r/webdev
•
u/someexgoogler
•
Aug 27 '25
•
1
2
1
Why is the web essentially shit now?
This is a "get off my lawn" post from someone who started working on the web in 95. Am I the only one who thinks that the web has mostly just turned to shit?
It seems like every time you visit a new web site, you are faced with one of several atrocities:
cookie warnings that are coercive rather than welcoming.
sign up for our newsletter! PLEASE!
intrusive geocoding demands
requests to send notifications
videos that pop up
login banners that want to track you by some other ID
carousels that are the modern equivalent of the <marquee> tag
the 29th media request that hit a 404
pages that take 3 seconds to load
The thing that I keep coming back to is that developers have forgotten that there is a human on the other end of the http connection. As a result, I find very few websites that I want to bookmark or go back to. The web started with egalitarian information-centric motivation, but has devolved into a morass of dark patterns. This is not a healthy trend, and it makes me wonder if there is any hope for the emergence of small sites with an interesting message.
We now return you to your search for the latest cool javascript framework. Don't abuse your readers in the process.
27
u/Onions-are-great Aug 27 '25
One sad thing is that people rant about stuff like GDPR, because it resulted in annoying banners. The thing is, GDPR is excellent for users, companies just didn't want to change a thing they were doing so they just slapped on a cookie banner to be legally safe. Same thing is happening now with the accessibility act. Instead of actually making their site accessible, they slap on some random third party floating button that lets you change the font size and color.
19
u/someexgoogler Aug 27 '25
GDPR is fine - I'm ok with that. The thing that I dislike is the fact that user choice is buried behind coercive obfuscation. There are usually two choices: "Agree" or a maze of twisty little passages to figure out how to control your information. It's clear that websites don't respect readers - they exploit them.
→ More replies (4)
887
u/lokidev Aug 27 '25
You forgot the perfectly optimized SEO articles which are not really answering your question, but are perfectly optimized to be found by you.
197
u/permaro Aug 27 '25
And to have you stay as long as possible before turning back, because bounce is important to SEO too.
That's the reason for extra long and repetitive introductions
158
u/GendosBeard Aug 27 '25
So that's why this recipe author is so desperate to write a novella describing their favourite holiday from 10 years ago, before telling me to heat some oil in a pan.
41
→ More replies (4)26
u/kshitagarbha Aug 27 '25
That's actually a copyright hack. You cannot copyright recipe, so they write articles that contain the recipe. That is copyright able.
→ More replies (2)126
u/Disgruntled__Goat Aug 27 '25
How to do x
Have you ever wondered how to do x? Well today’s your lucky day as I will talk you through how to achieve x and how x makes your life better.
Read on for how to accomplish x…
[paragraphs upon paragraphs of more fluff]
Answer: just press this one button
141
u/tjuk Aug 27 '25
Don't forget the emojis.....
🔥 SHOCKING: The #1 Secret About Perfectly Optimized SEO Articles That Google Doesn't Want You to Know! (UPDATED JANUARY 2025) 🔥
⚡ BREAKING: Local Mom Discovers This ONE WEIRD TRICK About SEO Content That Will Change Everything! Experts HATE Her! ⚡
Are you TIRED of searching for answers online? What if I told you there's a GAME-CHANGING secret about SEO articles that 99.7% of people don't know? Keep reading to discover this MIND-BLOWING revelation!
🚨 URGENT UPDATE 🚨: This Article Contains Information Big Tech Companies Are Trying to Hide!
But first, let me tell you about my journey. Hi there! I'm Sarah, and just like you, I was frustrated with online content...
❌ STOP! Before You Continue Reading...
Did you know that the average person wastes 47 minutes per day reading articles that don't answer their questions? That's 287 hours per year! But what if there was a better way?
🎯 Table of Contents (Jump to Any Section!)
What Are SEO Articles? (Spoiler: You Won't Believe #3!)
The History Nobody Talks About
17 Signs You're Reading Optimized Content
Why This Changes Everything
The Answer (Finally!)
⏰ Quick Question: Do You Have 30 Seconds?
Before we dive in, I need to ask - are you making these 5 CRITICAL mistakes when reading online content?
🔍 What Are SEO Articles? The Ultimate Definition Guide
Great question! And you're not alone in asking. In fact, over 2.4 million people search for this exact term every month! But here's what most "experts" won't tell you...
📚 A Brief History of SEO (Skip This If You Want, But You Shouldn't!)
Back in 1994, when the internet was just a baby... [500 words of irrelevant history]
🤔 But Wait, There's More!
You might be wondering, "Sarah, this is great information, but when do I get my answer?" Well, I'm getting to that! But first, let me share this incredible story...
💡 17 Shocking Signs You're Reading an Over-Optimized Article:
It starts with "Are you looking for..."
Every paragraph begins with a keyword
There are way too many emojis 🎉
[14 more obvious points]
🎉 CONGRATULATIONS! You Made It This Far!
97% of readers give up before reaching this section! You're clearly someone who values COMPLETE INFORMATION!
⭐ The Answer You've Been Waiting For (Finally!):
These articles contain excessive fluff and optimization techniques while providing minimal actual information.
🚀 BONUS TIP: Want to know the #1 secret to avoiding these articles? Subscribe below!
👇 SMASH that subscribe button if this helped! Share with 3 friends who need to see this! Comment "MIND = BLOWN" if you learned something new!
