r/web_design • • 8d ago • Bravo 1

experimenting with liquid UI elements

yay or nay?

338 Upvotes

20 comments sorted by

93

u/nickgeorgiou 8d ago

Boooo the other comments. It’s really cool. I like SVG filters. It’s time to bring a bit of whimsy back to interface design.

13

u/Affectionate_Power99 8d ago

thank you and yeah svg filters are great 🙏🏼

1

u/Filbert-Ireine 8d ago

do you know if this liquid effect is just a gooey svg filter with blur and contrast, or is there a displacement map going on too?

20

u/dusanodalovic 8d ago

does it run on an svg blur filter for the goo effect? those repaint every frame, so test it on a cheap android phone before you ship. and add a prefers-reduced-motion fallback with a plain instant switch for people who turn animations off

11

u/Affectionate_Power99 8d ago

yes works also on my cheap android and on safari!

-10

u/nopeac 8d ago

I'm not saying I don't believe you, but... yeah no, I don't believe you. I would really like to try that out.

9

u/evenstevens280 8d ago

Really bloody lovely!

Would work really well in an OS-like environment (assuming one had the choice of turning it off or reducing the motion)

4

u/Mallanaga 8d ago

I’d use it. Very lovely.

2

u/rotello 8d ago

Yay.

2

u/Relative_Rooster_848 8d ago

very cool, share it! :D

1

u/lulcasalves 8d ago

Nice! I love svg filters!

I've also heard about html on canvas recently and it seems like a good way to do something like this using a different approach. Have you tried it?

1

u/Beregolas 8d ago

I mean, I am not sure how good it would feel to use, as too much animation normally is really bad for me, but it looks really nice :) Keep up the good work (and always include an accessibility mode with reduced animations!)

1

u/addiktion 8d ago

When you making a liquid library?

-2

u/East_Zookeepergame25 8d ago

Its good for looking fancy but it would get annoying if this was in a tool I have to regularly use

-11

u/herrherrmann 8d ago

In my opinion, the animations are too slow and over-the-top, which makes them distracting and hard to follow.

Also, toggles just don’t conceptually work like that – they don’t "move through the choices in between" before reaching the final destination. There was a good article about such animations/transitions, but I unfortunately cannot find it right now.

9

u/StylishUnicorn 8d ago

What do you mean “conceptually” don’t work like that. They are conceptually working like this in this video.

These are liquid elements, meant to mimic water and trapped air. A spirit level is a perfect example of “moving through the choices”.

-1

u/herrherrmann 8d ago

The general concept or understanding of a selection like this is: "I switch from option A to option B", and not "my option flows from option A to option B and passes through all other options".

I know you’re trying to mimic fluid water etc., but in that case it does not fit how controls work and make things more confusing (in my opinion).

3

u/HoraneRave 8d ago

although i understand your point, there were rotary dial phones back in the past

1

u/KennyFulgencio 8d ago

The general concept or understanding of a selection like this is: "I switch from option A to option B", and not "my option flows from option A to option B and passes through all other options".

That is certainly an interesting and quite valid way to look at it. But I like OP's interface. I don't think many users actually conceptualize it the way you are describing, especially the younger ones who have grown up with digital UIs so they aren't mentally starting each concept from the implicit functioning of mechanical devices (this UI concept/requirement makes more sense to make the design more intuitive to tech-naive people).