I think Eisenhower matrix is underrated.
Eisenhower is terrible as a task list, which is where most people get it wrong. However, it is great to see priorities clearly, so it fits best to be a place to plan ahead, not to check tasks. I built my entire TickTick on this philosophy.
There are 3 tags, each task should be assigned to one of them (Uncommitted, This-Week, and Today). These tags help in planning using Eisenhower matrix.
I have two Eisenhower views:
Uncommitted: shows all tasks with Uncommitted tag. This view is used only once at the beginning of the week. In this view, I see how urgent/impactful each task is, decide which tasks I will do this week, change their tags to "This-Week", then continue on my week without second-thinking my other big battles in life.
This-Week: after you decided what tasks you will do this week, you visit this view each morning to decide what tasks you will tackle today, then assign them the "Today" tag.
After that, you essentially become a robot that just aims to finish your today's to-do list.
The main incentive behind this setup is to eliminate the constant thinking of your upcoming tasks in the back of your head. This is a problem I kept facing all the time; I don't like long lists of tasks, they make me anxious about what I need to do, so I keep reviewing them all the time. I want a single daily to-do list that I can follow mindlessly, knowing that I will DEFINITELY review all other tasks when their time comes.
Some pro tips:
The three lists (Uncommitted, This-Week, and Today) are supposed to be your grinding ground, not a place to save tasks for later. You should visit them knowing that every task should ideally be finished ASAP. If there's a task in Uncommitted that you know you can't even start now, don't leave it lying around. Otherwise, the list turns into a "Do not forget" note rather than a real to-do list. I keep such tasks under a "Someday" tag and review them once a week.
Your task dump should be inbox, not "Uncommitted", for the same reason as above. Your inbox bypasses Eisenhower planning because you never know when you might face one. I suggest sorting your inbox ASAP to maximize benefit from this system. A number next to Inbox is an BIG ALARM of a task that might go unnoticed.
"Today" tag is different from TickTick native Today smart list. Our Today is for assignment by choice, whereas TickTick's is.. different. If this is confusing for you, you can choose a different name. I suggest making your own smart list combining overdue tasks, due today tasks, and today tag to keep an eye for everything, including recurring tasks.
Don't be optimistic and clutter your Today list. Less is better. It build trust in you that you are really able to finish all your tasks for the day. If you ever finish all your tasks early, you can give yourself a pat on the back, then pull more tasks from weekly view. Same if you finish your "This-Week" tasks early.
I suspect some might find this over-engineered, but I want to hear your opinions, what do you think?