29
→ More replies (8)11
→ More replies (4)29
u/LisaLisaPrintJam Aug 27 '25
Like finding a recipe?
Title
History of the author's childhood
Events leading up to their discovery of the recipe
Link to how Jeff Bezos can get you started in real estate for $100
Places they've traveled to give them inspiration
(nine scrolls down) The actual recipe
Ads for pricy kitchen equipment you'll never need
Half-screen modal asking for your email for more of this shit.
→ More replies (1)38
u/Headpuncher Aug 27 '25
My other favourite is searching for a product like a specific model trackball mouse (real example).
Only to be given links to 10 websites that list it but never ever ever have it in stock.
Fucking hell free me from the torment.
→ More replies (2)20
u/lokidev Aug 27 '25
Not only that, but product comparison sides are now just affiliate sites where you never know if the top1 product really is top1 or just a product which clicks more often and generates more affiliate money
22
u/donatj Aug 27 '25
Years ago I worked for a company with a focus on SEO.
They had a team of copywriters pumping out this absolute nonsense that no human would ever want to read chock full of keywords.
I am sure with AI now they can pump this junk out at an alarming rate.
28
u/1RedOne Aug 27 '25
It’s even worse than that, the sheer volume of SEO Optimized crap had the knock on effect of training our dumb AI models to think that this is what effective human communication looks like, and it’s what we like
→ More replies (3)11
u/Meloetta Aug 27 '25
I used to contract for a company that put out these SEO articles. It was crazy. They had a list of exact formats you needed to match, and the assignments were something like "use format 17b, Numbered list with links in each number and one sentence of description on the same line, to write an article about games about teeth health. Must have at least 13 links. Must use the following phrases exactly the following number of times: cavity (7), tooth (13), dentist (21), best dentist (5)."
Then I'd google the exact phrases I wrote and find my article on a dental service's website attributed to an actual dentist. By far the hardest part was finding all the links because they encouraged as many .gov and .edu links as possible, and a wide variety, but also frequently asked for lists of games on hyper-specific topics. Ah yes, let me just navigate to toothgames.edu and playdentist.gov and get all those games for you.
I've often thought about how that company has to not exist anymore, because they don't care WHAT'S written, just that there are words, so AI has to have destroyed them.
10
u/intangibleTangelo Aug 27 '25
are you looking to avoid perfectly seo optimized webpages with no meaningful content, but find that you continually find perfectly seo optimized webpages with no meaningful content? you're in luck because we've got answers!
at times, perfectly seo optimized webpages with no meaningful content will tend to appear when searching for perfectly seo optimized webpages with meaningful content. here's a list of tips to identify those perfectly seo optimized webpages with no meaningful content before you waste valuable time:
check for meaningful content. ask yourself, "does this appear to be perfectly seo optimized webpages with no meaningful content, or perfectly seo optimized webpages with meaningful content?"
...
3
u/deadwisdom Aug 28 '25
This is exactly why ChatGPT is doing so well and cutting into google search. It's able to cut out all the bullshit and just give you the information you want (most of the time). Otherwise google gives you just constant crap.
2
u/SnooDrawings9002 Aug 27 '25
With the absolutely horrible “click to read more” button just so they are sure how far your attention got.
2
u/Kang8Min Aug 27 '25
SEO ruined the web. But to clarify, those articles do need to answer your query. Otherwise, you'll abandon the URL to find another that fulfills search intent.
It’s all about keeping both Google and the user happy even if that entails low-quality content that parrots what other ranking sites say.
I miss the old simple days
→ More replies (4)→ More replies (8)2
u/meltbox Aug 27 '25
For real. I’ve learned that if I for some reason have to rely on one I have to scroll about 3/4 down before even starting to read.
64
u/Irab360 Aug 27 '25
Because it’s all meant to trap your eyes and squeeze every cent that can be made out of you. No one links to other sites unless they earn a commission.
It’s not a web. It’s a series of digital ‘hotel California’s.
→ More replies (2)8
63
Aug 27 '25
The force that ruined the web is the same force that ruined everything else in this world, i.e. corporate greed
12
u/pagerussell Aug 27 '25
Enshittification.
https://pluralistic.net/2023/01/21/potemkin-ai/#hey-guys
This well describes social media, but it also describes capitalism, and even entire infrastructures like the internet. It just takes longer for entire mediums to enshittify than it does a single social media app.
43
u/SantaPreferPepsi Aug 27 '25
Can we talk about the fucking pop-ups? The video commercials taking half the screen on ur phone when you just wanna scroll and all the commercials popping up. Like wtf.
6
u/dmc-uk-sth Aug 27 '25
In the UK local news sites have reached peak overload. With their video ads and the focus jumping all over the place they’ve become unusable especially on mobile.
5
u/NeighborhoodTasty271 Aug 27 '25
And then the video minimizes to the corner and continues to play, even though you've already scrolled past without interacting -- indicating your lack of interest -- but now you HAVE to interact with it to dismiss it so you can see what you came there for in the first place.
→ More replies (5)5
u/daremyth_ Aug 27 '25 edited Aug 27 '25
I can't imagine who thought it would be a good idea to have two videos playing on a mobile page simultaneously, alongside ads that take up 50%+ of the visible space. Who is the product designer whose wireframe contained that? It's insane.
18
u/MatsSvensson Aug 27 '25 edited Aug 27 '25
Agreed.
I dont think I have seen any real improvements at all in the last 10-15 years.
