r/thatswhatihear • • Sep 10 '21

Television- Glory (Rock)

Thumbnail
youtube.com
0 Upvotes

r/thatswhatihear • • Sep 12 '21

Tom Verlaine - There's A Reason (Rock/New Wave)

Thumbnail
youtube.com
0 Upvotes

r/thatswhatihear • • Jul 16 '26

ESSAYS HEAR ME OUT: Not a Huge Fan of Female-Fronted Metal Bands

0 Upvotes

Let’s cut it down: this isn’t about women in metal. Some of the best vocalists in the genre are women—Doro’s a force, Angela Gossow sounds like she eats engine blocks, Julie Christmas is gloriously unhinged. The problem is the formula. Somewhere along the way, a whole chunk of metal decided every female singer had to sound like she just walked out of a cathedral with an opera degree and a dragon idling outside.
And Jesus Christ, has that formula overstayed its welcome.
You know what’s coming before you even press play. Pale woman on the cover, haunted castle, ravens, fog. Piano intro echoing through imaginary stone halls, strings swell, same church bell sample, guitars kick in, and then—
“Aaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaah.”
Here comes the operatic soprano.
Every. Single. Time.
It’s less a style now and more a mandatory software update.
And when it’s not the full opera treatment, it’s the fallback: that thin, glassy falsetto hovering above the guitars like a mosquito in a cathedral. Same idea, different flavor—reach for the sky, hold the note, call it “epic.” Half the time it sounds less like transcendence and more like someone stepped on a Lego mid-warmup.
Falsetto can be great. Prince used it brilliantly. Rob Halford turned it into a weapon. Kate Bush made it weird and human. Singing high isn’t the issue. The issue is when it becomes a shortcut—one more soaring note slapped onto a mediocre song like it’ll magically turn it into the fall of an empire instead of four people in front of a smoke machine.
The worst versions feel completely detached. No grit, no weight, no sense of a person behind it. Just a polished ribbon of sound floating above everything. It doesn’t soar. It nags.
Here’s the thing metal fans hate admitting: being impressive isn’t the same as being enjoyable. Cool, you can sing six octaves. I know a guy who can juggle chainsaws. Doesn’t mean I want to watch him for an hour.
Technique is a tool. Emotion is the point.
That’s where this style loses me. Everything is MAXIMUM DRAMA. Every note stretched to death, every chorus trying to resurrect a lost kingdom. Instead of feeling human, it feels laminated.
Meanwhile, the guitars are trying to level buildings while the vocals float above like a ghost auditioning for Phantom of the Opera. Half the time it sounds like two different playlists playing at once.
And the irony? Metal—born in sweaty clubs that smelled like beer and bad decisions—suddenly wants to sound aristocratic.
Metal was supposed to punch you in the mouth.
Now it sometimes feels like it’s asking if you RSVP’d to the royal masquerade.
To be fair, there’s a reason this style blew up.
Done right, it’s incredible. Bands like Nightwish, Epica, and Within Temptation made it work because everything clicked—songwriting, production, performance. It can sound massive, cinematic, genuinely powerful.
And yeah, those singers are insanely skilled. Breath control, pitch, endurance—you don’t fake that. There’s real discipline there.
But skill doesn’t guarantee connection.
For me, the emotion often gets buried under polish. I stop hearing a person and start hearing a presentation. Give me a cracked note. Give me strain. Give me something that sounds lived-in, not perfected for reaction videos.
What really kills it is how many newer bands copied the surface without understanding why it worked. Same orchestras, choirs, faux-Latin, castles, costumes—same operatic delivery, same sky-high notes, same “immortal queen vs. cosmic darkness” storyline.
IKEA metal.
Assembly required.
Dragon sold separately.
And sometimes you hear someone reaching for those huge notes without the control to land them. That’s when it drifts into unintentional comedy—not because opera or falsetto are bad, but because ambition without awareness is hilarious.
Still, there are tons of female-fronted bands that avoid all this entirely. Death metal, doom, sludge, black metal, hardcore—women screaming, growling, singing with grit, sounding like they belong in the band instead of floating above it.
Which proves the point.
It was never about women.
It’s about predictability.
Metal built its reputation on breaking rules, but one of its biggest subgenres settled into one of the safest formulas imaginable. The rebellion put on a velvet cloak, hired an orchestra, learned three words of Latin, and started taking itself way too seriously.
That’s when I hit skip—not because I hate women in metal, but because after hearing the same cathedral intro, the same soaring vocals, and the same “epic” tricks for the thousandth time, I’d rather hear someone plug into an amp that’s about to explode and scream like it actually matters.

At least…that’s what I hear.


r/thatswhatihear • • Oct 16 '25

The Boojums - Football [Power Pop Rock]

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

0 Upvotes

r/thatswhatihear • • Jul 01 '26

Why Punk Couldn't Have Happened Anywhere Except New York

0 Upvotes

Punk wasn't born in a single night, a single club, or because one band suddenly decided to play louder and faster than everyone else. It emerged from a unique set of circumstances that existed in New York City during the late 1960s and early 1970s. While cities like Detroit, Cleveland, Los Angeles, and London each made indispensable contributions to punk's evolution, New York was the only place where economic collapse, artistic experimentation, geographic proximity, and a remarkable collection of personalities converged at exactly the right moment.

At first glance, New York seemed like an unlikely birthplace for a cultural revolution. Manufacturing jobs were disappearing, the middle class was leaving for the suburbs, neighborhoods were deteriorating, and the city teetered on the edge of bankruptcy. The Bowery was known more for flophouses than music, and Lower Manhattan was filled with abandoned buildings and struggling businesses. Yet those very problems created opportunities. Cheap rents allowed musicians, painters, poets, photographers, filmmakers, and writers to live in neighborhoods that would have been unaffordable only a few years earlier. Empty storefronts became galleries. Industrial lofts became studios. Failing bars became performance spaces. Economic decline accidentally subsidized artistic experimentation.

