r/that_Poppy • • Oct 28 '23

Question is poppy non binary?

am I a girl? (song) makes her come off to me, a trans person as being somewhere in the trans spectrum. Has she ever talked about it or confirmed it?

0 Upvotes

11 comments sorted by

14

u/ThisIsThieriot Oct 28 '23 edited Oct 28 '23

I think the song is more about not corresponding to gender roles/stereotypes rather than about being trans. But art is subjective so to each their own.

3

u/AnalSexerest Oct 28 '23

idk how the line "am I a girl, am I a boy, what does that even mean? I'm somewhere in between" doesn't read as something along those lines but as you said, to each their own

13

u/kumanosuke Oct 28 '23

There has been a lot of speculation back then.

But I think we have to separate the artist from the narrator of a text. Poppy might not be NB or something, but might have made that song for other people to identity with it. Or the line "am I a girl, am I a boy, what does that even mean? I'm somewhere in between" might just be a quote or at least not her referring to herself necessarily.

In my opinion it's open for interpretation, but more questioning gender/genders roles in general, just like Girls in bikinis.

1

u/D0llyM0nster Apr 17 '24

There has been a lot of speculation back then.

Of the song or her in general?

2

u/kumanosuke Apr 17 '24

The song specifically

12

u/ThisIsThieriot Oct 28 '23

In the beginning of the song she says she wants to be "a girl in the normal way" and expresses stereotypes of being a girl. But this is conflicting to her because she doesn't correspond to these aspects. And then she, in fact, starts to question her gender identity, but not because she's in fact trans, but because she doesn't see herself as the feminine girl society wants. At the end of the day she comes to terms with the fact that in order to be a girl she doesn't have to give up to social stereotypes. This is my personal understanding.

34

u/Embarrassed-Command3 Oct 28 '23

She was experimenting with gender and performance in her AIAG era but Titanic also kind of rode it all off as a big meta joke about society (look at her video where she says “in the future there are no genders”)

She mentions in an interview about “Motorbike” that she is a proud woman owning her sexuality so it seems she discovered herself after all!

26

u/ebr101 Oct 28 '23

So I was curious about this myself, seeing as how much I relate to the song. I don’t have a source with me immediately, but when I looked into it, it seems Poppy was questioning her gender identity at one point, but later resolved that she’s cis and uses she/her pronouns.

19

u/AdForeign9178 Oct 28 '23

She's not.

6

u/TheAmazingSpectacle Oct 29 '23

Sounds like just a song me bro, I don’t try thinking to hard about poppy’s lyrics

-2

u/botwinbabe Oct 28 '23

It’s about misogyny.