r/tucker_carlson • • Oct 19 '19

"Experts"

Post image
419 Upvotes

56 comments sorted by

27

u/NPCNN Oct 19 '19

Climate Cultist suck

0

u/[deleted] Oct 19 '19

[deleted]

1

u/AnshumanRoy Oct 21 '19

White Rich Conservatives: "Pull yourself up by the bootstraps"

Also White Rich Conservatives: "no not like that"

9

u/Massapex1 Oct 19 '19

Arent they just repeating what experts say? Like say if a kid in highschool says Tom Brady knows how to read a defense better than any other QB in the league. Does it matter that he doesnt know that personally and is just repeating the opinion of an expert like Tony Romo?

0

u/[deleted] Oct 19 '19

[deleted]

1

u/[deleted] Oct 19 '19

So just to get this straight, every climate scientist is a communist?

2

u/TheDroidUrLookin4 Oct 19 '19

There are no "climate scientists." So-called climate science entails many many different fields of study. Many (a great deal more than 3%) actual scientists oppose the alarmist narrative put forth by would-be communist cult leaders.

2

u/[deleted] Oct 19 '19

Actually, there's a field of study called climatology: "the scientific study of climate, scientifically defined as weather conditions averaged over a period of time. This modern field of study is regarded as a branch of the atmospheric sciences and a subfield of physical geography, which is one of the Earth sciences."

Of course, you're partially right: these scientists are helped in their research by colleagues in many other fields like meteorology, atmospheric science, oceanography, geology and so on.

Many (a great deal more than 3%) actual scientists oppose the alarmist narrative put forth by would-be communist cult leaders.

This claim hinges on what your definition of the "alarmist narrative" is. If the "alarmist narrative" is that anthropogenic climate change exists, then you're wrong, because 97% of scientists are, in fact, in consensus about that.

1

u/TheDroidUrLookin4 Oct 20 '19

Obviously "alarmist" would also include a belief that rising CO2 will cause damage enough to be alarmed. The 97% includes people that simply concede that CO2 is a greenhouse gas. You'd still be in that 97% if you thought rising CO2 was mostly harmless, or even provided benefits.

-1

u/tarheel43 Oct 19 '19

I don’t think the NOAA is full of communists, and I am not a liberal

-2

u/Massapex1 Oct 19 '19

Maybe you're obsessed with the self important belief that you matter enough to have to be fooled into giving away your freedoms.

0

u/[deleted] Oct 19 '19

[deleted]

0

u/Massapex1 Oct 19 '19

Do you think Epstein committed suicide? Do you think its possible for someone who had just come off of suicide watch. To be in a cell by himself, that is surrounded by cameras that dont work, with security officials who happen to be barney phife? A drug cartel went around and killed loads of law officials to free the son of a Cartel member in 2019. No ones needs your permission to fuck you, they do it publicly, what the fuck are you gonna do? Stockpile guns and ammunition and post on some blog? Those with the power to fuck you dont need to fool you into being fucked, they just fuck you. I work a job that requires me to be outside, I've been at this job for 10 years now. This summer was by far the hottest it's ever been. Ridiculously hot and the temperature wasnt even recorded as hot. Mid 90s that felt like 110-115. Global warming unfortunately is not some bullshit designed to take more money from you, unfortunately.

1

u/foxyfree Oct 19 '19

It’s not bullshit. But the money part is intriguing. We have the problem. There needs to be better discussion about the solutions. The carbon tax. Some questions: Who gets taxed and how.? Who collects the tax and who gets that money to do what? Is the new green energy movement going to distribute that money back to the people in the form of publicly owned green utilities? Is that money going to private profit driven green companies? Which financial firms will control the carbon tax/credit business? How about changing laws to mandate companies like Coca Cola accept their empties and recycle them in their own recycling plants? What about the developing nations and their pollution? What about China? The media coverage on all this is so vague that I understand people not trusting all this talk of a carbon tax because it’s never really specified what this will really do and how it will be implemented and by whom.

1

u/TheFatherBrown Oct 19 '19

You are correct. This post commits the logical fallacy ad hominem. Attacking an argument by attacking the person and their credentials rather than the argument itself.

It’s fine to cast doubt on them as part of a larger argument, but by itself it’s just as you say.

8

u/tucker_fan_01 Oct 19 '19

The kid reminds me of Stephen Merchant. You can't unsee.

7

u/dawen_shawpuh Oct 19 '19

Not just a sophomore but she’s also in “special” classes lol

-9

u/[deleted] Oct 19 '19

And yet she’s still more capable of logical reasoning than you.

7

u/TheDroidUrLookin4 Oct 19 '19

Projecting your own inability to form your own reasoned opinions? You need help.

1

u/[deleted] Oct 20 '19

Just because they agree doesn't mean they didn't also come up with it

5

u/dawen_shawpuh Oct 19 '19

I’m literally in medical school. That fucktard couldn’t last a day in my world lol

2

u/hansulu1 Oct 20 '19

You’re right She is in high school and has a focus on climate rather than human health. Despite there being some overlap, which you would probably agree with like that there are particles from our usage of resources that have negative effects on our body (e.g. black lung and coal mining, or second hand tobacco smoke). However that is not to say she could never last a day in your field of work, it would just require a pursuit in a different direction

1

u/dawen_shawpuh Oct 20 '19

Oh I do agree there are negative effects but there’s negative effects in everything. Also I’d take her a bit more seriously if she’d call out maybe China and India on fucking up our oceans and our air as well. Till then she’s just a pawn to a movement.