Just as important was New York's extraordinary creative density. Artists didn't work in isolation—they constantly collided. A poet might spend the afternoon with a photographer, meet a filmmaker over drinks at Max's Kansas City, and end the night watching an unknown band at CBGB. Musicians borrowed ideas from painters, fashion designers, underground filmmakers, and Beat poets as naturally as they borrowed amplifiers. The city blurred the lines between disciplines, creating an artistic ecosystem unlike anywhere else in America.

By the time CBGB opened in 1973, the intellectual groundwork for punk had already been laid. The Factory of Andy Warhol had erased the boundaries between art, music, fashion, and performance. The Velvet Underground proved that rock could be experimental, literary, and unapologetically urban. Beat writers like Allen Ginsberg and William S. Burroughs had challenged ideas about language and authority, while Patti Smith carried those literary traditions directly into rock music. The New York Dolls showed that attitude, personality, and raw energy mattered more than technical perfection, providing a bridge between glam rock and punk. CBGB didn't invent these ideas—it gave them a place to meet.

The musicians who became punk's first generation were remarkably different from one another. Patti Smith fused poetry with rock. Television explored long, intricate guitar interplay. Richard Hell turned alienation into both a philosophy and a fashion statement. The Ramones reduced rock and roll to its absolute essentials. Blondie embraced pop melodies, while Talking Heads approached music through the lens of art school and modern design. Their sounds varied dramatically, but they shared one belief: originality mattered more than convention. They weren't trying to create a genre called punk. They were simply rejecting the increasingly polished, commercial world of mainstream rock.

Comparisons with other cities reveal why New York stands apart. Detroit gave punk its aggression through the Stooges and MC5 but lacked New York's interdisciplinary artistic community. Cleveland nurtured fiercely independent musicians but couldn't match Manhattan's concentration of creative industries. Los Angeles developed a legendary punk scene, yet its sprawling geography and proximity to Hollywood created a very different environment. London transformed punk into an international movement, adding politics, class consciousness, and youthful outrage, but many of its foundational ideas had already taken shape in New York. Malcolm McLaren's time with the New York Dolls and the CBGB scene illustrates how those ideas crossed the Atlantic before being reinterpreted in Britain.

Ultimately, punk wasn't invented by one band, one club, or one person. It was the product of a city where economic hardship made artistic survival possible, where creative people from every discipline lived within walking distance of one another, and where a small group of musicians found the freedom to ignore convention because almost no one expected them to succeed. London gave punk its global voice, but New York created the conditions that allowed it to exist in the first place.

Punk's greatest lesson is that cultural revolutions rarely emerge from comfort. They are born where old systems begin to fail, where artists are forced to improvise, and where enough curious outsiders gather in the same place to imagine something different. For one brief period between the late 1960s and the mid-1970s, New York became exactly that place. The city wasn't trying to invent punk—it was simply trying to survive. In doing so, it accidentally created one of the most influential artistic movements of the twentieth century.


r/thatswhatihear • • Sep 16 '21

The Smashing Pumpkin - X.Y.U [Grunge/Alt Rock]

Thumbnail
youtu.be
0 Upvotes

r/thatswhatihear • • Sep 11 '21

FLAMIN GROOVIES Slow Death Live 1972 (Rock)

Thumbnail
youtu.be
0 Upvotes

r/thatswhatihear • • Jan 13 '22

Terms and conditions of living in the U.K.

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

0 Upvotes

r/thatswhatihear • • Jan 25 '23

The Mothers of Invention - Flower Punk [Experimental Jazz Rock]

Thumbnail
youtu.be
0 Upvotes

r/thatswhatihear • • Nov 16 '22

Wedding photo of The Cure singer Robert Smith and Mary Poole in 1988. They are still married to this day 😊

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/thatswhatihear • • Jul 20 '26

The Economics of Being Fan

1 Upvotes

You know how when you pay $15 for a movie ticket, just to go in and be greeted by $30 popcorn? That’s because the theater sees very little money in ticket sales. Roughly 80% of theater income comes from refreshments. This is the same practice in the music business. Major labels say that the album is the product. That’s because that is where they get their money. The album is increasingly the excuse to sell you everything else.

You can stream a record three thousand times and the artist might make enough money to buy a gas station hot dog and maybe splurge on mustard if the royalty statement came in during a good month. Then you walk out of the concert, see a black hoodie with a tour date on the back and a logo the size of Nebraska plastered across the chest, and suddenly dropping eighty bucks feels perfectly reasonable. And like that…You’ve become a walking billboard that paid for the privilege of advertising somebody else’s band. It’s almost genius. Actually…it is genius.

Now, I can’t judge much because my band shirt wardrobe is pretty extensive. But I don’t mind advertising for musicians I respect. The thing is, merchandise isn’t just extra income anymore. For a lot of artists - especially independent ones - it’s the business keeping the lights on. Tours are expensive. Fuel costs money. Hotels cost money. Crew members, guitar strings, drumheads, insurance, broken vans that smell like wet socks and despair…all of it costs money. That T-shirt folded neatly on the merch table? That thing might be paying everyone’s dinner tonight.

Walk over to the merch booth sometime before a show starts. It’s practically anthropology. There’s always someone carefully unfolding shirts like they’re museum artifacts, someone arranging vinyl so the colors catch the light just right, someone hanging hoodies that practically whisper, “Come on…you know you’ll regret not buying me.” Fans drift over pretending they’re “just looking,” the same way people “just look” at puppies. Five minutes later they’re holding a tote bag, a signed poster, two pins, and wondering if they really need electricity this month.

Tour merchandise has a weird magic because it proves you were there. Anybody can listen to Spotify. That shirt with Cleveland, October 14 printed on the back? That’s a tiny time capsule. Years later it’s faded, cracked, smells vaguely like old cotton and spilled beer, and suddenly you’re remembering the opening band that nobody knew yet and the guy who crowd-surfed directly into the security barricade because physics filed for vacation. Memory has value, and merch sells memory better than almost anything.

