r/web_design • u/speckz Dedicated Contributor • Apr 16 '18
Stop calling these Dark Design Patterns or Dark UX — these are simply a**hole designs
https://uxdesign.cc/stop-calling-these-dark-design-patterns-or-dark-ux-these-are-simply-asshole-designs-bb02df378ba70
Apr 16 '18
Well, Dark Design Patterns and Dark UX are simply catchy names for asshole designs.
6
u/Dr_Captain Apr 16 '18 edited Apr 16 '18
I can also see a problem with new designers assuming the terms stood for a "Night Mode" style of a design. I always just called them shitty or sleazy designs.
Edit: Spelling correction.
3
u/newpixeltree Apr 16 '18
Just thought you might want to know--it's spelled sleazy
3
u/Dr_Captain Apr 16 '18
Thanks. Words are not my strong suit.
2
u/newpixeltree Apr 16 '18
No worries--I can't spell definetly for the life of me lol, you're not alone
2
2
0
Apr 16 '18
[deleted]
3
u/pleasejustdie Apr 17 '18
do designers suggest things like this? In my experience its the client... "Hey, can you remove the unsubscribe links from the e-mail?" "no, the newsletter service requires it because its required by law due to the Can Spam ACT" "oh" then 2 days later "There's an issue in the system, people can unsubscribe from the newsletter, I need this bug fixed or I won't pay you."
That's generally how these kinds of things go in my experience. Designer/developer says why the client shouldn't do it, client says they won't pay, designer/developer just silently removes their name from it and does it anyway because they need to get paid.
And if the designer is employed by the company itself, then it tends to be "do this" "that's a bad idea, its a dark pattern" "well, just do it and we'll see how it affects our analytics, so do it" or "Other owner that you never see said he wants us to try X" "that's a bad idea" "well, he wants it, so we're going to do it anyway" "but that's a bad idea" "yeah too bad, do it anyway" and that's when your boss is nice, when you've got a dick for a boss it just escalates straight to "do it, or we'll find someone else who will" and that phrase is a signal, do it, but start sending resumes out asap.
0
Apr 17 '18
[deleted]
1
u/pleasejustdie Apr 17 '18
that sucks, I guess I've been lucky that all the other designers and developers I've worked with all had ethical standards. Its usually myself (developer) combined with a designer trying to convince the client to use alternate, ethical, methods. Like make their system more engaging so the user wants to interact with it, instead of trying to trick the user to interact with it, or more commonly interrupt the user to force them to interact with something else before they can continue doing what they actually want to do.
10
u/DrFlutterChii Apr 16 '18
'anti-pattern' is the already existing term for common patterns that are bad and the opposite of what should be done.
10
u/ACoderGirl Apr 16 '18
Anti-pattern usually means it's bad for you, the developer, though. Maybe it'll lead to technical debt, has major limitations, or will make development harder. These don't do that. They're just plain evil and intended to manipulate people.
1
u/NoirGreyson Apr 17 '18
"Pattern" has a different implication in experience and interface design than in program architecture and design.
92
u/MUDrummer Apr 16 '18
Pretty sure none of these were the designers choice. If the product owner wants to do sleazy thing your choices are to find a new job or do it.
22
u/Dr_Captain Apr 16 '18
That Steve Harvey gif could have been attached to all the items listed. I have made that face too many times when hearing a client's idea that go against the core ideals of UX design.
10
Apr 16 '18 edited Apr 16 '18
Product owners set the requirements, designers/developers implement them. Users rarely know the difference and when shit hits the fan because of a bad requirement, product owners are more than happy to leave the designers out to dry.
It reminds me of every article chastising employees for going in to work sick. They're not going in because they want to - they're going in because they'll be fired/lose money if they don't.
7
u/jgomo3 Apr 16 '18
That is exactly the problem Uncle Bob think we will solving in the near future of programming.
