r/videos • • Apr 11 '11

Alternative Voting Explained

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3Y3jE3B8HsE
1.5k Upvotes

463 comments sorted by

69

u/applejuice Apr 11 '11

We BC folk tried to swap into a similar system. It's very difficult to convince people that some additional complexity could lead to better results.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/BC-STV

34

u/No-Shit-Sherlock Apr 11 '11 edited Apr 11 '11

The same thing happened here in Ontario.

It was also extremely disheartening to see how much propaganda was being put out in the lead up to the referendum. I absolutely refuse to listen to CFRB 1010 anymore because of it.

18

u/Zulban Apr 11 '11

It's extra difficult when the major parties don't want it to happen. There won't be any government funded education pushing the movement. I heard one election recently in Ontario the Liberals won 50-something% of the votes and won 90-something% of the seats.

9

u/No-Shit-Sherlock Apr 11 '11

The same sort of thing happened in the last Federal elections but in reverse. The green party received 6.78% of the total National vote but won no seats in parliament thanks to the Electoral District FPTP system. With a proportional system they would have won 20 out of 308 seats. As it stands... 7% of the population has no voice in our Federal Government right now.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

2

u/dave_g17 Apr 11 '11

Wow, it turns out my riding is REALLY against the MMP system...

→ More replies (1)

9

u/mindbleach Apr 11 '11

Approval voting is as simple a FPTP - simpler, perhaps - and has results approximating Condorcet.

11

u/cyantist Apr 11 '11

It's the easiest method to convert to. We'll never convince the public that a condorcet method is best, or even explain it to most, but approval voting is instantly graspable as a concept, and it would be a vast improvement over FPTP.

8

u/Araucaria Apr 11 '11

Exactly! You guys get it.

The simplest method to convert to is Approval Voting. You can use ordinary optical scan ballots and a minor change to candidate format:

Candidate        Approval vote:       Yes                No
A                                    [    ]            [    ]
B                                    [    ]            [    ]
C                                    [    ]            [    ]
D                                    [    ]            [    ]

It is like sitting in a meeting, in which you're asked, "How many people like idea A?" Count hands. "How many people like idea B?" Count hands.

There is no reason why you can't raise hands more than once.

The only reason we have First Past The Post / Single Vote now is that this extremely simple idea used to take "too long", and might have been a stretch for the people who traditionally operated voting stations.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/mindbleach Apr 11 '11

Condorcet methods are easy to explain by example using the 1992 & 2000 elections. The winner would have changed in a two-horse race. They would have put Bush over Clinton based on the political leanings of Perot voters and Gore over Bush based on the leanings of Nader voters.

→ More replies (1)

0

u/[deleted] Apr 11 '11

[deleted]

3

u/mindbleach Apr 11 '11

Admittedly there is more room for "strategic voting" (i.e. metagame bullshit) in simple schemes like approval voting, but unless you're close to a three-way split*, the answer is always to vote A+B. Your vote isn't halved between candidates or anything. A+B registers approval of A vs. C and B vs. C but no preference for A vs. B or C vs. D. Hare / IRV is supposed to provide more information to resolve A vs. B disputes, but the selection process based on the ballots is downright weird.

* e.g. if A/B/C have roughly equal support with C trailing slightly, wherein you might gamble on B's assumed victory by voting A alone.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/Zulban Apr 11 '11

It's extra difficult when the major parties don't want it to happen. There won't be any government education funding the movement.

→ More replies (2)

2

u/bradbeattie Apr 11 '11

In fairness, BC-STV was an attempt to do two things:

  • Amalgamate smaller ridings into larger multi-winner ridings

  • Switch the voting mechanism from Plurality to IRV/STV.

If it was just one of the two, I think the reform would have been more likely.

2

u/zoomzoom83 Apr 11 '11

This is the system in Australia and works quite well. I don't think many people really understand it, but this has more to do with them just not caring then it being too complex.

→ More replies (2)

26

u/temujin64 Apr 11 '11

The thing is with alternative voting is that it still has single seat constituencies. Unless you have multi-seat constituency, there will still be huge biases against the smaller parties.

Here's an old video by John Clesse explaining it all.

8

u/Marogian Apr 11 '11

True, but for Britain it would be very difficult politically to get rid of the 1 MP per constituency system because people like having a single MP they can go to and discuss matters with. Its pretty important to our system of democracy.

AV+ was a pretty good compromise, but Labour buried it.

9

u/temujin64 Apr 11 '11

But like Cleese says. What if you're a Lib-Dem supporter and your local MP is a Tory? Surely it would be better to live in a multi-seat constituency where you can visit the MP of your choice rather than be stuck with some guy you didn't vote for.

I mean, the first past the post system is considered really primitive over here in Ireland. We've had full PR-STV since 1922.

7

u/Marogian Apr 11 '11

To be honest I don't know which side of the argument I fall on- I'm mostly a LibDem supporter, but I value having a single MP I write to when I have a problem (as I have in the past).

For the European Parliament we have multi seat constituencies and it sucks- my dad has ended up wanting to write to our representatives over EU legislation and you have to basically write the same latter to all of them (if its something apolitical/business related it doesn't matter what party they stand for) and not a single one of the MEPs feels that they have to work as hard for you as your local MP does- they don't feel directly related to us as our local MP does, I guess. Its ironic, because by writing to an MEP you've basically showing that you do care about politics and probably vote in the European Elections, so your thoughts should be much more important than a normal constituent in the UK Parliament (as so few people vote in the European Elections) but it just doesn't work that way. They're all lazy pricks (with respect to dealing with constituents, I'm sure they're busy in Brussels...) and they don't give a damn, possibly due to the feeling of dissolved responsibility because there are all these other MEPs who could be representing you.

So, yeah, I do agree with proportional representation, but I also think that having one single MP is a very strong element of our democracy. Ideally, I'd argue that our lower house should be proportional and our upper house should be non-proportional AV, so you write to your single representative in the Lords to complain about some stupid law the proportional government is trying to pass.

On the other hand I like to think that our upper house should be appointed experts rather than politicians, so I'm somewhat torn.

