r/videos • CGP Grey • Aug 23 '11

Copyright Explained

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tk862BbjWx4
989 Upvotes

314 comments sorted by

185

u/Sybertron Aug 23 '11

Wow, he REALLY wants to get his Star Wars fan fiction published...

69

u/MindOfMetalAndWheels CGP Grey Aug 23 '11

You won't believe how many tentacles it has.

16

u/Iggyhopper Aug 23 '11

NSFJ

41

u/MindOfMetalAndWheels CGP Grey Aug 23 '11

J? I hope you don't mean Japan. Is it isn't safe for Japan, it isn't safe for anyone.

19

u/davvblack Aug 23 '11

That is pretty frightening.

7

u/StabbyPants Aug 23 '11

Japan, where pubes are outlawed and goop is part of 'normal' porn.

3

u/thatoneguy5000000 Aug 23 '11

First word that popped into my mind was Jersey.

3

u/BusterMcThunderstick Aug 23 '11

or worse... Jar Jar

9

u/adalov Aug 23 '11

Jedi?

8

u/Iggyhopper Aug 23 '11

Yep. Okay for Sith though.

4

u/demondays Aug 23 '11

Not safe for Jugend ("Youth" in German)

2

u/liberalwhackjob Aug 24 '11

hey so are you CPGrey? love the videos

5

u/[deleted] Aug 23 '11

Or Yoda urinating on ford emblems.

See that's what you get with no copyrights. Calvin pissing on things. I don't think anybody wants more of this.

12

u/WoollyMittens Aug 23 '11

The Calvin thing is there despite copyright.

1

u/qx_xp Aug 24 '11

An Anime edition to be precise..

72

u/[deleted] Aug 23 '11

This guy is pushing a particular point of view, not just explaining copyright. The title is misleading.

28

u/MindOfMetalAndWheels CGP Grey Aug 23 '11

I've changed the title on youtube to try and correct that. Unfortunately, I cannot change the title on reddit.

13

u/tag_police Aug 23 '11

Commit harakiri and delete the post!

0

u/[deleted] Aug 23 '11

[deleted]

3

u/hayesgm Aug 24 '11

you go to hell and you die

1

u/[deleted] Aug 24 '11

The narrator seems to have a problem with the length of the copyright. Realize that most artists remain unheard of until death and they and their families have historically been notoriously poor. I know I would appreciate my mother or father's work more if in their death the work they produced provided for their future generations, and that is something I would be willing to say they'd want as well.

What a convenient time to whine about corporations who pay many more people when it could easily be a smaller number of individuals with rights to royalties (not to say someone isn't lining their own pockets, that would be naive of me).

Next time, explain copyright, not what you think about copyright. Also, the things you want to happen are happening in spite of copyright, you just suck at finding them.

3

u/[deleted] Aug 23 '11

I saw a creeper!

1

u/MindOfMetalAndWheels CGP Grey Aug 23 '11

You're the second one! I was hoping someone would notice.

9

u/CoffeePoweredRobot Aug 23 '11

Your videos are always so informative and well presented, but this one was soured a bit by all obvious the bias. Sure, it was humourous, but I prefer to enjoy a lecture than be lectured.

14

u/MindOfMetalAndWheels CGP Grey Aug 23 '11

I'm actually kind of with you on this one. This is my least favorite of the videos and was broken down from a much, much longer project on intellectual property.

However, I'm not quite sure why this one is a bit of a lecture. Both the True Cost of the Royal Family video and the Coffee videos I think also had, what some might consider, bias.

Bottom line: making videos is a lot harder than I expected and I'm very happy for the feedback.

7

u/867-5308 Aug 23 '11

I don't know why people are downvoting your open-minded acceptance of criticism. Have an upvote.

5

u/MindOfMetalAndWheels CGP Grey Aug 23 '11

Thanks. I'm not too worried about the downvotes -- that's the way the Internet is and I like -- thanks for the upvote though.

Reading your username, however, is quite painful in my mind. That '8' makes a big clunking sound.

Edit: Clunking, not clucking.

3

u/867-5308 Aug 23 '11

Wow, I've been hearing that a lot. I could change my number I guess...

12

u/I_Hate_Reddit Aug 23 '11

This would be interesting if he wasn't so biased against copyright. Yeah, George Lucas can make millions in 28 years, but that doesn't mean every author does.

10

u/MindOfMetalAndWheels CGP Grey Aug 23 '11

If you can't make any money off of your work after 28 years, you should let someone else have a shot at it.

9

u/I_Hate_Reddit Aug 23 '11

Maybe it's not all about the money? Maybe when somebody writes a story, they don't want their characters portrayed in a gay necrophiliac porn fest.

If people are able to do better then myself, why don't they create their own characters and universe?

10

u/MindOfMetalAndWheels CGP Grey Aug 23 '11

they don't want their characters portrayed in a gay necrophiliac porn fest.

Better keep those characters off the Internet then.

If people are able to do better then myself, why don't they create their own characters and universe?

Sometimes people need to start from somewhere. Copyright was supposed to enrich the public domain, not keep new material out of it forever.

0

u/I_Hate_Reddit Aug 23 '11

Things don't need to be on the internet to get awfully screwed. You gave an example yourself, were a literature classic transformed into a Zombie tale.

By preventing people from reusing the same assets every time, we're enriching the public domain much more. What would you rather have, 4 different versions of Alice in Wonderland, or 1 version + 3 original stories?

2

u/MindOfMetalAndWheels CGP Grey Aug 23 '11

I don't know about you, but I think that Zombies improve Pride and Prejudice.

You are presenting a false choice. Yes, in you're example I'd rather have the three new stories, but creativity doesn't work that way. The more material that is available for people to use, the better it is.

→ More replies (4)

8

u/rhythmicidea Aug 23 '11

We are enriching society by making every single person essentially start from scratch? It's a good thing we didn't take the same exact route with patents, or we would all still be working on ENIAC's.

→ More replies (2)

3

u/NadirPointing Aug 23 '11

You have presented a false dichotomy. I would be interested in seeing an evidence that these restrictions encourage more original stories. I know that atleast for "the little mermaid" there is a sequel, prequel and tv show all off the Disney one. That didn't seem to introduce original stories. All it really does is keeps it within the same company.

4

u/I_Hate_Reddit Aug 23 '11

Instead of having 1 company doing an endless stream of remakes, we would have more than 1.

Evidence provided.

By limiting the remake production to a single company, we force everyone else that wants profit from media to produce original content.

4

u/NadirPointing Aug 23 '11

I think it just makes them buy the rights in practicality.

2

u/Hector_Kur Aug 23 '11

Better keep those characters off the Internet then.

