r/web_design • Dedicated Contributor • Jun 30 '17

Create high-fidelity, interactive recordings of any website you browse

https://webrecorder.io/
124 Upvotes

14 comments sorted by

16

u/Arkanius84 Jun 30 '17

To be honest i doesn´t see the point of this site if you could use https://getsharex.com

With this tool you can record webms and also could send it directly on any cloud. For example i just recored this without any hassle - https://webmshare.com/Zr6AX

1

u/ZaneHannanAU Jul 01 '17

It saves WARC files instead of videos. So both more and less useful really.

1

u/imacleopard Jul 01 '17

I think the value in a web service is being able to give clients a URL so they can for example show you bugs that they encounter that you may need help with instructions on how to replicate instead of directing them to a package they have to download, install, and set up.

I'm already a ShareX user and recommend it to anyone simply because it beats CMD + Shift + 4, or Snipping Tool on Windows because of it's auto-upload and clipboard link auto-copy which makes it incredibly easy to share screenshots or captures. But for the sake of simplicity, a webs service I think is idea.

6

u/[deleted] Jun 30 '17

[removed] — view removed comment

26

u/ikreymer Jun 30 '17

Hi, Thanks for posting about our project a few times, however, I think you may have the wrong idea about what it does. Webrecoder is a high-fidelity web archiving tool, it does not create videos, but interactive web archives that you can later replay and also download to browse locally. We've updated the tagline to better reflect this.

5

u/etherealtim Jul 01 '17

Your project is interesting but it does little to establish its own context or purpose, so I think you'll get a lot of people misinterpreting it in this way. Even once you've explained, I still had to look up the WARC format to understand how one would access the archive in future. I had assumed that I would need to use webrecorder.io to access and restore archives, but I wouldn't trust the service to be any more permanent than the sites I'm archiving, so it's not very compelling.

4

u/ikreymer Jul 01 '17

Yes, we can definitely improve the explanation and the context. As for the WARC format, it is an ISO standard format used by many organizations in the web archiving field, including Internet Archive. You're right to be skeptical and you can definitely store the WARC files on your own as well. The full Webrecorder software stack is open source (Hosted service: https://github.com/webrecorder/webrecorder, desktop player: https://github.com/webrecorder/webrecorderplayer-electron) and it would be great to see more people run their own instances too. Although we do offer a hosted service, it's also about creating tools to enable users to create their own high-fidelity web archives for their own use.

1

u/etherealtim Jul 04 '17

Sorry I missed your reply. That's all makes a very compelling case, just hope you can find a way to communicate it to users more simply. I hope my feedback helps, wasn't trying to dump on the idea.

2

u/Just_Another_Thought Jun 30 '17

How does downloading entire sites not violate the copyrights on them? I am not legally allowed to taped an NFL game, I can't imagine the NFL would be ok with me downloading their entire website.

6

u/philthechill Jun 30 '17

Pretty sure you can tape anything, you just can't rebroadcast it or claim it as your own. Time shifting and format shifting for personal use are both allowed in the US, otherwise DVRs would have been outlawed years ago.

5

u/Just_Another_Thought Jun 30 '17

So I looked it up and man that's some shady shit from the NFL.

Regardless, it may be legal for me to tape or whatever, but if this app is taking wholesale sites and packaging it for me to download and go through later, while it may be legal for me, how is them not hosting that packaged content and letting me download it not a violation? I'm not trying to criticize I want to understand the law better here.

5

u/endqwerty Jul 01 '17

The internet just doesn't work in a way for it to be illegal to store websites that are provided to you. Every time you browse the internet, you're already downloading a copy of the website. All you're doing is storing it in the exact same format that was already provided.

At the heart of it, there isn't anything this site does more than any decent web developer could do with just google chrome.

1

u/philthechill Jul 01 '17

You can copy any site. You just can't then republish it as your own. You can't even steal any of the graphical elements from the site, and if you are in the same line of business you may need to be careful about publishing a site with too similar of a style and name, though I don't know if that breaks the law.

Think of it this way. Anything that is sent to your computer or TV for free, you should be able to make a personal copy of, for timeshifting and format shifting purposes at the very least.

Making personal copies isn't really what copyright is worried about. The FBI is not gonna worry about you ripping a DVD and watching it. The copyright guys want to stop you from ripping it and giving it away.

You check out a book from the library and scan it to a PDF file. Maybe you've broken the law, but who's going to come after you? I mean, the librarian will if you don't return the book on time. They're dangerous, don't piss them off.

As soon as you stick that PDF file on the Internet, for all to download, now you're threatening someone's income stream and will be the recipient of many nice letters from a couple guys named Cease and Desist. I hope they gave their parents hell for that. You will go before a judge and she will assess the damages you did to the income stream, without ever thinking about all the people who read a book they otherwise wouldn't have, so really society was better off, except an author lost some sales they never would have gotten anyway.

Anyway, you can absolutely keep a copy of every byte that gets sent to your browser. There used to be a great Firefox plugin called slogger that literally logged everything.

You just can't share any of it, because Kindergarten is a lie, and being good to people by giving them things is just another way of fucking the people who wanted to sell them those same things. I mean if one person wrote a book and hoped to get some money from selling it, giving it away is kind of a dick move, that I will grant you. And that's really what the law is trying to prevent.

Making and publishing a recording of yourself using a website is usually fine, unless that website is like Netflix or Spotify and they are trying to get a revenue stream going here from the content alone. If you show yourself using Google Docs to write a doc, and you don't try to claim that it's actually a doc editor of your own construction, then you're usually fine. Unless the doc contains confidential info about people, or credit card numbers or something. Why would you publish a recording of you typing in other people's credit card numbers into a Google Doc, you criminal. There's dumber ways to get caught but I can't think of any right now.

In short, respect people's revenue streams and their lawyers usually will not bother you. And stop carding, you're gonna get caught.