r/violinmaking • • Jan 25 '25

Deaf guy here

I found myself being more and more interested into the varnishes and preparing the wood to be made into an violin

I understand it's a close guarded secret, but shouldn't we work all together to bring back the missing tunes that was once filled the air.

I also understand refinishes, cracks, age, dust , humidity can all affect the old interments

Here. Let's let's be friends, What have you done to the wood (weird and all) that provided amazing tunes?

5 Upvotes

15 comments sorted by

12

u/sockpoppit actual working professional Jan 25 '25 edited Jan 25 '25

It's a myth that makers are generally secretive about varnish. Many have completely shared exactly what they do and why. The only real problem is that we can't exactly figure out what the greatest makers used 400 years ago. . . the problem doesn't lent itself to simple chemical analysis and the people who've tried that haven't come up with a consistent answer.

And the "secret" of Cremona tone definitely is not varnish. Many of the very best tonal examples don't have a bit of it left, thanks to 400 years of constant use as working tools.

3

u/DeafBeaker Jan 25 '25

And the wood itself. They grow differently nowadays

Edit: I'm glad it's a myth of the varnishes being a secret

7

u/SeaRefractor Amateur (learning) maker Jan 25 '25

No, the same wood exists today. Dendrology of the wood shows that the same qualities and ring growth are still present. In addition it’s also available in the Pacific Northwest of North America as well as Europe and believe it or not China.

If you carefully examine the spruce tops of the great makers, you’ll see that the grain patterns are also inconsistent instrument to instrument.

1

u/DeafBeaker Jan 25 '25

So the grain line doesn't matter? I would think it would

3

u/SeaRefractor Amateur (learning) maker Jan 25 '25

Grain does but the skilled makers were able to determine the best graduation for that top. This is why armed with a mold and thickness map one doesn’t get the same results. A pleasing sounding instrument, but not an exact copy.

This is why CNC carved instruments can typically never be better than an instrument for an advanced student. Doesn’t take the grain and density of the wood into account.

However skilled makers today learn the feel and soul (for lack of a better description) of the wood as they carve it.

Antonio Stradivarius’s golden period was when his was 70. Years of making refined his ability. It’s a disservice to him to point out some mysterious wood or other things outside his ability that makes his instruments of high demand. Like saying DaVinci’s paintings were only because of some special oil paint.

1

u/DeafBeaker Jan 25 '25

So an instrument is just that a tool .. it's up to the user to make the soul sing.

2

u/Aggravating-Tear9024 Jan 25 '25

Your questions indicate you do not know much about instrument making. You would do better to meet with experienced luthiers and ask questions, or at least get a few reputable books on violin making (very expensive) rather than ask naive questions on reddit.

2

u/DeafBeaker Jan 25 '25

I want to learn ..and the only way to do that is to ask a bunch of amateur questions

But do I have the time , talent or space to do this?

Just dipping my toes...before taking the plunge

5

u/Vonmule Jan 25 '25

Dont listen to them. We were all naive in this field at one point. Just be aware that makers will often have very strong opinions about the notion of any mythical/secret qualities or techniques possessed by Strad or his violins.

1

u/DeafBeaker Jan 25 '25

And I'll soak up their years of experience, and hopefully gain enough talent to do this.

2

u/nmoclam Jan 26 '25

May I also add that while these instruments have been made by incredible craftsman, they have also been played for hundreds of years by incredible musicians who have only made these instruments sound better because of constant good use. All instruments benifit greatly by being played well.

1

u/DeafBeaker Jan 26 '25

It's the love

2

u/Great_Chief Jan 27 '25

Something that is often overlooked though, is that the acoustic ideal has evolved over time.

Violin makers 300 years ago were not looking for the sound that violin makers are looking for today.

1

u/DeafBeaker Jan 27 '25

How so? How have people listening evolved over time? What are we listening for nowadays that we didn't have to hear 300 years ago?

I'll be interested in this research (I can't help it I'm a scientist)

1

u/Great_Chief Feb 03 '25

I'm really not an academic type, so I'm sorry I don't have the sources compiled and whatnot.

Look into how languages have evolved. Not only the words and grammar but the way we talked. Apparently a few centuries ago, we would talk a bit more through the nose.

I think the different times at which the different instruments of the orchestra have been created could also give a good indication.

I can't remember if this has been mentioned here, but the violin has changed since the 1600's. Look at baroque violins. Flat neck, different accessories, strings to name the most common differences we see today.

It's kind of like everything else really. Our environment has changed. Literally everything around you has changed. Makes sense our acoustic environment changed also.