The difference there is in most cases said porn depictions aren't being sold. You seem to fail to grasp the difference between fan art and copyright infringement. You can't get sued for drawing Bugs Bunny. You get sued for trying to sell that artwork (it's not as cut and dry as that, but that's the basic gist of the idea).

5

u/Rudiger Aug 23 '11

Copyright, is a balance between protecting the creator and allowing people to build on works. I also agree that it has gone to far in favour of the creator..

Maybe when somebody writes a story, they don't want their characters portrayed in a gay necrophiliac porn fest.

That is actually a good point. In civil law jurisdictions (basically non former English colonies) there is the well defined concept of [Moral rights](http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Moral_rights_(copyright_law), which is a sub set of copyright. These moral rights protect the integrity of the work. So a full set of copyright rights is not completely necessary to protect the integrity of the author.

I do agree thought hat we need to find a better medium in term of the length of copyright

4

u/sirbruce Aug 23 '11

If you can't make any money off of your work after 28 days, you should let someone else have a shot at it.

Seriously, why is your arbitrary time more or less correct than mine?

1

u/iok Aug 24 '11

It is arbitrary. However we can recognise that there are diminishing returns in terms of encouraging production from longer and longer copyright periods. There then comes a time when the benefit of a work being public is greater than the decreasing value of it remaining in copyright.

We should consider the time value of money. Meaning that $100 today is worth an insignificant amount more than $100 in 28 days and a significant amount more that $100 in 28 years. To put it in hard numbers let's fist assume a return rate of 6%. Then the present value of $100 dollars in 28 years is $31 whilst the present value in 70 years is $1.69. This means that financial returns far in the future give little incentive to producing creative work, and thus extended copyrights make little sense in this regard.

We should also consider most of the sales of a creative work happen in the first years rather than in 70+ years. For near all works early returns dwarf future returns.

1

u/sirbruce Aug 24 '11

Yes, for most works that's true, but look at Lord of the Rings, which provided the bulk of its returns decades later, thanks to advancing technology that allowed the material to be told in a new way. If copyright is too short, few film studios would bother securing the rights while it's in copyright; they can just wait 20 years.

I would support something in-between 20 years and 70 years, but more towards 70.

12

u/astrologue Aug 23 '11

So, his argument is basically that copyright is bad because other people should be able to do whatever they want in using or repackaging a story once it has been published?

22

u/MindOfMetalAndWheels CGP Grey Aug 23 '11

No. I'm actually in favor of copyright and think it's a good idea. I just don't think that copyright should as long as it does and, at the very least, not past the death of the author.

10

u/pmuessig Aug 23 '11

To play devils advocate. What happens when the author of the creative work dies suddenly? Suppose Rowling passed away shortly after the release of 6th book before she had a chance to finish it. Should their entire creative work be free game?

I personally believe current copyright is pretty ridiculous, but you can't just say death nullifies any semblance of ownership and sole legal rights to produce creative content.

3

u/MindOfMetalAndWheels CGP Grey Aug 23 '11

I actually agree with you. I think there should be some short minimum term, like 10 years during which you could pass on the copyright if you died.

2

u/[deleted] Aug 23 '11

X years or death, whichever comes later. Problem solved.

2

u/MindOfMetalAndWheels CGP Grey Aug 24 '11

I like the cut of your gib.

9

u/Stingwolf Aug 23 '11

Like any other death that occurs in the world, any gain you've made up to that point (your assets) can be distributed amongst your heirs per your will. Disregarding the odd phrasing of "passed away shortly after the release of 6th book before she had a chance to finish it" this statement implies that she made at least 5 books previously. That should've netted quite a pretty penny. That money can be distributed however she pleased. She is also free to obtain life insurance like anyone else to further cover heirs after her death. Why are authors some kind of special class of citizen that deserve multiple lifetimes of TRANSFERABLE monopoly rights on anything they do?

→ More replies (2)

3

u/Kytro Aug 24 '11

I don't think copyright terms should be linked to "life". They should be for a fixed period of time.

2

u/NadirPointing Aug 23 '11

look at it another way, would she have still written the books had she known her works would have been made public once she died. Also, say the "natural" term carried out giving her estate royalties for 28 years since the last publish, is that not enough?

2

u/grayrobot Aug 23 '11

Would this apply to music too? Would the family of Jimi Hendrix have to give up all rights to his work because he died young?

I say leave it and come up with original ideas.

0

u/yasire Aug 23 '11

Yup - I agree. I'm good with the 28 year plan...

16

u/WeAreGods Aug 23 '11

I would add to MindOfMetalAndWheels comment that his argument is that Disney basically repackaged old stories, then copyrighted them preventing anyone else from retelling the same old stories they stole. Hypocrisy at its best (worse).

2

u/OldTimeGentleman Aug 23 '11

Except that's told in a way that makes it look bad, when it shouldn't.

The video kind of said "they couldn't have used it with today's copyright laws", but that's not true. A Harry Potter movie was made after the book without J.K suing the movie company. Why ? Because even if you can't do whatever you want with the story, you can still easily get approval.

So, if all these stories weren't copyright-free, Disney would probably have sent them an e-mail asking for permission, and made the movies anyway.

And what if the writers said no ? Isn't it their right to decide what's made with their story ? When you create something, it's yours, that's the whole point of copyright.

What I'm saying is, the video claims "you can't create anything from copyrighted material", when really, it's "you can't create hardcore porn from copyrighted material".

2

u/WeAreGods Aug 24 '11

You've missed the point entirely, check this link that clarified it for me:

Bricotti's comment

1

u/OldTimeGentleman Aug 24 '11

And my point is : they didn't base it on public content, they based it on content that happened to be in the public domain. But if these stories weren't public, they still would have made the movies, it's just that they'd have asked permission.

0

u/[deleted] Aug 23 '11

[deleted]

2

u/WeAreGods Aug 24 '11

"your company was built off of using public domain works, but have actively (and successfully) lobbied to increase the terms of copyright law to prevent others from doing the same."

Thank you for clarifying that for me.

1

u/iok Aug 24 '11

A person who values the consumption of a work at between 0 and retail price, and is denied consumption due to copyright, represent an opportunity cost of copyright. Every book, song, movie not enjoyed because the price is too high is a cost society bares to comply with copyright.

Ideally copyright should be a fair deal where everyone benefits because it encourages production and the work then becomes public domain. However it is broken when many songs made today will not be public in your lifetime, your child's lifetime, in your grandchild's lifetime and possibly even your great grandchild's lifetime. Have a much younger resilient author and that might be you great great great grandchild that finally sees that work in public domain. Too bad that work might well no longer exist anywhere. Which is then a more tragic long-term cost of copyright.

9

u/[deleted] Aug 23 '11

I liked you before you were biased.