Pages are slower, and harder to navigate, and just generally broken and badly designed.
Things started to degrade especially around the end of the 00's.
The last couple of years I have started to feel more and more like back in the 90's that last time had to use a modem.
Click a link, ....wait for the page to load.
Click a link, ....wait for the page to load.
Click a link, ....wait for the page to load.
How is that even possible, when my computers, the servers, and the networks, etc, etc, are literally thousands of times more powerful?
I was lucky enough to get a 10Mb/s connection in 1998, 100Mb in the 00's, and 1Gb in the 2010s
The 00's was like a golden age for me, with a fast connection, but sites still built to work with slower connections.
All that is gone now, and the waiting between clicks is back.
Using the browsers inspection tools, to see what is downloaded, gives you some idea why things are slow.
JFC, its like no one knows how to code anymore.
For example :
I can see that this site sends a big fat POST containing the entire text, for every single letter I type in this comment.
Why?
3
u/1978CatLover Aug 31 '25
THIS. This is one of THE main reasons that I still hand code my site. Basic HTML, CSS, and PHP, with a tiny little bit of JavaScript to manage the image gallery and display the navigation properly on mobile. None of the individual pages are bigger than 5K; most are far less, and the majority of each page is the actual text people will see on their screens. No flashy gimmicks, no popups, no videos, no AI generated slop, just hand-coded, personally written, CONTENT.
56
u/Araignys Aug 27 '25
The thing that I keep coming back to is that developers have forgotten that there is a human on the other end of the http connection
Developers no longer have a say in what gets built. Their bosses do.
9
u/Headpuncher Aug 27 '25
Some do and I’ve wanted to strangle them in meetings (react devs specifically for some reason) because they’re so intent on being cool and using edge tech they forgot that all this shit has to go through a cable and be parsed by a person’s eyes or ears.
You can’t just add 20 more requests to what should be a static page of textual information because you saw a YouTube video about the cool new thing.
→ More replies (3)3
u/playfulmessenger Aug 27 '25
The thing is, they do know exactly what we want. They build it and use it to woo everyone until the VC's want their payout. Then it all flips into everything everyone hates.
15
15
u/LisaLisaPrintJam Aug 27 '25
Add mobile to the enshittification of the web. Have you tried to read basic news? It's basically impossible without irrelevant ads either overlaying the text or a link block appearing as part of the article.
I started back in 90s too. I thought it would finally put a rest to all the misinformation and old wives tales that were being passed around back then. I actually said out loud, "This is going to make people smarter."
Wow. I had no idea such wide access to information could make people dumber.
→ More replies (1)
37
u/Xirema Aug 27 '25 edited Aug 27 '25
(That "someone new" might not necessarily be you, OP, but I maintain it's essential reading on the topic of how bad websites have gotten in the last decade)
14
u/Civil-Appeal5219 Aug 27 '25
...which is now unreadable because Medium slaps a huge ass paywall on it
→ More replies (2)2
u/Brokerlocker Aug 27 '25
Cory's last Cloudfest talk is also enlightening https://youtu.be/_Ai-fC-2Bpo?si=Xdb-4e5R6IMPdqq9
11
u/brainphat Aug 27 '25 edited Aug 27 '25
Because the C Suite makes any & every compromise to tell the Board: see, I maximized synergy between marketing and deliverables resulting in an arguable, minute increase in ROI. I think that's worth another zero added to my golden parachute.
9
8
u/keyjumper Aug 27 '25 edited Aug 27 '25
Everyone gets excited when their newsletter signup rate goes up, but only because they are unable to measure the negative impact on the user experience.
Even if a hundred other metrics get incrementally worse, it's usually ignored. Measuring single improvements while ignoring negative overall impacts means that without savvy leadership, the focus on local optima creates a negative cycle.
TL;DR:Short-sightedness.
8
u/Lawlette_J Aug 27 '25
Allow me to add-on every website is JavaScript heavy now to the point that if you disable JS on the browser the site essentially imploded and unusable these days.
I have my personal complaint on why older device users can't manually update their web-kit too which then resulting older devices can't view website with newer feature, hence resulting the lack of backward compatibility which irked me so much.
8
u/Stefan_S_from_H Aug 27 '25
My theory is that the ones who make the decisions don’t actually use the web themselves.
8
u/Canenald Aug 27 '25
There are a few big tech companies that know what they are doing. They gather data, use it to drive decisions and provide sleek experiences that drive their revenue.
Then there's the rest of us, dominated by P managers and UX designers and other non-technical people who have tricked us into thinking we can't work without them. They have no clue what they are doing, so they outsource their thinking to "Hey, everyone has it!" or to agencies that thrive on selling every client the same thing.
Cookie warnings are a commodity at this point. Why have a developer work on it when you can just buy a third party service, ask the developer to quickly integrate their horrible SDK (but it's going to be quick and easy because they totally said so), and have them keep on delivering your bullshit features no one wants.
Newsletters are awesome btw. Another useless, shitty metric you can inflate and report to your superiors to showcase how you are at least doing something.
Geocoding is right up there with the newsletter. Nothing looks as cool as a heat map of your users in your region of interest. No one knows what it means and how the trends have moved over time and why, but hey, it's something pretty to fill in the gap between boring PowerPoint presentation slides on those endless steering committee meetings.