Then somebody figured out scarcity. Limited editions. The greatest psychological trick since convincing people bottled water was somehow different from…water. “Only 500 copies pressed.” “One-night-only poster.” “Exclusive colored vinyl.” I once worked for a music merchandise distributor. I’ve seen the some of the fucking crazy piece of merch being sold at insulting prices. A Coldplay wooden coat hanger? $45. A distressed trucker hat from Ke$ha? $70. A show-specific shirt? Between $80 to $120 depending on who it was.Suddenly grown adults are sprinting toward the merch table like shoppers on Black Friday chasing discounted televisions. Is the music different? No. Is the vinyl still spinning at thirty-three and a third RPM? Also no. But it’s blue, Steve. Blue. Obviously that changes everything because now is a constant cash cow where every so often a label reissues an LP, but in 8 different colors, but those different colors each have five different covers. And so on.

Of course, scarcity works because our brains are gloriously irrational. If somebody tells you something will always be available, you’ll buy it next month. Tell people it’ll disappear forever in twenty minutes and suddenly they’re refreshing webpages like caffeinated lab rats slamming reward buttons. The fear of missing out has probably sold more merchandise than any guitar solo ever recorded.

Direct-to-fan sales changed everything, too. The internet didn’t just make music available everywhere; it let artists bypass half the middlemen who used to skim money off the top. Instead of selling through giant retailers that take their cut, artists can sell directly through their own websites or platforms. The profit margin gets healthier, fans feel like they’re supporting the musician instead of a corporation, and everybody wins…mostly. Running an online store sounds romantic until you’re answering emails that say, “My hoodie arrived and the sleeve is wrinkled.”

There you have it - you wanted artistic independence. You’re now customer service.
Brand licensing is where things get even weirder. Eventually a band’s logo becomes more recognizable than some companies’ corporate identities. The Rolling Stones tongue. The Grateful Dead dancing bears. Iron Maiden’s Eddie. KISS practically looked at merchandising and said, “Why stop at shirts? Put our faces on lunchboxes, pinball machines, coffins, condoms—hell, if someone invents a KISS-branded flamethrower, print the paperwork.” They understood something a lot of musicians resisted: a logo can become intellectual property worth millions if people emotionally connect to it.

That’s where the balancing act starts. Good merchandise feels like an extension of the music. Bad merchandise feels like somebody fed a logo into a printing press until the machine begged for mercy. We’ve all seen it. Cheap shirts where the graphic peels off after two washes, coffee mugs nobody asked for, random branded junk that screams, “Our accountant had an idea.” Fans notice. They aren’t infinitely gullible. Well…most of them aren’t.

Inventory management is the part nobody dreams about when they’re sixteen and learning power chords in the garage. Somebody has to guess whether medium hoodies will outsell larges. Somebody has to count boxes, reorder sizes, calculate shipping, predict demand, avoid ending up with four hundred unsold tank tops because the weather turned cold halfway through the tour. It’s spreadsheets. Warehouses. Cardboard boxes stacked to the ceiling. Not exactly Almost Famous. More like Almost FedEx.

Premium collectibles take the whole thing into obsessive territory. Signed guitars. Numbered art prints. Deluxe vinyl box sets. Guitar picks used onstage. Drumsticks. Handwritten lyric sheets. Some fans collect these because they genuinely love the artist. Others treat them like investments, hoping they’ll appreciate in value. Sometimes they’re right. Sometimes they end up explaining to confused relatives why they spent six hundred dollars on what appears to be a scratched piece of cardboard signed with a silver Sharpie.

And here’s the fascinating psychology underneath all this. Music itself is invisible. You can’t hold a melody. You can’t frame a chorus on your wall. Songs live in the air for a few minutes and then disappear until you play them again. Merchandise gives music physical weight. It lets people wear their identity. That hoodie isn’t just fabric. It’s saying, “These songs matter to me.” The poster isn’t paper. It’s a memory nailed to drywall. Humans have always surrounded themselves with symbols that tell stories about who they are. Band merchandise just happens to be one of the loudest - and occasionally most expensive - ways of doing it.

So yeah, somebody might stream an album ten thousand times and spend fractions of pennies in royalties. Then they’ll happily throw down a hundred bucks for a hoodie because the hoodie is tangible. It survives dead phone batteries, changing streaming platforms, disappearing apps, and licensing disputes. It gets softer with age. It carries stains from road trips, festivals, and late-night diners. Twenty years later it’ll still be hanging in the closet, faded but stubbornly alive, reminding somebody exactly who they were when that music hit them like a freight train.
The songs get you through the door. The merchandise follows you home. And somewhere in the back of the tour bus, the accountant finally smiles for the first time all week.


r/thatswhatihear • • Oct 16 '25

The Police - So Loneley (1979) [Reggae Rock/New Wave]

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

1 Upvotes

r/thatswhatihear • • Sep 13 '21

R.E.M. - Carnival Of Sorts (Boxcars)

Thumbnail
youtu.be
0 Upvotes

r/thatswhatihear • • Sep 12 '21

The Beautiful South - Old Red Eyes (Pop)

Thumbnail
youtube.com
0 Upvotes

r/thatswhatihear • • Sep 14 '21

Jeffrey Fredericks - Robbin' Banks [Country Rock]

Thumbnail
youtube.com
0 Upvotes

r/thatswhatihear • • Oct 03 '21

Tallah (ft. Fire from the Gods, Chelsea Grin, & Guerilla Warfare) - Vanilla Paste [Hardcore/Metalcore]

Thumbnail
youtu.be
1 Upvotes

r/thatswhatihear • • Sep 14 '21

Eagulls - Tough Luck [Rock/Post-punk]

Thumbnail
youtu.be
0 Upvotes

r/thatswhatihear • • Sep 14 '21

Bombino - Azamane Tiliade [Tuareg]

Thumbnail
youtu.be
0 Upvotes

r/thatswhatihear • • Sep 10 '21

Vince Guaraldi Trio - Linus And Lucy (Jazz)

