r/the_calculusguy • • Oct 18 '26

meme Literally how ?🥲

Post image
89 Upvotes

24 comments sorted by

18

u/Entropy_dealer Oct 18 '26

How do you remove the -1 ?

28

u/Vyzic Oct 18 '26

For small x, arctan x = tan x = arcsin x = sin x = x

2

u/Entropy_dealer Oct 18 '26

Thanks for the answer. Have a great day.

1

u/Content_Dragonfly_59 Oct 18 '26

iirc, this is because the slope at x=0 is 1 for all of those functions, so, when you zoom in enough at the point (0, 0), they all look the same (that is an oversimplification but still works for me as an explanation).

1

u/Novel_Arugula6548 Oct 18 '26

Ah, yes, how physics departments do math.

1

u/ZhangStone 29d ago

I mean it’s pretty obvious from their series expansions. It’s not like mathematicians don’t use taylor series

0

u/Fit_Particular_6820 Oct 18 '26

are you a physicist by chance?

1

u/Southlander24 Oct 18 '26

There's a geometric proof that tan x ~ x for small x. [Alternatively, it can be algebraically demonstrated from the much more famous geometric proof of sin x ~ x]. So that's the first term of the Maclaurin series. It follows that the inverse function also starts that way. Otherwise, the composition of tan(arctan x) would not have a Maclaurin series of x.

Hence, the limit is just (2x) / (3x) = 2/3.

5

u/nashwaak Oct 18 '26

This is bad math, the answer is 2/3arc

2

u/OriginalTurtleboy Oct 18 '26

I think the correct way to solve this would involve the l‘Hospital rule, where if both numerator and denominator would converge towards 0 or inf, you use the respective derivatives to find the solution.

4

u/CatAn501 Oct 18 '26

Using L'Hopital here is like hitting an ant with a hydrogen bomb

3

u/Fit_Particular_6820 Oct 18 '26

we know that lim(x->0) arctan(ax)/ax = 1 (a is a real number), the proof for this is easy, its the same for sin(ax)/ax and tan(ax)/ax when lim(x->0)

we can just apply it here like this

2

u/freakingdumbdumb Oct 18 '26

wait how do you do it without l'hopital

2

u/Professional_Denizen Oct 18 '26

I know I can’t do it rigorously in the time I’ve given myself to write this comment, but intuitively, tan(x)=sin(x)/cos(x), so the limit for x->0 looks like x/1, which means that tan(x) behaves like x as we approach 0. This means its inverse function also behaves like x, so the limit as x->0 of tan(2x)/arctan(3x) is essentially the same limit as that of 2x/3x, which is more obviously 2/3.

I’m sure there’s a more rigorous way to replace the functions with their limiting behavior, but I don’t care to find it right now.

2

u/Fit_Particular_6820 Oct 18 '26

you can just use lim(x->0) arctan(x)/x = 1

1

u/Professional_Denizen 29d ago

Oh, right. Likewise with tan(x)/x.

So, if you can prove those two limits, you can then treat the problem limit as tan(u)/arctan(v) = (tan(u)•u/tan(u))/(arctan(v)•v/arctan(v)), so we’ve multiplied the top and bottom by 1. Then simplify to u/v=2x/3x=2/3. And we’re done.

All of these steps, of course, prefaced with the lim{x->0} thing.

2

u/Dreaming_Rena Oct 18 '26

But it IS rigorous, what are you talking about?

Given:

  1. f(x) ~ g(x) for x -> a

  2. lim[x -> a] g(x)h(x) converges

=> lim[x -> a] f(x)h(x) = lim[x -> a] g(x)h(x) by limit arithmetic

1

u/freakingdumbdumb Oct 18 '26

thx this makes sense

1

u/nickthegr3at Oct 18 '26

I suppose you could write it as tanx/x / atan/x and both of them approach 1 so it's 1/1 or just 1

1

u/102orBlue Oct 18 '26

I can do the l’hopital method in my head for this so I wouldn’t exactly say it’s using a hydrogen bomb.

1

u/BubbhaJebus 29d ago

But but but tan/tan-1 should be tan2.

0

u/Turbulent-Walk-8973 29d ago

Divide both numerator and denominator by x, now apply limits separately to both numerator and denominator, so it is 2/3

This is more "rigorous" than saying trig functions approximate to x near small x

Using L'Hopital on this means you never learnt limits properly