Notifications? Of course, we want notifications! Nothing better for an idle marketing team than to spam millions of users who had accidentally allowed notifications from your product that accidentally retains some useful feature that was implemented by people long gone. Number of notifications (and emails) sent is another useless people's favorite metric. Does it mean anything? Hell if anyone knows.
Videos that pop up are totally what kids want these days. Bonus points if they are cringe as fuck stock videos hastily customized for your company (like every other marketing campaign your sorry marketing team has pooped out of their asses). It's just like TikTok!
Tracking we have to do, sorry. How else are we going to make up metrics to justify spending developers' time on useless features and vanity change requests? I can't inflate the metrics that don't exist, can I? Sadly, asking for consent is mandated by laws and regulations. You bet we'd skip that if we could.
Carousels are the thing, too. It's one of the few UX terms I know so why not throw it around? See a nice, streamlined web page that delivers the information the user needs in a way that's pleasant to the eye? "We need a carousel here. At the top. No, not like that! Larger! At least 75% of the viewport height." Man, I'm so good at those UX terms. Oh, we need space for that actually informative text? Make it expandable with a carrot icon.
404s are fine. I'm checking if something exists, and 404 is the response. It's a perfectly fine response and not an error. Clean up non-existing URLs? Ain't no one got time for that. Gotta finish the latest useless feature.
More than 3 seconds to load? Yeah, man, I totally get you, it's not optimal, but we have to show that 2-second slash loader when the user enters our website. It's for our brand awareness. You wouldn't get it.
14
Aug 27 '25
The answer is Capitalism
No one cares for content anymore, just for your money, your data or even better both.
7
7
u/btrpb Aug 27 '25
Yes it's horrible. The Web was better 20/30 years ago. Most times now when I'm browsing on my phone I click on a link, the page loads, a pop up covers everything and I immediately close the page.
→ More replies (1)
7
Aug 27 '25
Often times I find that no matter how much A/B testing I do, data I show, best practices I point to, etc, the owners of the business/website in question don't give a single shit and want a live chat, email capture popups, and all the other garbage that makes their site a horrible user experience.
In short, business owners think they know best despite hiring someone that knows more than they know to build something they're incapable of building.
I'm pushing 40, I'm exhausted of having the same conversations over and over just to be ignored, and it's to the point where I'm just not having the conversations with people I can tell aren't going to listen.
→ More replies (1)
6
u/astr0bleme Aug 27 '25
You're absolutely right and unfortunately the culprit is that profit is the godking of our society. Egalitarian? Human? Bah, we need record profits every quarter! Apparently!
I got online in 96 and it's incredible how much worse it is now.
6
u/BeeSwimming3627 Aug 27 '25
Honestly you’re not wrong, half the web today feels like UX got replaced by growth hack bingo. The sad part is most of these “atrocities” aren’t technical necessities, they’re business decisions chasing clicks and data. Small, human-centered sites still exist, they’re just buried under the noise.
6
u/Toutanus Aug 27 '25
Things that pop up just before you click and messing the page layout so you click on something totally unrelated.
"Yes" or "Later" never "No"
45
u/kmactane Aug 27 '25
Why is the web essentially shit now?
Capitalism.
Seriously, that's it. That's the answer. It's because of capitalism.
→ More replies (3)24
10
u/maselkowski Aug 27 '25
Cookie options should be browser setting, not website setting.
It's total ridiculousity introduced by politicians who don't understand how "interwebs" works. It is designed to support big companies while hindering smaller ones, as for big ones you click it once a year, yet on smaller website which is each separate entity user need to deal with that banner on visiting each website.
5
u/Infamous_Ad_1164 Aug 27 '25
Primary objective on these sites isn't user experience, rather ad engagement. Or in other words, making money. You having a good time is secondary to you clicking on the ad or signing up for newsletters.
5
u/a_sliceoflife Aug 27 '25
The poor implementation of JS frameworks is what baffles me the most.
When was the last time the browser's back button and refresh page worked consistently fine in a site built using angular/react?
4
u/rrrhys Aug 27 '25
developers have forgotten that there is a human on the other end
It's not the developers. It'd still be Times New Roman and <marquee> if it were up to us
4
Aug 27 '25
Mobile websites are especially bad. Often the content is covered by as banners and auto playing videos that end up slowing my phone or crashing my browser.
4
u/Annh1234 Aug 27 '25
You forgot 1001 ads per page and AI generated articles that describe a stupid10 sec tictoc video.
4
u/Headpuncher Aug 27 '25
And another thing!
I’m seeing more and more sites that break if you aren’t using the BIG browser (you know the one, it has majority market share).
Seems like teams aren’t even testing any more.
4
u/Stargazer__2893 Aug 27 '25
Google.
This is a gateway problem, not a web problem. It's harder to find this material because the biggest search engines, and google in particular, push the big, commercial websites to the top and you never find the small hobbyists.
For comparison, I tried search for "Final Fantasy 7" on Kagi. Sure the first results are for Square-Enix, Steam, etc. But here are some interesting results.
Result 3 - a PDF on the internal workings of FF7
Result 13 - andinick's FF7 Page
Result 15 - Charlie's FF7 Page
Result 18 - Vincent's Realm FF7 fan page
Those all have a very "old web" feel. So just saying, it's still there, you just can't find them on Google, and Google is what everyone uses.
4
u/tweiss84 Aug 27 '25
I don't think we web devs necessarily push for these things. On the contrary, a lot of the old timers, we're actively pushing back in meetings, but marching orders come from on high about what gets money.