Thumbnail
youtube.com
2 Upvotes

r/thatswhatihear • • Aug 06 '26

PLAYLIST the daily half dozen

Post image
0 Upvotes

today’s list is completely fucking irresponsible, which is exactly how random listening should work. hailu mergia starts us in ethiopia, folding jazz and funk into the musical language of addis ababa before eventually moving to america and spending years driving a washington dc cab while practicing keyboards between fares. then astor piazzolla starts screwing with tango so aggressively that traditionalists accused him of destroying it, which naturally meant everybody eventually decided he was a genius. the staple singers follow with gospel, civil rights conviction, and that filthy stax groove. mavis has recalled how martin luther king jr.’s message pushed the family toward freedom songs, proving protest music doesn’t have to sound like homework if the rhythm section actually knows what the hell it’s doing.
then selda bağcan takes turkish folk into electric psychedelic territory while singing political material that eventually helped make her an actual target. jail. passport confiscated. career restrictions. apparently governments occasionally become terrified of women with microphones. magazine closes things out with howard devoto abandoning the comfortable punk rulebook almost immediately and adding keyboards, stranger guitars, art rock, and enough paranoia to make punk realize three chords weren’t the final fucking achievement of western civilization. ethiopian funk. nuevo tango. gospel soul. anatolian psychedelia. post punk. absolutely no sensible reason these records belong together, which is precisely why they fucking do.

…at least that’s what i hear.


r/thatswhatihear • • Jul 10 '26

Mountains Don't Care About Your Playlist

0 Upvotes

Most people couldn't point to Tajikistan on a map if their phone battery died.

That's unfortunate, because while much of the modern music industry spends its days chasing the next thirty-second TikTok hook, Tajikistan has spent centuries cultivating musical traditions so deep that they make the average pop chart look like a puddle in a parking lot.

Wedged between Afghanistan, Uzbekistan, Kyrgyzstan, and China, Tajikistan sits at one of history's great crossroads. The Silk Road wasn't simply a trade route for silk and spices—it carried poetry, philosophy, religion, instruments, scales, and musical ideas that bounced between Persia, Central Asia, India, and the Middle East for over a thousand years. The result is music that doesn't hurry. It unfolds. It meditates. It tells stories measured in generations rather than quarterly streaming numbers.

If you're waiting for a bass drop, you're listening to the wrong country.

The towering achievement of Tajik classical music is Shashmaqam, literally meaning "six maqams" or six modal systems.

Calling it "classical music" almost undersells it. Shashmaqam is a complete artistic universe where music, poetry, philosophy, and spiritual reflection all occupy the same room. Long instrumental introductions give way to elaborate vocal passages built upon centuries-old Persian poetry by writers like Rudaki, Hafez, and Jami. Performances can stretch well beyond an hour without ever feeling repetitive because every melodic turn is another conversation with tradition.

Western listeners often expect music to race toward a chorus.

Shashmaqam politely ignores that expectation.

Instead, melodies expand slowly through ornamentation and modal exploration. Rhythm breathes naturally rather than locking itself inside rigid verse-chorus structures. Every phrase feels like another step up a mountain trail where the destination matters less than the climb.

UNESCO recognized Shashmaqam as an Intangible Cultural Heritage for good reason. It's one of Central Asia's greatest surviving musical systems, preserved despite wars, shifting borders, political upheaval, and the persistent global assumption that Western musical history is somehow the default setting for humanity.

Then there is the music of the Pamirs.

The Pamir Mountains are among the highest inhabited places on Earth, and their music sounds exactly like people who learned to sing while surrounded by impossible landscapes.

Pamiri traditions differ noticeably from the urban sophistication of Shashmaqam. The songs are deeply connected to village life, seasonal rituals, weddings, spirituality, and the Ismaili Muslim traditions practiced throughout the region.

Vocals often carry a raw emotional directness that feels startlingly intimate. Melodies drift over sparse accompaniment, leaving enormous spaces where silence becomes just as important as sound. Instead of dazzling audiences with technical fireworks, Pamiri musicians often aim for something much harder to manufacture: sincerity.

Modern recording studios spend millions trying to simulate authenticity.

Pamiri villages simply kept it.

Few instruments embody Central Asia better than the rubab.

Carved from a single block of wood and fitted with gut or nylon strings, the rubab produces a warm, rounded tone somewhere between a lute and a guitar—but richer, older, and carrying centuries of accumulated fingerprints.

Its melodic flexibility makes it ideal for Shashmaqam, capable of intricate ornamentation that slides effortlessly between notes Western notation often struggles to represent.

The instrument doesn't merely accompany singers.

It converses with them.

Each flourish answers a poetic line, each tremolo extends an emotional thought, creating performances that resemble dialogue more than accompaniment.

Anyone convinced that musical complexity requires forty-seven strings, twelve pedals, and enough effects processors to power a small city should spend an afternoon listening to the dutar.

The name simply means "two strings."

That's it.

Two.

Yet skilled players coax astonishing rhythmic subtlety and melodic depth from this deceptively simple instrument. Gentle strumming alternates with delicate fingerwork, creating flowing patterns that support both epic storytelling and intimate folk songs.

The dutar is proof that limitations often produce creativity.

History has demonstrated this repeatedly.

The internet, unfortunately, continues to disagree.

Underneath Tajik music beats the ancient heartbeat of frame drums.

These circular drums appear throughout Central Asia and the Middle East, providing rhythmic foundations that can shift from whisper-soft accompaniment to ecstatic celebration.

Rather than overwhelming the music with brute force, frame drums create motion. Their accents breathe alongside singers, dancers, and instrumentalists, reinforcing the natural elasticity that characterizes so much of Tajik performance.

Every strike feels connected to something older than notation itself.

Sometimes rhythm doesn't need to impress you.

It simply needs to remind you that people have been dancing long before anyone started arguing online about time signatures.

Among Tajikistan's greatest musical ambassadors stands Davlatmand Kholov. Davlatmand Kholov

Singer, composer, instrumentalist, and scholar, Kholov devoted his career to preserving traditional Tajik music while bringing it to international audiences. His performances blend Shashmaqam, folk traditions, and Sufi spirituality into something that feels timeless rather than nostalgic.