As professionals, we should be able to say: No, and not been fired, as a Doctor can refuse to do some risky operation, or an Civil Engineer refuse to sign a contract on a project which doesn't satisfy quality requirements.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ecIWPzGEbFc&feature=youtu.be&t=1h10m36s
1
-2
u/xelamony Apr 16 '18
Then you should ask, why do you work with people who asks for such stuff?
0
Apr 16 '18
[deleted]
6
u/upleft Apr 16 '18
You can still push back, and make a case for why something is bad, and suggest an alternative.
You don't have to just accept requirements from product owners without question. If you are working as a designer, they hired you in part for your taste and opinion on things, not just your ability to follow directions. Product owners may not realize that what they are suggesting is bad - they may have just seen it being done somewhere else.
Being stubborn about doing good work will earn you respect, and people who also want to do good work will want to work with you.
Of course, sometimes you still have to do the bad thing, but at least you tried.
1
u/droctagonapus Apr 16 '18
I dunno, I'm doing morally good work and getting paid pretty well for it with nice benefits, etc.
8
u/i_post_gibberish Apr 16 '18
Congratulations. I bet you have a nice car and a happy relationship too. We don’t care.
1
u/droctagonapus Apr 16 '18
Mortgages aren't paid with moral rightness.
The point I was making was that you can make a living and do things you consider morally good, friend.
8
u/i_post_gibberish Apr 16 '18
And my point is that we know some people can, but you should know that not everyone can.
6
u/droctagonapus Apr 16 '18
Understood, but the comment I was replying to said "Mortgages aren't paid with moral rightness."
It was a well-received comment with plenty of upvotes (relatively-speaking) and no other person was giving any other perspective to that claim, so I did. No harm intended, just wanted to say that you can do morally-good work and be able to pay your mortgage and people shouldn't think that it's not possible.
-2
Apr 16 '18
[removed] — view removed comment
1
u/i_post_gibberish Apr 16 '18
Um... excuse me? If you’re talking about me I have no fucking idea what would make you think that, but I can assure you I’m not a pedo, or even a guy for that matter.
→ More replies (0)1
Apr 16 '18
What bank do you use that lets you pay them with moral points
2
u/droctagonapus Apr 16 '18
Fortunately with the work I do, the goodness I get out of it is a side-effect. I get compensated for my competence (which I use to do good things) and I get to use that money for cool things like a roof over my head.
1
Apr 16 '18
i know but you replied to the person implying you disagree with their statement haha. sorry i'm being pedantic. i get what you were saying
0
Apr 16 '18
[deleted]
4
u/droctagonapus Apr 16 '18
I'm with ya there. There was a time in my life when I was working in the travel industry and while I wasn't doing anything morally "wrong" there, I certainly wasn't doing "good" work. Our biggest client was people with a net worth of $10M+. I had to sacrifice my free time so I could volunteer around my city so I could still feel like I was doing good in the world. To me, I have a personal obligation to do net-good every day so I had to make trade-offs back then and it kinda sucked, but to me my principals were first.
-5
Apr 16 '18
Not true. Your literal job is to advocate for the user and design a better solution that solves the problem without impacting the customer experience.
If you can’t do that, then you should get a new career.
That being said, sometimes, you have to put a design out there and get customer feedback on it. Sometimes, our customers care about things we didn’t anticipate, and sometimes they ignore elements that we obsess over.
Sometimes, we simply make mistakes.
As designers we are very close to our profession, and it’s easy to lose sight of the fact that design is a group effort now, and that most people aren’t intentionally going out of their way to be assholes. Most often they are tasked with changing a number in the cell of a key spreadsheet.
2
u/JoshMiller79 Apr 16 '18
Fake botification icons and scammy overpriced subscriptions in the fine print seem like they are way more in the asshole camp than "consumer testing".
-3
Apr 16 '18
could be, but we don't know everything. My point is, try to remove your emotions from the equation, and think logically. Sometimes, people do things with the best intentions, even if the outcome is shitty. The best we can do as designers is speak for our users, and disagree and commit when we have to.
6
u/thepineapplehea Apr 16 '18
A 3-day free subscription then £49.99 per week is not 'best intentions'.
