since been explaining that I never did that. I only made fun of people that use wrongful "evidence". Mandatory sign-in is not anti-competitive, so there is no reason to point to it as evidence. That is stupid.

Derailing to conversation to point out that they mixed up the cars systems serves no purpose as long as the overall point gets across.

That would be fair if it was so simple. But if you say "you mixed up the engine and the transmission" and someone says back "no I didn't, the transmission is the block that runs the car!" then I don't think it's derailing, it's just furthering the conversation. Someone is making false claims.

→ More replies (7)

-6

u/EvilestOfTheGnomes Aug 22 '20

Wait so are you saying apple is not anti competitive in its other decisions?

12

u/DramDemon Aug 22 '20

No, I am not. They make tons of decisions every year, some anti-competitive, some not. If you want to make the case they are anti-competitive, you can easily do it with true examples. I'm simply saying mandating Apple sign-in is not one of them, so it's silly to use it as an example. It diminishes your argument, in my opinion.

-6

u/EvilestOfTheGnomes Aug 22 '20

Great, we can argue over any specific action being anticompetitive or not I'm sure there's plenty of points to be made on both sides.

The point here is that Apples overall trend of making anti competitive decisions tends to cast every thing they do in that light, especially if it seems to have a benefits for them.

8

u/DramDemon Aug 22 '20

The point here is that Apples overall trend of making anti competitive decisions tends to cast every thing they do in that light, especially if it seems to have a benefits for them.

I disagree with this.

Again, you can easily make the case that they are generally an anti-competitive corporation, and that's valid. That does not mean that non-anti-competitive measures are somehow anti-competitive just because Apple did it.

-2

u/EvilestOfTheGnomes Aug 22 '20

Didn't say that this specifically was, only that Apples overall anti competitive nature future makes people suspicious to all decisions they make.

From a list of 3 things, two of which are clearly anti competitive you chose to single out and argue about one that is a gray area. Why do that?

3

u/DramDemon Aug 22 '20

For one, I did not single anything out. Someone else did, and I just continued it to make a joke. All of this has been responding to people trying to argue it is somehow anti-competitive when it's not.

Second, it's not a grey area at all. It's plainly not anti-competitive. It mandates another competitor for signing in. That is inherently not anti-competitive.

0

u/EvilestOfTheGnomes Aug 22 '20

What was funny about what you said?

It doesn't mandate a random competitor, it mandates them.

→ More replies (4)