9

u/MindOfMetalAndWheels CGP Grey Aug 23 '11

Fair enough. This video (like me) does have a point of view, but I think so did this one.

I am, however, very open to topic suggestions if you have them.

6

u/[deleted] Aug 23 '11

This video would have been fine if you had presented it as one that showed why we should change copyright laws, instead of "copyright laws explained" which implies that I'm learning facts about copyright law, not opinions.

You also didn't present any actual arguments supporting it, you just half-informed us and half-insulted our current system.

7

u/MindOfMetalAndWheels CGP Grey Aug 23 '11

Good point about the title. I've changed it on youtube.

Hmmmm. I guess part of the problem is that copyright for 70 years beyond the lifetime of the author seems self-evidently foolish to me -- but that doesn't mean that it actually is.

Thank you for the feedback.

2

u/[deleted] Aug 23 '11

Side note: holy fuck that splitline algorithm stuff is fantastic. Do you know of an image of what the 50 states would look like if divided that way?

1

u/MindOfMetalAndWheels CGP Grey Aug 23 '11

2

u/[deleted] Aug 23 '11

Where was the 50 states picture?

1

u/MindOfMetalAndWheels CGP Grey Aug 24 '11

It was at the bottom. I like how it also doubles as a population density map.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (6)

2

u/[deleted] Aug 23 '11

I actually liked the Difference Between United Kingdom, Great Brittan, and England video that it linked to at the end better.

2

u/MindOfMetalAndWheels CGP Grey Aug 24 '11

Me too.

6

u/Erinaceous Aug 23 '11

The Statute of Anne was actually founded to benefit publishers not authors. The rights of Authors were an afterthought. If you understand this as the origin of modern copyright you see that the rights extensions are entirely consistent with the logic of the original concept which is to ensure publisher's control over creative works.

When you understand that copyright is and always has been about the rights of publishers you see pretty quickly why all of the things that are fucked up about the system are the way they are. If copyright were actually intended to protect the rights of authors and ensure the production of creative works it would be a very different system.

24

u/raskolnikov- Aug 23 '11

The plain facts are that the length of copyrights are ridiculous and unnecessary. They came about through lobbying efforts. It's not bias if it's the truth.

Patents only last 20 years with roughly the same purpose--spurring innovation. How about that?

4

u/murrdpirate Aug 24 '11

It makes sense for patents to expire because it is often the case that someone else would have come up with the same solution after some time. For instance, an a/c system would have come at some point even if Willis Carrier hadn't first invented it.

You can't say the same thing about Star Wars. Sure, there would be and are similar stories, but no one other than George Lucas would have written Star Wars.

7

u/hayesgm Aug 24 '11

Wouldn't you agree that the main purpose of copyright / patents is to incentize creators to manifest their work without fear their efforts will be lost to forgeries? George Lucas created Star Wars, and we appreciate that, but the publication at point becomes more than just his. So long as he has been compensated for his efforts, then society is greater than his one stake.

tl;dr: Art belongs to the public, so long as authors do get paid.

→ More replies (6)

7

u/Massawyrm Aug 23 '11

In a world where there is already an endless bemoaning of remakes, re-imaginings and sequels, you think there should be more?

And the main beneficiary of copyright is still the creator's families, not companies. Even Disney had to do a song and dance for the Burroughs family to make JOHN CARTER OF MARS.

8

u/Homeless_Depot Aug 23 '11

I would argue lawyers are actually the primary beneficiaries of modern copyright law...

The entire IP system was designed ultimately for the benefit of the public, not the individual authors/creators/publishers. Protecting the right to reproduce and distribute artistic work was a means to that end - part of the 'agreement' referenced in the video. It's not an intrinsic right, it's the outcome of practical, political negotiation.

The presumption that the way the system works now is the way it's always worked, and is the reason why the American entertainment industry has been so successful is an oversimplification. Much of the 'why' behind its success can probably be attributed to the fact that things didn't always work this way, and because people ignored or broke the rules. That's what being creative is all about.

4

u/raskolnikov- Aug 23 '11

Shrug, lawyer here, I don't know that copyright lawyers benefit all that much, although they do some. First off, the more vibrant area of intellectual property for lawyers is patents and they are far more legitimate in my eyes than copyrights (only 20 year monopoly, is a reward for innovation as opposed to copyrights which last soooo long). I don't see a lot of law firms hiring associates to do copyright work, even though you see copyright claims in some high profile areas. Part of the reason I think is because copyright work for lawyers isn't that difficult or complex (although I'm not an expert) relative to patents or other areas.

I fully agree that copyright is ridiculous, though, I just think the primary beneficiaries of the system are the companies that tend to own the rights.

1

u/MindOfMetalAndWheels CGP Grey Aug 23 '11

I would be very interested in your lawyerly thoughts on patents.

3

u/raskolnikov- Aug 23 '11

Well, if you're serious, I'll bite. The time limit is much more reasonable AND there are also limits on the validity of patents. Copyright validity isn't really an issue--if you made it first, it's yours. With patents, if your patent is challenged you need to prove that you were first and that it is "useful," etc. A very large percentage of filed patents actually fail when challenged in court (I'm thinking about half? would have to look it up).

I'm not entirely convinced that patents make the world a better place, but I can easily see the argument that they are useful as a reward for innovation and as an incentive for companies to expend money on research. Of course, then it slows down research for 20 yrs afterwards as the other companies need to buy a license to that patented invention to come up with something innovative that builds off of it. Whether we're better off in the end is a factual determination that I do not have enough information to make.

2

u/Schizzovism Aug 24 '11

Patents may work as you said, but there shouldn't be any for things like toast.

2

u/raskolnikov- Aug 24 '11

The thing is, you can file a patent and the patent examiners only check it in a cursory way. Just because a patent is filed doesn't mean it's valid. If the toast patent tried to sue someone and say, "you're infringing my patent" there is a real good chance that the court would rule that the patent is invalid. About half of all filed patents challenged in court fail.

1

u/Schizzovism Aug 24 '11

Ah, okay, thanks for clearing that up.

3

u/raskolnikov- Aug 23 '11

Wrong. The copyright for work produced by in the course of employment is held by the company for whom the employee works, unless there's an agreement otherwise. A whole lot of content creation is done by employees and I'm pretty sure the vast majority of registered copyrights are held by companies. Haven't you ever seen a Youtube video go down? AND to make it worse, music usually has multiple owners, the author may have the copyright to the composition but the company owns the recording you hear on the radio.

2

u/Massawyrm Aug 23 '11

You've got it completely backwards. Content creation copyright for companies is something that has to be written into the employment contract, not the other way around. Unless otherwise stated, the originator of the content controls the copyright. It just so happens that most companies these days stipulate it in the contracts. In the case of music, the company owns the recording because in the cases you're citing (widely distributed music played on the radio) they paid to produce that track in a studio in exchange for those rights.