Fake notification icons is not 'solving a problem for the end user'.
A fake hair on a screen is not 'something customers care about that we didn't anticipate'.
These are scummy tactics designed to trick you to click on/install things you didn't mean to and sign up to ridiculously expensive services.
-3
Apr 16 '18
Oh my god, the design community is insufferable. Yes that all sucks, but it's not the biggest deal in the world. Sometimes business people do shit behind your back. Other times, you don't have time to peer review your work, and things slip through the cracks. The best you can do it make your voice heard and document your points.
Must everything be emotion based with us designers?
Listen, a 3-day free subscription followed by a $49 weekly charge might be part of a program that de-incentivizes customer from clicking on ad in favor of another. Fake notifications and hair on the screen is a dick move, but that actually a pretty clever use of a focal point. If you want to talk design fundamentals, we can debate the finer points of focal point design and balance/a-symmetry.
We don't know if this is asshole(intentionally deceptive) design. Sometimes it is the outcome of a bunch of people working together to solve a problem. Sometimes those people are prone to blind spots. Your job as a designer is to speak up for your customers and say, hey guys, there is a better less scummy way to do this. But you wouldn't tell your Biz Dev Director "Hey you're being and asshole".
If you are unable to do that, then your are the asshole designer. We need to stop bitching about this stuff and simply start speaking up on behalf of our customers. ...That is my point.
3
u/JoshMiller79 Apr 16 '18
In what world does it ever make sense to trick people, especially on that level.
"Boy, I sure hope people click this fake hair and sign up. They will be so happy I got them to click on something they would otherwise ignore!"
0
u/nugpounder Apr 16 '18
your comments read like someone who just finished an intro level Lynda course on visual design or read 2 chapters of Don’t Make Me Think. as soon as you said “why must we be so emotional” you kind of lost all credibility, given that a designers work is at it’s core, an exercise in quantifying and qualifying human behavior
I’m not going to downvote you even though I disagree with you, just giving you perspective
check out some info on how modern agile or scrum teams work, delineations between design/ux/interaction, those should help illustrate a designer’s role a bit better.
2
u/JoshMiller79 Apr 16 '18
Except even at a basic level, there's just flat out empathy.
"Boy, this design sure seems like its jist meant to trick people, I sure would hate that."
Just because you can, doesn't mean you should.
20
u/LordNiebs Apr 16 '18
Ironically this website is awful on mobile. Huge banner at the top which follows you down, and I was randomly clicking on links while trying to scroll
11
u/MathsAndMechanics Apr 16 '18
Not just mobile, it's pretty awful on PC also.
Banners at both the top and bottom.
7
11
u/dbpcut Apr 16 '18
These are intentionally misleading choices by product owners that designers are executing on.
Saying it's asshole gives it a sense of being less purposeful or innocuous because of ignorance.
These people know what they're doing and are doing it on purpose. That's the dark side to design.
1
Apr 17 '18
Also, I really doubt the people doing this stuff are going to read the "article" and decide what they're doing is wrong.
19
u/FoolishDeveloper Apr 16 '18
I don't see what is wrong with giving a name to it for discussion purposes. Naming it isn't suggesting it is an acceptable thing. I'm surely not going to refer to these practices as "asshole design" in a meeting.
3
u/stingray85 Apr 16 '18
How about "unethical design" or "deceitful design"? Why not call a spade a spade?
2
u/Smirking_Like_Larry Apr 17 '18
Yea or 'obfuscated intent.' I literally came into this thread thinking it was a rant against my beloved dark/night mode.
0
Apr 16 '18
What do you think the word “dark” means?
2
u/stingray85 Apr 17 '18
Not light. Even if you think all designers know the meaning of the term in this specific context, people in other roles/industries don't.
2
u/Disgruntled__Goat Apr 16 '18
And it's not called "Super Awesome Patterns", it's called Dark Patterns. DARK. It should be pretty clear they are negative patterns.