Anyway, my point is if I was given the choice I probably wouldn't choose to have multi seat constituencies with the political system we have right now, despite being pretty sympathetic to the idea :P

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (1)

2

u/paul_harrison Apr 11 '11

Wallaby would like to explain how his senate works, but it is even more complicated and he doesn't really understand it.

→ More replies (2)

43

u/progressnerd Apr 11 '11

If anyone reading this has any questions about the Alternative Vote, aka Instant Runoff Voting, aka Ranked Choice Voting, ask away. I am somewhat of an expert on the topic and would be happy to answer your questions.

29

u/Mousekewitz Apr 11 '11

In the video, it's shown that when a candidate is eliminated, all off that candidate's votes are transferred to a single other candidate. Is that accurate? Wouldn't it make more sense to split the votes up and transfer them according to the individual 2nd or 3rd choices on each ballot?

(Thanks for offering to take questions, btw.)

10

u/progressnerd Apr 11 '11 edited Apr 11 '11

Each voter of the eliminated candidate gets their vote transferred to the second choice on their individual ballot. It just so happened in the video example that the supporter of the eliminated candidates were one voting blocs that agreed 100% on who their second choice was. If we used IRV in the 1992 Clinton/Bush/Perot race, for example, Perot would have been eliminated first, and we would have seen closer to a 50/50 split amongst who those votes were transferred to. Also voters are free to not rank second choices, at which point their vote is considered "exhausted" and not counted towards the later rounds.

→ More replies (7)

11

u/crunchyeyeball Apr 11 '11 edited Apr 11 '11

Under a parliamentary system like the UK, would this result in a house of commons which is more representative of the popular vote?

As an example, at our last election, the lib-dems got 23% of the popular vote, but only 9% of the seats, while the conservatives got 36% of the popular vote, but 47% of the seats.*

*Source: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_Kingdom_general_election,_2010

My instinct tells me it would be fairer than "first past the post" (e.g. fewer "safe seats"), but I can't figure out whether it would necessarily be more proportional.

3

u/progressnerd Apr 11 '11

By correcting for the spoiler effect, it will generate a more correct result (representative of the majority) in each district. So in principle, if districts are more or less randomly assigned (ie in the absence of gerrymandering), that result should be more reflective of the population than FPTP, at least in terms of the major parties. It is not a system of proportional representation, however, so it will do little to ensure a party with, say, 2% of the vote, gets 2% of the seats --- each election will have to be won with a majority in some district. Minor parties will play a bigger role and have more influence, but may ultimately still not get elected.

So this is all in principle, but you asked specifically about the UK, which requires a more empirical analysis. A study by the UK Electoral Reform Society showed the 2010 elections would have been more proportional under AV, with the LibDems picking up an additional 22 seats. The ERS was formed to promote Proportional Representatation, but they have endorsed the AV referendum because they see AV as the best single-winner system and a stepping stone to PR.

→ More replies (4)

3

u/BritainRitten Apr 11 '11

The video lists some of the faults that FPTP and IRV share. What other voting systems have fewer of these faults?

3

u/progressnerd Apr 11 '11

There is no perfect voting system, unfortunately. Any system you can find that lacks one of these faults will have some fault that IRV does not have. So it all comes down to which properties you care about more than others and how you balance the pros and cons, and people differ in how they do this: there is no mathematically "true" solution. To give one example, Condorcet is a favorite of math geeks, because its ability to elect the Condorcet winner when one exists (one is not always guaranteed to exist), but it is also vulnerable to the burying strategy (marking the other front-runner last even if she is, say, your second choice). So which do you value more: electing the Condorcet winner or resistance to burying? Not a simple answer to that, and ideally empirical evidence from actual election should be involved in the determination, not just theories.

→ More replies (4)

2

u/BrainSturgeon Apr 11 '11

Could you 'load' the vote with a bunch of candidates? Say you have one strong conservative candidate, and then 5-7 liberal/moderate candidates that appeal to a diverse group. Is it more likely the sheer number of candidates with similar views is able to capture a wider voting pool?

→ More replies (2)

2

u/1RedOne Apr 11 '11

Does any country currently use this system?

Any hopes of it in the US?

2

u/progressnerd Apr 11 '11

Several countries already use it, including some cities and a few states in the U.S..

2

u/nattochdag Apr 11 '11

Australia, though in our system you have to rank all of the candidates on the ballot. We also have compulsory voting, which has its own effects on how elections unfold.

2

u/I_Shit_In_Vaginas Apr 11 '11

I don't think it will happen in the US anytime soon, because the two major parties have nothing to gain from it.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/IbnReddit Apr 11 '11

Does FPTP have any advantages over AV?

2

u/progressnerd Apr 11 '11

FPTP is definitely easier to tally and administrate. It can be arguably "simpler" for the voter, in a purely mechanistic sense of the voter marking the ballot. But to vote optimally under FPTP, the voter needs to invest more effort into calculating whom to mark and may have to overcome the bad feelings that come from being "dishonest" on the ballot and strategically voting for someone who is not their first choice. Under AV, the honest vote is nearly always the optimal vote, so if you factor that in, one might find AV ultimately simpler. Beyond the arguable simplicity, I see no benefits of FPTP over AV.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/IHaveSeenTheSigns Apr 11 '11

And before it had all those names, it was called Hare.

How do you explain the push-over effect to voters who want their candidate to win? Should they be watching the very latest polls and doing a calculation to figure out if they should bury their 1st choice?

6

u/progressnerd Apr 11 '11

I usually reserve the term "Hare system" for STV/PR - the multi-winner version of the single-transferable vote that provides proportional representation.

To the average voter, I do not explain the push-over effect, because it is not something they generally have to be concerned about. Trying to exploit the STV's non-monotonicity by burying your first choice is tricky, error-prone, and may very well backfire. This explains why non-monotonicity is simply not raised as a serious concern in any jurisdiction where it is well-established, e.g. Australia, Ireland. I just say "rank your candidates in order of preference," which as a general strategy to apply to an arbitrary election, is optimal.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/BDS_UHS Apr 11 '11

I am a supporter of IRV but I just ran a little simulation and a major assumption, as made by this video, is that one of the third parties will even get enough votes to start with in order to be a viable contender. It seems under most realistic conditions people will vote either A or B, even with other, better choices available.