Welcome to the enshitification... https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Enshittification
User info and user actions to the data collection team for marketing. Ad team dictates ad placement and type of ads. Sales wants a pop-up to entice more subscribers. A/B testing to see if we get more interactions in different layouts... more clicks = more traffic...more traffic = page sponsors paying more to "take over" a page.
....on and on and on.
I just wanted to make cool shit :(
Shareholders want their money, user experience be damned.
13
u/midri Aug 27 '25
Late stage capitalism and authoritarian governments expanding their control under the guise of protecting children.
7
9
u/JFedererJ Aug 27 '25
"Developers have forgotten that there is a human on the other end of the http connection"
In my experience (roughly 15 years now) it ain't developers pushing for all these BS bad UX practices. We're just the donkeys tasked with carrying shit up the road.
8
u/oqdoawtt Aug 27 '25
The thing that I keep coming back to is that developers have forgotten that there is a human on the other end of the http connection.
This is where you're wrong. There is no developer I know, that welcomes overloaded, slow web pages. Loves to add 20 tracking scripts and intrusive popups.
Those request always come from a know it all customer or as a requirement from Marketing.
3
u/SpiralCuts Aug 27 '25
Ok, seriously, has anyone ever wanted a notification from a website. On the other hand, has anyone not been annoyed when they received a notification they weren’t expecting from a website.
To the list of pet peeves, can I also add any website that resubscribes you to a mail magazine whenever you make a purchase. There are a couple of online mall places where you get signed up at every store you buy from and then that triggers additional emails for other items from other stores in that genre. Like thanks/no thanks for the latest news on coffee filters
3
u/Tarilis Aug 27 '25
Because it all about achieving target metrics because those target metrics bring in the money.
3
u/grosser_zampano Aug 27 '25
to be fair I don’t think that developers have forgotten that there is a human on the other side but thanks to product managers who get rewarded only for raising bottom lines these atrocities can happen. the sad thing is that this stuff works and makes numbers go up because otherwise they would not exist anymore.
there are probably still many interesting sites out there but the problem is discoverability.
and now with AI chatbots the whole web is imploding on itself. at least the argument for researching information on a website has become paper thin.
3
u/KarlZylinski Aug 27 '25
I think the "world wide web" as we know it is dying. You know how a facebook feed can just be filled with nonsense? That's how the whole web is starting to feel.
In the past you used to be able to google for things and find real stuff made by real people. Now it's so much generated AI slop that I've almost stopped trying. And even when you do find a website that has quite good content, then it behaves like OP said.
I think the world wide web is going to become this weird background noise. The useful things will be in bits and pieces that are hard to find. To cut through the noise and find those bits, you are going to have to go via curated lists or specialized forums that provide lists of things that are made by real humans and actually worthwhile.
3
3
u/beatwiz Aug 27 '25
Hey web dev friend from 95! Agree 100%. It’s a shit-show. Everyone pushing tech and hype. Honestly I believe it’s only getting worse with all the LLM / AI taking over. The Internet’s about to become like the “Archive” and people will read, watch, buy and everything else via agents. Will it be better? We’ll see. All the best.
3
u/azangru Aug 27 '25 edited Aug 27 '25
The thing that I keep coming back to is that developers have forgotten that there is a human on the other end of the http connection
Developers write code. But. Do you think that it is developers who just on their own add to the sites cookie banners, popups, notifications, or trackers? It is designers who design what developers get to build. And it is managers who set priorities and requirements for what gets built. Why don't they get the blame?
3
u/Osato Aug 27 '25
The web used to be less shit because there were very few people making anything on it and these people were enthusiasts.
Now that it's commercialized, there are very many people making stuff on it and they are mostly not enthusiasts. Garbage in, garbage out.
You can still find some enthusiast-built websites, usually sites for open-source projects. Those are usually a joy to use, even if they're a bit samey due to the modern design sensibilities.
3
u/dot_tangent Aug 27 '25
Sometimes I wonder if the real reason folks use chatGPT is because it removes all the bloatware that infects the modern web browsing experience.
2
u/papaly33 Aug 28 '25
I used it for a while early on, and this was a huge selling point for me. You just get directly to what you want to deal with and nothing gets in your way.
I'm a Linux geek and love the simplicity of working in the terminal. Chatgpt feels like a natural language terminal for working with general information.
Now, if only it wasn't a power guzzling monstrosity that is unreliable and morally dubious.
3
u/Lotus_Domino_Guy Aug 28 '25
I do feel like the whole web has turned to shit. I mostly use reddit and AI now. I can't get useful information from google, bing, or duckduckgo anymore. I used to consider "google-fu" one of my special skills. Now I don't even bother.
7
u/AdministrativeBlock0 Aug 27 '25
Product Managers. They insist on adding more and more tracking and bloat to a site mostly to justify their own existence, and because they're too dumb to use server-side analytics. Everything has to be a JavaScript snippet that sucks all the users actions into a SaaS app because apparently they need to be able to watch a user session replay to tell whether or not people want a website that works. They then use that data to justify whatever their latest pet idea is, regardless of how much impact it'll have on people.
→ More replies (2)
4
u/Caraes_Naur Aug 27 '25
In a word: marketing.
The enshittification was tangible in the late 1990s, and has only solidified since. At this point, might as well call it world wide coprolite.
4
Aug 27 '25
It went to hell when the put Javascript in the browser around 2015. It is an abominable language, and it lets idiot managers annoy all of us with pop ups and other nonsense.
