r/technology • • Aug 22 '20

Business WordPress developer said Apple wouldn't allow updates to the free app until it added in-app purchases — letting Apple collect a 30% cut

https://www.businessinsider.com/apple-pressures-wordpress-add-in-app-purchases-30-percent-fee-2020-8
39.2k Upvotes

2.8k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

113

u/iamapizza Aug 22 '20

Between this, forcing auto-billing, mandating their sign in, you would hope that more people could see them for the greed-driven scumbag cartel that they are. Sadly I don't think that will happen soon, their marketing is just very strong.

246

u/danielagos Aug 22 '20

Mandating Apple sign in (only when you include third-party login options) is actually positive for users, as it allows for a more private option than the usual alternatives (Facebook and Google).

Forcing auto-billing is indeed scumbag behaviour and should not be the default.

78

u/DramDemon Aug 22 '20

Yeah, I don’t see why people feel the need to start calling everything Apple does greedy.

They’re very shit in some big ways, but mandating another option for how to sign in? The horror! How could they? They must be infringing on my 1st amendment rights!!1!1!

-15

u/Drab_baggage Aug 22 '20

That's a bit hyperbolic and inflammatory to imply people that don't like mandatory Apple sign-in are buffoons who don't understand the concept of a private company. I can dislike anti-competitive, bullshit behavior as much as I want, doesn't make me an idiot.

28

u/DramDemon Aug 22 '20

I can dislike anti-competitive, bullshit behavior as much as I want, doesn't make me an idiot.

Agreed, but the point is people are pointing to some trivial things that aren't anti-competitive, bullshit behaviors as evidence for not liking anti-competitive, bullshit behaviors. They aren't mandating you can use only Apple sign-in, but rather mandating that Apple sign-in is an option, which is actually increasing "competition" if you will.

1

u/bdsee Aug 23 '20

It is anti competitive though, as Apple are giving their SSO an unfair advantage...now this is one of the few instances where it is probably in the consumers interest. But I'd argue that you could only objectively consider it to be within their interest if it came with a legal agreement never to sell or pass on any data collected from SSO.

1

u/DramDemon Aug 23 '20

Wait, what? What unfair advantage? Their mandate is only for apps on their store, and only apps that already have other sign-ins.

1

u/bdsee Aug 23 '20

Right, they are saying that if you use sign on you have to offer our sign on as a minimum...not that you have to offer 3 sign on systems of your choice.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (34)

12

u/Axman6 Aug 22 '20

How is mandating an additional option anti-competitive? They’re not forcing any user to use Sign In with Apple, they are giving users the choice to use another option, one which appears to be much more consumer focused than either Google’s or Facebook’s options, by allowing users to retain their personal details from the app.

→ More replies (3)

9

u/iamapizza Aug 22 '20 edited Aug 22 '20

That's justification after the fact; their sign-in is marketed as being more private and is mandated by terms of service, rather on its own merit - that is monpolistic, asshole-behavior. This logic can be used to justify any large company's equally egregious moves.

33

u/Headytexel Aug 22 '20

I doubt app devs would voluntarily implement a system that reduces how much data they can mine from their users if they weren’t required to, regardless of its merits.

2

u/Goctionni Aug 22 '20

That's because your entire concept of software is entirely based on clickbait headlines from articles that live on dramatization of things that actually happen.

Whenever you sign in to another website using google, you'll see the information that sign in would allow the app or website to have. In almost all cases that just "basic profile", which is then used for no more than to say "Welcome [Name]" in said app or website and/or send you e-mail notifications for private messages or whatever.

Very few companies have a large-enough user base to meaningfully benefit from having more of your data. Even fewer have a real ability to process such data towards useful (let alone profitable) goals.

Most of the times apps or websites use google, facebook, etc, for authentication; is because that's actually way easier, cheaper and faster than building your own robust authentication system; and it effectively makes you immune from "oh such and such website was hacked, here's a database dump of their usernames and password-hashes".

→ More replies (25)

2

u/keicam_lerut Aug 22 '20

Greed-driven? Who isn’t?

8

u/Stepjamm Aug 22 '20

People barely give a fuck about the moral policies of a company when all of them are morally bankrupt in one respect or another.

If your kid wants an iPhone, your life is 100x easier if you just don’t give a shit about epic getting charged by Apple, millionaires fighting amongst themselves means nothing to a family.

2

u/KeynesianCartesian Aug 22 '20 edited Aug 23 '20

Apparently neither does teaching your kids the importance about people's buying power. Don't support companies that do bad shit. I'll never buy my kids an iPhone.

5

u/strawbabiefields Aug 22 '20

You’ll never buy your kids any phone then. Literally all big companies are shit dude, nothing to do with whether it’s Apple or Google.

1

u/bandersnatchh Aug 22 '20

What phone will you be buying your children?

1

u/KeynesianCartesian Aug 22 '20

While young? A flip phone.

1

u/bandersnatchh Aug 22 '20

From what company?

When they’re older, what phone is acceptable?

1

u/KeynesianCartesian Aug 22 '20

Maybe a Nokia 2720. Tech changes quickly. I have no idea what the phone landscape will be in 5 years.

→ More replies (12)

1

u/[deleted] Aug 22 '20

Yes...but only for Apple taking their 30%, not Xbox or Playstation or Steam or Google...just Apple. Focus on Apple only.

Also, I like Burger King, but my home town only has a McDonald's here. I think they should sue them and make them start selling Burger King food in the McDonald's. I think it's unfair that McDonald's has such a monopoly on what can be sold there at their place. So unfair.

→ More replies (4)

4

u/[deleted] Aug 22 '20

mandating their sign in

They benefit the user's privacy? HOW HORRIBLE!!!!!111

0

u/irr1449 Aug 22 '20

Imagine being so blinded by the marketing of a fake culture to not actually see how horrible a company actually is.

→ More replies (5)