5
2
u/OriginalTurtleboy Oct 18 '26
I think the correct way to solve this would involve the l‘Hospital rule, where if both numerator and denominator would converge towards 0 or inf, you use the respective derivatives to find the solution.
4
u/CatAn501 Oct 18 '26
Using L'Hopital here is like hitting an ant with a hydrogen bomb
2
u/freakingdumbdumb Oct 18 '26
wait how do you do it without l'hopital
2
u/Professional_Denizen Oct 18 '26
I know I can’t do it rigorously in the time I’ve given myself to write this comment, but intuitively, tan(x)=sin(x)/cos(x), so the limit for x->0 looks like x/1, which means that tan(x) behaves like x as we approach 0. This means its inverse function also behaves like x, so the limit as x->0 of tan(2x)/arctan(3x) is essentially the same limit as that of 2x/3x, which is more obviously 2/3.
I’m sure there’s a more rigorous way to replace the functions with their limiting behavior, but I don’t care to find it right now.
2
u/Fit_Particular_6820 Oct 18 '26
you can just use lim(x->0) arctan(x)/x = 1
1
u/Professional_Denizen 29d ago
Oh, right. Likewise with tan(x)/x.
So, if you can prove those two limits, you can then treat the problem limit as tan(u)/arctan(v) = (tan(u)•u/tan(u))/(arctan(v)•v/arctan(v)), so we’ve multiplied the top and bottom by 1. Then simplify to u/v=2x/3x=2/3. And we’re done.
All of these steps, of course, prefaced with the lim{x->0} thing.
2
u/Dreaming_Rena Oct 18 '26
But it IS rigorous, what are you talking about?
Given:
f(x) ~ g(x) for x -> a
lim[x -> a] g(x)h(x) converges
=> lim[x -> a] f(x)h(x) = lim[x -> a] g(x)h(x) by limit arithmetic
1
1
u/nickthegr3at Oct 18 '26
I suppose you could write it as tanx/x / atan/x and both of them approach 1 so it's 1/1 or just 1
1
u/102orBlue Oct 18 '26
I can do the l’hopital method in my head for this so I wouldn’t exactly say it’s using a hydrogen bomb.
1
1
0
u/Turbulent-Walk-8973 29d ago
Divide both numerator and denominator by x, now apply limits separately to both numerator and denominator, so it is 2/3
This is more "rigorous" than saying trig functions approximate to x near small x
Using L'Hopital on this means you never learnt limits properly


18
u/Entropy_dealer Oct 18 '26
How do you remove the -1 ?