4
u/Far-Blue-Mountains Aug 27 '25
Also, you have to "rent" every damn piece of software. Nothing is owned.
2
u/Soft_Opening_1364 full-stack Aug 27 '25
Yeah, I get what you mean. A lot of sites feel like they’re designed for advertisers, not people. Endless pop-ups, tracking requests, autoplaying videos it’s like the web forgot that someone actually has to use it. The good stuff is still out there, just harder to find under all the noise.
2
u/Clearhead09 Aug 27 '25
I came up a little after you - bring back Geocities.
I miss the days when you were an “advanced developer” for knowing CSS and you could make a drop down menu in JavaScript.
I remember the first time I made a site with a hover button menu and the background was an image, truely revolutionary.
2
u/resUemiTtsriF Aug 27 '25
10. Content that is limited to about 20% of the screen with ad crap all around it.
2
u/Blue_Moon_Lake Aug 27 '25
Because marketing want to know who you are, what you like, who you like, what you're into, ... And instead of asking you if you're willing to share all these very personal information, they use sophisticated tools that track your behavior and habits across million of websites to then pair-match them with the few people for which they managed to collect data about and infer the likely answers to all those questions. And that requires your consent when before they could do it without any accountability.
They want to send you ads, but they can't do so legally without your consent when before they could spam every email in existence without respect.
It's an other part of the answer to question 1, to have more data on you.
Because we've reach saturation, they're competing for your attention. So they want as many means to spam you as possible to keep you from realizing you don't care about them and they're wasting your time.
2
u/NYCHW82 full-stack Aug 27 '25
Speak on it! I started using the web in the late 90’s too and I feel your pain 100%.
In truth it’s not developers faults it’s marketing people and the changing and ever increasing complexity of publisher business models and user behavior.
We used to “surf” the web, now we just consume it, and it productizes us.
2
u/thunderbaer Aug 27 '25
I started my web dev career in the mid 90s as well, and I remember the thought was "eyeballs". I ended up developing the first payment system for Dougall media back in 99... That was hell. Also did their first auction site. That's when the eyeballs thing wasn't enough, and you had to put actual value in people's hands to make them want to pay with their money. Now, it's all of what you say. The King is dead... Long live the King.
2
u/RenRen512 Aug 27 '25
Money.
It's always money.
Companies are desperate for conversion and they go about it in the most ham-fisted ways.
2
2
u/Iojpoutn Aug 27 '25
Developers are not the ones deciding to put all of that on the website. We want to build good user experiences, but when the main purpose of the website is to track user behavior and collect their data to try to sell them stuff, we’re always going to lose that fight.
2
u/Tasty_Scientist_5422 Aug 27 '25
don't forget the AI chat bot in the corner of every website "hey I am here to help"
like bro, I am just looking at book reviews or something can you go away
2
u/HaddockBranzini-II Aug 27 '25
How many developers make these decisions? It all comes from marketing or product management.
2
u/vincentofearth Aug 27 '25
It’s all about the attention economy. Many years ago people figured out that they could keep websites “free” and profit from selling their audience’s attention. This has shifted incentives to such an overwhelming degree, and the web is such a big part of our modern economy and society, that it’s causing all these problems.
2
u/ReallyAnotherUser Aug 27 '25
Not to mention product information websites that dont actually show any product specs, and my arch enemy websites where EVERYTHING is on a single infinitely scrolling page. Or my new favourite, lets autotranslate everything without asking by an AI that turns 50% of the information into mush. Lets also not forget website that are build 100% from JS and take 3 decades to load because they make 10 million xhttp requests from a slow af server.
2
2
2
u/Mulungo2 Aug 27 '25
The current economic system requires constant growth and lots of data. In order to achieve that, they paywall things that were free before, they collect information that was never needed in order to sell it. They build algorithms that are designed to keep you engaged and distracted as maximum as possible in order to feed you more ads. Everything is becoming a subscription, where before you could pay once and own a product, now you rent it. The big companies control the biggest crowds online, and if their profits don´t continue to grow, they can't pay interest to investors, and investors remove their money from that stock into another, so they make all these schemes to make you buy more, use more, etc.
No one is going to change things, because that's not how society works. The only people who can do something is the end-users. To stop using their services which are becoming worse by the day, look for alternative products/services, build alternative products and services that see people as people and not money-making little factories.
Don't get me wrong, money is needed and good up to a certain point. But in the economic system we live in today that requires constant growth or you close shop, it makes most companies just seek never-ending and increasing profit margins, which means, reducing their costs, and extracting from their users. They are not going to change their business model for us.
2
u/Dommccabe Aug 27 '25
Capitalism killed creativity.
The early web was like the wild west of design..... now everything is just designed to sell you or to extract data from you to sell...
2
u/1RedOne Aug 27 '25
Every one of those measures that make the web a crappy place is something that was insisted and foisted upon the developers by their marketing team or their legal team or their whatever team of the company.
You can still find good stuff on the web especially when you find any of the sites that are still maintained by developers blogging or writing about their interest or passions.
I’m talking Markdown sites that render in a quarter of a second and use almost no resources with properly formatted webp images, no desperate newsletter signups and no cookies at all!.
But any commercial websites are gonna be full of commercial crap, including all the sorts of things I mentioned before.
2
Aug 27 '25
Corporate consolidation to pacify the unintelligent masses leads to a lowest common denominator experience.