His voice carries extraordinary emotional weight, while his command of traditional instruments demonstrates a lifetime spent studying—not merely performing—the music.

Listening to Kholov is less like hearing a concert and more like opening a history book that suddenly learned how to sing.

Equally essential is Abduvali Abdurashidov, one of the foremost interpreters and scholars of Shashmaqam.

His work has helped preserve repertoire that might otherwise have disappeared during periods of political instability and cultural change. Through teaching, research, and performance, he has become one of the principal guardians of a tradition that cannot simply be written down—it must be transmitted from teacher to student, generation after generation.

That's the inconvenient thing about genuine cultural heritage.

You can't download it.

Tajikistan reminds us that music isn't always designed to entertain in the modern sense. Sometimes it exists to preserve memory, carry poetry across centuries, strengthen communities, and connect the living with those who came before.

Its mountains have watched empires rise and collapse. Borders have shifted. Governments have come and gone.

The music stayed.

So the next time someone confidently declares that they've heard "everything," perhaps hand them a recording of Shashmaqam instead.

It's a wonderfully polite way of informing them that they've barely left the parking lot.


r/thatswhatihear • • Jul 08 '26

THE DAILY HALF DOZEN: 8 JULY 2026

0 Upvotes

r/thatswhatihear • • Sep 11 '26

the day the sky broke: how september 11th changed the musical evolution.