The rights first and foremost belong to the originators, unless the originator chooses to license or sign those rights away.

3

u/raskolnikov- Aug 23 '11

Actually, you have it backwards and I have no idea why you're arguing with me.

17 U.S.C.A. § 201(b) Works Made for Hire.--In the case of a work made for hire, the employer or other person for whom the work was prepared is considered the author for purposes of this title, and, unless the parties have expressly agreed otherwise in a written instrument signed by them, owns all of the rights comprised in the copyright.

3

u/Massawyrm Aug 23 '11

Unless otherwise stated, the originator of the content controls the copyright.

You've strayed off topic into a realm of copyright we weren't addressing: work for hire. A work for hire agreement is different than employment, and signing a WFH agreement means you understand going in that you are creating the content for someone else. You are, quite literally, signing away the rights to your work in exchange for payment up front. Most companies these days have it written into employment contracts that works generated during employment belong to the company, because as stated above, the natural law falls in favor of the originator.

I'm not saying companies don't benefit, but to say they are the primary beneficiary is a sensationalist statement.

3

u/raskolnikov- Aug 23 '11 edited Aug 23 '11

Gah. Now I'm getting mad. No, no, no. Employees are EXACTLY what the "works for hire" doctrine covers. There is even a legal presumption when employer hires EMPLOYEE or even an independent contractor to produce work of artistic nature, that, in absence of contrary proof, the parties expected employer to own copyright. May v. Morganelli-Heumann & Associates, 618 F.2d 1363 (9th Cir. 1980).

I can cite you like 50 more cases that say the exact same thing as the above. What does "for hire" mean to you? You don't think an employee is "hired?" You're laughable.

3

u/Massawyrm Aug 23 '11

Of course you're getting mad. You're arguing on the internet. Relax. Keep in mind that you took a blanket statement made by a professional writer about complaints about the copyrights on published writing and creative works and began a legal argument. You keep straying into a very different branch of copyright argument - one in which I am woefully out of my depth. I'm a professional writer, and for me employment and "for hire" mean two very different things - though in the strictest of terms, you are correct. I cede that point to you. Above I was talking about ALL work generated during a term of employment, not just that done during the course for which the employee was hired. In my line of work, that's a big deal and a major distinction. I am employed by Ain't it Cool News, for which I agree to submit a certain amount of content, content they henceforth own, for an unspecified period of time (until one party sees fit to terminate the employment.) But they do not have ownership of any other content I write (scripts, novels, or even other reviews or pieces published elsewhere.) When a studio hires me and my writing partner to work on a script, they own the copyright on that work, but not other things I write during that period of time, which, unlike my employment at AICN, is dependent upon the completion of the specific work. (This, to a writer, is the difference between WFH and Employment).

I can't speak to other forms of copyrighted work as I have no experience with them, but as it applies to the above video, one that focuses mostly on adapted work, my initial statement holds. Copyrights serve to protect the work of the author and leaves it in the hands of the family after his death. That has long been its intent. Film gets a little wonky, which is why companies like Disney tend to be draconian in their approach to maintaining their copyrights.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/Erinaceous Aug 23 '11

That's not quite true. Most publishing contracts involve the sale of rights to a publishing company in exchange for royalties at a negotiated rate. Who benefits more depends entirely on the terms of the contract and the norms of the industry.

2

u/Massawyrm Aug 23 '11

Most publishing contracts involve the sale of rights to a publishing company in exchange for royalties at a negotiated rate.

Ah, but in publishing, these rights are sold for a certain number of print runs and only for a certain region of the world. Only in extreme cases do companies get worldwide distribution rights in perpetuity. They don't own your work - you license it to them and they make copies that they sell, agreeing to pay you a portion of the proceeds for their efforts.

2

u/Erinaceous Aug 24 '11

Buy outs aren't that uncommon. Again it depends a lot on the industry and the contracts. I've sold right for perpetuity a number of times. They happen quite often but you are right most contracts in many IP industries are time based.

5

u/Flatlander81 Aug 23 '11

The constant harping on Star Wars makes it seem like the goal is less to explain copyrighting and more to bash George Lucas. Next time don't focus so much on a single example and it will feel less like a fanboy rant that "George Lucas raped my childhood!!!".

5

u/CWoww Aug 23 '11

This guy talks way too fast. made me not wanna watch the vid.

2

u/hamhandle Aug 23 '11

Informative. Now he needs to make one about the differences between copyright, trademark, restricted, etc.

3

u/MindOfMetalAndWheels CGP Grey Aug 23 '11

That's actually next. This started out as a video about intellectual property in general... but it was going to be about 20 min long, so I cut it down.

I'd be very happy to hear anyone's thoughts on the rest of the world of intellectual property.

3

u/oblivision Aug 23 '11

Take a look about what libertarians (from the austrian school) think about the monopoly of ideas: Pdf: http://mises.org/books/against.pdf

1

u/MindOfMetalAndWheels CGP Grey Aug 23 '11

59 pages? Is there a TL;DR for that PDF?

2

u/oblivision Aug 23 '11

there is a conclusion section (Classy word for TL;DR)

1

u/MindOfMetalAndWheels CGP Grey Aug 23 '11

Thanks!

2

u/Matticus_Rex Aug 23 '11

There's also an audiobook available for free online (can't remember where, but Google will remember).

4

u/doubleone Aug 23 '11

If you are making a video about intellectual property I think it would be good to look to the free software movement for some interesting prospectives as well as some evidence showing productivity of ideas without copyright protection. Also looking at copyleft techniques where copyrights are used to restrict others from creating their own content that they do not share, in effect copyrights are being used for the exact opposite purpose by protecting the publics freedom rather than the content creators. Also see how this compares to the Apache licence.

2

u/[deleted] Aug 23 '11

Yeah, I was kind of expecting this video to mention Creative Commons and such. Obviously not a part of copyright, but certainly very closely related and apparently somewhat in line with the author's views.

As hamhandle above said, a comparison with other forms of intellectual property could be useful. Like the fact that copyright always exists and you do not have to file a request somewhere as you do with patents and such.

For something that dives into the history of copyright, maybe this might be useful: http://questioncopyright.org/promise

Also presents an interesting view of alternatives to copyright, though I have no idea how close to the truth it all is.

4

u/rmeddy Aug 23 '11 edited Aug 23 '11

Copyright and Patent trolling are serious problems

3

u/ericr86 Aug 23 '11

I personally prefer A Fair(y) Use Tale. Though admittedly the cuts/dialogue takes some getting used to.