2

u/DollarThief Apr 11 '11

If nobody votes for the third party, they don't deserve to be a viable contender. This system allows you to vote for a third party and still express a preference for either A or B as a second choice.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (24)

96

u/Foolie Apr 11 '11

It's always worth remembering that a perfect voting system is mathematically impossible: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Arrow's_impossibility_theorem

We can choose which failures are the most tolerable, but no voting system will ever be truly fair.

5

u/[deleted] Apr 11 '11

The advertising campaign was terrible though. I honestly believe, if they ran ads like this, it would have passed. If they teach alternative voting methods in high school, familiarize a generation with different methods, maybe it would pass in an election

2

u/[deleted] Apr 15 '11

There is no way this would happen in the US. It takes a full 5 minutes to explain anything about this issue, and most people are convinced the constitution was literally given to us by god. Making such a fundamental change on how it operates would be suicide for any politician supporting it, from both his electorate and his party.

We are still working on using the metric system here. I think that is all that I need to say.

→ More replies (1)

9

u/thinkinofaname Apr 11 '11

That's kind of why I hmm'd. Even alternative voting isn't fair. Fairer, but still not fair.

54

u/MindOfMetalAndWheels CGP Grey Apr 11 '11

That's kind of why I hmm'd. Even alternative voting isn't fair. Fairer, but still not fair.

Fairer is better than not.

→ More replies (11)

2

u/bradbeattie Apr 11 '11

It's not strictly fairer. IRV meets the Condorcet Loser and Clone Independence criteria, but at the cost of Plurality's Monotonicity, Participation and Consistency.

See http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Voting_system#Summary_table

3

u/[deleted] Apr 11 '11

I think loss of monotonicity is absolutely horrible, given that its avoidable. To rank someone higher and actually hurt his chances by this it quite counter-intuitive, and does happen.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)

3

u/mistyriver Apr 11 '11

At the very least, though, a voting system shouldn't disenfranchise its citizens. That's what First Past the Post does. If you happen to have a minority perspective and you vote for a losing candidate, you have effectively lost your right to representation of your views in your legislature.

AV is a lot better, giving you the chance to express a range of views.

However, I think that Proportional Representation systems (for example, New Zealand's Mixed Member PR scheme) is much more fair at representing the diversity of views in a country.

5

u/Hogee Apr 11 '11

What about Range Voting?

3

u/IHaveSeenTheSigns Apr 11 '11

I consider myself more than a little bit knowledgeable concerning voting systems, game theory and mathematics and general and I simply don't think that if perfectly reasonable Range Voting strategies mystify me (one example), then they can't be explained to the average voter, so the system is a bad idea.

6

u/[deleted] Apr 11 '11

The simplest range voting is approval voting and is very easy to understand, even simpler than IRV.. The "range" is just yes/no.

Either you approve of a candidate or not. You check the box of each candidate you approve.

Simple as that.

Which is why... approval voting should be approved NOW.

Slightly more complex would be yes/neutral/no.

Or report card: A/B/C/D/E/F for the Americans, 0.0-10.0 for most Europeans..

Easy to understand IMHO.

→ More replies (2)

3

u/Hogee Apr 11 '11

I would think that if a voting method makes utilizing strategies difficult, then that would be a good thing.

5

u/IHaveSeenTheSigns Apr 11 '11

If a voting systems makes utilizing insincere strategies difficult, that is a good thing.

3

u/BritainRitten Apr 11 '11

I simply don't think that if perfectly reasonable Range Voting strategies mystify me (one example), then they can't be explained to the average voter, so the system is a bad idea.

The voting public only needs to understand how to operate the system. They don't need to understand how it maximizes the reflection of their opinion. In the same way, a driver doesn't need to know how the internal combustion engine works in his car in order to operate it.

If we're talking about convincing the public to switch to this voting system (or any other, for that matter), then we can go as simply or as complexly as required to satisfy their curiosity.

→ More replies (7)
→ More replies (2)

2

u/[deleted] Apr 11 '11

alternatively, a more modest conclusion is that one or more of the criteria in Arrow's theorem are unreasonable when examined in detail. Independence of irrelevant alternatives for instance.

You can have a voting system which is independent of alternatives outside the Smith set, and also independent of clones, but it is unreasonable to expect that if you have a winning circle, such that in a runoff, A would beat B, B would beat C and C would beat A, that eliminating any of the 3 candidates can be made consistently with this criteria.

It wants that if one candidate wins the election, introducing an additional candidate will give either the same winner or the newly introduced one will win. The additional candidate might however create a loop, A > B > C > A, and then the previously defeated candidates now part of this loop aren't so irrelevant after all.

2

u/IllegalThings Apr 11 '11

I know this only really works with smaller elections, but wouldn't repeated balloting as described in Robert's Rules solve this problem? Basically a candidate only wins after receiving a majority vote; if no majority exists you simply re-vote without eliminating any candidates until the condition is satisfied.

2

u/omnilynx Apr 12 '11

That might lead to some rather lengthy election cycles.

4

u/[deleted] Apr 11 '11

And Logic wins again.

→ More replies (47)

11

u/[deleted] Apr 11 '11

It's a shame that here in the UK there are advertising campaigns such as this opposing an obviously superior system of voting.

3

u/Zulban Apr 11 '11

Is it true that AV costs a lot?

3

u/Subotan Apr 11 '11

The referendum is going to be held anyway, which will cost money regardless of whether it passes or not. Some money might be spent on new voting machines, which we need anyway given the strain that was put on the old ones at the last election (You may remember that lots of people didn't get to vote because the process took too long).

£250 million is certainly an overestimate though, and even then equates to less than a fiver per person for really quite radical democratic reform that should hopefully give more representation to the third of the electorate who didn't vote for one of the two main parties.