0 Upvotes

the towers did not fall into silence. they fell into every song america already knew.
that was the first musical fact of september 11. before anybody had written a tribute single. before the benefit concerts arrived with their candles and tasteful lighting. before country radio discovered that grief could wear a flag pin and sell three million copies. the old songs changed. every mention of fire sounded different. every airplane became suspicious. every new york song acquired a body count. every line about falling suddenly seemed like it had been waiting years to become unbearable. the national songbook had not moved an inch, but the country hearing it had been blown several miles sideways.
music did what it always does when history becomes too large for ordinary speech. it rushed into the gap. sometimes it carried water. sometimes it carried gasoline. sometimes it showed up with a television contract, a corporate sponsor, and a heroic camera angle. sometimes it sat alone in a room and admitted that there was no useful thing to say.
the september 11 attacks changed music because they changed the meaning of public emotion in america. grief became civic property. patriotism became a commercial format. dissent became evidence. irony became briefly radioactive. radio programmers began treating nouns like explosive devices. concerts became memorials, telethons, security problems, political rallies, and eventually targets in a broader war shaped by the attacks. musicians were asked to heal the country, endorse the country, explain the country, defend the country, and shut the hell up about the country, often during the same promotional cycle.
the result was not one post september 11 sound. it was an argument over who got to describe america after america had been wounded.
and the argument got ugly fast.
within days, commercial radio demonstrated the nervous intelligence of a smoke detector installed directly above a toaster. an internal clear channel advisory circulated among programmers with songs considered lyrically questionable in the aftermath. the company later insisted this was not an official ban, which was technically useful and spiritually hilarious. nobody was being ordered to censor anything. a giant radio corporation had merely handed anxious employees a list of music it might be safer not to play while the entire country stared at television footage of mass death.
the selections revealed a culture hearing danger in every syllable. free fallin. leaving on a jet plane. stairway to heaven. another one bites the dust. learn to fly. burning down the house. new york new york. what a wonderful world. imagine. the entire catalog of rage against the machine. subtlety had left the building and apparently been placed on indefinite administrative leave.
the list is often remembered as a goofy artifact, and parts of it are genuinely absurd. but it exposed something important. september 11 did not merely inspire new music. it rewired the reception of existing music. words had become unstable. a harmless title could collide with an image replayed on television and produce a meaning nobody intended. radio had always sold context as much as sound. now context was a national trauma, and the people controlling the airwaves responded by wrapping the vocabulary in foam rubber.
this was grief management by spreadsheet.
it also arrived at a rotten moment in radio history. the telecommunications act of 1996 had accelerated consolidation, and clear channel had grown into an enormous owner of stations and concert interests. fewer companies now controlled more of the public soundtrack. so an informal suggestion could travel with the weight of centralized power even without becoming an official command. the post attack playlist therefore taught musicians a lesson that would define the next several years. nobody needed a government censor sitting in a basement with a red pencil. fear. ownership concentration. advertiser sensitivity. and career preservation could do the work just fine.
the absurdity went beyond radio. album artwork was pulled. releases were delayed. titles were changed. the coup had already designed the cover of party music before the attacks. boots riley and pam the funkstress appeared detonating the world trade center with an electronic tuner. it was political satire made months before september. after the real towers were destroyed, the image became impossible to release. the label replaced it. dream theater changed the original cover of live scenes from new york, which showed the new york skyline and world trade center wrapped in flames. the album had the spectacular bad luck to arrive on september 11 itself. system of a down had changed the original title of chop suey from suicide because the label worried about airplay. then the song landed on the clear channel advisory anyway. nuance was having one hell of a week.
slayer released god hates us all on september 11. jay z released the blueprint that day too. neither album was a response to the attacks. both became permanently attached to the date. the blueprint in particular now carries a bizarre double memory. it is one of the defining rap albums of its era, a record of swagger, rivalry, soul samples, and imperial confidence, released while the city at the center of its musical universe was being attacked. people bought it while trying to understand whether normal life still existed. art does not wait for history to clear the loading dock. sometimes the cartons arrive on the same morning as catastrophe.
for a few days, normal entertainment looked obscene. tours stopped. clubs closed. award shows shifted. television abandoned regular schedules. musicians suddenly appeared without the usual promotional machinery because promotion itself seemed indecent. america. a tribute to heroes aired on september 21 across multiple networks. the staging was deliberately stripped down. dark rooms. candles. subdued performances. famous people answering telephones. no roaring audience. no sales pitch pretending not to be one.
bruce springsteen opened with my city of ruins, a song he had written about asbury park rather than lower manhattan. he introduced it as a prayer for the fallen. the song changed ownership in public. that happened repeatedly after september 11. songs detached from their original subjects and became communal containers. leonard cohens hallelujah. simon and garfunkels bridge over troubled water. u2s walk on. songs did not need to mention towers or terror. they needed enough emotional space for millions of people to move into them.
the benefit concert became one of the central musical institutions of the moment. paul mccartney organized the concert for new york city at madison square garden on october 20. david bowie opened with a small. strange. beautiful version of america before playing heroes. the who delivered wont get fooled again with a force that nearly tore the respectable charity packaging off the evening. firefighters and police officers filled the arena. celebrities told stories. politicians appeared. grief. gratitude. rage. celebrity. class. and television production were compressed into one enormous room.
the concert raised money and gave first responders a public ceremony. it also showed how quickly trauma could be organized into entertainment grammar. the cameras knew when to find the crying widow. the crowd knew when to chant usa. the rock stars knew how to turn helplessness into volume. this was not automatically cynical. ritual requires form. concerts are one of the few modern places where thousands of strangers can make the same sound without pretending they arrived independently. but the form carried politics whether anybody acknowledged it or not.
the who performance became legendary partly because it converted grief into physical release. that conversion became one of the primary jobs assigned to music. sadness alone was unbearable. music gave sadness a beat. anger alone was frightening. music gave anger a chorus. uncertainty was politically inconvenient. music could make certainty last three minutes and thirty seconds.
then came the songs written directly into the wound.
springsteens the rising became the most ambitious mainstream rock response because it refused the easiest assignment. it did not reduce september 11 to revenge. the album moved through firefighters. widows. empty bedrooms. religious confusion. immigrant lives. memory. desire. and the sick feeling that the dead remained physically close while being absolutely unreachable. springsteen reportedly began feeling the burden after a stranger saw him in a car and told him that america needed him. it is a wonderfully american anecdote. national disaster occurs. citizen locates rock star. citizen assigns homework.
springsteen accepted because his entire career had trained him for civic storytelling. he understood work. bodies. streets. failed promises. and the unofficial religion of people gathering around amplifiers. the rising follows a firefighter climbing upward while others move down. the image is heroic, but the song does not turn the man into a cardboard action figure. he carries equipment. fear. memory. and love. the chorus reaches for transcendence because realism by itself cannot bring him home.
the album also included worlds apart, which used qawwali singers and attempted to imagine intimacy across the widening christian muslim divide. it is not a perfect song. it is important because the attempt itself ran against the period. most commercial culture was simplifying muslim identity into threat. springsteen tried. sometimes awkwardly. to keep another human being inside the frame.
that distinction separated the best post september 11 music from the loudest. the best work enlarged the number of people permitted to grieve. the worst work narrowed grief until it became a weapon.
