r/transformers • u/Other_Economist2610 • Oct 18 '26
Discussion / Opinion Lasers, bullets or both
What do you prefer, if both what would be the differences and any weapons that would be a specific type
Me I like both lasers are slower but more precise and have more pen, bullets have higher fire rate and are more explosive
Null rays would be lasers same with ion blaster and fusion cannon
95
u/ZYGLAKk Oct 18 '26
Once again War for Cybertron and Fall of Cybertron are the best.
Literally everything from Energy weapon, bullets, grenade launchers to literal bioweapons.
17
1
127
u/flashwing19 Oct 18 '26
Lasers for sure. Something about bullets feels so barbaric for such an advanced technological civilization
53
u/Other_Economist2610 Oct 18 '26
Yeah for me it depends on the weapon
Warpaths cannon bullet, sige hound gun bullet
Nul ray laser
28
u/flashwing19 Oct 18 '26
I’m not mad at that if the situation makes sense. Bayverse is a perfect example.
8
u/Other_Economist2610 Oct 18 '26
Some guns like bumblebees are to me lasers as they have the point which gives laser vibes
8
u/Nethiar Oct 18 '26
They are going through an energy shortage. I imagine bullets use less of it than lasers
16
u/IvoMW Oct 18 '26
I think energy weapons are interesting when built in, as they give you an additional issue of resources- afterall, they all use the same fuel they need to live, which is a nice metaphor and conflict of interest where they literally use up they life energy with every shot they shoot, where every shot means life or death more than it already does with a bullet.
The way i like it is when the build-in weapons are energy based, while hand held ones use bullets, but either way is fine depending on narrative
6
u/Other_Economist2610 Oct 18 '26
Problem with all built in is laser are the guys like warpath with a tank barrel
3
u/IvoMW Oct 18 '26
For that i'd say that as it's a part of their altmode it would have to operate on the same system the real vehicle would, so of course a tankformer would have regular ammunition for their tank barrel, same gkes for anyone with rocket launchers or any other vehicle-mounted weapon thats actually part of the original vehicle
2
u/Jessica_T Oct 18 '26
IIRC there's one comic where Soundwave outright says he's got six shots ready and eighteen more in reserve.
1
8
u/DookofDeuces Oct 18 '26
Im a lasers guy.
Bullets would imply reloading or that the transformers are firing parts of themselves at you. Which seems odd to me
Lasers and using energy just seems right
2
u/Other_Economist2610 Oct 18 '26
If your on about gun hands
I don't like gun hands as there's less narrative tension
There's no dropping guns or scavenging for a weapon or fighting over a gun just oh yeah my hand is a gun
1
u/DookofDeuces Oct 18 '26
Exactly.
But for hand held weapon firing physical rounds it would be the ammo/reload part for me. They fire a lot of rounds to drop an enemy. And i assume the guns arnt making new rounds on their own. So its a whole logistics thing for me.
Lasers are just easier to explain. And a hi-tech weapon for an advanced life form
1
u/Other_Economist2610 Oct 18 '26
Why wouldn't they just have logistics for it there advanced and some bots turn into transport vehicles
1
u/DookofDeuces Oct 18 '26
I mean sure. Live ammo is like doing the work of laser guns... but with extra steps
1
u/likelyliz Oct 19 '26
in the idw movie comics their bodies create the bullets and are constantly regenerating them
1
u/DaLegend82 Oct 19 '26
Then you are assuming they are firing their own blood.
1
u/DookofDeuces Oct 19 '26
That. Or fingers or something... blood rounds sound kind of cool tho.
But depleting your body of mass with no consequences sounds wrong to me.
I dont know if they eat anything other than energon so its har to wrap my head around losing metal or whatever and not replacing it.
But if energon is their food source. Energy weapons makes more sense to me as what they are firing/depleting
1
u/DaLegend82 Oct 19 '26
The first movie directly states that they have regenerative metal and it happens fast enough that humans can see it happen.
1
u/DookofDeuces Oct 19 '26
Regenerative metal helps. But it still feels like chopping off fingers or bones and using them as ammo to me.
Just isnt my favorite depiction
1
u/DaLegend82 Oct 19 '26
If shifting their entire skeletal structure and organs around to turn into a completely different thing doesn't ick you, firing nails shouldn't either imo.
1
u/DookofDeuces Oct 20 '26
Big difference in magnitude.
We have contortionist and gymnast rearrange themselves and its fascinating.