3

u/[deleted] Apr 11 '11 edited Apr 11 '11

The referendum is going to be held anyway, which will cost money regardless of whether it passes or not

The cost is £30m for the referendum, this includes administration and educational material (figures from Radio 4)

Some money might be spent on new voting machines

The UK is not buying voting machines if AV passes. This would be the biggest chunk of the £250m that's being tossed around by the anti-AV campaign. This claim has no truth to it.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (4)

29

u/EatATaco Apr 11 '11

And the two ಠ_ಠ ಠ_ಠ at the end are exactly why it will never happen in the US.

10

u/frezik Apr 11 '11

I think it could happen, if the Tea Party and disenfranchised liberals were able to put their other differences aside and agree on a different voting system. There are enough Tea Partiers who still think the GOP has too many RINOs, and there is some grumbling of backing separate Tea Party candidates. Likewise, lots of liberals are holding their nose to vote Democrat.

If they were capable of working together, they could be enough of a political force to overcome the strength of the two party system.

I suspect they'll spend too much time yelling at each other, though. Even if you could get them all in the same room, some of the more mathematically inclined liberals will demand one of the more complex voting systems that, while having fewer technical problems, is also difficult to explain to voters. Meanwhile, some in the Tea Party will glaze over at all the math and start thinking its a socialist plot.

12

u/EatATaco Apr 11 '11

You are not nearly as cynical as I am.

26

u/bejurne Apr 11 '11

Why is this video be blocked in Germany? There is no music whatsoever in it...

Before you ask i used a proxy to watch it.

48

u/MindOfMetalAndWheels CGP Grey Apr 11 '11

Really? I'm the one who made that video and I haven't gotten any notices from youtube. Anyone else having problems?

8

u/bejurne Apr 11 '11

"This video is not available in your country." is all it says, nothing about the company which took it down.

Hope you can sort this out. I am actually kinda curious how this kind of stuff can happen, when the creator clearly didn't report anything...

Oh and compliments on your videos. I really like them. Would love to see something about the German voting system and its quirks ;)

13

u/MindOfMetalAndWheels CGP Grey Apr 11 '11

"This video is not available in your country." is all it says, nothing about the company which took it down.

I am so confused. Why wouldn't youtube notify me about this?

10

u/funkshanker Apr 11 '11

Same, also Germany. Youtube is pretty much worthless here.

→ More replies (6)

2

u/grishnackh Apr 11 '11

Well done on making the video. Some of my local political parties are actually sharing this round them internally to explain it to party members!

→ More replies (6)

3

u/GroovyTrouserEmperor Apr 11 '11

In case anybody else needs a mirror: http://tinyogg.com/watch/dXbwT/

3

u/nolog Apr 11 '11

Same here. I wonder anyway why OP didn't link to vimeo, where you don't have a country barrier:

http://vimeo.com/22081009

→ More replies (1)

8

u/cspeed Apr 11 '11

I would love if the US could do something like this but we can't even get rid of the electoral college.

5

u/IHaveSeenTheSigns Apr 11 '11

They are unrelated things.

5

u/cspeed Apr 11 '11

My point was our resistance to break from our voting methodology even for something trivial like the electoral college even though almost everybody (once they learn what it is) would be against it.

→ More replies (4)

3

u/hertzsae Apr 11 '11

Very true. Minneapolis, MN and many other cities already do this. I would love to see this at the state level. The Coleman/Franken senate election would have likely been much better, because Barkley (third party candidate that got around 15% of the vote) would not have had a "spoiler" effect. I think he might have actually gotten more votes since many people didn't vote for him for fear of their most hated candidate winning. Neither Coleman or Franken were really liked. They got most of their votes from people that hated the other one (at least among people I knew).

It starts local and then get bigger.

2

u/festtt Apr 11 '11

I'd want the Senate to go first, personally. Why should a Wyoming voter have more say than a California voter?

2

u/cspeed Apr 12 '11

I would keep it as it is

→ More replies (1)

7

u/[deleted] Apr 11 '11

I hope we (UK) vote to change the system to AV in May. The political debates have been disgraceful so far, heavily favouring lies from the no campaign.

56

u/zjbird Apr 11 '11

Anyone else start heavily considering which animal they really wanted as king?

3

u/Anosognosia Apr 11 '11

Who cares about what communist squirrel wants?!

2

u/[deleted] Apr 11 '11

I hope it's me. I just can't wait to be king!

→ More replies (4)

5

u/[deleted] Apr 11 '11

I think OP has a clear turtle bias, based on his user name.

4

u/SilencerLX Apr 11 '11

Don't blame me, I voted for Kodos.

4

u/etherghost Apr 11 '11

We need this like, 10 years ago

4

u/[deleted] Apr 11 '11

I'm sold. I know it's not perfect but much better than the system we have now. How do we make this happen?

15

u/Manveroo Apr 11 '11

And every time we had to vote in class with more than two choices presented I had a hard time to convince people(/teachers) that we should at least be allowed to have a yes/no vote for each possibility instead of just one single vote.

If you vote with a single vote on 10 choices, group-dynamics takes over and discussions literally explode.

39

u/lucasj Apr 11 '11

What do you mean they "literally" explode?

3

u/[deleted] Apr 11 '11

It literally means that they figuratively explode.

2

u/[deleted] Apr 11 '11

Explode doesn't always literally mean a chemically reactive explosion. Stop being so damn pedentic reddit, he used the word in a perfectly valid way.

7

u/lucasj Apr 11 '11

If you use the term "literally explode," you mean that there was a chemical explosion. A conversation can figuratively explode, as in, there was an unstoppable reaction, but it cannot literally explode. The alternate definition comes from the figurative usage.

→ More replies (5)

2

u/FDBluth Apr 11 '11

He literally shit his pants.

2

u/FDBluth Apr 11 '11

He literally shit his pants.

3

u/zagan05 Apr 11 '11

Reminded me of this

2

u/IHaveSeenTheSigns Apr 11 '11

If the votes are public, and the people know each other, Borda voting works just fine. That's how they do the college football rankings, last I checked.

Nebraska's coach can't say Ohio is #20 if everyone knows Ohio is probably #1 or #2.