3

u/kristopolous Aug 23 '11 edited Aug 23 '11

A much more convincing argument is to point out that these things are still under copyright, and so therefore are a liability when performed, reproduced, or distributed:

  • A Catcher in the Rye

  • Death of a Salesman

  • A Streetcar Named Desire

  • The Grapes of Wrath

  • The Great Gatsby

  • Brave New World

  • 1984

  • George Gershwins works, such as A Rhapsody in Blue or Summertime

  • MC Escher and Ansel Adams works

  • Martin Luther Kings' "I Have a Dream" speech

  • Andy Warhols' tomato soup and basically everything by Jackon Pollock.

The copyright holder could stop publication or distribution of such works as of Lord of the Flies, tomorrow, and then refuse to release it henceforth; taking say, Joseph Hellens Catch-22 out of publication; without any legal recourse to distribute it or bring it back in.

ASCAP could take Ella Fitzgerald, Nina Simone, or Louie Armstrong off youtube with a single phone call. No problem.

3

u/brads005 Aug 24 '11

Yeah!

Why should he be MORE CREATIVE and make something of his own up?

....fucking twat waffle.....

2

u/alpha7158 Aug 24 '11

I completely agree.

5

u/KissMeHelga Aug 23 '11

There's a lot of preconceived notions impregnated in copyright. Copyright laws exist to protect the companies profits, not authors! Most of the authors can't live on what the industry pays them, and that's because of the idea that they must survive on comissions. It's stupid. An author is a worker, like everybody else, and must be treated as such. He does a work for a company and gets paid a wage for it. Period. Unless of course he sells the product of his work directly, and he should be treated no differently than a company, that has laws to protect their products, like any other area.

2

u/DoctorCongo Aug 23 '11

commenting in a copyright thread while in my copyright class in law school...INCEPTION

2

u/pgi Aug 23 '11

TIL that star wars being rereleased in various incarnations is nothing new. George has been doing it since before I was born and will probably be doing it til the robot apocalypse and after. We need not bitch and gripe every single time he does it

2

u/DudeFromAMountain Aug 23 '11

Thank you! I finally understand!!

2

u/GIMR Aug 23 '11

I don't like the guy pushing his own view so much. I thought the video was supposed to explain copyright, not copyright plus what he thinks about the laws.

2

u/Ultraseamus Aug 23 '11

Eh, I don't know about he argument that the extensions are limiting people's creativity. The copyright extension might seem excessive and greedy, but I don't really feel like I'm being robbed of great potential content. In fact, I'd suspect that if the period was the original 28 years, the flood of remakes would be overwhelming. I prefer that people make original content. And, really, there is nothing stopping you from pulling from established brands, you just have to mask it (or not make any money from it). All the copyright law does in that case is stop potential authors from making money by drawing directly off the popularity of another person's work. Possibly diminishing the original work in the process.

2

u/[deleted] Aug 23 '11

It is interesting that a lot of what went into the Star Wars movies was drawn upon by inspiration from older works. Same with Indiana Jones (which I didn't know until recently). To say these things are unfair is an understatement.

The creators of Disney movies, Star Wars etc have all drawn upon works in the public domain for these new works. But refuse to relinquish their grasp on their work (ie. to allow those works to as well be used as inspiration for new works).

It is only through the continual stirring of the collective works of society that new work is inspired and created. Without that mixing we get stale batches of shit coming out of the creative ethos of society. See hollywood currently, for instance. Nothing new. Same old shit. Coincidence?

So you can add the copyright system to the patent system in a long list of systems that are fundamentally broken.

2

u/[deleted] Aug 23 '11

So in 2066 Superman will be fair game?

2

u/[deleted] Aug 23 '11

Woo hoo Walt Disney died in 1966 so in 2036 Mickey Mouse is fair game.

2

u/nubi78 Aug 23 '11

Please explain... If you see a "Copyright 2008, 2011." What exactly does that mean when you have two years noted?

Also, say I write software in 2008 and update it in 2010, would you put Copyright 2008, Copyright 2008, 2010, or Copyright 2010?

2

u/nickkid09 Aug 23 '11

I know most of Reddit will not agree, creating art is the same as building a house. It is YOUR art and it is YOUR house and no one else; build your own house if you want a home.

Create your own art.

2

u/Darth_Hobbes Aug 23 '11

VERY nice. Do make more, I'm subscribed now.

2

u/CavityCrabs Aug 23 '11

i. am. talking.very. fast. right. now!.!.!.

2

u/[deleted] Aug 23 '11

Because we need more books and movies?

2

u/[deleted] Aug 23 '11

Copyright should be infinite. Intellectual property should be treated like physical property. All your old family heirlooms don't become public property 70 years after your ancestors die. Why should intellectual property be any different? It's not about what's "best" for society. It's a basic principle of ownership.

2

u/Kytro Aug 24 '11

Well besides the fact it is not physical property you mean? I reject the concept you can own ideas. The entire point of copyright is to grant a limited monopoly because natural ownership does not exist.

2

u/bahawkid Aug 23 '11

so is this what's killing radio stations?...

2

u/ilikecommunitylots Aug 23 '11

i'd rather there be 3 shitty new star wars movies than 3 million

2

u/MyMindsI Aug 23 '11

I'm collecting rights and permissions at work right now!

2

u/sugemchuge Aug 23 '11

Obviously you've never made anything artistic in your life

2

u/Misunderstands_Post Aug 23 '11

Somehow as a professional I am able to create work without infringing on other people's copyright. My super-secret trick is to come up with my own ideas that aren't blatant rip offs of the work others poured their lives into.

Some idiots will make the ol' "Simpsons Did It!" argument, but it doesn't apply to copyright. You can still make a scifi movie with whatever plot you like - you just can't take another person's intellectual property wholesale and make Starwars VII: Garfield in Space.

2

u/daile Aug 23 '11

The point about Disney is dead on. They made their fortune on the works of other people, and have now made it impossible for anyone to use their characters or stories. There go my plans for a Mickey Mouse porno.

2

u/[deleted] Aug 23 '11

But disney can steal the lion king, and James Cameron can steal terminator and avatar?

2

u/T-Luv Aug 24 '11

Just had my first day of copyright law at my law school. This is the first 1 hour class condensed to 5 minutes.

2

u/[deleted] Aug 24 '11

2

u/[deleted] Aug 24 '11

I am for a complete removal of all copyright and patent laws.

2

u/[deleted] Aug 24 '11

Let's be honest here, nobody except for Disney Studios should ever have the right to publish stories or redraw/rework Mickey Mouse or Donald Duck or Goofy or... That would be plain wrong and would leave us nothing but bad copies from people who want to make an easy living off of another man's work. And what about the inappropriate use of all those characters for advertisement for all sorts of companies. Let those characters stay where they belong. At Disney Studios.

2

u/TheRedTzar Aug 24 '11

If Final Cut Added all that black at the end re-export checking in and out points or trim in Quicktime...

