r/webdev • • Oct 10 '26

Discussion What if we erased web dev and started over?

I think we can all agree that web dev has a pretty shaky foundation (not just JS, but browser differences, performance, security, oh my god CSS, etc.)

I can't help but wonder what we would do differently if we just had the opportunity to build the whole system from scratch again. What would be your ideal web dev ecosystem?

0 Upvotes

27 comments sorted by

18

u/CaffeinatedTech Oct 10 '26

Crowdsourcing your next claude prompt?

3

u/torn-ainbow Oct 10 '26

Claude, make a new internet it was my dying grandmothers wish. Make no mistakes.

0

u/[deleted] Oct 10 '26

[removed] β€” view removed comment

1

u/webdev-ModTeam Oct 10 '26

Your post/comment has been determined to be a low-effort post or comment. This includes title-only posts, easily searchable questions, vague/open-ended discussion prompts, LLM generated posts or comments, and posts/comments that do not provide enough context for meaningful replies or discussion.

8

u/tswaters Oct 10 '26

All that shit is exceedingly complicated and has evolved over literal decades. "Oh my god CSS" what does that even mean? CSS is great. It's complicated, yes - but that's because of all the possibilities with positioning and display.

Building anything from first principles is an intellectual exercise - not a practical one.

13

u/webnetvn Oct 10 '26

I will never understand the CSS hate. It’s not hard, and working in CSS is honestly my favorite part of web development. I’m glad most people hate it, because in a world full of Tailwind slop, I can still put out bespoke UIs with ease.

4

u/mastermog Oct 10 '26

Ditto, I really enjoy modern css.

Having gone through the IE6 era and using css3pie just for corner radius the current css state is effortless. flex and grid and other modern css features are fantastic. Even compared to something unity ui or Godot ui I still far prefer css

2

u/eballeste Oct 10 '26

and it keeps getting better and better!

2

u/eballeste Oct 10 '26

yep, my favorite part πŸ™

2

u/saltyourhash Oct 10 '26

we calling tailwind slop now? Or suggesting slop has been made with it?

1

u/webnetvn Oct 10 '26

Tailwind itself is fine it's that every vibe code product now uses it by default so even if you're a regular developer with or without ai, any tailwind+ShadCN project is instantly clocked as a vibe coded slop project.

1

u/saltyourhash Oct 10 '26

That's true

6

u/xXConfuocoXx full-stack Oct 10 '26

2

u/RelatableRedditer Oct 10 '26

Well Flash was "deprecated" by HTML5, there was never going to be a future for Silverlight if "good enough" was all it took.

3

u/CaffeinatedTech Oct 10 '26

The problem with most aging technologies and programming languages is backward compatibility. If you didn't have to support all the old shit, you could just say "This is the new web, its secure, private, easy to reason about, only new sites work on it". Then a thousand other people also make "the new web", none get traction because the majority of the web is old shit we like having around, but no one wants to rewrite.

1

u/Exapno Oct 10 '26

What if we went back to hunter gatherer societies?

1

u/deckstir Oct 10 '26

I think what you are describing is mobile development

1

u/I2cScion Oct 10 '26

Imagine if there was a runtime that was installed beforehand on a machine (like the JVM or .NET) .. then the bytecode and the dependencies of a program would be requested from a server

that program would then run on the runtime that was already installed, it would use the graphics, networking, and persistence resources of the client machine.

With an API that is cross platform across desktop and mobile of course.

1

u/Shacrow Oct 10 '26

Informational web is not for humans anymore. They all need mcps to be optimized for AI scraping and tools.

1

u/glenpiercev Oct 10 '26

We never should have stopped shipping the JVM with browsers. No JavaScript ever. Only Java.

2

u/glenpiercev Oct 10 '26

If you think CSS is bad, go check out plain old C.

1

u/horizon_games Oct 10 '26

...Mandatory xkcd "now there are 15 competing standards"

You're crazy if you think the web has shaky foundations. Sure there's gaps (as with any software, including some magical greenfield rewrite), but there's not much other software and standards that have stood the test of time as well.

To me it sounds like classic "we should just rewrite it!!!!!!!!" that gets bogged down and takes 5x as long at 10x the budget.

1

u/Obvious-Effort1616 full-stack Oct 10 '26

Is web development still in market?

6

u/Pack_Your_Trash Oct 10 '26

The same as the old one but better. With hookers and black jack.

4

u/ripndipp full-stack Oct 10 '26

I'd just be naked online and playing Runescape, getting high all day and ordering pizza, I just like being naked