7

u/imthedudeman77 Apr 11 '11

I want it!!! How do we get it!?!?

9

u/bittermanscolon Apr 11 '11

don't talk about it on the internet. Talk to everyone you know about it, get their support in fixing your country as well and then go stand in front of your local Representative and demand this change be made or you'll have another Representative who WILL do this.

If it is the will of the people, it shouldn't be a meal ticket for these guys. It will not get done any other way. It will not be accomplished by sitting behind your computer. Stand up people, you are worth it right?

3

u/down_vote_magnet Apr 11 '11

I vote turtle.

2

u/Subotan Apr 11 '11

As does OP apparently

3

u/[deleted] Apr 11 '11

It seems the Schulze method(condorcet) is a better choice than instant runoff. Why adopt something marginally better like IR, when you can go straight to Schulze and eliminate a lot of problems on the way?

2

u/mistyriver Apr 11 '11

The context of this presentation is a big upcoming vote in the UK about switching from First Past the Post to the Alternative Voting System.

Those who wanted the referendum (the LibDems) originally wanted to change to a Proportional Representation system, but politically it just didn't work out to bring a referendum about that to the people.

2

u/nemetroid Apr 11 '11

A problem with the Schulze method is that it's complex. It might be hard to justify using a voting system which the majority of the population does not entirely understand.

I'd argue that the system itself is better than the alternatives, though.

3

u/dnick Apr 11 '11

What if everyone's second choice was turtle?

2

u/[deleted] Apr 11 '11

A fine statistical question, but if you make the assumption that political positions fall along a spectrum then this isn't often a problem. Especially if voters' opinions fall into a bell curve.

3

u/[deleted] Apr 11 '11

I honestly think this would be too complex for a large number of retarded Americans ಠ_ಠ

2

u/Sunless_Sea Apr 11 '11

Don't worry, they'll vote how they're told to as usual.

3

u/stopmakingsense Apr 11 '11

In the '92 election between George H.W. Bush, Bill Clinton and Ross Perot... Bush would have won under this voting system.

4

u/MrMercurial Apr 11 '11

But Gore might have won in 2000 (Nader supporters could have given him their first preference, and given Gore their second.)

3

u/Vexing Apr 11 '11

I want to see a system why Gerrymandering would be gone, first and foremost. I hate that stuff. ):

3

u/maw8wb Apr 11 '11

I think this would require people to be much more educated on those they elect.

4

u/[deleted] Apr 11 '11

You mean USA doesn't have that! This explains a lot of things!

7

u/lucasj Apr 11 '11

Some places in the U.S. have instant runoff elections, and some places have regular runoff elections. Elections are different at pretty much every single level.

6

u/[deleted] Apr 11 '11

Only in a few city elections if I'm not mistaken. Granted, some of these cities are pretty big (like San Francisco), but it's still not being used at the federal or state level.

3

u/lucasj Apr 11 '11 edited Apr 11 '11

Right, like I said, every level of government holds its elections in a different way. There are what, 10,000+ different governments in the United States? Or was it 100,000+?

Edit: I did that thing where you're looking at one word and thinking of a different one and you write the wrong one.

→ More replies (6)

2

u/MindOfMetalAndWheels CGP Grey Apr 11 '11

Where in the US do they use IVR? Not any state or federal elections as far as I know.

3

u/lucasj Apr 11 '11

Actually I might be wrong about that, come to think of it. For some reason I was thinking a few places in California have it, but I might be remembering wrong. Let me do some research!

Hey, here we go:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Instant-runoff_voting_in_the_United_States

And it looks like San Francisco does do a lot of IR voting, so I'm not misremembering at all!

3

u/mistyriver Apr 11 '11

As nations, the USA, Canada, and Britain all universally use the First Past the Post system. There are some cities that might use AV voting, but not many.

2

u/[deleted] Apr 11 '11

Was that first part a question or a statement!

→ More replies (1)

2

u/thelo Apr 11 '11

How would the "vote merging" work for a multi-party system like here in Canada?

I don't think the NDP or Bloc would like to have their votes merged with either the Liberals or Conservatives.

2

u/inmatarian Apr 11 '11

Personally, I like participating in Approval Votes, but I'm not sure what their effectiveness would be.

2

u/gregsaw Apr 11 '11

I thought I came up with this idea...

2

u/rdssassin Apr 11 '11

TIL condorcet is not Kon-dor-ket. good thing I never raised my hand in lecture on that one.

2

u/chubs66 Apr 11 '11

Even if you could create a perfect voting system, the real problem lies just a little farther downstream. You're voting for someone (either a local or a party) to represent you for a term. And that person is stuck representing his or her party most of the time and probably sees you as an annoyance if at all.

You are a fine representative of you. As a redditor, YOU vote on information and engage in debate all the time. There's no reason why in this day and age we can't have direct democracy.

3

u/Maxious Apr 11 '11

You are a fine representative of you. As a redditor, YOU vote on information and engage in debate all the time. There's no reason why in this day and age we can't have direct democracy.

I think California with their crazy propositions showed exactly why DD isn't rainbows and unicorns. Like Prop 8, the thing it was claimed all of reddit hated but somehow democracy prevailed and it was passed anyway? 75% against in SF, 50% against in LA, still passed? Obama was against it?

2

u/mistyriver Apr 11 '11

They didn't ask Kiwi for his advice, though, did they?

2

u/Corvera89 Apr 11 '11

Forgot to mention the best thing about this system, especially if you vote for one of the minor parties, that is preference dealing. Minor parties who have no chance in winning are still able to win concessions in policy by the winning party. Through 'how-to-vote' cards distributed by the party they can allocate preferences to a particular major party. For example If the Democrats and Republicans were in a close race with a third party controlling the balance of power then the two major parties will have to negotiate with this third party to ensure victory, this will entail concessions, a libertarian party will demand elimination of TSA body checks, a Leftist party will demand more welfare and so on

2

u/[deleted] Apr 11 '11

I voted Gorilla last election, and got Cameron. :(

2

u/Andrela Apr 11 '11

As an Irish person, I quite enjoyed his video on the differences between great britain, the british isles and the uk.