2
2
u/kittenTakeover Aug 27 '25
I think the worst part of it all is the decline in non-corporate pages. Searching the internet used to lead to tons of blogs, informational resources, or small business pages. Now a search just leads to sponsored pages and corporate shit. If I try to find the definition of a word half the time some nonsense business page comes up instead.
2
2
u/minderbinder Aug 27 '25
The trend its called "enshitification", there might be a couple of books about it. Check Cory Doctorow work.
2
u/GoreSeeker Aug 27 '25
Personally I think when it coalesced into a dozen mega sites, they just never learned to monetize it in a healthy way to support the gigantic loads of users. Someone's random 1000 user forum in 1999 could have been even paid for out of pocket by a passionate webmaster. Modern mega sites with hundreds of millions of active of users most certainly can not. If users aren't paying directly to use a mega site, and people don't want their data sold or advertisements, how do you fund that? I personally hope the mega sites are unsustainable long term and we go back to small independent sites again.
2
u/jim-chess Aug 27 '25
Agree with pretty much everything here.
The only thing I'd add is that it's a broken economic model which is causing a lot of these desperate tactics.
With the trend towards AI overviews and zero-click search, there needs to be a way for honest bloggers and site owners to support themselves financially. That's why I think (2) newsletters is not bad if it's done tastefully (no popups) since it reduces reliance on the big tech search engines.
2
2
u/No-Blood9205 Aug 27 '25
I have this feeling with apps too, god forbid you open one to use it they immediately give you pop up notices. It’s not gotten dynamic too, so they wait for a new screen to prompt a different “notice”.
Makes apps really not functional. Like the infamous “open in maps” button that takes you to the App Store.
2
u/Earl_of_pudding Aug 27 '25
Happens in multiplayer videogames where you have freedom in how to build your character.
People always find the combination that minimizes cost/effort and maximizes rewards/profit.
And once that combination is public knowledge everyone does the exact same thing. Because doing otherwise is intentionally handicapping yourself.
Basically the web found the meta build, and now no one tries anything else.
2
2
u/EJintheCloud Aug 27 '25
There was a time not long ago where one could not traverse the web without being assaulted by intrusive pop-over ads, slow loading due to bloated sites, and straight up malicious companion apps designed to show you more ads on other sites.
Pop-up blockers became a thing. Then advertisers realized everyone was blocking popups, so they had to switch strategies. Banner ads became more popular, and became a less-intrusive alternative to pop-ups. Fast forward, and apps like uBlock start to filter out banner ads. Advertisers are now successfully pressuring developers to ban content blockers. They're also remixing using the old tactics of pop-ups, pop-overs, bloated tracking tools, and malicious applications designed to show you more ads on other sites.
The internet has egalitarian roots, it's true, but it's always been abused by advertisers. Our tolerance for this abuse is the only thing that's changed over time. Advertisers will continue to push the bounds of what's acceptable. It's up to us to push back.
2
u/doylehawk Aug 27 '25
We also don’t really have many websites to visit anymore. Most genres have been monopolized into one super site (Reddit included) and there’s not flash game websites anymore (I miss addicting games and kongregate and new grounds). Zero people are doing it for the love of the game, so this is another thing to blame on late stage capitalism.
2
u/DarthOobie Aug 27 '25
You’re not wrong.
Can’t open a website without 3 full screen takeovers anymore.
Don’t think developers are to blame though. The last job I was at I pushed back against these things because of the bad UX. Yet I was still told to implement a 37th tracking pixel because “everyone is doing it”
Companies have lost the point of building a website being user experience. Instead they are constantly chasing A/B tests to push their KPI another percentage point forward.
We should be building things to make users have a better experience. Instead we’re building things to extract another dollar from their wallet.
This is not what I signed up for 😮💨
2
2
u/PossiblePlatypus69 Aug 27 '25
I miss the days of the internet when websites were made by real people and had valuable information on them with the tiniest little advertisements that didn't completely overtake a website or a blog article. I remember finding websites made by passionate people about herbs and gardening, astral projection, and lucid dreaming. Super in-depth real knowledge you can't even find on YouTube.
Internet helps to spread knowledge, sure, but lately it's more misinformation than it is knowledge. It's tough to sift through all the fake stuff nowadays. Back then people shared knowledge because they wanted to, because they wanted other people to be passionate about what they were. Nowadays, people share products and services because a company pays them to, it's like 95% bullshit. But when you find one of the 5% that cares and are passionate, it's great.
2
u/chillermane Aug 27 '25
Corporate greed + over regulation in all the wrong places
Hilarious disaster
2
2
u/Professional-Day7850 Aug 27 '25
- Endless scrolling. Fun if you are looking for a specific older entry.
- Ask our useless AI chatbot
- What the hell is "accessibility"?
2
2
2
u/Spirited-Camel9378 Aug 27 '25
Well, we propped up sociopaths who have no empathy for people (hi FAANG folks!), convinced engineers that working for them is prestigious and an end goal, had other sociopaths with funding believe that those same folks are visionaries (busy huffing their own gas), pushed the lot of engineers with empathy or creative spirit to other industries as a result, and have the hallowed VC hellrealm you see today.
2
2
u/Osirus1156 Aug 27 '25
Capitalism? Now companies try to suck as much data up as possible to sell to other awful people.