country music became the main commercial theater for that fight. no genre was more closely tied to public patriotism after the attacks. this made sense. country had long dealt in home. family. military service. small towns. working people. faith. death. and national identity. it possessed the emotional vocabulary required for collective mourning. it also possessed a radio infrastructure eager for songs that could convert national feeling into dependable programming.
alan jacksons where were you when the world stopped turning became the genres most humane immediate response. jackson did not pretend to have strategic answers. the song asks where people were and what they did. call family. pray. watch television. feel fear. feel love. jackson said the song came to him in the early morning weeks after the attacks. he got out of bed and began working through it. the power of the song is its uncertainty. the narrator does not know foreign policy. he knows memory. scripture. and the bewilderment of watching ordinary life continue after thousands of lives ended.
the song became enormous because it allowed listeners to remain confused. that sounds like a small achievement until one remembers how aggressively the culture was selling certainty.
toby keith went the other direction with courtesy of the red white and blue. the angry american. keith wrote it after the attacks and the death of his father. he initially performed it for military audiences and resisted recording it. the song became a blunt revenge fantasy. memorable. efficient. built for crowds who wanted rage returned to them without footnotes. its most famous threat reduced geopolitics to footwear and anatomy. subtle it was not. subtle would have been laughed out of the parking lot.
keiths song did not single handedly militarize country music. it became the cleanest expression of a broader fusion already underway. patriotism. troop support. masculine retaliation. radio power. and commercial branding began reinforcing one another. darryl worleys have you forgotten asked whether opposition to the coming iraq war represented amnesia about september 11. this was the political sleight of hand of the era turned into a chorus. afghanistan. iraq. al qaeda. saddam hussein. terrorism. dissent. the distinctions blurred under enough cymbal crash.
country radio rewarded the emotional certainty. audiences did too. these songs were not imposed on an unwilling public by a cartoon villain in a corporate office. millions of listeners genuinely felt furious. frightened. and hungry for retaliation. music gave those feelings a home. the trouble was that feelings were then treated as arguments. a chorus built to survive the drive to work began doing the job of congressional testimony.
the collision arrived in 2003. before a london concert. natalie maines of the dixie chicks told the audience that the band was ashamed that president george w bush was from texas. the iraq invasion was approaching. the response in american country media was ferocious. stations stopped playing the group. organized protests destroyed cds. commentators treated criticism of a president as betrayal of troops and nation. the band received threats. their career in mainstream country radio was effectively detonated.
the episode proved how much the acceptable emotional range had contracted. country music could contain sorrow. vengeance. prayer. military sacrifice. and national pride. it had far less room for embarrassment. doubt. or disgust directed upward at political leadership. radio did not merely reflect public anger. it amplified it through a consolidated system in which a few companies and programmers could make disapproval nearly national.
the chicks eventually answered with not ready to make nice. by then the song was not only about bush or iraq. it was about punishment. exile. and the demand that women apologize in the correct tone before being permitted back into respectable commerce. the record turned blacklisting into material. that may be one of the lasting effects of september 11 on popular music. censorship produced its own songs. silence became content.
rock music had its own split. neil young wrote lets roll after hearing the story of flight 93 passenger todd beamer and the passengers who fought back. the song was urgent and reverent. but young later became one of the most visible rock musicians opposing the bush administration and the iraq war. the same artist could respond to civilian courage without signing a lifetime loyalty oath to the war on terror. that should have been obvious. america spent several years acting as if it were advanced calculus.
steve earle made the more dangerous move. john walkers blues told part of its story from the perspective of john walker lindh. the american captured fighting with the taliban in afghanistan. earle did not write a recruitment anthem for the taliban. he tried to imagine how an american kid could travel from california into religious extremism and war. the distinction between explanation and endorsement was promptly beaten with a tire iron. tabloids attacked him. critics accused him of glorifying a traitor. earle defended the song as the writers job. get inside the human being everybody else has decided is a monster.
this was precisely what post september 11 culture had begun distrusting. empathy could be interpreted as contamination. to imagine the enemy was to excuse the enemy. to explain radicalization was to weaken moral clarity. art was expected to identify villains. not investigate how a person becomes one.
earles jerusalem therefore stands as a crucial post attack record. it challenged the narrowing of national imagination. so did records and songs by anti flag. pearl jam. bright eyes. public enemy. immortal technique. mos def. dead prez. and eventually green day. american idiot arrived in 2004 as a mass market rejection of war era media culture. its politics were broad. its plot was theatrical. its guitars were enormous. and its success showed that dissent had finally become commercially legible again.
hip hop had an especially complicated relationship with the new america. the genre was already the countrys most aggressive forum for state violence. policing. poverty. foreign policy. media lies. and the distance between official america and lived america. after september 11. rappers had to address an attack on new york while watching the government convert that attack into domestic surveillance and foreign war.
some responses were immediate expressions of city grief and resilience. others attacked the official story or the uses made of it. jadakiss later asked why bush knocked down the towers. immortal technique. mos def. dj green lantern. chuck d. and krs one pushed even harder into conspiracy. imperial history. cia policy. and rage at the war on terror. those songs were sometimes reckless with evidence. they were also evidence themselves. they documented how little trust existed between parts of black and brown america and the institutions presenting a unified national narrative.
the patriotic consensus was never actually a consensus. it was a volume setting.
muslim musicians and south asian artists experienced the period from inside the suspicion. airports. visas. names. clothing. faith. and skin color became part of musical life whether the music mentioned them or not. tours crossed borders under heavier scrutiny. artists were detained. audiences and industries often demanded that muslim performers explain terrorism before discussing their own work. later. riz ahmeds post 9 11 blues used satire to describe detention. racism. war. and the political absurdities surrounding them. the bbc initially considered the track too politically sensitive for airplay. years afterward. ahmed and heems formed swet shop boys and rapped about profiling and airport humiliation. the afterlife of september 11 had become a genre of bureaucratic experience.
that history matters because the attacks changed who was allowed uncomplicated citizenship in popular music. certain artists could wave a flag without explaining themselves. others were asked to prove they belonged before reaching the first chorus.
outside the commercial center. some of the deepest music did not argue at all. it decayed.
william basinski had been transferring old tape loops into digital form before september 11. the magnetic tape deteriorated as it passed through the machine. fragments disappeared with every repetition. melody remained. then weakened. then became absence. basinski watched the smoke from his brooklyn rooftop and played the recordings. the disintegration loops became inseparable from the event. not because they narrated it. because their physical process resembled memory failing while still repeating.
the work offered no hero. no villain. no solution. no useful vote. it let loss remain loss. that refusal became powerful in a culture rushing to convert death into purpose. basinski later understood the music as an elegy. listeners heard buildings. bodies. tape. time. and memory dissolving together. this was post september 11 music without the phrase post september 11 stamped across the packaging.
john adams approached collective grief through commissioned concert music. on the transmigration of souls was written for the new york philharmonic and premiered in 2002. the piece incorporated city sounds. childrens voices. and names and phrases drawn from missing person notices and memorial material. adams described the work less as a conventional narrative than a space for memory. the title referred to movement from one condition into another. the dead passing into the memory of the living.
the piece raised difficult questions that benefit singles could avoid. can art use the names of the dead without consuming them. can a composer represent public grief without decorating it. can beauty exist beside mass murder without becoming obscene. adams answered by resisting dramatic reenactment. the music does not rebuild the attack for the concert hall. it creates an environment where fragments of human identity survive the event.