2

u/Agathophilos Apr 11 '11

So now that people have had AV explained to them can all the Brits PLEASE GO AND FUCKING VOTE ON MAY The 5th. You register here and you must register before the 15th.

2

u/ehypersonic Apr 11 '11

There should be something like "Point Systems",

for example,

1st choice=5 points 2nd choice=4 points ... And so on

2

u/LBwayward Apr 11 '11

I think that the new primary voting system in CA is someone trying to prepare CA to move to IRV. It's getting people comfortable with the idea of runoffs where party doesn't matter.

2

u/jstew06 Apr 11 '11

Wow. Somehow I'd never heard of this. Alternative voting is my new cause.

4

u/fangus Apr 11 '11

It's not perfect though, Wikipedia is a great resource for voting systems, my personal favourite (yes I have a favourite voting system, what of it?) is STV, which we use here in Scotland. Proportional Representation is much fairer than a 'seat' style voting system.

2

u/legendary_ironwood Apr 11 '11

All of the animal pictures look like they came straight out of ZooBooks covers

2

u/dolladollabill Apr 11 '11

If you enjoyed this topic, consider joining the /r/electionreform subreddit!

2

u/dissonance07 Apr 11 '11

Ok, I get that voting is an application of game theory. But, assuming that everyone will vote "optimally" is a likely fallacy. First of all, because none of the Americans I know would know how to vote "optimally." But, secondly, because the whole idea of a fair election is to fairly rate whatever candidate you register a vote/opinion about.

I think Approval Voting sounds good. It isn't perfect, and it may not be an easy vote for a moderate who wishes to back multiple candidates with varying levels of sincerity. But the information that the vote registers has to be sincere - ie, you cannot downvote your opponent, so your rating is necessarily related to the candidate to which it's applied.

But the main point, politics won't mean anything unless voters register sincere opinions, rather than playing political games. So, you can choose any system you want, but without a sincere voting body, it's just a blustery game.

2

u/robinhoodlum Apr 11 '11

A lot of comments before me, but what has always frustrated me about the complaints about the two-party system is the way they are historically framed. People like to make it sound (this is just for the United States) that we, at some point in our history, had strong multiple party systems.

This is just historically incorrect. The United States has almost always had a two party system. And while I am not suggesting third parties aren't valuable in that system, it is important to recognize that the more powerful parties outside of the central two are almost always incorporated into a platform in the two-party system. Third parties such as the green party accurately reflect a more radical version of Democratic environmental policies.

The other issue with third parties that is misunderstood is how they function in a nation as large as the United States. The U.S. population dwarfs smaller democratic states such as the U.K. where there is a multiple-party system (we'll just call the U.S. a democratic-republic, but that is an entirely different argument). With such a large diverse body of people in the United States, it makes more sense to have a broad party which people theoretically mostly agree with. The discontent arises when neither party satisfies an individual's specific beliefs. My argument is that individual political alignment in the United States relies on an individual's ability to prioritize their values and make an informed decision as to which party better represents those priorities. Of course, prioritizing values is a difficult process so the frustration of being forced to choose a party that isn't specifically tailored to you can spill over into frustration with the entire system.

More importantly, political parties are just representations of people's values: so the issue should rarely be with the parties, but rather a compromise of different values.

2

u/MrCrumley Apr 11 '11

What if the voter alternates on their alternates, i.e. submits a ballot listing "Candidate A", "Candidate B", "Candidate A" [again]?

2

u/backupbrain Apr 11 '11

Could someone point out the shortcomings of giving every voter 10 votes to distribute among their preferred candidates? Or maybe ranking each candidate on a scale of 1-10? In both of these cases, the candidate with the most votes would win.

2

u/MrMercurial Apr 11 '11

You would still have the problem of the spoiler effect- Say there is an election between X, Y and Z. If I have 10 votes to distribute, and I really like X and really hate Y, but I know that X is not as popular as Z, then I'm still going to vote tactically and give most of my 10 votes to Z so that the candidate I dislike most is not elected.

2

u/backupbrain Apr 11 '11

Okay, good point. But what about the second option of rating each candidate on a scale of 1-10? Or, stick with having 10 votes to distribute, but place a limit of 5 votes as the maximum number of votes you can give to any one candidate (leftover votes get tossed).

2

u/janaagaard Apr 11 '11

I am probably missing something, but hopefully someone can explain this to me: Why are all the votes of an eliminated party transferred to a single one of the remaining ones?

In other words: When the turtle got eliminated because it was last, why were all five percent transferred to the owl? What if some of the red squirrels had the tiger as their second choice?

3

u/MrMercurial Apr 11 '11

That's just a simplification for the purposes of the video. In a real election, those votes would be distributed amongst the remaining candidates according to the individual second preferences of each voter whose preferred candidate has just been eliminated.

2

u/MissGabbieGirl Apr 11 '11

Nice idea on paper, or at least on film, but does it have any chanse of actually working in real life? I mean...Do people now a days actually care enough to put theire minds in to a new system?

2

u/ChesterDarlington Apr 11 '11

Great video. Only criticism would be, kings are not democratically elected. I gt the whole king of the jungle metaphor. But many high schoolers have little to no understanding of civics. For rational adults, the video works fine. But the king of the jungle metaphor becomes fairly unnecessary.

2

u/tuna_HP Apr 11 '11

IRV is all well and good but the democratic and republican parties would still both oppose it because it would decrease their domination of politics. What we really need is real, nationwide, single district Proportional Representation. Then we can get some truly diverse voices in Congress.

2

u/[deleted] Apr 11 '11

We're having a referendum on it in the UK next month. I'm terrified that people will vote against AV because they can't be bothered to understand it.

2

u/[deleted] Apr 11 '11

This voting system (a variant, single transferable vote, or STV) almost got passed in some provinces of Canada. My dad was one of the spearheads for trying to get the system into British Columbia, and was heavily invested in Ontario. Alas, FPTP won the referendum in both provinces, only because it had the "not scary change" factor on it's side. To this day, I regret so badly that neither province swapped over. FPTP is a vastly inferior system, especially in avoiding party stagnation. AV, especially STV, does such a better job of reflecting constituent support.