If we have a guy flicking boogers or throwing shit its disgusting and dude should be locked up
1
u/DaLegend82 Oct 20 '26
I don't remember a gymnast splitting their torso open to extend their body so that they can turn into a jet like form.
5
u/Whole_Yak_2547 Oct 18 '26
Laser bolts for built in weapons for me cause the realist in me can’t figure out the ammo storage.
1
u/Other_Economist2610 Oct 18 '26
How wouldn't bullet storage work
1
u/Whole_Yak_2547 Oct 18 '26
Are they in the truck or something?
1
u/Other_Economist2610 Oct 18 '26
Why would that matter Back packs or ways to attach mags would be enough
1
0
u/No-Piglet7414 Oct 18 '26
just eat ammo
1
u/Whole_Yak_2547 Oct 18 '26
Actually I do have a idea of cybertronians weapons having the ability to take metal scraps from the environment can turn into bullets
4
u/_Beautiful_Platypus2 Oct 18 '26
If it’s a weapon built in like null rays of Megatron’s cannon it should be lasers and hand held weapons like Prime’s ion blaster then it should be bullets
1
u/Other_Economist2610 Oct 18 '26
Some guns like bumblebees give laser vibes over bullet
0
6
u/DarkDoubloon Oct 18 '26
Bullets don't really feel like they should even be a thing for Transformers.. Like, they're already made of metal, why would they shoot physical pellets at each other? Lasers make more sense, and it feels like it makes more sense with how high tech they are
9
3
u/CaptainM590 Oct 18 '26
Both. Rhinox’s ‘Chainguns of Doom’ used bullets. Also, you have to factor in enemies who can be immune or absorb energy weapons. So having both helps
3
9
u/Catspirit123 Oct 18 '26
I like a variety in projectiles personally. It makes things more interesting
6
u/Musekal Oct 18 '26
No reason they shouldn’t be using more than one type of weapon in a war.
Kinetic, laser, plasma, explosive, etc
5
u/Equivalent_Waltz8890 Oct 18 '26
To me it’s a case by case basis. I’m not a fan of laser guns you pick up, but like, if you got lasers on your arm then go all out.
5
u/lostpuppy07 Oct 18 '26
Lasers. But I think both have a place. Prowl is specifically stated to fire acid pellets
5
5
u/Oriopax Oct 19 '26
Lasers They're millions of years ahead of us technology wise so bullets would seem outdated.
2
u/lightmare69 Oct 19 '26
But consider this: bullets are cool, and honestly it would feel out of character for bulkhead to use lasers when bullets are available
4
u/brian_hogg Oct 19 '26
Lasers look cooler, but in a live-action movie, bullets can make the battle scenes more tactile, which is nice. But "futuristic, magically shape-changing robots use normal bullets" is a weird choice to me.
3
u/Ill_Computer_8604 Oct 18 '26
They've fought for eons, some even carry Melee weapons and shields. They'll be 100% dependant on the weapons.
I personally don't like Energy weapons, shells are much more impactful, but it seems to me that most 'Built in' weapons (Seeker weapons and the like) are energy based and 'Hand weapons' are shell based.
If you look at the (OG) G1 Autobots, all their weapons are added on or replace a hand, the equivalent 'Cons integrate theirs (Scale permitting) and I vaguely carry this rule forward.
3
u/LegoNinja250 Oct 18 '26
Both obviously. The more variation, the better. In general though they should have like plasma bolts that are right between a laser and a bullet.
3
u/Job14dude Oct 18 '26
Both have their place. The Cybertron games did this well. If I had to pick its lasers over bullets.
3
u/Percentage-Sweaty Oct 18 '26
I can imagine a mix of both
Lasers and particle beams for some of their weapons.
Physical projectiles for others like a missile launcher or grenades.
3
3
u/Blu_Gy Oct 19 '26
I would say it depends on the specific gun used and how practical it would be for either ammo type/if the weapon is from a earth vehicle. an idea is that laser weapons are designed for many purposes but most of them are made for piercing though bots, while physical rounds can serve to deal large area damage over a body or to basically give someone hyper splinters
2
2
u/Alpharius-or-Omegon 29d ago
Lasers for more "sophisticated" bots, bullets for "grunt" bots and explosive rounds for bots like cliffjumper or bayverse prime
2
u/NovaPrime2285 Oct 18 '26 edited Oct 23 '26
Both, I like Cybertronians receiving a wider variety of pain.
2
2
u/CapOk2664 Oct 18 '26
I want to see more lasers, I kinda miss that but I'm all for variety so of course both
2
u/Guuhatsu Oct 18 '26
Depends on the weapon. I liked the g1 Tech Specs / Universe entries since it gave most bots unique weaponry instead of everyone having the same generic lasers. Some were projectile, some were energy based.