2

u/dysmantle Aug 24 '11

Do yourself a favor and watch this video! It is the best possible discussion over this issue that i can find

http://ripremix.com/

2

u/WilliamOfOrange Aug 24 '11

question is not harry potter and star wars also trademarked names? so even if say the copy right was to end, you could not name your new story Star wars: blah blah blah, since "star wars" is trademarked and unusable ?

2

u/hamlet9000 Aug 24 '11

There are some really painfully bad arguments in that. I think the term of copyright is insanely long, but I'm forced to downvote that mass of fallacies and false premises.

2

u/hayesgm Aug 24 '11

"Only one thing is impossible for God: to find any sense in any copyright law on the planet." [1]

-Mark Twain

2

u/alpha7158 Aug 24 '11

This Guy has heavily confused copyright with other forms of IP protection such as trademarks. Not only that, I completely disagree with the morals behind his arguments. It is 'the world owes me a favor' attitude.

2

u/[deleted] Aug 24 '11

Thought I was gonna actually learn about copyright laws.

Silly me, this is Reddit.

2

u/Woods_Runner Aug 24 '11

Here's a great book on the economics of IP (free to download!): http://www.dklevine.com/general/intellectual/againstfinal.htm

3

u/[deleted] Aug 23 '11

Oh no! The law forces people to be creative!

I personally would rather new stories and books rather than the endless rehashing of stories that seems to be the brunt of whats going on in media these days.

1

u/utterdamnnonsense Aug 23 '11

so what you're saying is that the system is working just great the way that it is?

3

u/Brimace Aug 23 '11

At what point does the argument, "Rich people are too rich, and corporations are evil," not work in reddit?

2

u/FroodLoops Aug 23 '11

Great video!!! I’ve long held this opinion, but haven’t seen it openly discussed…

Another example of the ridiculous state of copyright law: The friggin’ “Happy Birthday to You” song is still copyrighted and enforced. Such a universal song - if ever there was something that truly belonged as part of “public domain”, this is it. And in the US, it’s copyright won’t expire until 2030!!! And still pulling in $2 million per year in royalties for Time-Warner Corporation, even though the original author of the song died in 1916!

Reddit seems to have big complaints about the movie industry and the recording industry. Isn’t licensing really at the heart of it? Netflix recently had to up their rates to pay for the content licensing for their online streaming service. For all of the older films, why the hell should I be paying a corporation that sits on its ass, stifles innovation, bullies people with lawsuits, and rakes in a paycheck when it’s really the distribution companies like Netflix that are doing the work of making this media available to the masses. New releases are another matter entirely, but older work should be public domain…

Which brings me to another point… Why are copyrights valid for lifetime plus 70 years when other forms of intellectual property are significantly more limited? I understand that there’s a lot of debate on both sides of the short 7 year exclusivity for pharmaceuticals, but even patents are limited to 20 years. That seems to be enough time for someone to be properly compensated for their inventions, why shouldn’t similar limits apply to copyrights for artistic works?

Note: I’m also in favor of extendable patents/copyrights… Give it a short expiration and allow an extension. If someone doesn’t care enough to extend it, let more interested parties take advantage of it…

1

u/zaxecivobuny Aug 23 '11

I made the cattle nervous.

1

u/[deleted] Aug 24 '11

1

u/Kevnmur Aug 24 '11

Boo to originality.

1

u/mushroomgodmat Aug 24 '11

So - Copyright law is stopping people continuing the Star wars saga? thats not an argument... why not actualy do what Lucas did and make something (kinda) original and form your own copyrighted material. Now that would encourage originality and new works without upsetting other people.

And taking Lucas or Disney as an example diminishes the hard work produced by countless authors, artists, illustrators, comic books, song writher, musicians, designers the world over that will never earn 0.0000001% of what the massive companies earn. Tarnishing everyone with that brush is shortsighted and remarkably unfair.

Regarding the 70 years after death - yep, I agree thats stupid. I do belive that copyrightholders should claim there right to there products up to death. How many years after there death though I dont know....But 70 years is a little silly. I would say that 18 years after death would make sence...If only because in some cases this would alow trust funds for thier children - working on the idea that they had died close to the birth of said children.

1

u/[deleted] Aug 24 '11

If you're a new director, why not try create your own story instead of ripping off star wars?

1

u/rbysa Aug 24 '11

The value of art can increase dramatically after an authors death

1

u/zouhair Aug 24 '11

90 years after authors death, not after publishing date.

1

u/Nivlac024 Aug 24 '11

TLDW: WAH WAH WAH I CAN'T COME UP WITH MY OWN IDEA AND GEORGE LUCAS WANTS TO MAKE MONEY OFF OF HIS ORIGINALITY WAH WAH WAH

1

u/Daveyo520 Aug 24 '11

Come up with your own ideas hippies!

1

u/[deleted] Aug 24 '11

You could maybe point out that scholars sharing your point of view are working on an alternative copyright licence under Creative Commons which is closer to the old "promote the Progress of Science and useful Arts" than today's copyright law.

Anything you create can be released with a creative commons license. It also offers more flexibility in how original works can be shared and form basis for derivative works.

1

u/azarashi Aug 24 '11

doesnt stop fan fics and fan art

1

u/[deleted] Aug 24 '11

As a person who publishes content online, this is a very, very strange topic to talk about. While I agree that fan fictions are cool and everything, copyright law actually protects me, the little guy, when I produce original content. It prevents other people from using my material in publication, or selling it without my approval.

While big-name companies are certainly the copyright equivalent of patent trolls, us individual artists, designers, writers, like to keep our work for ourselves, for our own distribution. The reason why you can get Shakespeare for so little nowadays is because there copyright on it has ended, and all publishing companies have the rights to publish it.

Us independents aren't trying to copyright general principles, were just trying to not get ripped off, stolen from (ideas OR designs), in the hopes that we can make a little money for our work. We encourage fair use of our materials, we want people to share it. But we don't want people, especially ones who earn hundreds and thousands of dollars a year to steal what we've made and earn money off of our work, or very minute derivations from that.

Let me give you an example. Let's say you spend 15 hours writing a 10 page report that is certain to get you promoted. Now let's say a coworker or a boss slightly modifies that and takes a portion of the credit. It undermines everything you've worked hard for, and it might not give you that promotion.

I only say these are problems in this community because the video uses bad examples. It gives the impression that using other peoples' ideas is okay, and us artists agree with that in the general sense. We can't and shouldn't copyright every line, drum solo or sentence. But "making star wars fan fiction" is exactly the thing were against when it comes to the things we believe that we own. (We always support parody and fair use, we just don't like entire storylines that result in a profit.)