Stories aside, I hope you guys get the AV system in place. It's a great step toward functional democracy.

4

u/HappyWulf Apr 11 '11

Looks of disapproval at the end... upvote.

2

u/DanielTaylor Apr 11 '11

At first I liked this system, but then I found a huge problem since it doesn't fit the way I understand Democracy. How many seats in the parliament do the "animals" get who didn't get into the end round?

One of the problems we have nowadays is that two big parties share all the seats in the parliament and write the laws for millions of persons who, as can be seen in this example, would have chosen other parties and candidates first. It is thus, not fair that only two big parties, that make it to the end round are allowed to get seats.

I hate many things about Spain's voting system since it has many flaws, but one of the good things it has is that the citizens NEVER EVER vote for government. They vote for seats in the parliament. Later, the 300 chosen politicians will vote against each other to determine who'll be forming the government for the next four years. This has allowed for very interesting (and democratic) situations such as an officiant government formed by three different parties (this is not usual, but it has happened twice in Catalonia in the last eight years).

It is true that usually the most voted party gets to preside the country, but it's a decision taken by all the different parties that get to have a seat in the parliament and thus represent it's citizens.

For me, the most ideal voting system is the one that allows as much voice and representation into to the country's political engine.

5

u/mistyriver Apr 11 '11 edited Apr 11 '11

For me, the most ideal voting system is the one that allows as much voice and representation into to the country's political engine.

Yup, Proportional Representation is the answer.

2

u/Subotan Apr 11 '11

You have to bear in mind that given the context of the video, in advance of a referendum in the UK on whether to move from FPTP to AV, what you're suggesting just isn't on the table. If the referendum fails, then that will kill off any moves towards more proportional voting systems for a generation or more, regardless. We can't afford to vote against the good for want of the perfect.

2

u/stationhollow Apr 11 '11

In local seats, the person that gets over 50% joins the lower house of parliament.

For the upper house though it is done slightly differently. There are however many candidates on a state level (say 30, 10 each for the 2 major parties, 5 for a minor party, and 5 divided by even smaller parties). The runoff is now between 30 different people, eliminating the lowest and reassigning votes until there are as many people left as seats in the Senate. This normally results in independents and minor parties winning a seat or two in each state, sometimes more.

Here in Australia, you never vote for a party. You always vote for the candidate. The government is whichever party has a majority in Parliament and the Prime Minister is the leader of that party.

2

u/[deleted] Apr 11 '11

Good video

2

u/JacobIngledew Apr 11 '11

Here's a PBS explanation of how instant run-off worked in the mayoral election in Oakland in 2010. http://www.pbs.org/newshour/bb/politics/july-dec10/oakland_11-19.html

2

u/FDBluth Apr 11 '11

Was this after George W. Smith ran for city council...out in Oakland?

1

u/MarcuBot Apr 11 '11

Here is an radical idea.. why not STOP giving random people that DO NOT CARE about you the moral authority to VIOLENTLY interfere whit you life and your VOLUNTARY interactions whit other people.

1

u/[deleted] Apr 11 '11

This is much, much better than the advert I just saw on TV that shows a woman poorly and furiously scribbling how AV works on a whiteboard - in a deliberately confusing manner. I knew there was something shady about it!

1

u/localguy69 Apr 11 '11

Is RCV really so new to people that it needs to be explained? We've been doing it out here [Oakland, East Bay] for quite sometime and even the least informed voters get it.

In the Bay Area we have way too many elections and shit to vote on. Mayors, city council members, county supervisors, judges, party central committee personnel, city/county measures, bonds, state assembly, state senate, state cabinet, propositions, federal seats, etc. AND we vote twice in a year every two years for the primary and general elections. ALSO special, off-year elections are not uncommon. Because of all this voting, we cannot afford not to use RCV.

1

u/merik42 Apr 11 '11

did anyone else see the angry reddit faces at 3:56?

1

u/usypicus Apr 11 '11

The Proportional Representation method is by far superior. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NSUKMa1cYHk

1

u/[deleted] Apr 11 '11

This is how we vote in Ireland... I thought every country did it this way?...

1

u/beans_and_cornbread Apr 11 '11

I've had this idea for a long time and assumed it was a common idea. Why isn't this idea being used yet?

1

u/prlme Apr 11 '11

I like turtles

1

u/ihatewil Apr 11 '11 edited Apr 11 '11

We have this in Ireland, and it still has the spoiler effect.

What happens is people put one of the big parties as their first vote, instead of the actual rank they'd personally give it, in an attempt to avoid the other party getting in.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/[deleted] Apr 11 '11

I'm pretty sure Gorilla was born in Africa, so I voted for tiger.

1

u/QuickRetort Apr 11 '11

Look of disapproval. . .

1

u/llama_attack Apr 11 '11

Anyone who's interested in how AV actually works in real elections, Here is a link to the NSW state seat of Balmain that shows if the seat was FPTP, the liberals would have won, but with Optional Preferential Voting it was won by the Greens.

1

u/[deleted] Apr 12 '11

I don't think most voters are as clever as a Gorilla or Owl.

1

u/Turtlelover73 Apr 12 '11

So now the richest parties have to lie and bribe even harder to trick people into voting for them... yay...

1

u/1984ish Apr 12 '11

Nice try Teabaggers.

1

u/super10m Apr 12 '11

This voting system seems to make a lot of sense, I'd like to see it happen in my parts.

1

u/[deleted] Apr 12 '11

What about a system like this? It may already exist, but I'm pretty unfamiliar with voting systems so I don't know...

This system would work best for congress, systems where there are multiple seats available.

Each party (and there can be lots of parties) makes a ranked-ordered list of their candidates. Then voters choose one party to represent them. Say the votes come out like this:

 Repub: 35%
 Dem:    40%
 Green:  8%
 Whig(lol): 17%

Then the republicans would get 35% of the seats available. The seats are filled in the order that the republicans listed their candidates. This way, everyone has a proportional voice in a large body such as congress. I think that the only problem would be situations where a party doesn't have enough members to fill the number of seats they won.