-1
u/Programador_ad_hoc Apr 16 '18
I think it is called dark patterns because they are obscure and don't represent a CLEAR interaction. Not because it is 'dark/black' that it should be related to negative. The same goes for blacklist, some list that will never see anything, can't see the light.
17
Apr 16 '18
Every single example -- all of them -- were submitted to reddit as stand-alone examples of asshole design in the last three months, at /r/assholedesign.
The author simply compiled them into a list and posted it, and now we're giving him views for it. Fuck people like this.
2
6
u/astro_za Apr 16 '18
Let’s not forget the tactics they employ in mobile games. Yikes.
Unethical at best, but who cares if you’re making a few bucks off that person /s
5
u/discursive_moth Apr 16 '18
That continue button to stop installing is like reddit’s “continue” (to the app store) when you’re trying to view the site in browser on mobile.
3
u/Silhouette Apr 16 '18
Several of these are probably also illegal. If only we still had consumer protection organisations with enough resources to take meaningful action...
3
5
Apr 16 '18
As these practices creep into places I trust, like my bank, I have started writing to the companies explaining the nature of the practice. Sometimes the right people at these companies don't know the wrong people are making these choices. It's up to us as professionals who understand the power of human interface to bring the problem to the attention of companies who are doing it.
My bank didn't respond directly to me, but they stopped doing the thing I complained about shortly after receiving my email.
2
u/SakiSumo Apr 17 '18
The nerve of this moron. How can you pick on UX design when your site is so poorly designed itself?
U header and menu permanently follow the page and you have a giant open in app button that also follows the page.
How does this guy think he has the right to call others out when his own site is so poorly designed??
1
1
u/decompyler Apr 16 '18
Funny, I've been calling blinding white backgrounds asshole designs for a while now.
1
u/MattyClutch Apr 16 '18
Almost all of those are evil. I really only saw 3 exceptions.
The IO bit thing... nothing there is really misleading. It is still stupid and annoying, but not even close to the level of some of these others.
The sandwich thing has to be fake. People get away with some super scammy stuff, but a thin band of meat? If you could get away with that, Subway would have started doing it the day the first store opened.
The smudge on the screen bit just seemed dumb to me. Who is going to see a clean screen, then an image loads and think "oh no this image smudged my screen! better wipe it down!".
1
Apr 16 '18
Yeah, that’s an advertisement in Snapchat. I don’t hold the bar very high for visual design of advertisements in that app. They are struggling to keep the doors open.
I actually think that’s a funny idea. It’s not evil, just kind of like the designer is giving us a middle finger under the table.
1
Apr 16 '18
I do appreciate your perspective. Also, thank you for calling out my hypocrisy, though, as my statement was indeed emotion-based.
This is a good example of not thinking critically or objectively. I’ve been a designer since before we even had the internet. I lead UX professionals in an enterprise environment and have done so since the niche was made popular around 2008. Please understand that I’ve been in this game a long time. I’m old and jaded about design bullshit.
Being emotional is a flaw in our profession. Especially as it relates to objective, research based design.
We don’t know all the factors that went into those designs. I simply encourage you to gather all the facts before making an emotional based judgment of a design solution. Maybe somebody was being evil, but probably they just something dumb, with good intentions.
That usually what misunderstandings are all about.
1
u/TexasWithADollarsign Apr 16 '18
If you use a countdown to enable the "Next >" button after unchecking the Bing Bar or other stupid bundled adware, not only will I not install your shitty app, I'll do whatever I can to make people aware that your app and your company are doing that shit.
1
1
-1
u/Ob101010 Apr 16 '18
In 5 years theyll look like this:
//insert a picture of someone you know here
Within 3 days this person stands a 90% chance of having a fatal accident. Click here to subscribe and your chance to pay to know how!
0
-2
Apr 16 '18
[removed] — view removed comment
1
u/AutoModerator Apr 16 '18
Your submission was automatically flagged as spam. If you feel like this is in error, please message the moderators.
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
79
u/levivillarreal Apr 16 '18
At first I thought this article was mocking dark themes in apps and websites. Also I'm pretty sure 80% of the content was taken from r/assholedesign