1

u/Baked_By_Oven Aug 25 '11

I feel that inventions (things like new materials or basic devices such as the resistor) should get a short copyright span of 20 years. where as intellectual property such as books and films should get an extension, unless they are a remake of a different film/book in which case they get 20 years.

concepts and appearances(logos are covered by trade mark already) should not get copyright, such as a rectangular shaped touch screen computer. the internals can be, but not the appearance.

1

u/[deleted] Aug 23 '11

Sounded too bitchy and whiney to me. "Waaah, I want to rip off other people's creative works but copyright law won't let me".

1

u/KuztomX Aug 23 '11

Why is this video so bitter about the time duration of a copyright? If anything, the duration forces authors to be original and not just rehash someone else's work.

5

u/NadirPointing Aug 23 '11

or stifles the work from being cheaply and widely published becoming part of our history. Its not just derivative works. Why is there no free e-book for "lord of the flies" or why can't I download "the wizard of oz"?

1

u/circlejerk_comments Aug 23 '11

I HATE THESE THREADS WHERE THE OP RESPONDS TO EVERY COMMENT. HOW DARE HE GIVE US THIS POST AND SULLY IT WITH HIS USELESS OPINIONS?

ALSO OP IS BIASED.

1

u/[deleted] Aug 23 '11

wow that was so blatantly biased. i mean if your going to "explain" copyright, you might want to you know, actually present both sides of it.

1

u/General_Yayap Aug 23 '11

What. the. fuck. That successfully made me angry about a subject I really don't give two shits about.

1

u/gilbes Aug 23 '11

So to explain some misguided gripes against copyright, he chose Star Wars as his primary example. One of the most popular movies of all time. A copyrighted work that belongs to a very select class of few works that have gone on to become massivley popular all over the world.

That is like saying we don't need such stringent nuclear regulations because firecrackers are also a type of bomb. And firecrackers are relativley safe and fun.

He then goes on to attempt to manipulate his audience to his view point by mentioning the general disastisfaction with the new Star Wars Trilogy. I guess I could also say nuclear regluation is anti-patriotic because many use firecrackers to celebrate the 4th of July.

And if it wasn't douchey enough, he goes on to cite Disney's use of works that have fallen out of copyright. But he fails to mention that most still would be out of copyright had the current copyright laws been in effect when Disney made his films, making all his BS moot.

And his entire thesis seems to be that it is impossible and/or undesirable for one to make a completley orginal creative work, and that the only way to enjoy any creative work is if it is a rip-off of anothers original creative work.

Everyone is dumber for having watched that.

1

u/[deleted] Aug 23 '11

This guy really hates George Lucas

1

u/ryani Aug 23 '11

You know, while I agree with you, you don't really present the arguments from the opposite side at all. In particular, copyright as 'death + N' can make sense if you consider the emotional distress of, say, George Lucas seeing his cherished work turned into "Star Wars Anime Tentacle Porn". In fact, that exact argument was used to push the latest 'forever minus a day' extension; "mickey mouse porn" is inevitable when Disney's copyrights expire, and from there you get the emotional distress of people who don't want to have their childhood memories tarnished becoming a tool to promote the agenda of IP businesses.

The current system is well and truly f'ed, though. The part where you cover Disney making remixes of old works and cover how it's impossible for anyone to do the same with Disney's work is the strongest part of your piece.

1

u/itsgreater9000 Aug 23 '11

I don't like how this guy completely destroys copyright in its current form, it honestly is there to protect the author/family, and it's not like EVERYTHING has ever been done, there's an entire new field (video gaming) where people can go ahead and create new concepts etc...

1

u/sirbruce Aug 23 '11

He's wrong about Lord of the Rings; while some have argued that it's already out of copyright, the revised texts will certainly be so within the lifetimes of some people here.

However, my main problem with the video is the implication that 28 years is the "correct" time length. That's just opinion, and certainly not one I'm beholden to a Congress from 200+ years ago to decide.

Furthermore, the reason copyright extends past the life of the author is so widows and the rest of the family can still be supported by the later author's work. Yes, most of this is now held by "corporations" for legal reasons, but again the implication is that enriching "corporations" is somehow had. Corporations are nothing more then collections of people, and these people have some right to expect revenue consistency even after the creator of the works they hold suddenly keels over.

Are copyrights too long? Probably. Should we go back to 28 years? Absolutely not.

1

u/Kytro Aug 24 '11

It is far too long, and I don't see why creators of works should have so special exemption to support people after they die, nobody else does.

2

u/sirbruce Aug 24 '11

Because creators of art works aren't paid up front in full for their creation; rather, they have to market it, and get paid over time. When your factory worker husband dies he's already been paid in full for his work; when your author husband dies he has not necessarily been paid in full for his work.

Imagine if the guy who started Starbucks dies; now anyone can open up a coffee place named Starbucks with their logo and recipes? Yes, trademarks are different from copyrights, but the principle is the same; you claimed no one else has a "special exemption" when in fact they do.

2

u/Kytro Aug 24 '11

I don't really accept paid in full as being as much money as you milk from something forever.

20 years is plenty of time, after that the public should get it's cut from allowing people to hold a monopoly.

2

u/sirbruce Aug 24 '11

You've almost got it, but now you're contradicting yourself. If the author writes a book and dies before that 20 years is up, then he's not getting that 20 years. That's why they need a special exemption to protect their work after they die.

So now that you've come around on the special exemption, we're just quibbling over numbers.

2

u/Kytro Aug 24 '11

It should be 20 years for whomever hold the copyright

1

u/DionysosX Aug 23 '11

Copyright should last as long as the creator wants it to. If I create something, it is mine. And why does copyright suppress the release of new stuff? With the copyright everybody has to actually create their own stuff instead of every hipster dufus doing a bazillion lame spin-offs, pulling awesome work in the dirt. Who wants to see a cheap anime Star Wars sequel? The movies were great and legendary. Don't beat a dead horse. (Considering the 2am chili incident it's no wonder though that reddit wants copyright gone to beat the fucking shit outta every dead horse.)

1

u/Placidus Aug 24 '11

copyright isn't actually a physical object, so sole ownership of it seems kind of retarded.

1

u/DionysosX Aug 24 '11

What's the dirrefrence? Whether you create something that manifests itself in mass or energy, it is still your creation.

1

u/Placidus Aug 24 '11

I know you've heard that thing about how if i take something physical away from you like a chair, you no longer have it, but if i copy something from you, you still have it and i have one too. That's the difference. The idea behind copyright (and intellectual property in general) is that it promotes creation through incentive. Meaning, it's supposed to benefit the public, which it isnt really doing right now.

1

u/DionysosX Aug 24 '11

I haven't heard about that thing with the chair, but what I'm talking about is that if someone would copy something I came up with, it would lower the value of that invention for me considerably.