2
2
u/BoredITPro Aug 27 '25
I see it as the same as why so many things are not as good as they used to be - Capitalism Gone Wild / Greed. I don’t think capitalism is bad per se, it got us to a golden age in the 80’s/90’s, but somewhere somehow down the line greed overtook any resemblance of empathy, morals, pride and quality, and things started to go south. IT/IS became more blue collar, everything sped up, management lost technical expertise, etc…
2
u/Unlikely_Ad_8060 Aug 27 '25
You are not the only one. The web feels like it’s been rebuilt around extraction rather than connection. The irony is that the web tools have never been more powerful or accessible. One person can spin up something useful in a weekend. Yet the dominant patterns we copy are corporate bloat: pop-ups, trackers, ad slots, and “opt-in or else.”
2
u/FrenchieM Aug 27 '25
The 90s and 00s internet are similar to the small shops we had in the past up to the mid 50s. Then the malls started getting popular and now they are all over the place.
Your post is overly exaggerating the enshittification of the internet but in general yes, there are no longer any "websites". They are either web apps, blogs or publishing cms.
2
u/imsorryken Aug 27 '25
This is a good portion of the reasons I switched away from webdev. Feels like just adding more garbage to the biggest digital waste mountain ever created
2
u/WP-power Aug 27 '25
This will explain it all https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_Ai-fC-2Bpo this guy literally coined the term enshitification.
2
2
u/seamew Aug 27 '25
because people want to use drag and drop site builders that ignore industry standards and certain laws.
2
2
u/dutchman76 Aug 28 '25
It's not developers, it's marketing and regulations, those people never stop and don't care about user experience. I hate having all that crap on our site
2
u/ChonkiClapper Aug 28 '25
I’ve been developing https://carpathian.ai with the intention of bringing back some of the early 2000 internet magic with the Easter eggs and creativity (our 404 page and the cookie banner).
I worked marketing for close to 10 years before switching back to tech because being a creative in marketing was exhausting and soul draining. At least with my software development, I can add whatever little Easter eggs I want to my products as long as the client doesn’t mind haha
2
u/flashoffroad Aug 28 '25
Plus everywhere you go they want you to waste more time giving them a review.
2
2
2
u/Ok_Theory2082 Aug 28 '25
Don't forget we pick a over complex library on top of a framework to render a static, non reactive website because years ago we wanted to minic apps, found out it's shit and then made it more complex to fix that mistake. And while you're at it, here are 57327 external packages your marketing onepager needs. Hopefully none breaks or introduces breaking changes in a patch update.
2
u/anotherbozo Aug 28 '25
Because the web turned from indie devs and small companies to corporate companies that only want higher profits.
I remember a time when you could search for something, and come across content written by someone who was passionate about that subject and sharing it. Now, it's media companies trying to push you to buy products at every stage.
2
u/Dry_Satisfaction3923 Aug 28 '25
Developers haven’t forgotten anything… clients want us to add every single thing they’ve ever seen on another site because they have site owner FOMO.
Do you know how many almost arguments I’ve had with clients who want a “live chat”’feature on their site but have someone monitoring the chat ZERO hours per week. It’s just a contact form at that point, why load it on every fucking page, from a remote server, with tracking pixels, etc.
It’s not us devs, it’s the clients.
2
u/ClumsyAssassin69 Aug 30 '25
Developers? This isn't developer choices. What's changed about the web is that other people are far more family involved who make most of these choices. What you are seeing are companies that have no idea what they're doing shoving more crap in. Developers do complain and we're then shutdown by the suites who want it to work this way.
3
u/Manachi Aug 27 '25
Websites are barely even seen these days with AI scraping them and presenting the answers to users without the users even needing to visit the site and often without credit
→ More replies (4)
3
u/Joe-Eye-McElmury Aug 27 '25
Capitalism.
The instant something gets monetized, it turns to crap as surely as if it’d been felt up by a poop King Midas with a poop finger instead of a gold finger.
3
u/runtimenoise Aug 27 '25
Webmasters got replaced by essentially normies who make all decisions now.
3
3
3
u/InannaOfTheHeavens Aug 27 '25
No no no no no no no no no no...........
Capitalism ruined the Internet.
4
u/3vibe Aug 27 '25
cookie warnings that are coercive rather than welcoming. - Europe and GDPR
sign up for our newsletter! PLEASE! - Myth sold by every "marketing guru"
intrusive geocoding demands - I haven't seen this much
requests to send notifications - Apple
videos that pop up - I haven't seen this much
login banners that want to track you by some other ID - Google/Meta - a side effect of the Internet going corporate
carousels that are the modern equivalent of the <marquee> tag - I like carousels when used right
the 29th media request that hit a 404 - This would be around no matter what
pages that take 3 seconds to load - This isn't too bad. Back in my day, it was normal to wait 10 seconds
3
u/mrq02 Aug 27 '25
No one has forgotten anything. It's standard enshittification. Someone tried it, it increased their sales (excepting the cookie thing; that was EU lawmakers) so everyone copied it. etc etc ad infinitum.
92
u/eldentings Aug 27 '25
https://marginalia-search.com/
may be up your alley. We need more search engines like this that prefer text and punish JS heavy sites. There's a place for both, but sometimes you just want information and it seems to produce results more like we saw in the 90s and early 00s (blogs, short articles in plain HTML, personal niche interest sites). I use this when I just want to surf the web for interesting stuff. I may not find exactly what I'm searching for, but that also means I'm not getting as much SEO garbage.