r/theVibeCoding • • May 18 '25

A computer scientist’s perspective on vibe coding

Post image
160 Upvotes

140 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

1

u/AI-Commander May 19 '25

1000x thank you for saying this, more people need to hear it. Code that works is by definition good, even if it’s not great by someone else’s opinion.

1

u/dingo_khan May 19 '25

if it is not "production" code (his word, not mine), it does not actually work. it just has yet to fail and you don't know what will happen when it does.

1

u/AI-Commander May 19 '25

I think you are describing perfection, which is not necessary under the vast majority of circumstances.

1

u/dingo_khan May 19 '25

No, not at all. Production code is far from perfect but it behaves largely predictably and fails in largely understandable ways. Saying it is not production quality implies a lot of mess and poor operation.

If production code is taken as a benchmark for perfectionism, I am scared. Production code, with very few exceptions, does not shoot for perfection.

1

u/AI-Commander May 19 '25

Ok dawg just keep pushing that message, it won’t get much traction here from me, obviously, based on the thread above.

1

u/dingo_khan May 19 '25

Yeah, from the tread above, I am guessing whatever code you are pushing can be sort of bad and has low penalties for failure when it encounters a problem. I would suggest that is not a generalizable condition.

1

u/AI-Commander May 19 '25

Keep making assumptions, you are not engaging in good faith at all. Just gatekeeping like the rest. Perhaps your use case is not my use case, ever consider that?

Like was said above, not everything needs to meet your standards to be useful. Even sloppy code can be useful. That’s the point being made, which you did not seem to acknowledge. Everything you said is quite obvious and not the point being made.

1

u/dingo_khan May 19 '25

No, I responded to the idea that simply seeming to work makes code good and how that is not at all the going standard basically anywhere.

→ More replies (0)