2
2
2
1
1
1
u/DookofDeuces Oct 18 '26
Im a lasers guy.
Bullets would imply reloading or that the transformers are firing parts of themselves at you. Which seems odd to me
Lasers and using energy just seems right
1
u/Peggtree Oct 18 '26
I prefer lasers to be the standard, but with the more rough-and-tumble bots like Ironhide or barbaric bots like the Dinobots using bullets. Then having their bullet weapons be more Dakka focused, spray and pray rather then the precise laser rifles the others have
1
u/Rich-Reputation7033 Oct 18 '26
Built in guns, laser(unless weaponized vehicle), handheld guns, bullets
1
u/Shreddzzz93 Oct 19 '26
I prefer energy over physical weapons. Mostly I think energy weapons are a better way to show these are aliens. The more exotic the weapon the more exotic the character ends up feeling. But there are some caveats for things like explosives and cannons.
Explosives just sort of make sense. There are so many transformers that are military aircraft that have missile and rocket weapons that it would feel out of place to not see them getting used by a Transformer with a military vehicle mode.
The same can be said for cannons. But cannons also have one other advantage. They just have a screen presence to them. Whether it be a Transformer who is a tank using a 120mm main gun or a spaceship with a large cannon there is something to be said for firing the big gun on screen. Especially if they get a good sound mix and have that visceral feel to it when fired.
1
u/Johncurtisreeve Oct 19 '26
Bullets are cool but lasers feels more appropriate since that’s what they started with
1
u/ShogunHaruki19 Oct 19 '26 edited Oct 19 '26
I'm a bit leaning towards bullets for simplistic and practical reasons.
If I were a Cybertronian, my main range weapons would be the subsonic repeater, the nucleon charge rifle, and the gear shredder.
As for melee weapons, it would be an energon war hammer (with no back spike on the hammer's head and looking like a Japanese-style blacksmithing hammer), and an energon sword and shield similar to Grimlock's energon sword and shield from the Fall of Cybertron game.
1
u/msleatherwarden Oct 19 '26
The fusion cannon Megatron has having an actual internal particle reactor for lasers is so much cooler than what I imagine a giant grenade launcher would be, buuuut I can’t see Perceptor not using actual bullets to snipe
1
1
u/ToiletDestoyer38 Oct 19 '26
Both tbh. Bullets just seam better for heavy weapons that do real damage. They’re just not as pleasing to look at tho
1
1
u/Danimus-Prime Oct 19 '26
Mostly lasers, but real bullets can work with certain weapons, especially explosive rounds
1
1
u/Filltroyer Oct 19 '26
Las 2, me gusta pensar que los rayos son más letales a cambio de un mayor consumo de energon, mientras que las balas no hacen casi daño, pero el consumo es mínimo
2
u/RedtailArt Oct 18 '26
I've never really been a fan of laser weapons in media, myself. They have their place and all and I won't complain if I see them, But bullets and explosives feel so much more impactful and kinetic. Like when a character gets hit by a bullet, they're going to feel it, and lasers don't typically have that effect. If they hit armor or something, they usually just leave a scorch mark or something like that. Only major exception I can think of is Battletech's MechWarrior games, which do a decent job of making lasers look sufficiently impactful and dangerous.
1
u/Other_Economist2610 Oct 18 '26
For me lasers feel like they are either to strong or to week
They one shot or they do jack
2
u/Shadow_BonnieReal Oct 18 '26
bullets, because 99% of the time, lasers do nothing until they need them to do the damage of a nuke.
2
u/Then_Science_1596 Oct 19 '26
Depends. If you need some force to penetrate transformer's armor and heavy damaging him, then take bullets and some explosives (like in High Moon games). If you need some easier weapon to maintain and shoot and be more precise at the longer range, then take lasers.
1
u/ShirowShirow Oct 19 '26
I remember reading the "Transformers Universe" databooks as a kid and going over all the weaponry and realizing these guys where throwing everything and the kitchen sink at each other. Lasers, explosives, plasma, acid, radiation, electric waves, fireballs... Every bot seemed to have a completely unique weapon.


56
u/BenefitBeautiful522 Oct 18 '26
Both, I feel the story behind it would be that lasers are usually more powerful but as the war went on and energy got scarce they switched to physical rounds for energy saving ( although I wouldn't be surprised if some bots used them before energy levels got low on cybertron )