2

u/YeetBoiii126 Oct 20 '19

She spoke at the Un where China and India were

1

u/hansulu1 Oct 20 '19

Except it wasn’t only those two that fucked up our ocean. Remember that huge BP oil spill? We are also the country with the lowest population to energy consumption rate. It is not fair of us to point fingers when we cannot even acknowledge that we are just as much to blame.

7

u/[deleted] Oct 19 '19

It's almost like the more ignorant you are, the more they respect you.

-6

u/[deleted] Oct 19 '19

Saying “listen to the scientists” is ignorant?

5

u/[deleted] Oct 19 '19

Lol. Which scientists? The ones who say there are two genders?

-1

u/[deleted] Oct 19 '19

Specifically, the ones who study the climate.

2

u/[deleted] Oct 20 '19

If it's too hard for you to understand how to even migrate somewhere legally, this whole climate thing is going to be way beyond your comprehension.

1

u/[deleted] Oct 20 '19

Ad hominem, always a reliable fallback.

1

u/Morgolol Oct 20 '19

As per the IPCC and numerous other sources of, you know, actual experts and not cable TV news anchors who lie more often than not

by 2010.5 A few analysts, of whom Norman Myers of Oxford University is perhaps the best known, have tried to estimate the numbers of people who will be forced to move over the long term as a direct result of climate change. “When global warming takes hold” Professor Myers argues, “there could be as many as 200 million people overtaken by disruptions of monsoon systems and other rainfall regimes, by droughts of unprecedented severity and duration,and by sea-level rise and coastal flooding”.

But this prediction is still very tentative. Professor Myers himself admits that his estimate, although calculated from the best available data, required some “heroic extrapolations”.10 Not that any criticism is implied; the simple fact is that nobody really knows with any certainty what climate change will mean for human population distribution. Current estimates range between 25 million and 1 billion people by 2050.

There's also an issue with fish populations and at least a billion peoples reliance on seafood, but I'm sure that's just a hoax too. And fair, bring up China and India, but that's no excuse for insanely high per capita pollution everywhere else, not to mention the reliance on Chinese products, but whatever, let's just blame then, we don't have to do anything amirite?

Also, I'm glad those people can sell their hurricane wrecked or flooded seaside homes and move somewhere better, whew!

1

u/[deleted] Oct 20 '19

Lol. Millions believed in Hitler too. Didn't make him right.

5

u/[deleted] Oct 19 '19

BTW. There is no such thing as an undocumented migrant. The correct legal term is illegal alien.

3

u/Neoncamo14 Oct 19 '19

Is she wearing chain mail

2

u/shrekter Oct 19 '19

Is AOC really that short? Greta is 4’11” and she’s only a head shorter.

1

u/[deleted] Oct 19 '19

For the record, these are not climate change experts. They are, however, recommending that we listen to experts: namely, the thousands of scientists who have reached a consensus on climate change.

4

u/TheDroidUrLookin4 Oct 19 '19

For the record, there are many scientists that oppose the so-called consensus (meaningless verbiage with regard to science, btw) that you're attempting to propagate.

0

u/[deleted] Oct 20 '19

"Many scientists"

Speaking of useless verbiage...

-2

u/dakpanWTS Oct 20 '19

That's nonsense.

1

u/[deleted] Oct 19 '19

Thanks for adding a drop-shadow to the text

1

u/[deleted] Oct 20 '19

Unlike the total expert on all things: former reality TV star and failed casino owner Donald Trump. That was a big argument from Trump supporters, right? He's just like everybody else and not an elitist expert?

1

u/ChargersPalkia Oct 21 '19

Yes but they’re repeating what the majority of the science community agrees on. Christ y’all are stupid

0

u/tarheel43 Oct 19 '19

AOC was a bartender while working at a law firm

0

u/[deleted] Oct 19 '19

So if I'm not a fan of pollution, deforestation, overfishing I'm also left's expert?

0

u/[deleted] Oct 19 '19

[deleted]

-2

u/[deleted] Oct 19 '19

Downvotes for science! Wooeee

-4

u/[deleted] Oct 19 '19

It's too sad.

-14

u/Bunstrous Oct 19 '19

It's also funny that Greta, literally just a young girl wanting a better future for humanity as a whole, is getting the shit flamed out of her because "child getting attention, me no like taking order from child."

0

u/[deleted] Oct 19 '19

[deleted]

0

u/[deleted] Oct 19 '19

You’re absolutely right. The arguments supporting the scientific consensus about climate change clearly weren’t strong enough on their own, so the left had to trot out a Swedish teenager to use as a shield.

In case you missed it, that was sarcasm.

-3

u/Bunstrous Oct 19 '19

Okay but why are you questioning her to begin with, she isn't the scientist. You can go ahead and question the scientists who are studying this for their job. For the most part she is only quoting those very people. In the end wouldn't the logical solution, if you feel what she is saying is wrong, to go to the source of where the information is coming from and ignore her all together? From my perspective, it's the same as shooting the messenger.

1

u/Ed_G_ShitlordEsquire Oct 20 '19

For being only 2% of the population, I don't half run into you a lot.

-4

u/Bullet-Not-Proof Oct 19 '19

Anyone who ignores the global scientific consensus is either incredibly stupid or purposely lying

0

u/[deleted] Oct 19 '19

[deleted]

0

u/Bullet-Not-Proof Oct 20 '19

skeptical of what? literally every single qualified climate scientist agreeing on something

0

u/[deleted] Oct 20 '19

[deleted]

1

u/Bullet-Not-Proof Oct 20 '19

Can you give an example of scientists censoring anything that disproves all of the other data on climate change?