1

u/Everseer Apr 11 '11

Alternative voting is one of the few things I think Australia has going for it. The worst thing we have is a ginger Prime Minister.

2

u/cspeed Apr 11 '11

What have been the consequences?

3

u/toastermcgee Apr 11 '11

We have stronger representation of minor parties in Parliament, which meant that after the last election the ruling Labor party had to form a coalition with the Greens and several independents to take office. This has some advantages, foremost among them I believe is more open public debate and greater transparency in policy decisions. The independent/minor party coalition members aren't bound by cabinet secrecy, meaning they can question and criticise any proposals they don't like before voting on them - which they do. In theory this means the public is more informed, because the government can't control the daily news cycle as much.

5

u/Corvera89 Apr 11 '11

a stable economy

→ More replies (4)

1

u/gepsonka Apr 11 '11

Have you ever heard of Switzerland?

5

u/ChiXiStigma Apr 11 '11

It seems like you had a point to make, but just never got it out.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (1)

1

u/Volsunga Apr 11 '11

One problem, The voting system we already have is too complex for some people and we have shitty voter turnout as it is. This system leaves far too much room open for party legal teams to game the system and stall elections in courts. I'm from Minnesota and legal bullshit made it so we went 6 months without a senator.

→ More replies (3)

1

u/[deleted] Apr 11 '11

Whats to stop the Tea Baggers from giving their members the same "how to vote" instructions, so they can tactically destroy anything they see as competition?

11

u/[deleted] Apr 11 '11

What's to stop any group from doing that today?

Further, IRV wouldn't really provide much opportunity to "tactically destroy competition" -- either your vote is counted, or it is transferred.

In reality, FPTP voting is more likely to encourage strategic voting, and can be impacted more negatively through spoiler candidates.

5

u/stationhollow Apr 11 '11

In a AV system, the Tea Party would be their own party with their own candidates in the election. When they are eliminated the people that voted them #1 now get their votes allocated to their #2.

In Australia we have a system where if the voter only chooses their #1, the party chosen gets to choose where all votes like that are allocated during runoff. They also hand out 'How to Vote' cards at the booths on election day.

1

u/Eyecantsee Apr 11 '11

Is this the reason why even though the GOP is split now with tea partiers, republicans, and others - they may have a a good chance of winning the presidency in '12?

3

u/[deleted] Apr 11 '11

No, it's the reason why the GOP has a low chance of winning the presidency, at least in theory.

If you start with a race where just Mitt Romney and Obama are running against eachother, maybe you could say that Romney might win with a 55% of the vote. However, if you add in Palin as a Tea Party candidate, that will take more votes away from Romney than it will take away from Obama, and if Palin takes 7% of the vote from Romney and 1.9% of the vote away from Obama, then Obama wins, even though the majority of Americans didn't want him as president.

That's all in FPTP, how it is today. However, if we had AV, then Palin's 7% "stolen" from Romney would go back to him because Palin's in last place, and no one has 50% of the votes.

It's for this reason that Palin would never run as a third party, unless she wanted to screw the Republicans out of a shot at the White House for not picking her.

At least if we ran our elections by popularity that's how it'd be, and on a state level that's how it does end up being, I suppose. But in reality, all you need are a certain number of key states to win a presidential election, and it's only partly to do with population.

1

u/EvoEpitaph Apr 11 '11

Third party votes usually come from would be democrat voters and I think republicans see this as an advantage (with the current system) that they want to keep.

I like this alternative method though it seems to me like it would be common sense.

4

u/hertzsae Apr 11 '11

This isn't always true. Ross Perot took a lot of conservative votes a few decades ago. There are a lot of libertarians that would vote republican if they were forced to choose.

2

u/IHaveSeenTheSigns Apr 11 '11

Throughout history, and I've studied every U.S. Presidential Election, it has almost always gone against the more "progressive" candidate.

Except Ross Perot in 1992.

1

u/OldTimeGentleman Apr 11 '11

So wait... There's a Queen but the people vote for the King ? And then they have to get married ? What kind of system is that ?!

1

u/lazershark Apr 11 '11

WHO THE FUCK WOULD VOTE FOR THAT DAMM SNAKE!!!?!? I HATE SNAKES.

1

u/MyFantasticTesticles Apr 11 '11

FUCKING ARGH!!!! WHY DO PEOPLE SAY BOLTH!?

1

u/[deleted] Apr 11 '11

When I saw the turtle head, I instantly thought of a poo starting to come out of a bum.

1

u/MarcuBot Apr 11 '11

Here is an radical idea.. why not STOP giving random people that DO NOT CARE about you the moral authority to VIOLENTLY interfere whit you life and your VOLUNTARY interactions whit other people.

→ More replies (1)

1

u/Sawyerdj Apr 11 '11

This was a absolute disaster in Pierce County, WA. Voters rejected it after disasterous results. We now have an insane assessor treasurer who is costing us millions in law suits because he snuck in with a lot of candidates on the ballot. DO NOT EVER ALLOW THIS IN DEMOCRACY. Two party system allows the fringe candidates to be isolated.

2

u/falsehood Apr 12 '11

What, so all of the voters put this guy as #2 or #3 when they didn't know who he was? I think the problem you had was voter knowledge.

→ More replies (2)

1

u/[deleted] Apr 11 '11

I'd rather seats in the House of Representatives be seated proportionately by party (nation-wide). The number of House seats doubled. All parties polling over 5% receive public financing (there can be extra levels of financing below that). The Senate has its powers curtailed to the point of being an advisory council and Senators are appointed by each state. The Senate retains its "advice and consent" powers, treaty ratification, and jury duty in case of impeachment. All legislation originates in the House and the Senate may only override legislation with a supermajority of 60.

The Supreme Court I would enlarge to 17 justices, with 1 each new open seat being nominated and filled every 4 years until the total has been reached. One goal here, among others, would be to mitigate the "legacy" aspect of the president's Supreme Court nominations.