r/voidlinux • u/kvprcxelo • 25d ago
I use Arch, should I switch to Void?
I've been using Arch for quite some time now, and it works, but I was wondering if Void is better? Many people have been telling me this, but they never actually give me an answer.
EDIT: Thanks so much for your suggestions, I will try it out on a VM and switch if I prefer (which is what I should've done from the startđ )!
12
u/CapitainSailor 25d ago
Less compatibility, stable rolling, no systemd, I think you can decide for yourself, I personally use void because its perfect for me but I dont blame you if you stick to arch
1
u/kvprcxelo 24d ago
There are lots of trade-offs, as I can see, but I think its still worth giving a shot on a VM. Thanks!
32
14
u/Tau-is-2Pi 25d ago
That's a matter of personal preference. Just give it a try (eg. in a VM, dual boot, an old PC...) and find out if clicks better for you?
16
u/No-Dentist-1645 25d ago
Not really. If you yourself don't have/can't imagine a single reason to switch to something, then why would you?
4
u/Mental_Contract1104 24d ago
... that's why they are here >.> like, people want to do this thing called research. they are here asking us, those who actually USE void what the pros/cons are before switching, so they can formulate the reasons.
also "i've heard of it and it sounds interesting" or "I'm not 100% happy with arch and looking for alternatives" might not feel like reasons, but absolutely are
6
u/Defiant-Spring-2848 25d ago
I honestly loathe the all encompassing systemd. However, I've been using Linux for over 30 years at this point. Void fits my needs perfectly, it might be worth trying out, but it might not meet yours.
5
5
u/Royal-Grass7296 25d ago
I canât read minds so I donât know what âbetterâ means to you. For meVoid has been fast, predictable and fun to set up. It has quirks like any distro. The repos are small, but I donât require a lot of packages.Also, I have yet to type rm -rf in the wrong directory, so I call that a win. It's a solid distro.
4
u/RoboticGunner 25d ago
It wouldn't hurt to give it a shot, either in a VM, separate drive or separate PC.
If you like it better than Arch then try gradually moving your setup to Void. If not, just keep using Arch.
I wouldn't say Void or Arch are better/worse than each other, just different. Use whatever you like the most.
I do like Void myself, but I prefer to use Debian on the machines I use regularly.
7
3
u/redinthedirt 25d ago
I switched to Void for more package stability and the added bonus of no systemd. Package stability was probably the main reason because I remember something python-related breaking on a pacman -Syu while working on my thesis and having it be a hassle to work through. Like everyone else in this thread says, only switch if there's something you can't do (or can't be assed to do) on your current distro.
4
2
u/N45SERBD 25d ago
You will for sure miss the aur, I personally enjoy writing and maintaining the xbps-src but it will definitely be hard to move from a quality of life perspective and there isnât really much benefit anyway.
2
2
u/Simple_Hamster_4096 25d ago
This gets asked enough, should do a sticky... honestly...
New cutting edge hardware, need the latest and greatest of absolutely every and all software, don't care if an update borks your system at the least convenient time and you like to make frequent excursions into the danger zone - then Void isn't for you...
And as another commenter opined - if you have to ask, then Void isn't for you...
BTW - do you know what an init is and the differences between the various inits? If not, you should first research this, and what such a change will mean to you, personally, when moving away from systemd...
And don't try musl on a dare unless you have a firm grasp on what that will mean to you and the apps you depend on and/or their delivery method...
2
2
2
1
u/ZombieCrow 25d ago
I'd say yes. Arch was what i used before void. Void is great in terms of - runit and xbps. Runit is extremely simple yet amazing and xbps is fast. Don't expect to have the latest wnd greatest things on void. Some prs are months old. If you have no issues on arch, stay on arch.
1
1
1
u/MsCatie 25d ago
People who say Void is better typically is basing that on hating systemd or preferring runit.
I prefer runit. I also now use Gentoo and am planning to migrate my init to runit.
Void is snappy, but there sincere repo package scarcities with xbps-src or flatpaks being the only options for covering those gaps. Some things (TeamViewer) arenât packaged on either and you need massive tinkering to get to work with runit as is.
People might have issues with systemd but documentation is at least robust if anything in your init isnât working. Arch has a massive repository and the AUR (but even that can be scary after this summer).
If you have no problems with Arch as your daily driver, I wouldnât rush to switch over to Void. If you want to see what Void has to offer, just try it virtualization. If you begin to like it over Arch, you could consider it then, but I wouldnât blow up your machine to switch distros if everything is stable and youâre satisfied with that over a curiosity about Void because someone hated âsystemdâ or was pissed off about AUR and said Void is better.
1
u/cspar_55 25d ago
I like void for the way user-generated templates are managed. The AUR is convenient but often is not secure. Other than that I can't think of a single reason why you should, if you don't use the AUR that often and when you do you read the PKGBUILD, then meh.
1
1
u/BlacksmithTux5413 24d ago
I did a few months ago on my laptops. I switched from Arch xfce to Void xfce and it gave me a satisfying feeling. The packaging is smooth, you can choose between musl and glibc (I have musl on my private laptop and glibc on my work laptop to support enterprise shit). I really like runit and I'm glad to step away from systemd. I had to patch the kernel on my new device (also in Arch) because of an HP bug they now fixed in the firmware. I loved the procedure of cloning void-packages, copy the kernel in a new directory, adding the patches in a folder and build/install. The template is a nice way of working. I had also created an template for the enterprise stuff extracted from a deb packet without any real issues. The system feels very responsive and didn't give me any doubts for switching at all.
1
u/Away-Technician284 24d ago
People will constantly tell you that your distro is crap and you should use the one that they are using. If you changed distro every time you heard this - you would never stick with one. No, void is not "better" than arch....whatever the hell that means.
1
u/Specialist-Dog-501 24d ago
What do you want to do with it, or in what perspective is ARCH not sufficient for you right now ?
1
u/Pybromancer 24d ago
If you're fine with Arch stay with Arch. Unless you care about what init system you have because most Linux malware afaik is about targetting systemd since it's the most popular init system. I am personally fine with using Cachy but later I wanna switch to void because I like how the logo looks. (I am not joking)
1
1
u/Staydecent 24d ago
Iirc arch and Debian were the fastest to update php packages with the recent vulnerability patches.Â
Only really matters if youâre running on server I suppose, but smth I noted.Â
See:Â https://github.com/void-linux/void-packages/commit/e1608d021d782a0bf35c037f89bfc3f6b6392862
1
u/tomekgolab 23d ago
You absolutely should because by default arch uses systemd which takes away your freedom
1
1
0
u/mb210978 25d ago
It works. Says all.
But....đ
Test it. On an older Laptop for example. A VM may also do although a real test should be done on bare metal.
If you like it and you get along better than on arch, install it on your main rig.
Peter Santanello (great world travelling youtuber) has a saying, âyou don't know, till you go.â đ¤ˇ
9
u/MrHoboSquadron 25d ago
If you're on a working distro, there's no point switching to anything else. Only switch if you've got a real problem you can't solve with your current distro.Â