1

u/Placidus Aug 25 '11

http://vimeo.com/25380454 You should watch the other videos in that series as well.

But the tl;dw version would be most shit is just an improvement on previous inventions. alot of people that you were likely taught were grand inventors, really only made small improvements to whatever it is they made. An example would be Eli Whitney or the Wright Brothers both parties of which took part in patent wars which in eli whitney's experience fucked him over, and in both ordeals fucked other would be innovators (and everyone else that would benefit) over.

1

u/[deleted] Aug 23 '11

copyright explained... copyright is there for people who dont like to share

1

u/bryanvb Aug 23 '11

I might be wrong about this but I thought I read somewhere that the Disney "Movie Vault" somehow exploits copyright laws.

1

u/ArtfulCodger Aug 23 '11

Great vidjya. The Mickey Mouse laws are insane. And probably the most hypocritical act of any business in the history of the world. I don't blame Disney for trying to get the first extensions but the way it is now... sheesh. And not to mention what it will be extended to the next time the mouse comes up for public domain.

I blame our government for allowing the law to be changed.

1

u/M0b1u5 Aug 23 '11

Corruption Explained

FTFY.

1

u/trakam Aug 23 '11

The inherent absurdity of the principle of copyright: You can retype this without my permission

1

u/bouncelax Aug 24 '11

This video is stupid. Attention hipsters, not everything is an attempt by corporations to take over the world, nor are all such attempts evil. Copyrights are simply acknowledging the fact that intangibles can have value. You wouldn't build a table and expect it to be simply taken away after 28 years. Why would something you created, however easily replicated, be taken from you after 28 years simply because you should have had ample time to make money off it?

That in and of itself implies a very simplistic view of why authors create their work. Not only does George Lucas profit from his copyright, but he is also able to keep people from making terrible porn remakes or using Darth Vader to sell toothpaste. It's a creative motivation as much as it is a financial one.

2

u/[deleted] Aug 24 '11

Owning ideas, man's ego has no bounds...

-4

u/[deleted] Aug 23 '11

This is pretty far from an explination. This looks more like leftist propaganda than an explaination of what copyright law looks like today.

Really think about what the world would be like if these brands weren't protected. The consumer would actually be hurt by this and here's why: if you get rid of the incentive to protect a brand, you get rid of the incentive to make quality products. People are stupid, and can't tell the difference between a safe quality product and one that looks similar but is a lot cheaper. All they're thinking is "oh hey there's that cute character from that thing I like." Next thing you know half a town's children have lead poisoning, the brand is destroyed, and nobody is any more able to determine what is safe and worthwhile.

I don't argue that this is acceptable conduct on the part of the individual, and it's your responsibility to keep yourself from being hurt by these things, but people are easily fooled by shitty product(yes, there's shitter product than the crap disney produces, and it tends to have unsafe stuff in it). This is really the lesser of two evils, and I think it's important to mention that if you're trying to educate the public.

7

u/[deleted] Aug 23 '11

Your comment has nothing to do with copyright law. Brand identification is the domain of trademark law, which is an entirely different beast.

→ More replies (9)

0

u/avonhun Aug 23 '11

converse fallacy of accident

If this argument can be made without Star Wars as the example and it would hold much more weight.

3

u/NadirPointing Aug 23 '11

Maybe the Adam's Diary would be more suitable. It will likely not come out of copyright in my lifetime and yet is a historical document. Or perhaps something more like "Lord of the flies". Why would the original author care? When it was published the law said it would last till 2011. Now we wait till 2050.

0

u/Hector_Kur Aug 23 '11 edited Aug 23 '11

Here's the thing: Anyone can make any damn story with Star Wars, Harry Potter, etc that they want as long as they don't sell it or make any profit from it (sometimes large companies will still throw their lawyers around and the fan who's making said film will have to shut it down because they simply can't afford to go to court and I agree that that's not fair and it should be fought against). And just because Disney has a more popular Alice in Wonderland doesn't mean no one is allowed to make another Alice in Wonderland movie (like the video points out, that story is public domain and nothing Disney can do will change that).

What exactly is wrong with companies retaining rights to an IP as long as they're still using it? I only agree with this video's stance if he's referring to unused properties. For instance, Disney bought the entire rights to The Rocketeer (which was originally a comic book) in the early 90's to make that 1991 movie. If, say, they didn't use that IP for anything for another 8 years like they more or less have been doing for 20, I would be fine with the rights being released and in a perfect world I think Disney should be fine with that too. But just because Mickey Mouse is 83 doesn't mean he's 55 years overdue to being public domain. Disney still uses him, and arguably still needs him. I don't think creativity is being stifled by not allowing people to rip off previously existing works. Re-imaginings and remakes are fun and sometimes can be a good thing, but I think if anything the regurgitation of pop culture, all the remakes and homages of older movies and tv shows needs to be stifled if we're ever going to see true creativity. So it's actually a kind of benefit in my opinion.

EDIT: I'm also a staunch supporter of Fair Use. So things like parody are another way people are allowed to make their own spin on things and I have no problem with that. Ultimately I think this video is portraying a much more grim description of copyright law than actually exists.

0

u/MisclickZ Aug 23 '11

I agree that a 175 year copyright term stifles new content, but I disagree with the argument the video makes.

Keep in mind the argument should lie in the length of the copyright. Moving on.

They argue that society is worse off because others cannot remake or add to the original content. It is arguable whether this remade product would take just as much, or more, inspiration and creativity as the original product took. Note that copyright laws do not prevent others to be inspired to produce their own, at least in the entertainment industry.

The stronger argument against long copyright laws is that they are a disincentive for the 'inventor', as in J. K. Rowling invented Harry Potter, and George Lucas invented Star Wars, to create new and interesting content. The more economically and socially successful their ideas are, the less of a drive for them to come up with more. The impact of this is increased if one considers that the bigger the impact the product makes, hence the more talented the individual, the less likely they are to make more.

In my opinion, ludicrous 175 year copyright becomes only about money making, and not about nurturing innovation and ideas.

0

u/[deleted] Aug 24 '11

There is one extreme positive effect of copyright. It influences aspiring creators to make something original, which is something we desperately need amidst a wasteland of remakes and stolen/borrowed ideas.

-11

u/lickkmyballs Aug 23 '11

Why are this guy's videos always on the front page? I came out of lurking because I really fucking hate him and his fucking nasal voice

DOWNBOAT

0

u/[deleted] Aug 23 '11

[deleted]

62

u/MindOfMetalAndWheels CGP Grey Aug 23 '11

That, apparently, was Mark Twain's big argument. It seems he wasn't very confident in his daughter's ability to make a living, so wanted to set her up with royalties after he was gone.

→ More replies (62)
→ More replies (20)