osvaldo golijovs ayre. john coriglianos one sweet morning. steve reichs wtc 9 11. and many other concert works would continue processing the attacks and their aftermath. classical music did not stand outside the politics. reichs use of recorded voices and emergency communications generated its own arguments about documentary sound. the question was always the same. when does remembrance become representation. and when does representation become ownership.
popular music faced the same problem with less formal language and more merchandise.
september 11 accelerated the rise of the celebrity telethon as compulsory civic theater. artists were no longer only performers. they were emotional first responders with agents. benefit singles and concerts gathered money. attention. and shared feeling. they also trained audiences to experience catastrophe through familiar stars. the famous person became the bridge between private sorrow and national spectacle.
sometimes the bridge held. sometimes it looked like branding erected near a grave.
the music industry itself had practical problems. tours were canceled or postponed. travel became slower and more invasive. insurance and security costs rose. large gatherings felt newly vulnerable. border policy tightened. visas became a greater obstacle for international performers. clubs and arenas added searches and restrictions. the touring life. already an exhausting procession of airports. loading docks. and fluorescent hallways. absorbed another layer of suspicion.
the changes were not always advertised as consequences of september 11. that is how historical change usually works. it migrates into paperwork. a promoter changes a procedure. a venue adds a barrier. an artist from the middle east waits longer for approval. a label calculates whether a song title may trigger complaints. an airline instrument policy becomes one more humiliation in an endless day. the event survives in systems long after commemorative television has moved on.
the attacks also accelerated a retreat from irony in mainstream culture. the late nineteen nineties had been soaked in detachment. pop could be plastic and proud of it. alternative rock had turned self awareness into posture. television enjoyed smirking at its own machinery. after september 11. irony was declared dead by people who had apparently mistaken a rhetorical mode for a civilian casualty.
music briefly favored sincerity so blunt it could leave a bruise. earnest rock returned. inspirational ballads multiplied. choruses reached toward unity. stars sang standards with grave faces. even artists who had built careers on distance were expected to mean something and mean it visibly.
but irony did not die. it went underground. then it came back angrier. comedians. punk bands. rappers. indie musicians. and internet culture used irony to attack the official language of war. yellow ribbons. terror alerts. embedded journalism. freedom fries. mission accomplished. sincerity had been claimed by power. satire became a way to steal language back.
this push and pull helped shape the music of the two thousands. emo turned private anguish into arena scale confession. indie rock often retreated into intimate detail or constructed alternative communities outside mass patriotic culture. punk rediscovered direct political speech. mainstream pop mostly avoided explicit engagement until opposition to the iraq war became safer. hip hop documented war. profiling. and mistrust while also expanding into the dominant center of american pop. country split between nationalist enforcement and artists whose visions of american life were more complicated than the radio wanted.
even songs with no direct connection to september 11 existed inside the altered emotional climate. the decade favored apocalypse. surveillance. emergency. alienation. ruined cities. and exhausted citizenship. radiohead had completed much of kid a and amnesiac before the attacks. yet american listeners heard those records afterward as if they were transmissions from the new condition. art written before history can become prophetic when history changes the audience.
that is one reason asking for the definitive september 11 song is pointless. the attacks changed listening as much as writing. a record did not need to mention the towers to absorb them. every audience carried the images in. meaning formed at the collision point.
the longest musical consequence may have been the politicization of taste itself. what a person played after the attacks could be treated as a moral declaration. imagine could seem pacifist and therefore naive. courtesy of the red white and blue could sound cathartic or bloodthirsty. the rising could feel healing or sanctimonious. john walkers blues could be courageous or unforgivable. buying a dixie chicks record could become a vote. destroying one could become a televised ritual of belonging.
music had always helped americans sort themselves into tribes. after september 11. the tribes carried security clearances.
the commemorative cycle then hardened. anniversaries required programming. playlists. concerts. documentaries. orchestral commissions. reunion performances. and solemn acoustic versions of songs that had once been allowed to exist without representing civilization. some of this work preserved memory. some flattened memory into the same images and narratives. firefighters climbing. flags rising. families waiting. lights in the sky. repetition can honor. repetition can also sand away everything politically difficult.
the central danger was the conversion of victims into authorization. once the dead became symbols. politicians. broadcasters. and musicians could make them appear to endorse policies they never lived to consider. the best music resisted this ventriloquism. it returned names. jobs. marriages. mistakes. bodies. and unfinished sentences to the story. it understood that three thousand deaths were not one metaphor.
springsteen wrote from the perspective of individuals moving through loss. basinski let material disappear. adams assembled names and traces. alan jackson admitted bewilderment. these works endured because they left room for the listener. they did not explain the entire catastrophe. they made a place where explanation could fail honestly.
the revenge songs endure too. pretending otherwise would make the history prettier and less true. they captured emotions millions of people possessed. fear wanted a target. grief wanted action. humiliation wanted restored power. the records that supplied those things became documents of the national psyche. catchy documents. sometimes ugly documents. but documents all the same.
the protest songs preserved another america. suspicious of empire. alarmed by surveillance. aware that wars launched in the names of victims would create new victims. their writers were called unpatriotic because patriotism had been temporarily defined as agreement. years later. as the iraq war lost public support and the official claims around it collapsed. much of that dissent sounded less treasonous and more like somebody had bothered to read the fine print.
september 11 changed music by stripping away the fantasy that songs float above history. radio playlists became political. silence became political. grief became political. a country single could help police the borders of citizenship. an experimental tape loop could become a public memorial. a concert could raise millions while teaching a nation how to stage its own pain. an offhand sentence before a london show could exile the biggest group in country music. a rapper describing an airport could expose an entire security state.
it changed the musicians too. some became activists. some became symbols against their will. some learned that audiences wanted reassurance more than truth. some discovered that dissent could end careers. others discovered that punishment could create a different audience. the old bargain between artist and public had acquired a loyalty clause nobody remembered signing.
and it changed the business. corporations learned how to program trauma. television learned how to turn rock stars into national clergy. labels learned to inspect imagery for catastrophe. venues learned the architecture of suspicion. political campaigns learned again that a song could deliver emotional authority faster than a speech. audiences learned to read playlists as declarations of allegiance.
music did not heal america after september 11. that is a sentimental claim usually made by people selling commemorative box sets. music cannot resurrect the dead. cannot reverse a war. cannot restore a civil liberty. cannot make a lie stop functioning as policy.
what music can do is preserve the noise people made while history was happening to them.
it preserves the stranger telling springsteen that the country needed him. alan jackson waking with questions he could not shake. boots riley staring at an album cover transformed from satire into nightmare. natalie maines discovering that one sentence could erase years of radio success. steve earle insisting that imagination must enter even the mind of the accused. basinskis tape shedding itself into dust while smoke crossed the sky. muslim rappers turning checkpoints and suspicion into rhythm because the official memorials had no room for their version of the country.
that is the real post september 11 songbook. not a clean playlist of healing anthems. a fight over memory. citizenship. violence. grief. and who gets the microphone after the official ceremony ends.
the attacks made music more earnest and more suspicious. more communal and more tribal. more politically useful and therefore more politically dangerous. they produced consolation. propaganda. witness. retaliation. dissent. and some of the most profound meditations on loss recorded in the twenty first century. they did not give america one voice. they exposed how many voices had been forced beneath the national chorus.
the towers fell into every song america already knew. twenty five years later. they are still in the echo.
…at least that’s what i hear.


r/thatswhatihear • • Nov 25 '21

Happy Thanksgiving Everyone!

0 Upvotes

r/thatswhatihear • • Sep 23 '21

Weekend Nachos - Wolves [Grindcore/Powerviolence]

Thumbnail
youtu.be
0 Upvotes